[Group] Adventures in swinging: Broke the condom rule & possibly more

In the spirit of the overall darkness many of us are coping with at the moment, I thought I’d share a bit of a guilty confession and also a submission for the November contest all in one. Hopefully it’ll be cathartic for me and hopefully it’ll serve as a welcome distraction for the rest of you perverts. This is a continuation of [my story involving my threesome](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/j320kb/mff_adventures_in_swinging_first_threesome_with/) with Beth (my then-gf) and Kara (a wife AND girlfriend). During this time my girlfriend and I had just begun to explore open relationships and group sex, and we were having the time of our lives. What we didn’t really anticipate was that open relationships can still have rules and that breaking those rules can feel just as bad as cheating in a monogamous relationship.

On this fateful night, Kara’s husband was away while Beth, Kara, Kara’s boyfriend (Justin) and I got toasted and went to bed together. We were all snuggled under the sheets, kissing and giggling, slowly but surely getting naked. Justin was a very devoted and loving boyfriend and despite him enjoying Beth’s body (a lot), he seemed intent on fucking Kara. As she lay on her back with him on top, Beth and I kissed her body and face on either side. Before I knew what was happening, Justin had slipped his dick inside her and was fucking her right in front of us. Well Beth and I didn’t want to get left in the dust so she reached down and played with Kara’s clit while I pulled my cock out and gently turned her head towards it by her small chin. She smiled and opened her mouth to invite me in while she let out a little moan.

I noticed, as she was dutifully sucking and licking my shaft, that Justin was inside of her bareback. Now I was drunk by this point but I knew that she had a rule: that she and her husband had to use condoms with EVERYONE except each other. After all, they were trying to have a fucking baby! This was counter-intuitive behavior at best. I looked up at Beth and we both kind of gave each other a ‘WTF? IDK.’ shrug, then went back to participating in the orgy. ‘Maybe she wasn’t breaking her rule, maybe their rules had changed and I was out of the loop,’ I rationalized to myself. After a couple minutes of Beth and Justin going to town on her and me fucking her mouth, Kara started to come, digging her nails into my thigh while she did.

Just then Justin bottomed out (admittedly he wasn’t super big) and froze; I could tell he was cumming in her. As far as I knew this woman was not on birth control so that seemed ill-advised, but hey, ill-advised is my middle name. I can’t knock Justin for doing what comes naturally I guess. If I was sober I might have said something but in that moment I was the perfect combination of tipsy, desperately horny and not a particularly good friend. I hadn’t come yet but I could tell Kara and Justin needed a break so we all laid back down together and cuddled for a minute.

Once the afterglow had sort of worn off I suggested that maybe we could split off into separate rooms and ‘swap’ instead of merely having group sex. Everyone chuckled awkwardly but they were all down. Beth and Justin stayed in the guest bed together and Kara and I scampered off to the master bedroom. As much as I had fun with group stuff, I really just wanted to get Kara all to myself. There was something about her that was so alluring. A woman with 2 men and still, I could have her all for myself. Whatever that desire was I was feeding it. She laid back on the king size bed and I followed, kissing her neck and shoulders before settling into her delicate little lips.

While I squeezed her tight and ran my fingers across her skin my cock lightly grazed her slick pussy lips, her boyfriend’s load was oozing out of her. At this point I was up to my eyes in cum and my brain was deprived of oxygen so I thought, ‘What the hell, right? I want some of that raw pussy too.” So I angled my dick down and looked into her eyes as I pushed it into her sloppy little hole. The more I plunged deep into her, the more of Justin’s cum got pushed out to accommodate my throbbing cock. It was like a fucking nature documentary where the males are competing to breed the female except I definitely had no CONSCIOUS desire to get Kara pregnant.

If I were less brain-dead in that moment I might have considered that I was leaking pre-cum into her like a cracked dam but I convinced myself that as long as I pulled out, everything would be fine. Railing a woman bareback with no birth control, a woman with a boyfriend and a husband who wanted a baby with her. Everything would be fine. Right? Also my girlfriend was in the other room probably getting railed bareback but at least she had an IUD. It’s all no problem, it’s all chill.

I lasted a bit longer than Justin (sorry man, no shade) but even so I started to feel it. I was edging closer and closer to release. We were both feeling it as we locked eyes, the hunger behind them was unmistakable. I knew that if I didn’t do something soon I would end up emptying my very full balls into her very eager pussy. But still I kept putting it off. I’ll pull out in a minute, I’m not quite there yet. Finally, when I reached the point of no return my creeping guilt got the better of me and convinced me not to sink down to the hilt and impregnate this girl. I was going to do the right thing. Then I felt her little cunt muscles contract around me.

All the best laid plans, right? The feeling of all the danger, all the risk and all the stupidity, combined with her squeezing me with all her might on my withdraw, amounted to the perfect storm. This was a cummergency. The moment I pulled out safely I immediately started to spurt thick white ropes of cum all over her pussy lips. Our bodies just sort of involuntarily started to convulse and grind against one another while we came. In our lack of coordination my cock slipped back inside of her mid-orgasm. And holy fuck. I don’t know if you’re ever started your climax only to be surprised by a very powerful little shutter that reignites it, but when my cock plunged back inside of her I squeezed every last drop out in an instant.

We both moaned, “Oh fuck. Fuck,” as our bodies clumsily pumped in harmony, slipping out and back in every few strokes as I filled her fertile pussy. My brain was rebooting but my body knew exactly what the fuck it was doing. When we started to wind down from all the shaking and moaning and cussing, I realized I was buried fully inside of her. My dick let out one final flex and I sighed deeply. “Well shit,” was all I could think to say in my incoherent state.

“Holy shit,” she responded as we caught our breath. After a minute or so she reassured me, “It’ll be okay. I can just buy a Plan B.” I nodded in agreement as I lifted myself off of her. For a moment I admired my handiwork, her pussy was a thoroughly fucked, cum-covered mess: coated, filled and dripping. I knew I shouldn’t have, I knew I had fucked up, but I was so incredibly glad that I did.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/jor40r/group_adventures_in_swinging_broke_the_condom