She wasn’t lying, the tightest girl I have ever come across [MF]

A little over a year ago I (M23) matched (Emma, 22) on tinder and hit it off, adding each other on Snapchat after a while. We continued to chat and agreed to meet up next week when we were both free. Emma was an open book, for the next week leading up to the date she was open about absolutely everything. Even when our conversation turned a little sexual, asking about what the other liked and so on, she didn’t shy away and told me more than I expected.

One night the conversation turned into light sexting. I was teasing her and I said something about making sure she cums before I do. To which she says that no guy has ever made her cum before. I didn’t believe this at all to begin with, she explained how it takes a lot for her to cum anyway and she usually gets close but has to take over to actually reach an orgasm.

Emma then said that the only thing that always makes her cum is her glass dildo, which I cheekily asked for a picture of. She sent the pic of it and I made a comment about it looking quite small. She confirmed that it was thinner than a normal dick but that she still needed a lot of lube to get it inside her, followed by more TMI about doctors visits about how tight her vagina is, being overly honest again lol. I said I liked how she trusted me with all this personal stuff, to which she replied, “I mean I feel like you’ll find out for yourself anyway”, and then all I could think about was fucking her.

Skipping to the date, Emma wore a body suit with her big (probably D-cup) tits almost bursting out of it. She was quite slim but I could see she had a good ass too, stood at about 5’7 (without her heels on) and had long brunette hair. The night went well, we had a nice dinner and a fair few drinks at different bars afterwards, and we were playing a game of pool in one place. She miss hit a shot and asked to take it again, looking at me with almost sad puppy dog eyes. So I said, “You can take your shot again if you kiss me”, and she instantly grinned, stepped towards me and we kissed for a good 10 seconds.

Later on when we walked into the last place we had planned to go to, we saw a huge queue at the bar and the place was packed. Emma turned to me and suggested we went back to hers to drink instead. She had said earlier in the week that she didn’t want to have sex on the first date, but I was wondering if she’d changed her mind. I was kinda hoping she had as I was on a long dry spell, the previous dirty talk and this kiss made me want her. Sure enough we get back to her bedroom and the kissing continues. I didn’t want to be the one to progress things further after what she had said but her hands kept wandering beneath my shirt and over my crotch, so I slipped the straps of her body suit down over her shoulders to see if she would stop me.

Of course this story wouldn’t be here if she had, her response was to pull my shirt up and off over my head. I pulled her body suit down more and her big tits popped out, I couldn’t keep my hands off them. We undress some more and now I’m playing with her clit and feeling how wet she is through her thong while she’s stroking my dick. Then Emma sits up as I lay on my back, she shuffles down her bed, pulls down my briefs, looks up at me and kisses my dick before taking it straight in her mouth. She spits all over it and gets sloppy which I love. I said I guess head doesn’t count as sex on the first date, she smirked and replied, “apparently not”.

The blowjob turned me on so much I couldn’t help myself, and I ask if she wants me to fuck her. She pauses for a second but looks at me with eyes that scream yes, fuck me. She’s toying with my dick in her hands now, teasing it, “Hmm what happened to no sex?”, she says. “I was wondering if you’d changed your mind”, I replied with a hopeful grin. She looks at me and pauses again when she eventually says, “It’s bad, but maybe I have”, as she moves to lay next to me on her back. She lifts her body up so that I can take her thong off, then bends her knees up and spreads her legs to reveal her clean shaven pussy.

I immediately kiss down her thigh and around her clit before licking her pussy completely with one sweep of my tongue, which makes Emma moan my name. While messaging she had also said about how guys can never be bothered to warm her up, so I made sure I used my tongue on her for a while, gauging her moans on what speed and pressure she liked. I could tell she was enjoying it, so I slowly slipped a finger inside her too and I could already tell how tight she was, I moved my finger up and down on her G spot to get her warmed up. I come up from between Emma’s legs and lean over her to kiss her again, and my dick falls down onto her clit. I tease her with it, moving my hard cock back and forth over her pussy.

“Get the lube”, she says while pointing to the top draw of her bedside table. I fully lube up my dick and get back in missionary. I ask if she wants my dick, she looks up at me with the same eyes as before and says, “Yes Max, please fuck me”. I lined my tip up with her entrance and began to push my length inside her. The lube really helped because my god she was not lying, Emma’s pussy was UNBELIEVABLY tight. It felt like it was holding onto my dick as I was pulling out of her, gripping on to me. It took a minute or so of slow strokes to ease the whole thing inside, I asked if it hurt and she said it was hurting at the start but not anymore.

I took that as my hint to speed up a little, I gave her a few more long strokes and it felt so amazing I couldn’t help myself and began to fuck her properly. Hearing her moans get louder and watching her tits bounce away was like a weight off my shoulders. But that incredible feeling didn’t last long as I felt I was about to cum. Confused and a bit embarrassed I blurt it out, but with out missing a beat Emma says, “Yes cum inside me, fill me up Max”, and I simply couldn’t hold on as I exploded inside her with her tight pussy squeezing my load out of me.

I didn’t know what to say. I usually pride myself on my good stamina, I always last for a good length of time (sometimes too long) and I had never finished prematurely before. I lasted no longer than 2 minutes fucking her. But surprisingly she didn’t seem to mind, saying we’d just have to try again. It must have been a combination of my dry spell, the blowjob and her incredibly tight pussy but I still couldn’t get over how quickly I’d just finished.

We woke up late the next morning and Emma had to rush to get ready for work. She said she would message me afterwards as I left her place to head home. All day I couldn’t stop thinking about next time, I wanted to feel her tight pussy again. I had to make up for last night.

So when the time came, I made sure I didn’t disappoint…

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/kp806j/she_wasnt_lying_the_tightest_girl_i_have_ever