The College Reunion, Part Four (of 6); Jenna & Leah Tell Their Story

Jenna & Leah’s Story, part one (told my Jenna)

Pre-kids there was a time at my parents lake place where the four of us ended up skinny-dipping together. That was when all of us were in our 20’s and had too much to drink, but it just kind of happened and we all went along with it.

Five years ago when Leah and I turned 35, we did a trip to Mexico with our husband’s. I’m not sure when and how things got to the point they did, but it was definitely fun for all four of us.

After a long day (and night) of drinking Leah’s husband Justin joked that we should all go skinny-dipping in the ocean for old times sake, which of course was backed up by my husband Mark. I’m not sure what got into Leah and I, but it sounded like a decent idea and next thing I know, we’re going along with it and the four of us are naked in the ocean.

After 15 minutes or so of acting like teenagers we dressed on the beach and went back to the hotel. Both Justin and Leah agreed to join us for a nightcap.

Earlier in the evening Mark and I had told our butler to have a hot bath waiting for us when we got back. I had forgotten all about it until I saw it prepared in our bathroom. Justin and Mark were out on the balcony having a drink and cigar, so I invited Jenna to join me in the large bath.

We’ve seen each other naked before and really had nothing to hide, besides we both kept our undies on and had just been skinny-dipping anyway.

A little while later Mark came in and saw the two of us in there and asked if we wanted company. We both agreed that would be fine. When he came back with Justin I think both of us were surprised when they stripped all the way down. I thought they’d stop at boxers. And while we had all just been skinny-dipping together less than an hour ago, that was in the dark. This was more up-close and personal.

Each husband sat behind their wife and we just talked. No big deal. We might have been a little tight with four people in there, but we made it work. I know Mark’s hands were wandering a little under the water, like I’m sure Justin’s were too, but none of us could see anything.

When we got out I borrowed Leah one of our robes, while the guys just wrapped towels around their waists. I’m still unsure why none of us ever bothered getting dressed, but we didn’t.

Out on the balcony Justin remarked about how he hated they didn’t have one, because he wanted to fuck Leah outside on the trip. I knew he was partially joking and so did Mark, but Mark told him to go for it with an audience. Much to my surprise, Justin loosened Leah’s robe and let it fall off her shoulders.

Silence came over all of us. I know I wasn’t uncomfortable and neither was Mark, but how far was this going to play out? Maybe more surprising was how comfortable Leah was standing there naked on our balcony, overlooking the ocean with the breeze in her face and an audience admiring her body.

She reached back and undid the towel around Justin’s waist. It was the first time I’d ever saw my best friend’s husband in a state of arousal like that. His hands rubbed up and down her body, over her perky breasts and down to a splendid ass. As he did this, his arousal was obviously growing.

Clearly distracted by what was in front of me, I hadn’t even noticed that Mark had loosened my own robe. I’m not sure our friend’s had either as both paid special attention to their partner.

Leah seemed to read her husband’s mind and bent over slightly in front of him. Justin placed his now hard cock at her entrance. Slowly he pushed his cock forward with Mark and I watching in amazement as it disappeared into her, a satisfied gasp escaping from her lips.

I must have looked like I was in a trance. My eyes were fixated on our best friends having sex right in front of us and I couldn’t look away. Mark, while also watching them intently, was now focusing more on me. My robe and his towel had both been completely discarded.
Before I knew it, I was standing over the top of my husband as he prepared to fuck me. I looked to our friends again who were now also paying attention to us. I lowered, Mark’s cock sliding into me easily.

While the two of us slowly made love to one another, Justin was now starting to pump into his wife as a more rapid rate. The intensity of their love-making also resulted in a more audible Leah. The sight of watching Justin plow into his wife and my best friend was starting to overcome me. Unable to hold it back, I soaked Mark’s cock with my cum.

My orgasm must have done it for Justin and Leah, too, as they both grunted each other’s name and came simultaneously. I kept bouncing up and down on Mark’s cock and before long he was filling me up with his cum.

I’d like to say the four of us came to our senses, but we didn’t. Once inside the room we all jumped into our large shower and kind of started things up again. Just lots of touching and feeling and rubbing. After the shower, it was into our bedroom for round two.

Mark and I fucked right alongside Justin and Leah. You name the position, and we tried it that evening / morning. In fact, they didn’t go back to their own room until the sun was rising. I think all four of us fell asleep for an hour or so in our king-sized bed, woke up and made love to our partners again.

I can’t speak entirely for Leah, but I know it was an absolute incredible sexual experience for Mark and I.

That’s our story!

“Holy shit!” exclaimed Emma. “That’s fucking hot!”

“So there was never any extra playing going on?” asked Teresa. “I mean, with someone other than your partner?”

Jenna and I kind of looked at one another and we were busted.

“I don’t think we’re getting the entire story,” said Maggie, looking each of us over.

“Ok, ok….so there’s one more part that happened the next day,” I admitted. “Should I tell them Jenna?” I asked her.

“I suppose we have to,” she replied.

Jenna & Leah’s Story, part two (told by Leah)

The previous night had been a first for Justin and I. I was actually worried about what it might do to our friendship. All four of us had drank way too much. Justin insisted it wasn’t that big of a deal but you all know how girls just think a little different.

