Continues from [Part 2.](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ixo7xy/makeup_sex_with_mary_mf_part_2/)
“??Good cum back over and I’ll let you pick a hole properly this time.”
I (23) wasn’t about to turn down an offer like that from Mary (21), my girlfriend of the last few years from whom I was now growing further apart by the day. But even the fits and starts of our sex life the last year were still far better than I could have ever imagined. Even the makeup sex after our admittedly vicious arguments was mind-melting amazing.
But who was I kidding? There was no way our relationship was going to last much longer. We were fighting more than fucking and fucking more than figuring our shit out. We basically tried to solve everything with orgasms. Today was going to be no different. We had each issued our truces over the Sofia incident and now were planning to seal the armistice with an afternoon of vigorous sexual activity. One of us was bound to break the ceasefire within a few days, but until then, the only shots would be cum.
I admit that knowing our days were numbered, I pushed Mary’s limits, wanting to enjoy everything I could with the woman who was, until my wife, the most sexually pliant person I ever met. It was totally selfish, too. Mary had an amazing body and knew how to use it. It irked me back then that one day she’d make some man the happiest (and luckiest) guy on the planet. The immature child in me wanted to make sure whatever he got to do with her, I’d done with her first. Super fucking petty, I know. I was never going to be able to seriously write her off as a “slut” or “bitch” or something like that because she wasn’t any of those things. Instead she was, at heart, a really wonderful human being, giving, unfailingly kind and good-natured.
That didn’t mean I hadn’t searched for porn to give me ideas of how to have fun with her. Which is, of course, what I had been doing after she invited me to come back to “pick a hole.”
I arrived at Mary’s place later. We were both clearly horny and had lost our ability to manage small talk, and neither of us wanted to risk our upcoming pleasure over a stupid fight. We each downed a stiff mixed drink she had made up to make the silences less awkward. In a brief lull, I broke the silence, asking if Mary wanted to play a game.
“What do you have in mind?”
“It’s a sex game. Kind of like, choose your own adventure meets Twister.” She looked puzzled.
I showed her the web app on my phone. It was an automatic randomizer with two columns – a male body part column, a female body part column and the idea was you’re supposed to put the two body parts together sexually. It announced the parts and automatically shuffled every two minutes, and was programmed with “Jeopardies” that were 15 second high intensity activities that popped up randomly for both girl on boy and boy on girl.
“Hah, sounds like we could get into some trouble. Game on!”
We went over to the living room and I hit the GO button. I guess this is the time to mention that there wasn’t actually anything random about this. It was a game designed to lead to sex and it gave you control over all the combos. I knew what I wanted to do with Mary, so I just fiddled until it gave me what I wanted in the order I wanted it.
As tempting as I was to have the first combo be “penis:ass” I chose something less intimidating.
The slightly computerized female voice said, “His hand. Her foot.” She sat down and kicked up a foot in the air. I took it standing in front of her and began to give her a foot massage. I was slow and took my time knowing that before long I’d have what I wanted. As I massaged her foot, she closed her eyes and relaxed. About a minute in I set her foot down and she raised the other to me. I continued until I was interrupted by, “His face. Her face.” I sat her foot down and straddled her as she sat up, taking her face in my hands and kissing her face, starting at her forehead and ending up at her lips. She kissed me back, deeply and I felt her tongue push past her lips and then mine. We continued kissing passionately for a full two minutes.
We went through my planned progression to Face:Foot where I kissed her feet and sucked on her toes, Hand:Face where she sucked suggestively on each of my fingers while never breaking eye contact. Then the first Jeopardy came up, “Jeopardy! You have fifteen seconds to remove all your clothing.” We both laughed and hurriedly removed our clothing, making a pile on the ground. I never tired of seeing Mary’s nude form, but I had decided to keep the humor up with the next combo of “His feet. Her breast.” We tried me standing first and her sitting on the couch, cupping her perfect retrousse breasts and me setting one foot between them. She tried titfucking my foot, which didn’t really work, but when we switched places, I began teasing her nipples with my toes. She surprisingly enjoyed that. I had selected Face:Breast next and she pushed her tits together. I motorboated her until we cracked up laughing again but then started to turn the heat up. Grabbing one breast in both hands, I raised her nipple to my mouth and began to suck on it, teasing it with my tongue and gently scraping it with my teeth, then pulling off and blowing cool air over the nipple before sucking it again. I was just getting into biting the nipple of her other breast when the phone announced a change: His ass. Her hand.
“Bend over, buddy,” Mary instructed me. I complied expecting some hard spanks. Her hand crashed down on my right ass cheek and made me jump. “Ow!” I protested. “Oh I’ll make it feel better,” she said sarcastically as she slapped my other ass cheek. I was just catching my breath when a sharp pain shot up through my perineum as Mary suddenly slid a finger into my ass. “Yeah, man, that’s what it feels like!” Well, I’m not sure what she was expecting it to feel like, but having her massage my prostate with a finger in my ass felt really fucking good. I reached between my legs to start to jerk myself off as she kept up the massage for a solid minute until we were instructed to change to His Hand: Her Breast. I had initially intended just to massage them firmly and toy with her nipples, but after she had fingered my ass I decided some more rough play was in order. I turned around reached out with both hands, grabbing her nipples and pulling her towards me. If being yanked by the tit was a surprise, then slapping one hard was another. But Mary didn’t flinch. Her stare grew more intense, trying to hide a grimace as I twisted and pulled her nipples, roughly kneaded her breast flesh and slapped them back and forth forehanded and backhanded as they swung from side to side. I could see she was planning her revenge. She’d have it.
