Dinner was interesting, as Mike was trying to process what had transpired when he got home. Was Beth hitting on him? That was an interesting notion, to be sure. She was such a cute thing, with her freckles and deep, red curls. Where Stacey was a curious mix of vivacious and shy at the same time, Beth was more forthright, but also more playful. Her conversations with him were full of double-entendres, dripping with sexual innuendo, all of which Stacey seemed oblivious to.
Later on, the girls did their homework at the kitchen table while he watched a basketball game, and then they both came in to tell him they were going to get ready for bed. As Stacey bounded away, as Beth bent over to whisper to him, “Don’t forget to tuck us in later!” She quickly kissed his astonished face.
“Beth…” he gasped back. “What are you doing?”
“Nuthin’…” She replied, standing up, yawning and stretching her whole body in front of him, as if for his benefit. “Just what comes natural, I guess.” She walked away, then turned her head over her shoulder. “I do hope to see you later, Mr. Reynolds.”
Mike was dumbfounded. She was obviously hitting on him, but what was he to do about it? He definitely wanted her, but how would he make that happen with Stacey right there?
He stewed over this for a few minutes, then realized the ball game had ended, and he didn’t even know who won. He shut off the TV and walked to his room. As he passed Stacey’s door, he heard whispers and giggles, normal for their sleepovers. Knocking, he said, “I’m turning in, girls. You two should hit the sack soon, too, okay?”
“We will!” they both shouted in unison, then laughed aloud.
*****
Mike was thoroughly worked up, and had resigned himself to a good wanking to help him get to sleep. He lay there naked, stroking his cock under the covers, thinking about what he would do to the hot redhead the next room over if she was naked in his bed at that moment.
Suddenly, his fantasy was broken by the sound of his bedroom door opening, and Stacey and Beth walked in, wearing the shortest, thinnest, wispiest nighties he had ever seen. The fabric caressed their nude bodies like a second skin, and he could plainly see two sets of very erect nipples through the sheer fabric.
The bottom was fur-lined, and came down barely far enough to cover their perfect teenage buttocks. It swished as they walked over to the bed, and Mike gasped as he caught a glimpse of Beth’s red pubic hair, realizing that she wore no panties underneath.
“Daddy,” Stacey said, sitting on her knees in the bed next to him. He tore his eyes off of Beth to look at his daughter, and catching a glimpse of her downy fur, realized that she, too, was also completely naked under the nightie.
Mike gulped. “Y… yes, sweetie?”
“We came in for a goodnight kiss.”
Beth now knelt on the bed on the opposite side of Mike’s body, and added, “Both of us.” His erection was obviously tenting the covers.
Stacey leaned over and planted her lips on his for a deep, passionate kiss, and Mike gave in, trading tongues with her as she lay down next to him. He felt Beth’s body alongside him, and heard her whisper, “My turn.”
She turned his face to hers and pressed her lips to his, Frenching him for all she was worth. Mike was lost in the savory taste of Beth’s tongue, and felt Stacey lift up the blanket to slide in the bed beside him, when he caught himself, and pushed Beth away.
“Wait, wait!” he exclaimed as he sat up in bed. “Just what is going on here?”
“Isn’t it obvious?” Beth said as she, too, lifted the quilt and slid in beside him.
“We’re sleeping here tonight, Daddy.” Stacey rested her head on his shoulder, gently rubbing his chest.
“B… but… but you can’t, sweetheart.”
“Why not? I sleep here all the time, Daddy!”
“STACEY!” Mike sat up in a fright, flabbergasted that his daughter had outed their forbidden relationship.
“It’s cool, Mr. Reynolds.” Beth said, rubbing his back and shoulders, urging him to lay back down. “I sleep with my dad every night, too.”
“WHAT?” Mike was shocked to his core. “You’re…you’re joking with me, right?”
“It’s true, Dad,” Stacey added. “You see, Beth told me how great sex with her father was, and that inspired me,…” She paused, not knowing if she should admit that she deliberately set him up.
