2011 was a wild and sex filled summer for me. One experience I won’t forget was with 20 year old college volleyball player named Sarah. Sarah just happened to be one of my best friend’s cousin.
I was 23 that August afternoon when I met her at our apartment pool. She was in town seeing her cousin, my buddy Ryan. Ryan and I went to college together and also lived in the same apartment complex. Our summer weekends at the time consisted of getting hammered at the wild pool parties at our apartment and then heading out to the bars. It was carefree living at its finest!
At the pool that day I ran into a girl I used to hookup with in college. She was one of my friends sorority sisters. Kayla and I used to hook up freshman year but then she got into a long term relationship and we drifted apart. She lived a few hours away, but earlier that summer she came in to town and we drunkenly made out and she gave me a handjob on my friends couch on my birthday. She told me she and the BF had broken up because he was an asshole. Turns out she was lying about that… the next morning after the birthday handjob she was so ashamed at what she did that she left and drove back home and I didn’t see her again until several months later at the pool. Turns out she was visiting her friend Megan who lived across the hall from Ryan. Ryan and Megan were FWB I should add.
I say “hi” to Kayla but she’s clearly uncomfortable and awkward so I leave her alone. Ryan mentions his cousin Sarah is coming to visit before she drives back up to college. She’s stopping by and coming to the pool. A few hours later we’re all buzzing pretty nicely and about to head back to our apartments to get ready for the evening festivities. That’s when Sarah finally shows up.
In walks this tall, athletically thick, blonde. She’s not by any means super hot but she has this cute athletic look to her. Turns out she plays college volleyball which is perfect for her 5’11 frame. She’s wearing a loose fitted tshirt and some volleyball shorts that show off her thick thighs and ass. She’s dressed pretty casually because she’s been packing all day. She just wanted to stop by and say hi before she drove 2ish hours back up to school.
We offer her a beer and she accepts even though she says she shouldn’t because she’s trying to stay in top shape for the season coming up. Sarah and I hit it off and immediately I get the vibe that this girl is cool as fuck. She’s into sports, drinking beer, she loves beer pong, and she loves the show Workaholics (which at the time was a huge hit for our demographic). We’re talking and really hitting it off. We invite her to stay and go out with us. She says sure and she has some going out clothes in her car. She then makes a joke about how we’re the same height so she can’t wear heels and stand next to me. I’m really digging this girl’s sense of humor too. We both get pretty flirty with each beer.
We all head over to Ryan’s to pregame before we go to the bar. In walk Kayla and Megan… Kayla had noticed me at the pool talking and flirting with Sarah. She wasn’t happy about it. She pulls me into the bathroom and lifts up her sun dress to reveal her pussy. “This could finally be yours tonight if you stop talking to that fucking girl” she tells me. I ask her about her boyfriend and she says “I don’t care about that fat asshole right now. This pussy is waiting for you if you want it.” She then gives me a kiss and slides my hand onto her pussy and says “Remember when I’d only let you finger me in the dorms and you always wanted more? Well this is your chance.”
We then leave the bathroom. I’m stuck with a major decision. Do I keep talking to Sarah and see where it goes, or do I finally take get to fuck Kayla. Kayla was a tan blonde that was about 5’7. She was a tad chubby as she had put on about 15 lbs since I had seen her earlier that summer. She was still attractive and I always had a thing for curvier girls anyway.
We exit the bathroom and are back into the party. Sarah comes up to me and she looks hot! She’s got on daisy dukes that show off her athletic, long, toned legs and a white tank top with a red bra showing through. She asks if I want to play beer pong with her. We play a few games and have a lot of fun together. I see Kayla from across the room giving me the stink eye. Sarah notices it and asks what’s that girl’s deal. I explain that we used to kinda talk in college and that she’s jealous I’m not paying her any attention. When I saw that a light goes off in Sarah’s head. I make a cup in beer pong and Sarah gives a very noticeable and sensual hug and a flirty kiss on the cheek. I can tell she’s doing this to annoy Kayla. A few hours go by and it’s getting close to time to go to the bars. Ryan and Megan are no where to be seen. Sarah is off with some of the other girls at the pregame taking shots and getting to know people. That’s when Kayla shoots her shot. “I’m going over to Megan’s. Come over there with me to get them so we can go to the bars,” she says. I drunkenly follow her across the hall. What we walk into we both weren’t expecting. Megan had a studio apartment with a divider wall for the bedroom and living room. The lights are off and we hear fucking going on. Ryan is railing Megan over the edge of the bed. They both stop and look at us and just tell us to turn the lights off if we want. They then go back to fucking. Kayla turns the lights off and pushes me onto the couch. She starts kissing on my neck and whispers to me that hearing Megan get fucked turns her on and makes her jealous. She wants us to compete with them. I’m intrigued by the idea so we start making out.
