A month or so had gone by since our first night together. In that time, Alex and I had sex at least twice a week, but otherwise our relationship was casual, more like a FWB situation than anything. I took her to breakfast a few times, basking in her “I came 4 times last night, and twice more an hour ago” glow as we sat across from each other savoring chocolate chip pancakes or french toast at her favorite diner.
I hadn’t gotten bored of seeing her writhe under my mouth or feel her hands on my chest when she sat on my face, grinding on my tongue. I had a feeling she wasn’t bored of me either; even when we passed each other between classes she flashed a cheeky grin and stuck her tongue out at me. Most of our housemates had to have known based on the sounds that must have come from her bedroom, and one gave me a two-thumbs up one morning as I stumbled out of her room on the way to the bathroom wearing only my boxers and a smattering of hickeys from my collar bone to my navel.
Alex was cooking us dinner one evening while the rest of the house was at night class or work. I was sat on the counter watching her stir this and add seasoning to that. She said I was a miserable cook, but I could chop onions without tearing up so that had been my only job. Don’t worry, I did the dishes after dinner when she cooked!
“Hey Sam, I was thinking about inviting a friend of mine over this weekend,” she said casually.
“Oh yeah? What’s the occasion?” I bounced my heels on the cabinet below me.
“Well he’s an old… Friend of mine and I think you would like him a lot,” she said slowly, turning around to look at me, “and I want to try a threesome.” She was blushing hard, all the way to her ears. I was surprised, I knew she was into threesomes and it came up on occasion, but I’d never had one with a man before. I nodded, interested in knowing more. I trusted that she wouldn’t ask me to do anything I wasn’t comfortable with, and I was willing to give it a shot.
“I kinda like that idea, can you tell me more about him?”
She smiled excitedly, “Yeah! His name is David, he’s kinda tall, buff, and at first he gives off “frat douche” vibes but I know that he’s a big bisexual softy and likes to be told what to do by hot women,” she said.
I nodded again, mulling it over. That could be interesting. Having a man willing to do whatever I asked, eager to please, and the idea of fucking Alex with my strap while she sucked his dick was exciting.
“Yeah okay I’d be down, I’d just want to meet him, y’know clothed first!” I winked at her.
“Yay I’m excited! I think it’ll be fun for everyone,” she smiled even bigger.
Later, she explained that he was an old fuck buddy of hers, and they still hooked up every once in a while (once since she and I had started) but enjoyed each other’s company as friends more often. I had no problems “sharing” her, as we were not in an official relationship and I was surprisingly looking forward to the threesome she had planned. I hadn’t done anything with a man since high school so was a bit nervous but she assured me of her confidence in his respect for his partner’s wishes no matter what. I looked forward to Friday night.
Friday arrived and I found myself preening in the bathroom mirror for longer than I care to admit before David arrived. We decided to order our favorite pizza with thin crispy crust and delicious white sauce, along with mozzarella sticks.
David arrived and Alex answered the door. I watched her hug him, and she led him by the hand over to me on the sofa.
“Hi I’m David, you must be the great Sam that Alex has told me about?” His handshake was firm, his grin warm. “Wow, you’re even hotter than I expected,” he said, half-teasing.
“The one and only. And thank you, Alex has fantastic taste in men, I must say. You want a beer or something before the pizza gets here, man?” I had to admit, his goofy surfer hair and blue eyes really were quite attractive. I knew he was excited for what was yet to come from his greeting. My heart sped up a bit in anticipation as well, but Alex had planned for a long build up so I had to wait. And so did he.
“Yeah dude break out some cold ones!” He gave me a fist bump as I stood to grab the drinks from the fridge. As the evening went on, the more I liked him. He was funny, respectful, and overall enjoyable company. He was an impeccable flirt too and I found myself getting worked up thinking about talking dirty to him in the bedroom.
Around 8pm the three of us were lounging on the sofa watching funny YouTube videos. Alex was leaning on me and I had a hand on her thigh, higher than just a casual touch. I watched David’s eyes get a little darker each time Alex whispered something in my ear. Sometimes it was naughty, and I made sure to bite my lip and catch David’s eye when it was. We all knew what was going to happen, it was just a matter of building up the tension until it broke.