Beth noticed this, and jumped to her rescue. “You see, once I confided to her about my dad and I being lovers, well,… she confided to me how she felt the same way about you.”
“Really? You and… you and Don? Seriously?” Mike was still astounded, but turned on immensely. He wasn’t the only one having incestuous relations with his daughter? Could it really be true?
“Yep!” Beth said, now moving her hand to grasp the obvious erection Mike was sporting. “Oooh! Nice and big and hard! Just the way I like ‘em!”
“I knew it!” Stacey suddenly pulled the covers away from all of them, exposing Beth expertly jacking on her dad’s stiff prick. “I just knew that knowing about Beth fucking her father would turn you on, Daddy!”
“So… you’re here because…” Mike began.
The girls giggled. “Well, Dad,…” Stacey started.
“She bet me that you were a better lover than my dad, and, well, I had to hop into your bed to prove it.”
“No way!” Mike interjected. “I don’t believe it!”
“Well, let’s see,” Beth said, sliding down the bed until her mouth hovered over his swollen phallus, twitching in anticipation. “How can I persuade you that I want to make love with you?” Lizzie looked up at him, absentmindedly licking her lips, and Mike gulped at the sexy sight of this gorgeous redhead about to devour him whole.
“Elizabeth…” he whispered.
“What can I possibly do that would show you how much I want you?” Beth planted a gentle smooch on the tip on his throbbing penis, giggling as it twitched in her hot little hand.
She could almost taste his arousal, and although she loved teasing him like this, the desire to savor him for real won out. She took a deep breath and swallowed his cock deep into her hungry teenage mouth, sucking hard and moaning.
He tasted different from her dad, and it turned her on so much to know she was sucking another man’s cock. She went to town on Mike’s prick, bobbing slowly and whipping her tongue all over it, which made him groan aloud and drive his hips upward, before pulling off with a loud smack of her lips. “Does that convince you, Mike?”
“Yes, it does,” Mike said, “… but I sure wouldn’t mind some more convincing.”
Beth smiled, and tickled the crown with the tip of her tongue. “Anything you want, stud,” and she took him deep again, in long, tongue-filled strokes of her mouth on his meat.
“Oh! Beth! You do that soooo good!” Mike was thrashing about on the bed at the sensory overload she was giving him. “Take me deep, sweetheart!”
Beth looked up at him as she gleefully sucked his cock, and noticed Stacey was also staring, wide-eyed and licking her lips. She pulled off to catch her breath. “Did I do that okay, Mike?” she asked, stroking him slowly. “Am I sucking your cock the way you like it?”
“Oh, yeah,” Mike reached down to entwine his fingers in her hair, guiding her mouth back to his wet prick-tip. “I love it!”
Beth smiled, and resumed her slow sensual blowjob, stroking him as she took him deep into her sweet sucking mouth. Mike moaned deeply, and started rubbing Lizzie’s body everywhere he could reach. She got up on her hands and knees, to give him easier access to her body, and Mike lifted her nightie to pay special attention to her erect nipples and perfect teen ass.
Stacey laid down in the crook of her dad’s arm, watching the sexy show with wide eyes. Mike was also rubbing his daughter’s back the whole time, from her shoulders to her tight little ass. She could feel his breathing quickening with sensual pleasure. “Wow, Beth. I can’t believe you’re sucking my dad’s cock! Daddy; I can feel your heart pounding in your chest. Is she making you feel good?”
Mike moaned, “It’s so good, baby.” He pulled his daughter tightly to him, kissing her deeply as Elizabeth laved his dick with her tongue.
“Mmmm. Daddy, I love you so much!”
Beth lifted her head from his throbbing prick, panting from her exertions. “Mike,” she intoned breathlessly, “Stacey told me she loves it when you play with her breasts and suck her nipples.”
“Elizabeth!” Stacey complained.
Mike laughed, and said, “That’s a wonderful idea! Baby, feed me your big beautiful tits.”
