[FM] I (21) Got Fingered by My BF’s Graduated Frat Bro (25)

I had previously met my BF’s Graduated Frat Bro when I started dating my BF and he took me to parties hosted by him. In fact, he was (is?) my BF’s Big. I always thought he was cool. He was nice. Seemed to care about my BF and me. Just overall gave off nice older brother vibes.

Needless to say, I tend to show off my 36D/34DD tits whenever I go to college parties. So it isn’t uncommon to me to receive compliments on them from my BF’s tipsy/drunk frat bros. And even before I dated my BF’s I would get these compliments and I never minded them. In fact, I like the attention my tits get me. So when my BF’s Big (his name is Marty), would casually tell me my tits looked nice (always in front of my BF, he never made any inappropriate comments when my BF wasn’t around, nor did he do so anywhere that wasn’t a party), it didn’t seem odd or weird. I was used to getting that type of attention, specially at parties. And as I said, I actively enjoy the attention. The fact that it was coming from Marty was a little plus. I mean, he had similar features to my BF and a nice beard.

He was a bit shorter than my BF, 5’6. (I’m only 5’2 and I’m not a huge fan of guys that tower over me. It makes sex tricky and photos awkward. So I prefer guys that are definitely taller than me but not objectively tall. 5’7-5’10 being my preferred range). He had black hair, nice eyebrows, and nice biceps. All like my bf.

Anyway, nothing ever really happened between us cuz he wasn’t about to mess with his Little’s GF and I don’t cheat.

He was a Senior our Freshman year, but he had to stay an extra year and was a Super Senior. Then, he graduated and moved one state over to get a job in a law firm. We don’t see him very often at all, but he does come back to town to visit friends every once in a while. He and my BF talk fairly often as they have a SC streak. Us on the other hand, didn’t talk very often. He would occasionally reply to my stories and we would have a short conversation and that was it. Nothing inappropriate.

It is worth noting though that he would reply to my BF’s stories and posts and tell him how hot I was, how nice my tits looked in that particular picture, or that he was very lucky to have me and get to fuck me. Luke (my BF) has always enjoyed the attention I get from other guys and at times, other girls. He’s always found it hot knowing that there were other people that listed after me but would never get to fuck me for as long as we were together.

Eventually, at some point, after one of those times that Marty replied to a post saying that my tits were amazing and that he would love to give them a squeeze. He had framed it as a joke. After all, it was common for the bros to comment on each other’s girls. Luke showed me the message and explained Marty had been doing this for a while. I was surprised. I wondered how many of his friends had sent him similar messages about me. I was also impressed by how respectful Marty was. Any other guy would be simply say those things to me directly and actively avoid letting my BF know they thought I was hot. But, like the attention whore I am, I was also flattered.

Luke then surprised me further by asking if he could offer to show him some of my bra & panty pics. Unbeknownst to Luke, by that point, I was actively showing these types of pics to complete strangers AND getting paid for them. So I agreed, but asked him to make sure to cover up my face and ask him to NOT save my pics. I’m a bit paranoid of my content being leaked (happened thrice already ?) or even worse, it being leaked and me suffering consequences (hasn’t actually happened yet, and hopefully, never does). So with my permission, he offered and Marty said yes so he started sharing saucy pics of me. Nothing too revealing really. Just bra and panty pics. Pretty much beach pics but without the beach. Needless to say, Marty absolutely loved all the pics he was seeing of me. They only got 5 photos in before Marty offered to show Luke pics of girls he had dated/fucked/sexted with. Luke told him he wasn’t sure that was ok and that he would have to ask me. After all, he had told him he had asked me about sharing pics with him. Marty replied telling him it should be fine since it’s pretty much just porn. Porn that wasn’t professional and hasn’t been posted all over the Internet. Luke asked me about it and Marty had a point. And even if Marty hadn’t tried to convince him, I would’ve let him. Cuz it really is the way Marty explained it. It’s not like he’s receiving these pics directly from the girls or anything. It’s just two bros sharing porn. So they started trading pics of me for pics of girl’s Marty had done stuff with. They were at it for about an hour. At the end of it all, Marty messaged me saying thank you for letting Luke share those pics with him. I told him it was my pleasure and that was that.

They would trade every couple of weeks and it did in fact, escalate. But going over all of that would be time consuming and I’ll probably cover that another day. But today, I’m hear to tell you guys about he ended up fingering me. And I’m sorry it’s taking a while. I just like to really tell a story the way it happened with all the context. So stayed tuned for whenever I get around to typing up how the whole trading thing escalated.

