[MF] A one-time sexual encounter that gave both of us a cum fetish

This is a little long because almost every detail is permanently burned into my brain, and figured I’d share every bit! Ages reflect ours at the time – I was 23, she was 19. I’m 36 now.

Years ago I had started talking to this girl after posting an ad on craigslist (before dating apps!). Once I determined she was actually a real person, I got a photo – really cute, a petite 5’0″, long dark brown hair and a great smile. Her body was well-developed for her age and I could hardly believe someone this cute would actually contact me through a sketchy website. For comparison at the time, I’m 5’10”, a wider and somewhat muscular build.

After talking for a bit, we go on a date – pretty standard chatty lunch just feeling each other out. I propose we walk towards where she lives because it’s on the way to my place and we can talk more. As we walk, I decide to try to get a little more personal and see how she reacts. I find out that she has only had one sexual encounter before, and isn’t sure what she likes. Not too surprising for someone 19. I don’t prod too far, because it’s our first time meeting and since she’s young I don’t want to push into uncomfortable territory and turn her off.

As we get closer to her place I can tell in her body language that she doesn’t want it to end. I had prepared for this and asked if she wanted to stop by a park nearby. An unequivocal nod and we keep going. It’s at this point that I figure I can start to push my luck a little, although I have no end-goal in mind. I find her cute and fun to talk with and I’m always willing to continue a flirty conversation.

While we’re at the park we sit at a bench, and luckily not many people around. I sit much closer to her so that our legs are firmly touching with a bit of pressure (side-note, she told me she was a Taurus before and I had to look up what that meant, so I knew to be heavy on the touch). She didn’t recoil at all and I noticed her draw a deep breath, probably unsure of what my next move would be. These are good signs, I think.

We talk for a little bit while I plan my next move. I wait for the conversation to create an opening to make another touch. I believe it was something about hands, but now we have to compare ours. I place mine on top of hers to show how much larger they are than hers. She stops talking at that moment and I slowly clutch her hand, which her body welcomes. In the nervous electricity of that moment, I pull on her hand gently to make her body twist slightly as I move in for a kiss. Again, without words, her body welcomes this. Now we’re making out in the park and I had run my hand up her arm to massage her neck as we kissed. At this point we both start to notice that we’re still in the park and a little embarrassed, so I propose we continue again at my place.

We walk fairly quickly, holding hands, not saying much and are there in no time. At the apartment, my roommate (30F at the time) is also there but she’s getting ready to leave. As my date excuses herself to the bathroom, my roommate looks at me with a surprised face and whispers to me “oh my god, she’s cute. I’ll go now”.

Now alone, I waste no time moving back on my date. I’ve been worked up enough at this point that there’s no stopping me from being completely in charge of the rest of our time. She doesn’t even make it back to the couch in time before I stop her, continuing our make out session. After our kissing intensifies I keep it up by pushing her slowly against the wall, pressing my entire upper body into hers. My hands are exploring more and more parts of her body occasionally starting to progress closer to private parts. My hand now teases just inside of her tight jeans as my lips move down her neck. I just then feel her hips gently thrust towards me and I know she wants more. I finally take a break and ask if she wants to go to the bedroom. A helpless whisper, and I’m leading her to it.

I put her down on the bed on her back and notice she’s leaking through her jeans, and there’s no hiding my bulging 7″ penis anywhere in my clothes. I think at this point we’re both desperate to get past the pleasantries and get to the orgasming. I take off my shirt and quickly help her undress, but leaving her lacey tank top pulled down below her breasts because I love how partially-clothed bodies look.

Knowing again that she hasn’t had a lot of experience, I don’t want to push this out of her comfort zone, so the things I try aren’t particularly kinky. I start eating her out, which proceeds to make her so wet, that I slide a finger in pretty easily. I then think, “wow, this is a really tight fit”. I move a second finger in and that’s all I can comfortably fit, which gets her off very quickly.

At this point I’ve had enough, I stand up and pull my jeans and boxers down and within a moment, my cock is free bouncing up and down a couple of times in a stiff salute, precum already freely flowing. I catch her staring in anticipation as I fit the condom onto me and she almost instinctually spread her legs a little wider as I approach her, and says, “you’re big” – almost in an alarmed manner as if she’s not sure if it’s going to fit.

