A little while ago I made a post on r/R4R seeking someone to join me and my FWB for our first threesome. I have all the usual men responding to the post, but then a couple get back to me asking if we’d be keen for some group fun. Obviously I think this sounds like a great idea. So me and the guy (Thomas) get talking on Kik. Turns out his FWB (Natalie) is a Redditor who posts on gonewild and sends me a few pics from her profile… my god she is so hot! Gigantic boobs, just what I love. Naturally I’m very keen at this point and we all get talking in a group chat.
We discuss our boundaries, hopes and expectations from the meet, logistics of when to meet up. Next thing I know Natalie is asking to see some more risqué photos of me. I send some through and she’s pretty responsive and wants to see more, to which I suggest maybe we talk privately, so that Thomas doesn’t have to see photos of my dick.
Natalie and I talk privately and before I know it, the conversation has turned particularly risqué. We start fantasizing about what it would be like if the two of us secretly met up before having a group session with our regular partners. We both acknowledge that it would be extremely naughty pretending that we don’t know each other, disguising that we don’t already have an intimate connection. One thing leads to another and this sexy concept has now become an idea set in stone, and we lock in a date to meet before our group session.
By the evening of us meeting we’ve been talking non-stop for 24 hours- discussing our fantasies, sending voice notes describing past sex acts, sending more nudes- it’s fair to say that we’re both incredibly excited, feeling especially dirty considering we’re breaking both of our FWB’s trust meeting without their knowledge. The plan is that I would arrive at her house, where she would be wearing the same sexy lingerie that I loved so much in one of her gonewild posts and we’d immediately start being affectionate when I walk through the front door.
I arrive and she looks out of this world. Her boobs are even bigger than they look in her photos and she looks amazing in her lingerie. Instantly we’re kissing and just as she requested I pin her up against the wall, caressing her entire body. I sink down onto my knees and lift up her outfit, spread her legs open and stick my tongue on her clit. What else can I see? A shiny butt plug that I had seen her teasing in her gonewild posts. I’d never seen one before and my god, they are even sexier in person. Barely any time has passed at all and she’s already undressing me, we’re in her bedroom already and we’ve only said hello.
I told her beforehand that I like to tease and she is literally begging me for my cock. I’m a man of my word, so I make her wait. I make her sit on my face and with her big amazing ass positioned in front of my eyes, I’m reminded by an extremely pleasing view of her butt plug. I decide I want to grab it with my mouth and pull it out, revealing the sweetest tasting asshole I’ve ever experienced. I feel like a pubescent teenager discovering sex for the first time, I’m so drawn to it, all I want to do is play with the new toy.
We eventually start fucking and I’ve got her bent over. I’m spanking her like she asked me to in our messages. Once again, I can see her toy shining at me- which makes me think, I wonder what it will feel like for her if I put a bit of pressure on it? I do so and she moans. I push a little bit harder… and my heart sinks. The butt plug has slipped into her asshole. Whilst this is all going on, I’m still pounding away… and she’s still moaning! She hasn’t noticed that it’s gone inside! I poke my finger inside a bit and it’s within touching distance. My internal dialogue is going crazy. I’ve only met this girl maybe 20 minutes ago, what on earth do I do now? Do I instinctively reach inside to try and grab the toy? Do I carry on? No, of course I don’t carry on. Wait a second… I can’t carry on… I’m getting soft!
We stop and she rolls over onto her back and is giggling, presumably about the situation that we’ve found ourselves in. As she goes to talk, I interrupt her “we’ve got a problem.. it’s really bad…” A confused look appears on her face. I explain to her that I got too excited, pushed the butt plug and “it’s gone”. Natalie briefly checks the entrance to her ass, discovering that it isn’t there anymore, proclaims that it must have just fallen out and starts looking underneath the folds of the sheets. Foolishly in denial, I briefly humor her logic and help her look. When she begins to look on the floor, I confirm that it’s *definitely* inside her and that I saw it slip in. The confused look on her face is now gone, and a look of horror is now all that is there.
With neither of us knowing exactly what to do, we decide that the best thing for her to do is for her to go to the bathroom and try to get it out. She goes and I’m left naked in this strangers bedroom and in complete shock with a thousand things going through my head. I’m no stranger to Reddit, I’ve seen dozens of stories on r/TIFU about partners getting toys stuck up their butts. The inevitable outcome is it’s a trip to the emergency room to get it out. Fuck, I’m such an idiot! What a horrible thing to put this girl through. Then I start selfishly thinking about how there’s been such a sexy lead up to this encounter. A 2 hour journey for barely 20 minutes of fun. Also what about the group sex? What is she going to tell Thomas? How is she going to explain that her butt plug got stuck in her ass the day before we were supposed to meet?
5 minutes go by and I can hear the toilet flushing, the seat opening and closing, but no sign of her. Natalie reemerges from the bathroom and she has an exasperated look on her face- it has turned sideways and can’t get it out. Fuck. Whether it was to calm her nerves that she has got her toy stuck inside her ass, or to ease the tension that there are two naked and complete strangers going through a mini crisis, she announces that she needs a Vodka. I realize this whole time I’ve been completely useless and hadn’t even googled if there is a solution to this problem. I do so and It’s not looking good, a trip to the hospital seems the likely way this is heading. Natalie returns with alcoholic beverages, meanwhile I’m not having much luck finding any positive tips of what to do. As a last-gasp tactic I suggest maybe I could try having a go at getting it out? At this point it is extremely obvious we only met 30 minutes ago, she politely declines my offer of surgically sticking my fingers down her ass and returned back to the bathroom to try shit out this 3 inch stainless steel gem out of her ass. I’m cursing myself! Is this really how the evening is going to end up? How could I be so stupid?
Thankfully, there must be someone looking down from up there and after a few minutes of Natalie being in the bathroom do I hear the most satisfying *‘CLINK’* of the toy hitting the toilet bowl. THANK FUCK! I literally scream “YES!!” whilst pacing around the room doing a victory lap. She comes out of the bathroom and to be quite honest, I can’t even tell you what exactly was said or done after this, it’s a bit of a blur. We share one of the single most surreal feelings I’ve ever encountered with a stranger before- a mixture of relief, euphoria, giggles and seduction.
The night continues and the sex exceeded all expectations either of us had. I ended up staying the night and had almost continuous sex from 7pm until 2am. We both contemplated how weird and awkward the conversation would have been if I would have had to have taken her to hospital after only having known her for less than an hour. However as it happened, we really connected. Not just on a sexual level, but an emotional one too and plan on meeting up independently in the future. It was the biggest roller coaster of an evening I’m ever likely to encounter.
***TLDR:*** *I met a stranger for sex, got a butt plug stuck in her ass, both panicked, she got it out and ended up having one of the greatest nights of sex of my life.*
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/jcartf/mf_i_m27_met_a_stranger_f25_for_sex_and_ended_up
Hot