Eventually, in early July this year, I got a message from Marty. It started as casual chit chat but eventually it turned towards the whole trading thing we had all been doing. We never directly sexted or anything. It was always with Luke and via his phone. So I wasn’t sure where this was going. Marty then explained how he had been enjoying everything we had been doing: seeing my pics, my vids, making Luke cum with pics/vids of his past girls, etc. However, he wanted more, but wasn’t sure if Luke or I would go for it. He had figured he would risk it with me first. He wanted to come to town to finger me and play with my tits. No sex, no mouth stuff. Just hands exploring my body. Seemed like a modest request and I was down. BUT I explained to him that I don’t cheat. He told me he obviously would want to Luke to be aware and did plan on asking both of us. But I explained to him that I don’t do anything with other guys unless I’m getting paid. I told him about the massages I had given to [John](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/eholgv/fm_massaging_my_bfs_friend/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf) and [Frankie](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/geys77/fm_massaging_another_one_of_my_boyfriends_friends/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf)

He was actually surprised to be hearing about all the juicy details. He knew them both but apparently they had done a good job of not telling anyone about the blowjobs and in Frankie’s case, the 69ing. As far as the group of friends new, all I did with John and Frankie was massage them and give them a happy ending with my hand. No one knew I had blown John or that I had 69ed Frankie. And only Luke knew I had ended up blowing Frankie. I guess my threat of squeezing his balls until I crushed them had kept him from telling the whole campus.

He then asked me how much I would charge him to finger me and play with my tits. I told him it would be $100. And that he needs to ask Luke and that we would redo this dealing with Luke as intermediary. I found it the most appropriate way to do it since every thing else had been down with Luke involved. So we did just that. He asked Luke if he could finger me and play with my tits. We did the whole deal where I explain I only do stuff with other guys for money. Luke was a bit hesitant but I told him it’s would pretty much be the inverse of what I had done with John and Frankie and that I was actually in fact going to be getting paid for receiving pleasure. He agreed but made sure to tell both of us that it would only be hand stuff. That was it. Marty then asked if I could also stroke his cock since I had already done that with John and Frankie. Luke said sure but that it was up to me how much extra that would be. Before I could decide on a price, Marty said he really could only pay $100 so he would stick to just touching me and would just stroke himself.

So we were all on the same page and started making plans for Marty to come to town. The day he had off from work was a day Luke would be out of town to visit family. But that was fine since Luke trusted me and Marty.

The day came. I had actually overslept. I woke up to a missed call notification from Marty from an hour ago. I frantically called him. He had driven like 3 hours and apparently had had to wait an hour. I apologized and explained I overslept. He said it was fine because he had gotten lunch with a friend and told me they were wrapping up and that he would be over soon.

While I waited for him, I got ready. Brushed my teeth, tried to fix my hair some, and changed into some booty shorts instead of the pj pants I was wearing. I also decided to put on a bra under my tank top for optimum cleavage.

He arrived and I took him to the bedroom. We sat on the bed awkwardly making small talk about his move and stuff. Eventually, he decided it was time to address the elephant in the room.

Marty: “So…….shall we get started or would you rather we just don’t?”

Me: “Yeah, for sure. Let me just take off my shorts.

I hopped off the bed and made sure to bend over sensually to show off my ass and my pussy from behind. I hadn’t slept with panties and I hadn’t put any on when I changed. Once my shorts and panties hit the floor, I turned around to find him with his mouth open.

Me: “You’ve seen all of this before. I don’t know why you’re so surprised.”

Marty: “Yeah, but it’s so much hotter in person. I’ve wanted to see your pussy in person for so long and I finally get to.

I got back on the bed and sat next to him. He reached over and started rubbing my pussy. I was definitely getting wet from the whole situation, but he was rigid. Probably nervous. I’m sure he hadn’t gotten himself in a situation like this. I’m sure most of his previous hookups have been more “traditional” where he just straight up fucks a stranger from Tinder. I don’t know. Anyway, I could feel how rigid he was and it was Lowkey ruining the vibe. But I definitely wanted this to work. Mostly cuz I needed those $100. So I had an idea.

Me: “I see you’re kinda nervous.”

Marty: “Yeah. Sorry. I’m in my head. I’ve never paid for anything like this before.”

Me: “It’s ok. Just don’t think of it. Just think it’s just you and me. No money changing hands.”

Marty: “Ok. I’ll try.”

Me: “Better yet, you know what? What if I pull up some of my pics and some of my videos? They’re mostly stuff you’ve already watched but maybe that’ll help?”

