Later that day, the Girls gathered together in the Circle for lunch. Beth was itching to get something off her chest.
“Ladies,” Beth intoned as soon as they were seated, “I’ve been thinking about it, and I don’t want to wait.” She paused. “About Phase 2.”
Laurie and Rebecca just looked at one another with raised eyebrows. “Really, Liz?” Laurie asked. “What changed your mind?”
“I just… I dunno,” Beth looked down, averting their gaze. “So far, all this has been TONS of fun, and hearing all of your stories, well… I just want to try it, y’know?”
Stacey sighed. “Me, too.”
Becky looked over at her. “Really? You too?”
“Yeah, you’re not gonna chicken out again, are you?” Laurie teased.
Stacey glared at her. “NO.”
“So why YOUR change of heart?” Laurie asked.
“I… I want to know what its like, that’s all.”
“No. I don’t buy it. “ Becky said. “You were so convincing yesterday, Stace. You made us all agree to cool it, remember?”
“That you did!” Laurie interjected. “Cmon, spill. What really happened?”
Stacey looked at Beth. “Tell them,” Beth encouraged her.
Stacey sighed. “Last night… I called Beth to ask her about the Science notes.” She noticed Laurie and Rebecca both raised their eyebrows at that. “REALLY! Honest!”
“It’s the truth, girls.” Beth defended her. “But I was… out of breath when I answered the phone.”
“So, I jokingly asked her if she had just gotten busy with her father…”
“… And I said to her, ‘I’m still busy!’” Beth finished, blushing.
“No, you weren’t!” Becky laughed.
“Hm-hmm!” Beth nodded, sipping at her straw. “I was on top of him at that moment, riding him slow as he played with my tits.”
“Right!” Laurie said with a laugh.
“Yes, I was! I’m that much of a slut, apparently.”
“So, anyway, she promised to call me back in 10 minutes…” Stacey began.
“… which turned into 30 minutes,” Beth added.
“At LEAST!” Stacey exclaimed. “Anyway, by the time my phone rang, well…”
“SHE was out of breath.” Beth said, grinning. “The slut!”
Stacey whacked her on the thigh. “Takes one to know one!”
“Or FOUR!” Laurie added, laughing.
“So… what WERE you doing when Beth called?”
“Daddy was behind me, fucking me hard and deep, and when the phone rang, he just FROZE.” Stacey laughed. “It was so cute, like he was busted or something!”
“I can picture it!” Becky exclaimed.
“And imagine his shock when I actually answered the phone!” Stacey laughed. “So… he’s stopped, buried deep, and I just started pushing back on him, until he got the hint, and started stroking back in and out, slow and deep.”
“Unbelievable!” Laurie said.
“So… I hung up on Beth, and Dad started REALLY slamming, me, talking about how I shouldn’t take chances like that, but who’s kidding who? He LOVED it!”
“I hear ya!” Beth piped in, “My dad really gave it to me hard when I hung up, too!”
“Anyway, I called Beth back a while later, but we never got around to the Science notes.” Stacey smoothed her skirt in her lap.
“We were too busy talking about how good our respective fathers had just fucked us,” Beth explained, “and how turned on each of them was when we were speaking to each other on the phone…”
“… while we were otherwise engaged, so to speak.” Stacey said, blushing.
“It appears that the danger of getting caught in the act isn’t limited to the back seat of a car!” Becky tossed in.
“Right you are!” said Beth.
“Anyway, the conversation quickly changed to ‘my dad fucks better than your dad’,” Stacey said.
“… And I told her, ’There’s only one way to prove it.’”
Stacey sighed, and looked down. “And I accepted her challenge.”
“So… here we are,” said Beth. “We want to move forward with Phase 2. What do you think?”
Rebecca and Laurie looked at each other. “I don’t know…” Becky began.
“I know.” Laurie said. “That was kinda sneaky of them, wasn’t it? Making plans against the expressed wishes of the Circle without us being involved in the discussion?”