His daughter now moaned at the suggestion, and kissed him hard. Stacey hadn’t even planned on watching, but caught up in the moment, made up her mind to enjoy herself. She sat up and sensuously peeled off the flimsy nightie, then leaned over his face, her perfect tits dangling over his lips. “Suck my titties, Daddy.”
Mike complied immediately, bringing both of his hands to her large breasts, gently kneading them as Stacey fed him one erect nipple, and then the other. Mike sucked and nibbled on her erect buds, eliciting moans of pleasure from his daughter.
In the meantime, Beth had resumed sucking Mike’s cock deeply, and the room was filled with the sexy sounds of sucking mouths bringing pleasure, moans of utter joy, and heavy breathing all around.
Beth was suddenly aware of the smell of pussy, and looked up to see Mike fingering his daughter’s hot hole. “Mike,” she said between licks. “Stacey says you’re the best pussy licker in the whole world!”
“Beth, I never said that!” Stacey exclaimed. Mike smiled around his daughter’s plump tit, sucked her nipple harder, and fingered her pussy faster.
“You told me how much you loved his tongue in your cunt, how he could make you cum, and cum, and cum.” Lizzie punctuated this last sentence with quick sucks of Mike’s swollen cockhead, pulling off with a smack every time. “Mike; I want to watch you suck her off while I do the same to you.”
Stacey was hot as a firecracker, but this was getting out of hand. While she wanted nothing more than to have her sweet Daddy lick her to an orgasm, could she really do that in front of her best friend?
Mike moved his hands from her breasts to her back, then down to her ass, squeezing her cheeks, and guiding her pussy up to his waiting mouth. “Let me lick your sweet pussy, baby.”
Stacey was simply too horny from his breast play to fight his sexy suggestion, and realizing she wanted nothing more that her loving father’s tongue deep in her snatch, gave up all doubt, and straddled his head, lowering her pussy to his waiting tongue. “Yes, Daddy, lick my pussy! Suck my clit and make me cum!”
Beth moved between his legs so she could watch the erotic sight in all its glory, while she did her best to drive Mike wild with her lips and tongue. Stacey was leaning against the headboard, writhing and moaning in pleasure as she ground her sopping pussy all over her dad’s face, riding his sucking mouth and whipping tongue. “So good, Daddy… Don’t ever stop eating me…”
He was running his hands all over her nude body; from her shoulders down her back, around to her tits, pinching her nipples, then down to squeeze her perfect ass, then down her thighs, to her calves, finally tickling the soles of her feet, all while she rode his tongue to a mind-bending orgasm. “Yes… touch me all over,” Stacey urged him on.
When Beth was satisfied that Mike’s dick could become no bigger or harder, the need for her own orgasm now gripped Beth fully, so she rose from between Mike’s legs to straddle his hips, peeling off her nightie in the process.
Mike was too engrossed in bringing his daughter off to notice, until Elizabeth notched his rampant prick-head into her soaking snatch, and sat down hard, grinding and twisting on his cock until it was fully embedded all the way inside her. Mike moaned loudly into Stacey’s pussy at the sensation.
Beth ground her clit on the base of his cock, making her see stars, and moaned, “Oh my god, Stacey, your dad’s cock feels so good inside me.” She started slowly rising and falling on his prick, fucking herself languidly. “Now I know why you love fucking him so much…”
“Oh, yeah, fuck her good, Daddy!” Stacey ground her pussy onto Mike’s face. “Beth, wait ’til you feel Daddy’s tongue in you! Oh my god, it feels so good! Keep eating my pussy!”
Mike was in heaven, with two gorgeous, nubile naked teens using his body to extract sexual pleasure, all of them rushing inexorably to the ultimate goal, mind-blowing orgasms. He started humping his hips upward, driving his cock all the way into Lizzie’s tight wet snatch, and stabbing his tongue deep into Stacey’s pussy at the same time, gripping her asscheeks tightly to keep her from squirming away from his oral assault.