Marty: “Yeah, ok, that sounds like that could work.”

So I pulled out my phone and started going through my content. Call me a narcissist, but I actually really enjoy seeing and watching my own stuff. I guess it’s mostly because they bring back the memories so explicitly and take me back to that moment in time. Either way, as we watched my videos and swiped through my pics, I felt him ease up and improve his fingering. As he got more relaxed and more into it, I could tell he was pitching a tent in his pants. Not a huge tent, but a tent nonetheless.

His hand then left my pussy and went up to my tits. He started squeezing them and feeling me up over my clothes as I put my phone down. I could feel my nipples yearning for his touch so I pulled down my tank top and brought my tits out over my bra. He gently caressed my nipples and gave them gentle pinches before taking on the task of full on squeezing both tits with his hands. He smiled as he realized they were a handful and a half each. I could tell this was like a dream come true for him, being able to play with my tits. After all, out of the girls he had sent to us, I think only two of them had tits that seemed to be as big as mine.

He then interrupted my pleasure to ask if I would mind if he stroked himself. I told him it was totally fine since we had previously discussed it with Luke. He pulled his pants and boxers off and his cock flung out. It wasn’t big by any means. It looked small compared to Luke’s. In fact, it was probably as big as Frankie’s maybe a tiny bit bigger, so about 5-5.5 in. He started stroking it as he continued to finger me. By now, he was fully comfortable with the situation and determined to make us both cum. As I sat there enjoying the pleasure, he eyed my pussy and my tits taking it all in as much as he could. He asked if he could suck my tits or maybe even eat me out. I told him we hadn’t discussed it with Luke, but that if we was willing to pay another $100, it could be our little secret just how it was John & I’s secret that I blew him or how it was Frankie & I’s secret that we 69ed. He replied telling me it would have to wait until next time because he didn’t have any extra money to spend.

He continued to finger me before asking me to pull up a video of me riding Luke’s cock. I was more than pleased to bring it up as I love showing off my riding skills, plus, you get such a good view of my tits. As we watched video on loop, I noticed him fingering me faster and stroking his cock faster as well. It didn’t take much longer for him to cum. I watched his cock carefully as it twitched and a stream of cum gushed out of it and onto his stomach. Watching him cum got me hornier. I love being the reason for someone’s orgasm. I started feeling my own orgasm building within me. He had kept his cum covered hand on his dick as it softened. All the while, he kept the same determined energy fingering my pussy. I could feel myself getting close, but I knew I needed him to focus exclusively on my clit if I was going to actually cum. Between moans, I managed to tell him to focus just on my clit. As he did so, I could feel myself getting so close to cumming. I was receiving such pleasure that I had to put my phone down. I closed my eyes and a second later, I came all over his fingers.

I sat there relishing in my orgasm for a moment, before getting up to get him our cum towel. Now, I had two guys’ cum on that towel. He thanked me for doing this and sent me the money. I told him I had fun and that I was glad I could help him cum. He told me we should arrange for another time when we could maybe have some extra fun like eating me out and sucking on my tits. I agreed and told him we should talk to Luke about it. He put on clothes and I put my tits back into my bra and tank top and walked him to our door still without any bottoms. We said our good byes and he was on his way.

Later that night, Luke called me and asked how it went. I told him all about it and even told him Marty had asked to eat me out and suck my tits but that I had rejected him since we hadn’t discussed that. I told him how he had said we should arrange for that to happen at some point and to not be too surprised if he brought it up.

After that event, we went back to the usual trading every couple of weeks. We still keep in touch with him and hopefully at some point, we can arrange for him to come eat me out and suck my tits.

NOTE: No, my boyfriend is not a cuck. No, we don’t have an open relationship. That’s why I don’t tend to do stuff with other guys and when I do, I get paid. So please don’t fill the comments calling him cuck or trying to persuade me into making it an open relationship. The way our relationship is works for the both of us perfectly and we like it as is.

NOTE 2: Yes, this was this July. During a pandemic. It happened after the stay at home order had been lifted from his state and it had been softened in our state. We felt safe having this arrangement as we had both been very careful about going on unnecessary errands and always wore our masks even before there were mask mandates. We had both also been tested for COVID-19 and both got negative results. Up to that point, he hadn’t been exposed to anyone with COVID-19. And neither had I nor Luke. Please don’t fill the comments saying that we were stupid for meeting up in the middle of a pandemic. We were safe about it. No one got COVID-19 because of the encounter, and I REALLY needed the fun and the $100

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/kiuab0/fm_i_21_got_fingered_by_my_bfs_graduated_frat_bro