This happened the second week of my senior year. I had matched with this freshman girl, a cute petite redhead with freckles and a firm body. She said she loved sweets and I told her she could come play with my chocolate (cheesy I know, but it worked). We exchange numbers and set a date about a week later.
As we texted, she told me about how this will be her first tinder date ever and that she was excited for it. I was concerned that she may be a bit too innocent for me, but my doubts vanished when she snapped me some nudes the night before our date.
We didn’t do anything too fancy, she came over wearing a black cropped tank top and some ripped jeans. She looked great in person and had a killer body. We hung out in the kitchen and talked for a bit while I made some drinks before settling on the couch. We watched some stupid TV and cuddled for a bit. I kissed her, and she kissed me back hard, grabbing my face and pulling it into hers. Before long she was sitting on me while I buried my face in her neck. She stopped me and told me “we aren’t having sex tonight”
Boys, if a girl ever says that to you, know that you 100% will have sex
Anyways, I smile and say “who said anything about sex” and go back to making out with her for a bit. We watch a few more episodes of the show and make out now and then, each time getting more heated than the last. By the time we were on episode 3, her tits were hanging out of her top and I was shirtless. I was rubbing her inner thighs, just inches from her pussy.
We drank and talked some more and soon enough, her jeans were unbuttoned and I was allowed access to her pussy. I was surprised to find her waxed and totally soaked. I pulled my fingers out and put them in her mouth. I asked her how she tasted, before kissing her finding out for myself. This drove her wild and she started rubbing me through my pants. I picked her up and carried her to the bed, setting her down gently.
I helped her take her pants off, and she was wearing nothing but a red thong that barely covered her puffy pink pussy. I stripped and got on top of her, making out with her some more. “We aren’t having sex” she told me, as she continued to run her hands all over my back. I didn’t say anything and kept making out with her, kissing her neck and sucking her little pink nipples.
We made out for maybe another 5 minutes when she whispered to me “do you have a condom”. I tried to hold back a shit eating grin as I reached for my nightstand and pulled one out. I took off my underwear that had been suffocating my raging boner and rolled it on. I pulled her thong to the side and lined up my head with her pussy, pushing gently.
She was very tight and was careful not to hurt her, but she was practically dripping so it didn’t take much effort to slide in all the way. She gasped as she took the last few inches and dug her nails into me. I gave her steady long strokes, which made her moan in pleasure. It wasn’t long until I felt her wrap her legs around me and her pussy contract and pulse around my cock. I pounded her in missionary for maybe another 15 minutes before her nubile pussy made me cum. I tossed the condom and collapsed next to her. She decided to spend the night, since her roommate would be still be awake or whatever. We spooned naked, and we fell asleep.
I woke up around 2:00am to find her grinding against me, half asleep. My cock was rock hard and in the crevasse of her asscheeks. The head was almost perfectly lined up with her pussy, which was coating my dick with its juices. I let her grind against me some more, enjoying the sensation as she reached a hand back to get the angle right and rocked her ass back onto my cock. I was now fully awake and balls deep inside this tight little pussy. I asked her what she was doing and if it was ok with her. She told me she was on the pill and that she trusted me. I decided to roll the dice since I was already balls deep. I didn’t have to do much work and I pulled the covers down to watch her throw her ass back and forth on my cock, milking me for cum. I couldn’t have lasted more than 10 minutes of this before I blew my cum deep inside her, feeling her pussy convulse again as she came right after me. I watched as my cum dribbled out of her, running down her thighs and staining my sheets.
The next morning I asked her what that was all about and she told me how she was so horny and that I was the second guy to fuck her. She mentioned that she loved getting cream pies from her boyfriend. “You mean ex boyfriend right?” I asked her. She said no, her boyfriend was a year younger and still in high school. I couldn’t help but feel sorry for the chap, as his girlfriend had my dried cum stuck to her leg as she texted him good morning.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/l27hpa/cheating_tinder_date18f_gets_creampied_mf
Loved the “roll the dice” line. So spot in. It makes it so much hotter