I posted part 1 yesterday intending to just write the whole story but it got way longer than I expected and I had to go back to work. This part isn’t as long but has more of the good stuff and less backstory.
Picking up where I left off, Macie had just drained my cock down to the very last drop (or so I thought). At this point I figured we were done as we both got to cum, and it takes me a little while to recover. Macie though, was immediately ready for round 2. It felt like there was only a few seconds before she was back at it again, desperately trying to keep me hard. She was vigorously sucking my balls and licking from them all the way up my shaft to the head while looking at me with her big brown eyes.
“Fuck, Macie…” I sighed as she continued to work my dick.
“I’m not done with this yet,” she said in between mouthfuls.
The saving grace here is that I had already cum, so I knew I could fuck her for longer. I told her to turn around, so that her little ass was right in my face. I fingered her for a bit from behind, teasing her and rimming her asshole.
“I need that dick in me right now,” she muttered.
“You’ve waited years for this, you can wait a little longer.” She sighed, which turned into a yelp as I spanked her maybe even a little harder than I was trying to. Then I reached around and started playing with her tits, and pinching her nipples. I found out earlier that she loved having them played with roughly. While I was doing that, I started rubbing my cock around her pussy. Even though my hands were occupied, I could feel how wet she was with the tip of my dick. She was desperately pushing her pussy against it, trying to slide it in, but I was watching and would move when she got close.
“I need to get a condom. I have one in my car.”
“NO.” She was firm about that. I had no idea if she was on the pill, but I knew her pretty damn well and I knew she had only had two other sexual partners. That and she takes good care of herself. Those reasons quickly went through my head and I gave in.
“I want you to beg me to fuck you,” I said.
“Please Derek, please please fuck my pussy. I need your dick inside me so fucking bad.” Sidebar – my name is Derek. I don’t think I mentioned that at all in the previous story.
I decided that was good enough and I lined up my cock to her slit and pushed in. Just a few hours ago I had no idea what exactly Macie wanted to do with me, and I had no idea that there was this entirely different person outside of a pretty quiet, shy girl. What I knew now based on playing with her some is that she liked it rough, so that’s how I decided to approach it from the beginning.
She was soaking wet so I was able to bottom out pretty easily after a couple thrusts (normally it’s a struggle as I’m above average in length). She made this low, guttural noise that I’ll never forget as I made her take every inch for the first time. It was so fucking hot and I still think about it often. Once I got her stretched out a little bit, I started pounding into her as hard as I could over and over. I was so thankful that I had cum a few minutes before because I would have been sent over the edge quickly. Her pussy felt like it was just gripping my dick. I was in heaven, it was a perfect situation.
I fucked her for a solid 10 minutes in that position, alternating between spanking her and yanking her head back by her hair. One particular time I pulled her head back and she rolled her eyes up to look at me. I loved the eye contact she would make with me.
“You like my big dick inside you?”
“Fuuuuck yessss” she said, her voice rattling as I continued to pound into her. I noticed how her voice was so different compared to the sweet, innocent voice I had been used to for so long.
Her mom was upstairs so I knew we needed to be at least a little quiet. Whenever she started getting too loud, I would push her head down into her pillow and spank her again. I was getting pretty exhausted at this point and her whole room reeked of sweat. I pulled out, turned her around and had her mount me.
I loved this position just as much as watching her perfect ass bounce on my cock. Now I got to play with her tits while she did more of the work. I let her ride and every so often, thrust up unexpectedly as she was coming down to keep her on her toes. Every time I did it, she’d yell out, so I started continually doing it and getting in the rhythm. I grabbed her ass and pulled her body down so she was laying against me, our sweat mixing together on our chests. I grabbed hold of her ass and fucked her as hard as I possibly could. We both were beyond the point of talking, our communication reduced down to grunts and moans. The sound of my dick smashing into her over and over was making her bed hit the wall. I knew her mom had to know what was happening, thankfully she was very laid back.
I was finally at the point where I was going to cum again. I pushed her up so she was riding me sitting up and started playing with her clit. I wanted her to cum again, hopefully at the same time as me. As soon as I started touching her clit, her mouth opened wide, eyes shut, head tilted up toward the ceiling.
“Fuck Derek, you’re going to make me cum again. Oh fuck oh fuck oh fuck,” she kept repeating. Worth noting I had never heard her curse before in all the years I knew her.
I kept playing with her clit. There was no going back, I knew I was going to cum in her pussy, we would deal with the aftermath later.
“God I love your tight pussy Macie, I’m gonna cum again.”
“Yeah? Cum for me Derek. Cum all inside this tight pussy. My pussy has been waiting for years for you to fill it up.”
That was all I needed. I came almost right when she said that and she was right behind me a few seconds later. She collapsed on top of me and we just laid there for a while, breathing heavily. I laid there and just tried to take in the moment.
Unfortunately, our relationship never developed beyond this. Wrong place, wrong time continued to be the theme just as it had been for the years I knew her in high school. We hooked up almost every night over that week long break, and same thing over the course of Christmas break. However, we were both afraid of getting into a long distance relationship as we both had bad experiences with those.
Eventually, we both fell into other relationships. She’s currently still in one with a guy she’s been with for a few years and we don’t talk a whole lot anymore. Makes me sad, she’s always felt like the one that got away. But I’ll never forget the moments we spent together, both as friends and as FWB’s.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/jjvpid/mf_fucking_the_valedictorian_part_2