She’s still on her back as I kneel down and try to negotiate the head of my cock into her pussy. Luckily she’s dripping wet which makes everything easier, and I now have the head inside of her, just as I feel the ridge of my dick sort of lock in place as it moves past her lips. I pause and she seems comfortable and shivering with anticipation.

My cock is thicker just below the head so as I start to slide it in further where the thickest part pushes her pussy the widest open, I feel her recoil in surprise briefly, only to release her breath in a moan. As I push down I can feel how inflated her pussy is and how fully I’m filling her. I now begin to move it in and out, trying to pay attention to getting myself into every part of her pussy to figure out how it’s shaped. I’m never able to manage more than a slow pace doing this but she’s enjoying every bit and she gets a little more proactive by whispering out, “I’m cumming” just before she does.

Even with the condom, everything feels amazing to me and I need to take a break to avoid finishing and reposition myself. I decide to lay alongside her because I determined it’ll be an easier fit inside her in that position. It works out because our height difference makes it possible to get full thrusts in while reaching any part of her body, and I’m able to fuck her faster without her seeming to have any discomfort.

This goes on for probably 7-10 minutes, and because of her position I can feel her wetness making a slight tickle against my inner leg as too much collects on the condom and looks for another place to collect. At this point, with how wet and tight she is, and how much she’s gasping and moaning, everything feels amazing and I’m playing every mental trick I can to keep me from cumming.

Eventually it’s all too much for me, I had accrued too much ejaculation debt and it hits me all at once. From here things happen very quickly and I don’t even realize what’s going on – because the condom is our only birth control and I’m paranoid, I do an emergency pullout. Holding the base of my cock I take it out and see it’s glistening, but there’s no condom anymore. I’m not able to realize it at the time, but with how tight she was, and how much precum I was likely leaking into the condom, it stayed in her.

Either way, before I can do anything I see a huge rope of cum fly from my own dick. As if I was surprised, the intense pleasure doesn’t even hit me until a moment later as 3 or 4 ropes of smaller, but varying sizes and speeds also spill out. Once I get over myself I begin to look at her body. She also appears to be in shock because I see an almost uninterrupted rope of cum from just above the right side of her mouth, all the way down to her stomach, where most of the rest of the cum collects.

I hadn’t even intended to cum on her, but I couldn’t stop staring at it after I did. I saw it starting to roll down her cheek, there was a pool of it collecting in the crevice of her collarbone, still heaving from deep breaths, the way it splattered and fanned out slightly on her right breast, and the sight of several cum-darkened streaks soaking into her green lacey top. Her stomach was mostly flooded with the rest. From my angle, with the afternoon sun in the window, there was a strong backlight between my glistening cum and her more matte skin. I had never before or since made such a large cumshot on anyone.

After we both recovered, I fetched the condom, which was wet on both sides, and grabbed a whole box of tissues to help her clean up. Then I walked her home after a bit.

Without going into it too much, I decided to break it off without seeing her again, as I had my previous ex-GF soon coming to live at my place for a few months. This girl didn’t seem too happy about it, which I understood, but that was that. But based on that experience I had developed a strong desire to cum on girls any opportunity I had, and I’d definitely call it a fetish now. I love watching their faces when they have positive reactions to it and seeing it get everywhere.

The confession part of the story came about 3 years later (and I’m already in my current relationship), when she messaged me on Facebook out of the blue. I could tell she was probably drunk, as she was pretty forward, which surprised be given how reserved she was a few years before. She was telling me she was dating a great guy and was done quite fine, in the way where they’re clearly still thinking about you. I kinda saw through it, rolled my eyes, and stopped responding.

She must have realized her ruse didn’t work, and decided to confess to me that she still thought about my cum all over her and often got off thinking about it. She then told me she makes every guy cum on her but still hasn’t had anything as satisfying. This compliment really got me turned on, because I also often thought about that moment, hoping to be able to coat someone just as good.

Nothing else came of this, but I’m always a little aroused thinking about how this one experience turned her from a shy girl into a cum slut.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/jy52w4/mf_a_onetime_sexual_encounter_that_gave_both_of