Why won’t he just cum in me?! [MF]

I’d been wanting to get creampied for the longest time. No interest in breeding. I just want my pussy filled with cum. 

I (27F) was chatting with my FWB Cole (27M), trying to find a good time for him to give me a creampie. Finally, I got a chance to sneak off work early and head to Cole’s place. I sent him a couple of Snaps before I headed to his place, teasing him on what’s to come.

“What’s the first thing you want me to do? ;)” I asked him. 

His response couldn’t come any faster. “I want you on your knees,” he said. 

I turned the corner and arrived at his place. 

Cole greeted me at the door with an easy smile, ushering me into his room where he greeted me with a passionate, open tongued kiss. He pulled apart to look me over before diving in for another kiss, pushing me slowly towards his bed, his hips against mine, I can feel the growing bulge in his pants. 

“Wait a minute,” I put my hands on his shoulders to stop him. He paused, surprised. And I kneeled in front of him, glancing expectantly at his crotch. 

I pulled his cock out from his boxers, admiring his lovely cock before I slowly swivelled my tongue over the tip, gently working my way along the shaft. 

Cole let out a breath and groaned, holding onto my head as I teased his growing cock. Switching to my hands, I looked up at him and maneuvered my way along his shaft, maintaining a steady rhythm. 

I gave him a sloppy blowjob, feeling his cock becoming harder in my mouth. 

Cole stopped me as I was really getting into it. “Your turn,” he said. I protested, but he was already guiding me towards the bed. 

He ate me out, with a cheeky finger on my asshole until I came hard. 

“Let me fuck you now,” were the magic words I’d been waiting for. 

He pounded me fast and he pounded me hard. Cole is an amazing fuck, but I literally saw stars as he was pounding me into oblivion. “I need your cum inside me please,” I whimpered as he kept on pounding. 

After a good while, Cole moaned “I’m cumming,” and I felt this immense relief. The relief very quickly replaced with disappointment, as he pulled out with a groan and came all over my stomach. Boy did he save his cum up for me, some even got on my tits. But I was supposed to be pumped full of cum. I was gutted, to say the least. 

We got cleaned up and rested, while chatting about what’s happening in our lives. 

“I want to cum another time,” he said to me sheepishly. I told him OK, but my pussy needed a break as it’s been a while. He nodded, and I assumed my position at the end of his bed, taking his soft cock into my mouth, feeling it grow harder by the second. 

I teased him, playing with his growing cock. His cock twitched as I teased him, and I sucked him off, taking him all the way in my throat until he was moaning uncontrollably. 

“I want to be inside you,” he pleaded, the lust in his eyes. 

How can I say no to that. 

I got up, and he tried to get up with me. I pushed him back on the bed, saying that it’s my turn to take control. He happily obliged. 

Straddling him, I hovered over his hard cock and slowly lowered myself onto him, inch by excruciating inch. 

He groaned as my pussy took the full length of him, and I slowly rocked my hips against his. I rode him for a good few minutes, alternating between bouncing and twerking on his cock. Then I turned over and rode him reverse cowgirl, giving him full view of my bouncing ass. 

He was really moaning then, grabbing and slapping my ass, calling me his little slut, telling me how good I was at riding. 

All of a sudden, he grabbed my hips with both arms, and rose off the bed. 

“My turn,” he said, pushing me forward, then plunging deep into me. I whimpered as his cock filled me up, and he started pounding me like there’s no tomorrow. 

At that point I was a dripping, wet mess. I didn’t know whether it was my juices or his sweat or what fluids we were flowing. He pounded me fast and hard, and I couldn’t hold my moans. I was still so sore from my earlier pounding, but I couldn’t get enough of his cock. It hurt so good. 

“Please, Cole… Please cum inside me,” I begged, as he fucked me harder.  

I felt him slowing down at some point, and I felt my pussy dripping. I don’t know how long he’d been fucking me from behind like that. At that point both of us were sweaty and tired, and neither of us could possibly continue on. 

“Turn around,” he said. “Let me finish inside your mouth.” 

I’m always happy to swallow cum. But on this occasion I was super disappointed. Nonetheless I obliged, and swallowed his load like a good girl. 

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/lfdsy5/why_wont_he_just_cum_in_me_mf

54 comments

  1. He’s probably afraid of babies. You have to talk about your desire outside of the context of the bedroom. It’s likely that he has not cumming in people as a rule and needs to be given assurances that it’s okay. He will probably want you to be on birth control before he agrees to do it.

    I was going down on a guy once and he asked for a rimjob and I just wasn’t ready to do that. But saying no and explaining why kills the mood so I just didn’t do it. That’s all you really can do in the moment.

    Super hot story by the way.

  2. Quite a lots of men is unable to finish inside. You would have to ride him, he will have no choice.

  17. I love it when my husband cums inside me it is the best. I also love it when his friends join in.

  18. What a wonderful story and a delightfully naughty username. You are, as my friend Ollie would say, a nugget (of gold)!