Beth was gasping, “Fuck me, Mike! Make me cum! I need it so bad!” She leaned forward to gain more leverage, and bumped into Stacey, who was in the way trying to reach her own peak. Beth was suddenly struck with the realization of the absolute joy they all were sharing, and was overcome with emotion at the depth of the experience. She gently kissed Stacey’s back, and reached around her to hug her from behind.
“Oh, Stacey, is your Daddy making you cum? He’s fucking me so good!”
Stacey pushed back against Lizzie. enjoying the hug while she rode her Daddy’s tongue. She could feel Beth’s breasts and rock-hard nipples pressed into her back. Beth then reached up to squeeze her best friend’s tits, eliciting moans from both of them. Stacey had now lost all inhibition. “Oh, yes! Beth, pinch my nipples! Daddy, fuck Beth harder! Suck my clit! I’m so close!”
Mike picked that moment to redouble his efforts. How could he refuse his little girl? He humped his cock into Lizzie’s pussy harder and faster, and she slammed down on him with every stroke. He latched his lips onto his daughter’s clit, and started sucking furiously as he whipped his tongue over the erect little bud.
Stacey was going out of her mind as Beth pinched her nipples and Mike squeezed her ass, and she could not believe how good it felt to have four hands on her tight little body.
The pace quickened all around, and the moans increased along with the sound of flesh slapping on flesh, added to Mike’s slurping hungrily on Stacey’s pussy. All three of them rode this wave of passion as it got higher and higher, finally cresting in glorious climax.
Stacey was first, but only by seconds. “Oh, Daddy, you’re making me cum! Oh! Oh! Don’t stop sucking me! Beth, I’m cumming so hard!” She arched her back as the orgasm overtook her, held in place by four loving arms and four squeezing hands.
This put Elizabeth over the top. “Oh! Oh! I’m cumming, too! Cumming all over your Daddy’s cock! Keep fucking me, Mike! It’s so good!”
That was all it took for Mike, who slammed upward one last time, as his prick exploded into Lizzie’s tight clasping pussy. His sperm burst out of his cock in blasts of pleasure, sending several scalding shots of hot semen deep into her pussy as he moaned into his daughter’s cunt. Beth came again as she felt each shot from his throbbing penis, and her squeezing snatch made Mike nip at Stacey’s clit. Stacey exploded in another orgasm from the sudden sensation of pleasure and pain.
The three lovers collapsed in a heap of heaving, sweaty bodies, all hugging and kissing each other breathlessly, and as they come down from their incredible highs, they all realized the import of moment they had all just shared.
Smiling all around, the girls took up position on either side of Mike, nestling themselves comfortably in his loving arms. He kissed each of them in turn, full of love for these nubile teens.
“Thank you, Mike,” Elizabeth said. “You made me cum really hard.”
She kissed him deeply, until Stacey pulled his face to hers for a deep tongue kiss. “Thank you, Daddy,” she added. “That was the best you ever ate my pussy! I can’t believe how hard I came!”
Mike kissed his daughter, and said, “I had a little help, sweetie. I saw Lizzie playing with your tits, and I know how that gets you off.”
Stacey blushed, and Beth laughed at the turnaround from her earlier attitude. “Was that too lezzie for you, Stacey? You did seem to like it when I pinched your nipples.” She reached over and lightly pinched the nipple in front of her.
Stacey could only sigh in resignation. She was outed; she loved the attention and they all knew it. “Okay, I admit it. I loved feeling of all of your hands on me. It made everything that much more intense.”
Elizabeth smiled broadly. This went better than even she had expected, and she wasn’t done yet. “I loved every minute of this. Your dad’s cock tasted so good.”
Stacey smiled, and moved the hand that had been lazily playing with Mike’s chest hair down to his stomach, to grasp his wilted penis, still sticky with his and Beth’s cum. “His cum tastes really good, too.”
“Oh, really?” Beth was watching Stacey pull on her dad’s prick, and noticed a twitch as she said that. “Only one way to find out.” To the amazement of the others, she quickly slid down to take his cock into her hungry mouth again.
[continued]
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/jcwotl/daddys_girls_chapter_27_bedtime_surprise_mff_inc