Somehow we had inched closer together until Alex’s legs were draped across David’s and her side was against my front, my legs bent to accommodate her in my lap. My hands were resting on her legs. She reached for my head and pulled me down for a quick kiss. Until then we hadn’t really shown affection and when she let go I saw David with his mouth open slightly, staring at us. Alex smiled coyly and did it again this time kissing me harder, tongue dancing across my lips. She teased me by pulling back slightly, making me chase her mouth, and kissing with lots of tongue. I was keenly aware of David watching us closely as I ran my hands up her belly and sides, grazing her breasts as I went. I glanced up at David and made intense eye contact with him, then tilted her head back to expose her throat. My lips dragged on her neck, kissing and sucking little marks here and there. She made a soft moan, smiling at the sensation. My other hand trailed rough down her body again, over her breasts and down to the hem of her pants. My fingers crept into her underwear, just a bit. I hadn’t noticed, but she was rubbing David’s half-hard penis through his clothes with her heel.
“David, why don’t you come over here and kiss her too?” I said softly. He hardly needed any more prompting, and crawled over to us. His arms caged us in as he kissed her with an open mouth. The position of my legs was growing uncomfortable but I watched them make out, enjoying the view. His tongue explored her mouth excitedly.
“We should take this to the bedroom before our other housemates bust in,” I suggested, squeezing Alex’s leg. She nodded and David stood up, both of us following her to her room. She was already tossing aside her shirt and leggings, and I followed suit once David shut and locked the door.
“The safe word is cribbage, if anyone does something you don’t want, just say it and we can stop and try something else, okay?” Alex confirmed with us, everyone in agreement.
I walked over to her, and stroked her shoulders, trailing my hands down her chest to her breasts, still covered with the thin lacey bralette. Her nipples were hard under the fabric and I rubbed them with my thumbs before leaning to bite her cleavage gently, licking over the mark and sucking a hickey there. Her hands pulled my hips against hers, bumping together in the best way.
“David, baby, come here and join us,” she breathed. He approached her behind, moving her hair off her shoulder before kissing her neck and leaving his own mark there too. His hands grazed over her back and to the clasp of her bra, unhooking it and letting it fall to the floor. My hands and mouth explored her gorgeous tits as if for the first time while he nibbled her neck and jaw. His hands found their way to her panties, brushing her clit with his fingers through the soft fabric. The two of us worshiped her skin with our hands and mouths, reveling in the soft noises she made when an erogenous zone was touched. He dipped a hand into her panties to feel her pussy that was already soaking wet. She moaned loudly and trembled between us. His fingers worked her clit slowly and she was wriggling, begging for more. I was starting to really like this threesome arrangement!
I knelt in front of her, dragging my lips and tongue down her body until my face rested right at her pussy and I peeled down her panties, eager to taste her juices.
“Oh I’m so wet Sam please, please,” she begged as my breath ghosted cool on her swollen clit. I obliged, plunging my tongue into her pussy and sucking her clit, spelling my name over and over again with my tongue. While I ate her out, David groped her breasts and helped support her over me. She whined and whimpered, cumming quickly with my mouth on her pussy and his fingers on her nipples. She panted and shook with her orgasm, and I stood up to kiss her.
“Wait, let him have a taste,” she urged, scooting out between us. I was surprised but went with it and he leaned to catch my mouth in his. It was so different from kissing her, and neither of us knew what to do with our hands until Alex said, “You can touch him baby it’s okay,” and I slowly ran my hands down his chest. His body was different too, muscular, a little hairy, and radiating heat. I felt bold so I hooked my fingers in his waistband and pulled his hips to mine. I could feel his erection through his sweatpants, and although strange, I decided to embrace the pleasure the pressure it brought, pushing against me. I rolled my hips a little and he gasped in my mouth.
Alex took my hand then, pulling me toward the bed and David followed.
“Who do I get to fuck first?” she asked, her eyes dark and lusty.
David had kicked off his pants and she was inching down his underwear until his cock sprung out. I nearly laughed, but the absurdity was taken away by the surprise when I felt the heat in my belly leap with anticipation. His cock was perfect. Thick, just the right length, and his balls were neatly trimmed. Alex grinned excitedly, and gave it a gentle tug before ordering him to lie on his back. She straddled his hips and slid her pussy over his shaft, giving it all the lube he needed.
“Mmm baby do you want me to ride you? Fill my tight pussy with your cock and cum around you? I won’t put it in until you ask nicely,” she teased, her tone strong. She never talked to me like that, but it turned me on even more to see her so dominant.