Becky tapped her on the leg in agreement. “You’re being polite, Laurie. Frankly, I’m shocked that our supposed friends are arranging things behind our backs.”
Laurie snapped her fingers. “You’re right! That IS what happened! You sneaky bitches.”
“Behind your… Becky, Laurie… What the FUCK?” Beth said. “I… We… This doesn’t even…” She was so flabbergasted by the accusation that she blubbered.
“No, girls, it wasn’t like that at all.” Stacey sat up on her haunches to intervene.
“Oh, really?” Becky replied. “So you’re saying last night, you DIDN’T make plans to sleep with each other’s fathers?”
“NO! We did NOT make plans!” Stacey defended herself. “We just agreed… Actually, I just came around to the idea, that’s all.”
“But we didn’t even talk about who would sleep with who’s dad first or anything!” Beth added. “Just that we should go for it, that’s all.”
“Ah.” Laurie piped up. “In that case, I concur.”
Becky nodded. “Me, too.”
“So… now that THAT’S resolved,” Beth said, leaning forward, “Who goes first?”
“Not me!” Stacey said. “I don’t mind if you guys start off this one.”
“I’m certainly game!” Elizabeth said, raising her hand.
“Me too!” Laurie raised her hand as well, smiling.
“No, no, no…” Becky said, reaching for both hands that were in the air, and pulling them down. “It’s me. I have to be first.”
“Oh, really?” Beth asked. “Why you?”
Laurie blurted out, “Because she already DID IT!”
“What?” Beth and Stacey said in unison.
“I slept over Laurie’s house last night.“ Rebecca said.
“And fucked my dad’s brains out right in front of me!” Laurie added, laughing. “Oh, you should see the looks on your faces right now!” She pointed at Beth and Stacey, then doubled over in gales of laughter. Rebecca caught the laughing bug, and burst into giggles herself.
Beth stared at the two of them, open mouthed. “You bitches!”
Rebecca and Laurie howled with laughter, rolling back on the grass together.
Stacey looked dumbfounded. “Wait a minute; so you two went behind OUR backs?”
“That’s what makes it so funny!” Laurie guffawed.
“I’m sorry…” Becky began, sitting back up but still grinning. “We were gonna tell you, but then you started the conversation, and we just played dumb, playing off of each other.”
“SO worth it!” Laurie said, wiping tears from her eyes. She smacked both shocked girls in the legs. “THAT’S for teasing ME about being second!”
“Okay, then,” Beth smiled, “Maybe we deserved that. But technically, you still HAVEN’T done it.” she pointed out.
“YET.”
“Your dad was the first to be double-teamed, but I was the first to get laid by another father,” Becky said.
“Wait, wait…” Stacey interjected. “How did all this happen?”
“And we want ALL the details!” Beth added.
*****
Laurie did most of the talking, since it was her idea after all, except where Rebecca talked about how different it was to make love to Paul as opposed to her own dad. Becky described how much she was turned on by sampling another man’s penis, in every way, especially with an audience.
“So she was definitely showing off for my benefit, but my dad couldn’t tell, of course. So, he was, like, totally committed to getting her off, and she was talking dirty right with him, and then they both started cumming.” Laurie sighed. “Girls, it was so amazing. I can’t believe how hot it made me watching them go at it!”
“So,” Rebecca continued, “we finished, orgasming together, which was AWESOME, and we’re just holding each other, kissing, as we came down from that incredible high…”
“… When they both noticed me, jilling off to beat the band,” Laurie added, “until I begged my dad to help me get off, and he ate me out ’til I came all over his face!”
“And seeing that was REALLY amazing.” Rebecca piped up. “Then later, we took turns sucking his cock hard again, and I talked dirty to him ’til he was cumming in Laurie’s mouth. That was super-hot!” Beth and Stacey kept exchanging glances.
