This is a bit long and I’m on mobile so bear with me here (made this alt to post. Long time reader)
I wanted to share this on here cause I can’t share it in my normal life anymore. This is all 100% true but names are redacted.
Back in college I had been friends with 2 girls for a long time. We’ll call one Becca and one Annie. Neither was friends with the other.
Becca was a 5’4 girl with big boobs. Thicker but wouldn’t consider her fat. She was fun to be around and generally added to whatever I was doing at the time. She and I met my freshman year but got closer my junior year.
Annie was 5’7 with an athletic build and was skinny. Great body. She and I met my freshman year. We were always friends but for a long time she was dating a guy so I never gave us much of a thought.
For your imagination I’m a taller guy with a baby face and have broad shoulders (6’3 about 205) people say I’m good looking.
It all started when Annie and I broke up with different people. For whatever reason it wasn’t working out with the people we were with. I actually didn’t know that she had been broken up until one day she asked me to come over and hang out. She was acting kind of off until she flat out said it. “‘Old BF’ and I broke up. We’d been fighting a lot. We agreed to see other people”. I told her I was sorry and that must be hard. She told me she had mixed feelings about it. She loved him but she wanted to have fun. She got up and closed the door. She told me “don’t be weird about this. But you an I should fuck”. I didn’t listen to her and proceeded to be weird about it. After some initial shock cause she’d always just been Annie to me. I said okay. NGL the first time was weird. She got really into it and was dirty talking the whole time which I loved. But it was always just Annie. So we agreed that it was weird but we should give it a try. We made an “appointment” for Sunday and left it at that. We told each other we would keep it quiet as I was kind of friendly with her Ex. ( was always friends with Annie but was on good terms with him when he was around).
The next day I was hanging out with Becca and a group of friends. We went to a bar and were all shooting the shit. My break up came into the conversation and I was kind of over it (nothing to do with the story the girl was just not a good person). I told everyone jokingly “well I guess I need to take friends with benefits applications”. Becca replied back “Guess I’ll have to submit a resume”. I was thrown off but thought she was kidding. Later that night we were both walking the same way home and were talking. I was walking her home (it was on my way anyways) and she asked if I wanted to come up to her apartment. I was thrown off again but said yes. Up there we drank some more wine and eventually turned into us hooking up. We went at it like animals. Connected really well but not in a we have feelings sort of way. We had a big group of friends together and didn’t wanna make things weird so we decided to keep things a secret for as long as we could.
That week Annie expressed that she was trying to meet new people since her ex and her had the same friend group. I told her to come out with my group of friends. Becca was there too. When we were out Becca and Annie instantly became friends they connected really well and it was actually kind of funny to watch as I was keeping a secret with the 2 of them but neither knew about the other.
Eventually they went to the bathroom together. I’m not sure who spilled the beans but they came back laughing. They pulled me aside and said “we know” kind of playing it off I asked what they meant. “We know we both fucked you in the last 2 days”. Didn’t have much of a response so I just said “oh”. They started laughing and told me they weren’t mad. They actually found it interesting and said that it was cool. They told me that they wanted to continue what they had with me. Now that they knew about the other they insisted on condoms but said we could all be friends. This resulted in me having around the clock pussy and not being tied to either of them. It was amazing. We welcomed Annie into the group of friends. Everyone eventually found out about the little arrangement as I soon learned that neither of them can keep a secret. Which made it weird but no one cared too much.
Normally I’d meet up with one of them before the night, Go out with the group and then leave with the other. Several times they asked each other “can I have him tonight”. This went on till the rest of college until we all graduated. They were both great in their own way. I loved fucking them both. Annie was a screamer where as Becca was a little quieter. Annie wanted to try more but Becca and I clicked a bit better. They helped me get a trifecta (3 girls in one day). The 2 of them and then one girl from a class we shared (yes we wore condoms)
I’m still friends with both of them. Annie is currently with her old ex and I’m very happy for her. Becca moved away but we still keep in touch.
I can go into details about specific times if there is any interest. Before you asked there was no Threesome yes I tried. Annie was down but not Becca. Can’t have it all.
I have a lot of other odd sex stories if anyone wants to listen.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/iyq15k/my_2_friends_with_benefits_knew_about_each_other
That’s awesome.