“Yes Alex I wanna feel you fuck my cock please,” David whined desperately. I could see how she enjoyed his submissiveness. It was beautiful to watch. I had retrieved the strap-on from the drawer beside her bed and was lubing up the soft, ridged lavender silicone.
She raised herself up just enough and inserted the head of his cock inside of her before sinking slowly down on it, all the way to the hilt. They both moaned with pleasure, and she began pumping up and down on him with her hands on his chest. Her gorgeous ass jiggled with every movement and I crawled up the bed to smack it. She moaned again at the sting of the spank. David was caressing her tits as she rode him ruthlessly. Suddenly she slowed her pace, sitting up straight and grinding in circles on him. David whimpered, rutting his hips up into her. I crawled behind her and kissed her neck while looking David in the eye. I thrust my hips so the strap slid past her hip and she grabbed it, playing with it like she would a real dick. The eroticism of this was intense, even if I had no sensation.
“You’re not gonna cum until I say you can, big guy,” she chided, pulling his cock out of herself, “and I want you to cum in my mouth while Sam fucks me from behind.”
I scooted back to allow space for her to lay between his legs, and she wrapped a hand around his shaft. I tilted her ass up and spread her legs a little, giving her ass another smack as I did. Then, as she kissed the head of his cock, I slid mine inside of her wet, pink pussy. She moaned around his cock, sucking it expertly. I thrust with an even, fast rhythm, and reached down to finger her clit. If he was going to cum, he’d have to hurry before I made her orgasm so hard she saw stars.
Sure enough, he made a strangled moan and his toes curled when she swirled a finger against his taint and filled her mouth. She kept sucking, milking him dry and her own breaths became ragged, practically whining with every deep thrust and the pressure I was applying on her clit. She came hard, spasming around the strap-on and arching her back. I pulled out so I could watch her squirm in ecstasy. Davids cock was soft but already starting to recover, and I knew we were going to keep fucking until everyone was satisfied.
“I wanna try something,” I said tentatively, “David just let me know if you don’t want to.” I moved toward him as Alex rolled to the side. She watched me with wide eyes; I’d never expressed desire to do anything one on one with a man, so she was excited to see what I’d do. I moved his legs to either side of mine, took my silicone dick and slid it next to David’s, already a semi. Wow, this guys got stamina! He’d have to, to fuck Alex as much as she likes to be though I thought to myself. I took both shafts in one hand and drizzled some lube on them.
I was kneeling, with my knees against his ass, rocking my hips slowly, rubbing our dicks together. I’d seen gay men frotting before in porn and in movies, so I wanted to see what would happen if I tried it with my fake dick. The ridges on the dildo and my slicked hand created a new sensation for David. His eyes were wide and he had a hand on my thigh. My pussy was dripping wet and I was deeply engrossed in the erotic, intimate act we were performing. Alex had long since recovered from her orgasm and was watching us in awe. Later, I learned that David’s experiences with men were very very few, even fewer were there instances when I was given dick by. David moaned and wiggled under me. My pace was slow and measured, I imagined he was growing impatient. I could feel my face forming an expression of pleasure, though I didn’t derive any physically from what I was doing, the act itself was enough to unravel the coiled heat in my belly. My senses were in fire and I reveled in watching what I did to him.
“Ugggghhh that feels so good, do it harder,” he whined. Alex giggled, knowing that I wouldn’t let him off easy.
“Ah, not if you ask like that babydoll,” I scolded, maintaining my painfully slow pace.
“Come one please, I need it, please go faster!” David whined, squirming. Alex was behind me now, kissing my neck and shoulders, looking at David teasingly like I had earlier.
“Please, who,” I demanded, more harshly than I intended. David whimpered and kept trying to move but I wouldn’t let him.
“Please Daddy fuck me harder!” David begged. I could have cum from that ego boost. Alex rarely ever called me daddy; it wasn’t my favorite thing but oh man. In the right circumstances it was enough to get me dripping wet. My hips picked up speed and I squeezed the base of his cock a little harder, thrusting against the slick space of my hand and his cock. His moans became insistent after a minute, and I slowed again, wanting to hear him beg for it. And beg he did.