“Jeopardy! Grind your ass and pussy on his face.” She threw me down onto the couch and jumped on top of me and before I could get a breath in she was grinding her pussy against my lips. I could feel her wetness and she started to slide her pussy around my face, over my forehead, down my nose, across my cheeks, smearing her sweet nectar all over my face. She spread her ass cheeks and pushed her asshole down onto my face so hard I could feel her sphincter drag across my cheek. She graciously paused over my mouth to let me eat her ass for a glorious moment.
“His cock. Her hand” came the edict. I felt Mary’s hand on my cock but she made no effort to stop sitting on my face, now positioning her pussy over my mouth. I plunged my tongue in and drank from her flower as she stroked my cock. She didn’t even stop at the next command or the one after, now grinding against my tongue, ignoring my dick and panting hard and heavy. She came in waves on my face, a small stream of her cum pouring into my mouth, acidic yet sweet. As Mary finished climbing off of me, just starting to catch her breath collapsing against the back of the couch, the phone intoned, “Jeopardy! Time to fuck her throat.”
I stood up and climbed up over her onto the couch my cock in her face, “Open your mouth,” I ordered her. My cock was already sliding through her lips as her mouth opened and I pushed straight to her throat pushing her head against the couch cushion. By now Mary never gagged anymore unless I broke her throat barrier, but this said to fuck her throat, so that’s what I did. For 15 amazing seconds, I went to town on her mouth, finally breaking through. It was my turn to ignore the next command and I held my cock in her throat. As she gagged, her throat muscles massaged the head of my cock, squeezing and milking the tip. She began to try to push away but I held her there, enjoying this special place. Eventually after almost 30 seconds she turned her head to the side, sliding my cock out and smashing it along with all the spit against her cheek. She was red in the face and coughing, some tears streaming down her face asI stepped down off the couch. I took her hand and pulled her up.
“The last one said His hands. Her ass.” And I turned her around and bent her over the couch. I had no intention of just spanking her amazing ass: Wiping some of the spit from her face, I lubed her anus and pushed my index finger in like she had done to me. Girl didn’t even flinch. Fine, two fingers and slipped my middle finger in. I was amazed that I caught almost no resistance! “You been fucking your ass with that dildo?” I asked Mary as I pushed a third finger into her butthole.
“Yeah and my pussy at the same time” she let escape through shallow panting breaths. Jesus. It was about that moment that I scrapped the progression through the app. My cock slipped almost as easily into her ass as my fingers had. God I loved fucking Mary’s ass. Her cheeks made the perfect bounce ever time my pelvis collided with them establishing a rhythm that took her breath away but kept me from cumming too fast. I won’t lie, I pounded some of my frustrations out into her that day. She was in some kinda zone because when the next instruction came up, she said nothing in response to “His cock. Her pussy.” I paused for a second maybe because something in my head said that was a bad idea, but then said to myself, fuck it, why not. I pulled my cock from her ass, admiring her gape from my dick as I slid it over her taint and straight into her pussy. She let out an audible gasp. “What are you…” I cut her off, “Picking a hole, Mary” and started to fuck her pussy doggystyle.
“Oh fuck!” She let out a string of expletives, “god yes, put it in my ass again!”
Going from her ass to her pussy was a whole new irresistible level of dirty Mary had taken on with barely a protest, and now she was asking for more. Grasping a fistful of her long flowing hair at the scalp, I pulled her back onto my dick, balls deep in her pussy. After pushing of her off I aimed and pulled her back again, my cock sliding effortlessly past her anal sphincter. I gave her a few deep thrusts in her butt before starting to sheath it back and forth between each of her holes. The sight and stimulation of using this Goddess like a dirty pornstar was too much and I was getting close. The absolutely filthy talk she was giving me certainly helped.
“You nasty fucker, I know the porn you watch. You wanna cum in my mouth don’t you? Say it. You wanna go ass to my slutty mouth. Say it!”
“Yes,” I hissed as I resumed plowing her ass, feeling my orgasm start to build, “I’ve fucked your ass and your pussy and now I’m gonna cum in your throat. Hows that for picking. a. fucking. hole.” I timed my thrust with each of the words. My orgasm started as I was balls deep in her ass but I pulled out and dragged her to the floor in front of me. My first shot of cum landed on her cheek as she turned, but her mouth was already open and she grabbed my ass and pulled my shaft all the way into her throat, pushing me past her barrier. She held herself steady, gagging intermittently as I ejaculated down her esophagus. Mary held me there until my orgasm subsided.
She spit my cock out and ran to the bathroom. I could hear her rinsing and spitting repeatedly. She came out a few minutes later, still nude. “My turn.”
She made me finger her ass (took three to get her enough stimulation and lick her clit until she came finally. She made me lick my fingers to share and it was, admittedly, unpleasant.
“Yeah, that’s right it’s effing nasty isn’t it. I can’t believe I let you deepthroat me out of my ass. I am so glad I prepped for anal. Fuck you I am never doing that again.”
As I looked up and down her spent body, I had no doubt she would some day do that again.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/j0fb3k/makeup_sex_with_mary_mf_part_3