  19. He doesn’t even want to risk getting you pregnant, something must be wrong with you

  33. My wife and I have actually been dealing with this for quite some time, and I think last night we found a solution! My wife and I are AO (anal only) at the moment because she has some ongoing vaginal flora issues which are most likely related to the immunosuppressants she has to take on a daily basis.

    Both of us were partnerless for almost 10 years prior to meeting each other, so for both of us until we met each other, our sole form of cumming was jerking off.

    Fast forward to now, I can get hard and stay hard indefinitely, but no matter which hole of hers I’m fucking, I just cannot cum. Always feels fucking amazing, but I can’t cum. I’ve carved a deep groove into my brain where I can only cum from the optimal pressure and positioning my hand can provide.

    But one of my wife’s biggest turn-ons is me cumming inside her. She’s been begging my to fill her asshole with cum for the past few weeks.

    So last night, we tried something a little different. After fucking for a while, she got on her hands and knees on the floor, played with her pussy, and I fingered her asshole with 2 fingers while I jerked myself off.

    When I was ready to cum, I told her, and I slid my cock all the way, really balls deep in her ass, and proceeded to squirt out so much cum that her anal walls were completely soaked in cum.

    She fucking DIED! Just from me cumming in her ass, it set off a massive anal orgasm for her.

    I’ll have to work on uncarving the groove for when we want to have a baby, but for the time being this could be a decent workaround.

  34. You need a man who has had a vasectomy. Since I had mine, I love filling my woman with my seed. Sure I enjoy cumming in her mouth or on her face but nothing compares to claiming and owning her pussy.

  35. Obviously he was treated badly by his father who was obsessed with having an heir to carry on the family name. So at his fathers death bed, he swore that he would never have children, thus ending the family line.

  37. The easy answer is because kids are fucking expensive.

    I got fixed years ago and some part of my well trained brain STILL tries to pull out sometimes forgetting there is no chance of pregnancy.

  38. Maybe he just likes cumming on you. There’s something really erotic about cumming on your girl, almost pornographic. Seeing how much of your load you can cover your girl with. I enjoy cumming on girls (more so their tits than face). Bet that’s it versus him not wanting your babies

  39. You sha’ll talk about it before fucking and maybe ask why he wouldn’t do it so he can tell you why.
    And whatever it is he will some day cum inside you if you have the right argument.

  42. Same here. Like there’s morning after pill. I can never get a guy to finish inside of me. That pulling out shit hurts ya know. It’s now an requirement that a guy finish inside of me or I’m just gonna dump him and keep moving. At this point I’ll never be bred

  44. I think that the man in this situation is like me because I am absolutely terrified of a birth control failure or some sort of other thing happening and then I am suddenly a father.

  45. Ha! I had the same issue recently, but I’m 48 and (probably) way past kids. If I’m having good sex with a partner, I just adore being filled with cum. I love everything about it. I love it when he goes down on me after filling me up. I love it when he cums and fills me but can’t stop fucking me because if feels so good, so he doesn’t. I love when he fills me, takes a break, gets hard again and fucks it out of me before filling me up again. I love being in public and feeling it drip down my legs.

    I did what cumsluts since the beginning of time have done and I finally got that pussy full of cum from my lover, and it has honestly made already amazing sex even better.

  46. ??? he’s smart thats why he doesnt want to blow inside! If you get pregnant, he’s done! He’ll need to give child support regardless if you trick him or not.

    The guy is smart and wont fall for that kind of crap. Good on him

  47. He def doesn’t want to get you pregnant. Can you explain why so many women have this desire? As a guy i cant understand why us cumming in you can be so desireable from a “it feels really good” standpoint. Is it the warmth of the cum? The girl i hook up with wants this too and even though i check she’s on the pill i have to take her word for it. As a skeptical/careful guy it just feels like a primer for a pregnancy trap

    Hot story btw, just trying to understand the desire

  48. I mean I’m not one to throw caution to the wind when it comes to getting someone pregnant BUT COME ON! The woman is literally begging to be filled up, I don’t care what mindset you have about kids, you fill that little whore up! Hahaha, I was upset with him too reading this lol, good guy I’m sure but got damn! “She need some milk!”

  49. One of the reasons I got my vasectomy. Love creampies but didn’t want children.

    Hope you get it soon!

  50. get an IUD, then he can cum in you and not worry about it. They’re 99.9% effective

  52. well you know – theres a thing called pregnancy and being responsible for the kid when you have no intention of having a kid … you should prob. clarify that with em that if he does knock you up , you wont guilt him into being responsible

  54. I have always wanted to cum in my girlfriend. But she’s afraid of babies. I have explained her about all the precautions and even once got her excited about going through with it. But as soon as I was about to cum she instantaneously took my dick out and sucked the cum. I am not complaining but I guess I was disappointed at the time.

Comments are closed.