“Ugh I wanna cum please Daddy let me cum I need you to fuck me until I cum please,” he babbled desperately. With a firm grip around him, a few more purposeful thrusts, his balls tighted and his cock throbbed in my hand; He came hard, ropes of cum spurting across his chest and belly. He panted and I gave his dick a few more gentle strokes with mine, cum leaking out of the tip.
“Holy shit, that was the hottest thing I’ve seen in a while,” said Alex from behind me, her breath cool on my neck. “Sam I think it’s your turn to cum too, isn’t it?” I nodded wordlessly. I unhooked the strap-on and tossed it to the side. My clit was swollen, and I ached for release. Without trying, this whole adventure also included me edging for the first time and I wasn’t sure I liked it. I felt restless and irritated but filled with insatiable lust. Alex and David would have to figure out how they would work together to bring me over the edge as I was a mess of dripping pussy and diamond cutter nipples. My butch ass had never felt such a great need for hands and mouths on me.
They must have gauged my desire and practically pounced on me. Alex went in for the kiss and I grabbed her face hungrily. The kiss was sloppy and sexy and then David hitched my legs up over his shoulders, settling in between them. He licked his lips and looked at me with electric eyes before licking a wide stripe across my clit.
Pleasure zinged through me and I moaned in Alex’s mouth, arching my back. David’s mouth moved diligently on my pussy; I could tell he was more experienced at it that Alex. My body seemed to move uncontrollably as my climax mounted, hands grasping sheets, then his hair, hips gyrating on his mouth. His tongue slipped inside me, and I was nearly screaming.
“That’s it baby, cum for us,” Alex whispered in my ear between nibbling my earlobe and kneading my tits. David pressed hard on my clit and I was over the edge. My body stiffened, arching off the bed and I screwed my eyes shut. The pleasure flowed in waves through me and I faintly felt his mouth still on my pussy, licking gently. As I came down from the magnificent high, I decided edging might be a fun treat every now and again. That was the best orgasm I’d ever had. Suddenly, I felt big fingers in my sensitive pussy pumping in and out carefully. The sensation was lovely.
“Mmmmm keep doing that please…”
“I’m hard again, if you want I could make you cum again with my cock inside you,” David offered, “Alex likes it when I do it right after she cums too.”
“Okay, you can do that,” I responded quietly. His fingers slid out and I looked to see his cock sliding though the juices on my pussy, lubing himself. Then he slowly pushed in. I was definitely not accustomed to the girth but the stretch was lovely and the full sensation ignited the coals of my last orgasm again. I sighed and he stopped for a moment so I could adjust. Alex kissed my cheek and caressed my abs down to my pubic mounds. Her fingers found my clit and rubbed it lazily. They were going slow and deep, the only way I really liked to be fucked with a dick, silicone or the real deal. After a few moments of David filling me without moving, I wiggled my hips.
“Move.” I said simply, and he did. Long, deep thrusts, to the hilt and grazing across my g-spot. He propped my legs up even higher, changing the angle he entered. He rolled his body in sweeping strokes, skin slapping skin. Alex’s ministrations to my clit we’re bringing me closer and closer. They maintained the even pace as I stuttered out, “I’m so close!”
My pussy clenched around David’s cock and I came again, less intense this time but in a warm and pleasant way. He pulled out, his cock resting on my belly and rubbed my thighs as the shook. He leaned down to kiss me. His lips were soft and he tasted like me. I savored the kiss. It was nice, intimate, gentle.
“Can I finish on your tits?” He asked Alex, who nodded. With a few quick strokes, cum splattered her chest and dripped off her nipples. I dug around in the drawer and procured a couple cloths and baby wipes we kept stashed for clean up. Everybody wiped fluids off themselves and we collapsed in a satisfied heap. David lay on his back, Alex snuggled into me, and I was the middle spoon.
“Fucking incredible. That was so good, thank you for the invite,” David breathed, “you gals know your stuff!”
Alex patted his tummy, already starting to doze off, “Yeah it was, I think my favorite parts were watching Sam jerk you off with the strap-on and cumming with both of you inside me. Top ten sex, bravo everybody!”
“Mmmmm yeah I would be down for doing this again too,” I slurred sleepily. The best aftercare for an incredible threesome is cuddling under soft blankets, no doubt about it.
_________________
Thanks for reading, let me know if you enjoyed it! This was fun to write ;)
XOXO – Blue
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/ihgt5a/surface_tension_pt_2_ffm_butchfemmeman_threesome