That day everything seemed pretty normal around the pool. I think all of us were a little embarrassed but as a group we didn’t really discuss it. I knew I had to say something to Jenna, so when the guys were off doing their thing and we were laying by the pool, I brought it up.

“So, last night,” I said. “Is everything ok with all of us?”

“I think so,” replied Jenna. “Is everything ok with you and Justin?”

“Oh yeah, it’s fine,” I insisted. “I just wanted to be sure all was fine with us. Things got a little carried away.”

“They certainly did,” agreed Jenna. “But I don’t think we’re the first couples to have sex in front of one another.”

“No, probably not, but you know how it is,” I said. “I just didn’t want there to be anything awkward between the four of us.”

“You’re fine, and thanks for asking,” said Jenna. “That said, I know Mark would be up for it again.”

“He said that,” I asked her.

“No, he didn’t. But he’s a guy. Last night was fun for him. And if I’m being completely honest, it was a lot of fun for me, too,” Jenna assured me.

“Same here,” I replied. “Justin was like an animal today, and I’d be lying if I didn’t say I really enjoyed it, too.”

“Is it something you’d do again?” Jenna asked.

“Is that an invitation?” I jokingly asked back, making Jenna blush. “Truthfully, I know Justin would do it again without even having to ask him. And me? Yes, I think I’d probably do it again. It was pretty damn hot, plus you two are our best friends and we’re on vacation.”

Without either of us saying it out loud, I think we had just agreed it was something we were going to try again that night if it presented itself.

I know when I mentioned something to Justin he was all for it. A text from Jenna confirmed they were in, too.

After dinner that night we went back to their room again. Something felt different. It was the alcohol, or lack thereof. All of us knew it, so after mixing some stiff drinks and doing a few shots, the four of us loosened up.

“Anybody for a shower?” I joked, trying to move things along.

I’m not sure the four of us could have stripped down faster. While I was feeling a steady buzz, I was also more aware of what was going on than the night before. The previous evening was just a little foggy in how we got to that point.

I noticed Jenna’s breasts more. They’re beautiful. Her nipples were erect and her body so smooth. I also paid extra attention to Mark. He really did have a nice cock. Justin’s is much more curved, while Mark’s stands straight out.

“Your boobs are so perky,” Jenna said reaching to me, out and fondling them.

This took me by surprise and certainly made me blush. Without thinking, I ran my hands over her full mounds. They were so firm. Of course, Jenna had one of the better doctors in the midwest work on them.

“I never realized last night how curved Justin’s cock is when it’s erect. Do you mind if I just feel it?” she asked. “I’ll let you touch Mark’s.”

I’m not sure why, but her asking to feel my husband’s dick really turned me on. The guys didn’t say anything. I think they realized it was best if they just kept their mouths shut.

“If it’s ok with Justin, it’s ok with me,” I told Jenna. “You alright with that honey?” I asked Justin.

He just nodded his approval.

“Is it ok if I touch Justin?” Jenna asked her husband. Mark agreed.

And so it was. In no time Jenna and I were both jerking off the others spouses. As I played with Mark’s cock I kissed my husband passionately.

“I think we need to get out and take this to the bedroom,” I suggested.

On this night we didn’t bother with robes or towels. The four of us just collapsed into Jenna and Mark’s bed.

After some sensual foreplay between Justin and I, I got on all fours and he entered me from behind. I love when my husband fucks me doggystyle.

Laying next to me was Jenna between Mark’s legs, working her mouth over his cock. I’m not sure what came over me, but my natural instincts kicked in.

“Would you mind if I put that in my mouth?” I asked Jenna, with Justin’s cock still filling me.

I’m not sure I waited for the answer. While Justin was ramming my pussy, Jenna and I took turns with her husband’s cock in our mouths, even stealing kisses.

That was just the beginning of the evening. We never did do a full swap with Jenna and Mark, but everything else was fair game the rest of that trip. Both Jenna and I were able to enjoy having our husband’s fuck us while we sucked the others cock. The best was maybe sucking Mark’s cock just after he’d take it out of Jenna’s pussy.

That trip is one that will forever bring a smile to my face. I still can’t believe how much fun we all had and how it seemed to bring us all closer. Wow….I’m hot now!

So that’s the whole story!

“Are you fucking kidding me?” Teresa asked with a scream. “Holy shit! I don’t care what anyone says, but that was hot!”

“Even I’m blushing from that one,” exclaimed Maggie. “Do you the four of you still play with each other?”

“Truthfully, nothing like that has ever happened again,” replied Jenna. “I’m not going to rule it out again, though.”

“Yeah, it was a lot of fun,” I replied. “But like Jenna said, we haven’t done it since and I don’t think we’d rule it out, either.”

“Do you think you could do it with another couple?” asked Emma.

“I know we couldn’t,” said Jenna.

“Same here. The thought is exciting but doing it with our best friends made it more special,” I said.

“So did the two of you play with each other?” asked Maggie. “I mean, besides the feeling each other up?”

“No, we didn’t,” insisted Jenna. “We kissed a little, but that was it.”

“Well, I never thought I’d say this, but Maggie has some work to do if she’s going to top that one,” sighed Teresa. “But before you start Mags, I need another drink! Yowzers!”

The five of us freshened up our drinks and settled back into our normal spots.

“You’re up, Maggie!” exclaimed Emma.

To be continued.

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/kf5dj7/the_college_reunion_part_four_of_6_jenna_leah