Having a threesome is one of those bucket list things for a lot of people. I know it was always on mine. But there should probably be some planning. Like any. Also communication. Ah boy.
To set the stage, I’m 19 in this story, coming back for my first summer after freshman year of college. I’m about a year out of my last serious relationship and 6 months away from starting my next. Also I’m incredibly horny and start chatting up the underclassmen from high school who just graduated and are looking for some fun (again, I was 19. Everyone in this story was at least 18).
Ronda (of course that’s not her real name) had had the hots for me for a couple years. She was a cute scene girl, red hair down to her chin that fell like a curtain over one eye. She had a few piercings. She was thin and pale, with a great laugh and big beautiful eyes (well, eye, the one I could see regularly. I assumed the other was of similar size and quality).
She and I had been chatting for a few days and then she invited me over to her place. I knew what was up, so I dressed a little nicer, put on a little cologne and showed up hot to trot. Ronda and I start kissing then she seems to get cold feet. Which is fine, I am not into pressuring anybody into anything. But then she seems to get back into it.
I’m a little thrown off by the hot and cold. I start asking her if she really wants this when there is a knock at the door. Ronda explains she had told her friend Mandi (also a nom de amor here) I was coming over and Mandi wanted to come see me. Now what I knew, that Ronda might not have, was that Mandi had been crushing on me for almost 10 years. She was crazy hot and also just… very clearly had some emotional issues that I didn’t want to exacerbate, which was why I had always kept her at a polite distance.
Only now she was in the house (really a double wide) with me and Ronda. There was a lot of whispered conversation while I sat on the bed a bit… confused and conflicted. On one hand threesome with two cuties! On the other hand… I had a suspicion this could go off the rails quickly. The girls announced they were going to take a shower together. I was not invited, but needed to sit and wait.
Visions of the two girls soaping one another up danced through my head (a group of girls in my graduating class had taken a spring break trip senior year and all fucked one another, so I was kinda thinking those Penthouse letters weren’t total bullshit). The girls came out wrapped in towels, whispering more conversation and giving me looks. At this point, I had decided I would roll with whatever came next because… fuck it, you know? Consenting adults and all that.
“So what is going on here?” I asked.
“We want to play a game,” Mandi said. She was taking the lead on this.
“Okay,” I said with a little nervousness, though I figured there was no way I could lose the game so long as it didn’t involve my butt.
“We’ll cover your eyes,” Mandi said. “And you have to guess whose mouth is on you.”
Well, we’re just jumping right to it then, huh? “Okay,” I say.
They first try to blindfold me but that’s not working cause I can see just fine. So instead then put a pillow over my head. Now, I was slightly worried they were going to kill me. But 19-year-old boys aren’t known for their critical thinking skills, so I thought it was worth the risk. And when my pants started getting undone by a pair of hands, I figured my bet had paid off.
At first they just stroked me, whispering to one another. I was already hard the minute they started on my belt buckle, and this just took it to another level. Then finally, I felt a cautious tongue caressing the head of my cock. I wanted to encourage who ever this was, so I let out a nice loud moan into the pillow. The tongue flicked along the shaft and then the girl struggled to get the head into her mouth. Ronda was the tinier of the two, so I figured it was her almost immediately. After swirling her tongue around the head a little she pulled back.
After a brief moment of chill as her saliva met the AC, my dick was enveloped in warm wetness. Almost the entire thing. Whoever this second girl was (probably Mandi), she only had room for two fingers encircling the base. I had never had anyone take that much and I moaned much more loudly and genuinely. She started to bob her head, rubbing her tongue along the underside while stroking with the perfect amount of pressure.
But after a few seconds I heard some more whispers. They sounded less conspiratorial and more angry. Someone was still stroking me slowly while this conversation was happening. The blowjob had brought me closer to cumming than anyone ever had before and I was really hoping Mandi (I was sure it was her) would go back down. But then I felt a weight leaving the bed and the door closed before the pillow was removed from my head.
Ronda explained that Mandi was stealing her thunder and this was HER booty call, so she had told Mandi to leave. I was internally let down but just rolled with it. Ronda was naked and I started kissing her, running my hands over her a-cup breasts and brushing her small erect nipples with my thumbs. I laid her back down on the bed, kissing down her stomach to her hips. I kissed them with a good amount of tongue and then moved down to her pussy.
She was clean shaved, and my tongue glided easily over her outer lips. She started breathing hard, but I like to build things up so I waited a long time before finally, sliding my tongue between them and parting her inner lips up to her clit. She shuddered hard and dug her fingers in my hair. I love when a woman does that, so I moaned into her and went back at it. I had read that humming while you suck the clit felt really good, so I tried that, humming as loud as I could. I don’t know if the humming actually helped, or if it was just the direct suction on her clit, but she came almost immediately.
I kept kissing around her thighs while she caught her breath, then she pulled me up, taking off my shirt and wiping my face off with it before kissing me hard.
“I want you inside of me,” she said. Roger that.
Except she was tight. Really, really tight. And I have a very girthy member. I rubbed the head around the entrance of her pussy, which was dripping wet. But each time I tried to press in, it just didn’t work. I tried to give up but she grabbed me with her arms and legs and told me to keep trying. After probably 5 minutes of work, I finally got the head in.
Which was when her little brother opened her bed room door and started telling her to do some chore.
I had never jumped OUT of someone before, but I did then. Somehow, mid-air, I grabbed my pants, rotated and landed with them in my lap to cover up my very confused penis. Ronda shrieked at her brother to get out of the room. I turned the color of beet juice. Ronda offered to continue but the experience had confused and scared the horny right out of me.
Mandi contacted me later, offering to do her magic again. I was tempted, but… something told me it was a bad idea. To this day she is still trying to get me to hook up with her. Talk about carrying a torch.
(side note: my mom found out about this story because I had been writing letters to my best friend while he was in basic training, and he brought it up in his first response letter, which she opened eager to find out how the kid was doing. I got a very awkward question about “the double blowjob” story and well…)
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ih0pl9/my_first_accidental_threesome_kinda_mff