She tells me to start fingering her. She’s soaking wet and I get so hard from anticipation of my dick sliding in her dripping pussy. She unbuttons my shorts, slides down my boxers and starts ducking my dick. I’ve been waiting years for this!
I’m fingering her still and it makes her mouth even more enthusiastic. She then gets stage fright as she hears Megan moan and dirty talk. It finally clicks with her that other people are going to hear her fuck. She clamps up. She pulls her head up and says let’s go try in the bathroom. I follow her in there and she hops up on the counter. As I pull my dick back out she says she can’t do this. She loves her bf (the same guy she just said was a fat asshole 3 hours ago) and that they’re going to get engaged. I say ok, and that I’m heading out. She starts crying and is upset that she cheated on him again. I leave the bathroom and never see her in person again. She now has 3 kids with the “fat asshole”… (he’s actually a nice guy from what Megan said).
I go back to the party once my erection is gone. Ryan and Megan are still fucking and it’s loud so it was not easy to lose my erection. Megan was a freak! She loved to have her asshole fingered while she got fucked from behind… at least that’s what I kept hearing her say.
Back at the party I walk in to see Sarah talking to another guy. Fuck… I blew it I thought. She sees me walk back in and kind of ignores me. I get it, and I can’t say I blame her. I was thinking with my dick. The apartment starts to clear out as everyone starts heading to the bar. Sarah can’t go because she is only 20 and her fake ID basically only works on shitty college bars. She asks if I’d stay back with her because it will only be her by herself. Ryan was not back over because he and Megan were either fucking or had gone to the bar. I tell her I’ll stay back and hangout for a bit.
We turn on the tv and sit on the couch. We’re sitting extremely close together and start making out. All of the sudden stops and looks me straight in the eyes. I think to myself that I’m about to strike out twice in one night. “I want to suck your dick, but I’m not going to have sex with you tonight. I promise we can have sex if you come up and visit me in a few weeks.”
“Sounds like a deal to me,” I tell her. I pull off my shorts and she gets on the ground on her knees and pulls out my cock. She starts licking up and down the shaft and sucking the head gently. It’s amazing and worlds better than the one Kayla gave me. She takes me deep into her throat. It feels incredible. I stroke her blonde hair and moan in pleasure. She pulls my cock out of her mouth. It’s dripping with precum and her slobber. She’s massaging as she asks “where do you want to cum?”
I tell her she gets to pick. So she takes off her shirt and I see her natura c cups pushed up in her red bra. She rubs the head of my dick all over her tits before she puts it back in her mouth. She begins bobbing up and down and making the sloppiest, wet noises with her mouth. I tell her I’m getting close so she gets even more enthusiastic. I let out a moan and a heads up that I’m about to cum. Right then and there she takes me deep into her mouth. She made up her mind about where she wanted me to cum. I filled her mouth and throat with my cum. She moaned as entered her mouth.
She opened her mouth and showed me that she swallowed. “How do you like that?” she asked.
I was at a loss for words.
“Just wait until you get to visit me.” she replied. She then put her shirt back on and went to get some water.
We sat back on the couch and fell asleep together. The next morning we woke up hungover and she asked me to walk her to her car. We exchanged numbers and made out. She reassured me that she wanted me to visit her.
Part 2, “the visit” coming soon…
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/k956h8/mf_an_old_hookup_a_new_fling_and_2_blowjobs
When’s part 2 coming out