“And this morning,” Laurie continued, “He woke me up by kissing my back and playing with my boobs, which makes me CRAZY, then he rolled over on top of me, and…” she snapped her fingers. “… just like that, he was all the way inside me, pumping away like a madman.”
“Were you awake for this?” Stacey asked.
“It’s kinda hard to sleep with the bed bouncing like that!” Becky said, sipping her drink. “They were so passionate, it made me REALLY horny!”
“And for me,” Laurie added, “having an audience really intensified the sexiness of the situation. It was so cool!”
“It was really something, watching her make love to her father. I wondered if that’s what me and my dad look like when we’re doing it.”
Laurie added, “That’s not all… after, he fucked me senseless while Becky watched, he leaned over and he licked her until she came all over his face, all while his dick stayed semi-hard inside me.”
Beth looked at Stacey, “I’m staying over your place tonight.”
“But, Beth…” Stacey said, the fright evident in her voice.
“But nothing. Oh my God, that sounds so hot! First, you get to fuck, and then you get to watch your friend get fucked. Which was better?” she asked them.
Laurie and Becky exchanged looks. “I don’t know. I guess actually doing it, but watching was also so hot. It made everything better,” Laurie said. “I was, like, so horny from watching the two of them fuck that I got off as soon as my dad started licking me. I swear, it was like, an instant orgasm the second he started!” Becky nodded agreement.
Stacey leaned forward. “Whose idea was it blow him at the same time?” Rebecca blushed, and Stacey knew the answer. “Wow. I’m amazed that you two would do such a thing.”
“What can I say?” Becky shrugged, “It just happened, and it was a ton of fun! It absolutely drove him wild. His cock looked like it was going to burst wide open, he was so turned on!”
“WOW.” Elizabeth was certainly impressed. “We are SO seducing your dad tonight.” she said to Stacey.
Stacey just sat there, dumbfounded, as Laurie, Becky and Beth burst into laughter at Stacey’s scared countenance.
“I am NOT helping,” Stacey said.
“We’ll see,” Beth said.
“And I’m certainly not doing any… any…”
“Any what?” asked Laurie.
“Well… y’know…,” Stacey whispered, “… any lezzie stuff.”
“Oh, grow up!” Rebecca chided her. It was ironic since their youngest member was telling the oldest to ‘grow up.’ “No one’s forcing you to do anything you don’t want to do.”
“Yeah, but you’ve just got to try it. It was such a turn-on just being there!” Laurie reassured her. “I GUARANTEE your dad will go nuts. It’s so cool!“
Stacey could only sigh. “We’ll see.”
*****
Beth and Stacey took the school bus to Beth’s house, where she packed an overnight bag and called her father to let him know she was staying over Stacey’s that night.
He was not pleased, but his sweet Lizzie played it perfectly. She reminded him that she had stayed over each of the Girl’s houses lots of times in the past, so Stacey was bound to get suspicious if he denied her permission this time.
In the end, she promised him some extra special loving the following night, going into whispered details about exactly what she was going to do to his penis the next time she saw him, and Don’s objection was overcome.
They caught a bus to Stacey’s street, and walked down to her house, chatting together excitedly. Beth had packed a few extra items, because she knew Stacey may need extra motivation to go through with her dad’s seduction, and there was no way Elizabeth wasn’t going all-out to succeed.
Stacey, for her part, was certainly nervous, but was totally on board with the outfit idea. Once they arrived at her house, they surfed the web together for a bit, seeking out the sexy stories for ideas. This was a mistake, as their original plan was to surf for a while and then do their homework, before it was time to prepare dinner.
After reading the first few stories, ‘a while’ turned into all afternoon, because they were totally engrossed in the sexy scenarios. Possibilities abounded for what each of them planned to do with their own dads, once they got them alone again.
They were strategizing up until the front door opened, and Mike walked in. He immediately noticed the sound of excited chatter coming from his little girl’s room, and recognized Elizabeth’s voice right away. He was also aware of the conspicuous lack of aroma, meaning dinner wasn’t even being considered at the moment.
