Well this happened about two years ago when I was 22, but I definitely will never forget it. I was home one year from school on winter break one night just browsing through tinder. This girl pops up that i know well…because she is my next door neighbor.
Now this girl has lived next door to me for over 10 years. She is one year younger than me and we never were friends in Highschool. I hung out with the “popular” crowd in Highschool while she was more part of the anime/goth scene at school. Anyway I said fuck it.
I swiped right, and a little bit later I get a notification that we matched. She instantly messages me asking if I found her attractive. I agree and said yeah I’ve kinda had a crush on you since you moved in… (this isn’t really true but forget that it got me laid) she responds with “I hope you aren’t vanilla” and this is where I start to get excited. I nervously told her no I’m not I’m open to all sorts of stuff. We exchange snaps and next thing you know she is sending me nudes telling me how much she wants me to let her come over fuck her. The only problem is my mom is still wide awake so I reluctantly tell her no. I waited quite some time and my mom finally went to bed. We both agreed to meet in her car at 11:30pm sharp and she would bring some blankets.
At 11:29 I start walking over to her car and see her in the back seat waiting. I hope in the car and say hello and she was in disbelief. “Oh my god I can’t believe you actually showed up.” I chuckle and say yeah and she continues to tell me how much she has always wanted to fuck me and that she used to masturbate to pictures of me. I just laughed and said “really that’s hot” it was kind of weird to me… but sexy. I consider myself a decent looking dude but I’m not brad Pitt I’ve never had girls drooling over me lol. So we start making out slowly and i start feeling her breast and ass as she grabs my cock. We do not have a condom and her family is super Christian and does not approve of birth control. So prior we both agreed to just oral sex. As we are making out she takes my cock out and starts jerking me hard and stern but slow. I take off her shirt and slowly start sliding her pajama shorts off to revel a cute pair of blue panties. I start rubbing her clit and to my delight she has a full bush and shyly smirks sorry I didn’t have time to shave. Of course this only turns me on more and we climb back to the trunk of the suv and I start fucking her throat with my cock. She Glucks and gags while her saliva drips down her lips and chin. You can barley hear her begging for me to fuck her over her gags.
She eventually bends over on all fours and asks me to fuck her in the ass. Now let me remind you we have no lube I’ve never done anal before and I’ve never really even hung out with the girl. So I spit on her asshole and start fingering her ass slowly and deeper.Once she finally exclaimed fuck me in the ass daddy. I start rubbing my saliva covered penis on her asshole and slowly penetrated her. It wasn’t even 1 minute until she starting screaming for me to fuck her harder and harder and by the time we were 5 minutes in I was full power as she moaned like some anime character. This leads to a euphoric orgasm as I cum in her ass. I slowly pull out and a gushing of cum waterfalls down her ass and on to her SUV’s carpet. We both take a couple breaths get dressed and sit there for a second I shyly tell her thanks and she does the same and ends with “okay you can leave now I don’t need you anymore” to which I kinda laughed. She just used me..? But I kinda liked this. I walk out the car and go back home in shock and delight.
I ended up deleting her on tinder and other socials and haven’t talked to her since. Maybe we will cross paths again one day for round 2.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/jkkmm9/mf_first_anal