[M]y wi[f]e’s [f]irst threesome

“I don’t think I’m going to eat her pussy,” Anna said.

I chuckled.

“Sure thing, babe,” I said. “Whatever you feel comfortable with, it’s totally fine.”

And I meant it. It was, after all, going to be her first threesome, and I knew she was taking a big step by even trying. We’d had quite a few talks over the previous weeks, after she felt that she was ready for me to start looking for a woman to join us.

I’d had a decent amount of experience with non-monogamy and group activities in my 20s: a couple dozen threesomes between my ex-girlfriend (the subject of one of my earlier stories) and some fun friends with benefits. But Anna had been unlucky to have a series of vanilla boyfriends in her 20s; we met early in our 30s, and she was ready to try new things. I’d told her about wanting to have some level of non-monogamy during our first couple dates, and she’d said she’d always wanted to have a threesome, just never had a willing partner or a way to even find a ‘unicorn.’ Anna doesn’t identify as bi, but she’s always admired the female form and had always wanted to see what it would be like being with another woman.

So a few months into our relationship (several years ago) we got on OK Cupid and it wasn’t too long before we matched up with Laura. Laura right away seemed like a great match: she was cute and curvy, said she was open to couples, and had no problem with a couple who was looking for their first threesome together; she’d also never had a threesome, and was willing to go along for the ride and see how things went.

We met up for drinks and had a good, flirty time, enjoying each others’ company, so we set up a date for her to come over on a Saturday night, have some drinks, and see what happens. The few days leading up had a fun tension; Anna and I were both revved up thinking about Laura and the potential fun to come. But I knew, and Anna reminded me, that she wouldn’t know how she felt until we were in the middle of things, and we might not be able to go all the way.

Laura showed up at our place wearing a cute dress that showed off just the right amount of cleavage, with leggings underneath as it was a cool fall evening; Anna had put on a tank top that also showed off her fantastic tits. As both women were clearly a little nervous and not ready to jump into anything, we spent the first couple hours of the evening drinking margaritas, playing a board game and getting to know each other.

Eventually we ended up on the couch, watching a rerun of a movie we definitely didn’t want to watch. Anna cuddled up with me on my left side, and I asked her if she was ready to move forward a little bit. She was. So I motioned over to Laura, who came over and nuzzled up on my right. Soon after Anna had her hand over on Laura’s leg, tracing her way up her thigh. I began kissing Anna, then with her encouragement turned over to Laura, feeling her soft lips against mine.

The two of them leaned forward across me and kissed each other for the first time, and it was no gentle kiss; they were both clearly very into the situation, and spent a couple minutes making out while I watched. By this point Anna’s hand was up in between Laura’s legs, gently rubbing against the spot where her pussy waited underneath.

Anna’s shirt was the first to come off, her gorgeous tits immediately attracting Laura’s attention. Laura and I each took one of her breasts in our mouth, which brought a big smile to Anna’s face, and brought out her first little moan. I was already quite erect; Laura had her hand on my bulge, sliding her hand against my hardness through my jeans.

More clothes came off quickly, until both girls were down to just their panties. Anna (whose photos you can see below) is 5’4″, pale and perfectly curvy, with a fantastic ass and tits to match, and soft lips both on her face and between her legs. Laura, an inch or two shorter and a little curvier, was more on the tan side with thick thighs and nice C cups of her own; both of them were shaved all over. Anna’s vibe was good-girl-turned-bad; Laura’s fuck-me look was clearly well-practiced, and combined it was quite the sexy atmosphere.

Both were touching each other over their underwear, but still a little too shy to go inside. I got off the couch and between Anna’s legs, spreading them as I pulled her red lace panties down over her ankles and tossed them on the floor.

I ate Anna’s pussy while she made out with Laura and moaned, finally sliding her hand down Laura’s panties to feel how wet she’d made our new friend. Once Anna finished, I moved over and went down on Laura, her moans joining with Anna’s as she played with my girlfriend’s pussy.

“Do you want to watch me fuck my girlfriend?” I asked Laura after she came, and she nodded eagerly. Laying back on our couch and touching herself, she watched as I slid my throbbing 8” cock inside Anna, putting her legs up on my shoulders as I started going faster and faster. Laura came by touching herself, then came over to make out with Anna as I fucked her, sucking on her tits and kissing her neck as Anna came on me. I then sat on the couch as Anna rode me, Laura making out with both of us until I came.

The night wasn’t too far along, and none of us were ready to be done yet, so we spent a few minutes cuddling naked on the couch, making out a bit and talking about how much fun we were having. Pretty soon I started getting hard again, the kissing became more intense, and it was clear we were headed for Round Two.

That’s when Anna surprised me, and not for the first time. As we were sitting there on the couch she suddenly dropped down and spread Laura’s legs, diving face-first into her wet slit. She didn’t hold back, eating Laura’s pussy with enthusiasm, Laura not taking long to come on her tongue.

At that point I suggested we all head to the bedroom, and the women agreed. Once on the bed, Anna got back to riding me, and I could tell Laura was getting a little jealous. Laura wasn’t quite bi either, and as much fun as she was having with Anna, she definitely wanted some cock before the night was out. Anna had clearly been enjoying the evening more than either of us expected, so I asked her.

“Do you want me to fuck Laura?”

“Yes.”

Without hesitation I got on top of Laura and spread her legs, sliding in easily. Anna cuddled in close, kissing me as I started pumping Laura deep, her hands grasping the sheets. After a couple minutes I laid down and Laura got on top of me, grinding her hips against me until she came again; Anna then got on top and took her second load of the night.

Things wound down at that point, the three of us kissing and touching for a little while longer, everybody exhausted from pleasing each other and ourselves.

Once Laura left, Anna and I went back to the bedroom, where she told me she needed to “reclaim” me, then rode me harder than she ever had, cumming a few more times to finish out the evening. (She’s continued that tradition, every threesome we’ve had since).

Afterwards, I turned to Anna, still surprised by how much she’d been into the events of the evening.

“I thought you weren’t going to eat pussy!” I said.

“Yeah, well,” she said. “What can I say? I was having fun.”

~~~

*Names have been changed to protect the naughty*

If anybody’s curious, my wife is u/thefirekite. She’s got plenty of great photos on her profile, including a few of her with one of our partners, but unfortunately no shots from the night above. And yes, this story (as well as the others I’ve written) is completely true. Scout’s honor!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/l9mav2/my_wifes_first_threesome