He walked down the hall, and stood well outside his daughter’s door. He always had a soft spot for Beth, and couldn’t help his curiosity. What were the girls so excited about? He heard whispering, then both girls laughed out loud. He approached the door silently.
“And you know Becky wouldn’t lie about something like that!” Stacey said, laughing.
“True!” Beth replied. “I mean, if it was Laurie… well, I always wonder if she embellishes things.”
“Oh, no, not me.” Stacey said. “Laurie’s competitive as hell, but she doesn’t make stuff up.”
“Maybe. But if Rebecca says he’s that large, then I believe her.”
“Well, let’s consider that she’s only seen two of them in real life.”
“True, but she’s certainly learned her way around a dick in a short time!” Beth giggled.
Outside the room, Mike was dumbfounded. Sweet, innocent little Rebecca was sexually active? The thought titillated him.
“Wow. You really think so?” Stacey asked.
“Absolutely,” Beth said. “I know for a fact she’s right about one thing. On a guy’s dick, it’s not all just about the top, while that part certainly is fun. A guys balls are REALLY sensitive, believe me.”
“I don’t know…” Stacey replied, “That sounds… kinda dirty!”
“Dirty can be fun, too!” Beth replied, and they both laughed.
Mike was suddenly filled with fear, felt in the pit of his stomach. Stacey would never betray the relationship they had developed, would she? The girls were all really tight in their little club. He had to stop this conversation before Stacey spilled any beans whatsoever.
He quickly backed up a few steps, and shouted, “Stacey? Sweetie? You home?” He strolled up to her door, and knocked.
“Just a sec, Daddy!” Stacey answered. He heard them clicking away at her computer, obviously covering their steps. Then, Stacey opened the door, literally bumping into him as she rushed into the hallway, and gave him a tight hug. “Hi, Dad! Are you home early?”
“No, honey, I think you just lost track of time!” He hugged her back, smiling. Both girls were clad in gym shorts and school sweatshirts that were way too large for them. As soon as he wrapped his arms around his daughter, he could tell she was braless underneath, and his prick twitched in his pants.
He was instantly self-conscious of this development, especially when his loving baby girl pressed her tummy against it. Reluctantly, Mike gently pushed Stacey away. “Hello, Beth. How have you been?”
“Really good, Mr. Reynolds.” Beth smiled as she walked over to him. “Can I get a hug, too?”
“Of course!” Mike replied, enthusiastically.
Stacey moved aside to let Beth take her father into her arms, feeling a sudden pang of jealousy watching her friend press her hips forward into his, watching his arms envelope her and hold her close.
“You know I’m always happy to give you a hug, Lizzie.” Mike could tell she was also braless under her sweatshirt, and his erection betrayed his desire. Any hope he had that Beth wouldn’t notice was dashed the moment she pressed her crotch to his, and he felt his penis harden even more.
“Mmmm…” she replied, “You give the best hugs, Mr. Reynolds.”
Stacey pulled Beth away from her dad, and stood before him, hands on her hips. “Dad, we want pizza for dinner tonight.”
Mike smiled. “Are you buying, with all the babysitting money you’ve got saved up?” This was a long-running joke between them, as Stacey HATED babysitting.
“Ha-Ha, Daddy.”
“Oh, c’mon, Stace,” Beth said. “We can afford to buy your dad a pizza.”
“Hmmm… you’re right!” Stacey replied. “That way, we can get the toppings we like!” She trotted back into her room to get her purse, her ample bosoms bouncing freely in the loose top.
“I agree,” Beth said, brushing past Mike on her way back into Stacey’s room, making sure to rub against Mike’s thickening member, now obviously tenting his pants. “I’m in the mood for Sausage.” She winked at him and smiled.
[continued]
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/jcwnj5/daddys_girls_chapter_26_whos_next_mf_mff_inc_oral