Swapping with my twin late one night [FM]

So, my twin and I went to the same college and we decided to not be roommates for the first time in our lives in the hopes of finally getting some much needed individuality. We kind of drifted apart for the start of the year and didn’t hang out together that much and aside from a few comments, no one really knew twins lived on campus together. All through high school we dressed alike and did the twin thing, but it was time for autonomy.

Anyways, towards the end of the year my sister and I were getting drunk and talking and at the time we were both kind of seeing guys that we weren’t super enthusiastic about. Like any good 80s movie, we hatched a plot to swap dudes for the night in hopes of seeing what the other guy was all about. We had done this once before years ago, so there we kind of had something to start with. We hadn’t been with either of these guys too long and they knew about us being sisters, and knew we were twins, but we hadn’t been talking much lately, so we never really hung out as a group.

The plan was basically we’d have a few drinks with our dudes, I was dating Tom, she was dating Darius, and then we would get them nice and turned on, then go to the bathroom and swap. We had an exact time set and identical outfits. We planned ahead and did our makeup the same, did our hair the same – luckily we had pretty much the same length, I had cut mine a bit shorter recently, and so it was close, but not exact. The hope was the guys would be all worked up and not notice. The morning of the plan my sister asked me if I was shaved downtown, which I was not, so we had to coordinate that whole thing too, which I hadn’t even thought about.

Tom, a pretty fit runner and all around dumb dude, and I were in my dorm having a few drinks watching a movie and leading up to it, I’d been teasing him a bit and getting him worked up. We were four beers in and getting pretty tipsy and started making out, and I say I have to go plug in my phone and I text my sister that it’s go time, she responds and I tell Tom I’m going to go to the bathroom and he better be ready for me when I get back, we kiss and I leave the room. My sister does the same and I go out the back door of the dorm and we pass and hand off key cards. It was pretty late so there was no one around. I walk across the quad and go to her dorm and key in.

When I get to her door, I have a momentary bit of panic, almost chicken out, and then realize that if I don’t go through with it, she’ll be over there with Tom and Darius will be by himself for like an hour and freak out. So, I take a deep breath and key in the door and there he is, my sister’s boyfriend who is a 6’4 (I’m 5’1) huge black dude, sitting on the bed totally naked stroking his cock. I got more panicky when I saw how big he was and he kind of looked at me sideways like he was confused.

“Took you a bit, thought you ran away,” he said, and I guessed that’s why he was weirded out a little. He walked over to me, his dick standing at attention looking like the start of a porn scene, and he picked me up like I was little doll. He said he missed me and started kissing me, I could taste beer on his breath and wondered if he could taste that I was drinking different kinds of beer than they were and I was suddenly worried I would get busted. Then, I also had a panic attack that our nipple rings would give us away. When we turned 18 my sister and I went and got our nipples pierced together, but one of us got the left done and the other the right and I was freaked out he’d notice my nipple ring was in the other nipple.

He carried me to the bed and dropped me on the thin mattress with a huge smile. Just staring at his dick made me realize my sister was a rock star and she was about to be disappointed with Tom who was just slightly above average for a white dude – but he was pretty good with it.

Darius pulled off my shorts in one swoosh and smiled when he saw I wasn’t wearing panties. He kneeled beside the bed and started going down on me with no hesitations. I wanted to turn the lights off so I didn’t get busted, but there was no way to do it smoothly, so I just rolled with it.

He was pretty garbage at oral. His tongue was forceful and just dug inside of my pussy, and he clearly didn’t have much experience finding a clit. He kept tongue fucking me and massaging my thighs and looking up at me. I tilted my head back and moaned a bit to keep his eyes off mine. Then, with zero warning he shoved his tongue right up my asshole. I grabbed his head and gasped in shock and he pulled away and said, “what?”

“I was surprised, sorry,” I had to just roll with it more.

He laughed and said how could it be surprising, I love that. And, I realized my sister was a total butt slut and laughed a bit as Darius dove right back in and started thrusting his tongue as far as he could into my asshole with zero shame. And, I was actually loving it. Tom wasn’t into anything like that and aside from a few trips down drunken Anal Boulevard, he didn’t like ass play much. I wanted to text her to tell her to keep her fingers away from his ass or he’d freak out, but it was too late.

Darius stood up, and I leaned forward and took the head of his massive cock into my mouth. I had a few concerns about taking him inside my pussy.

“Go get your thing,” he said to me, smiling with all of his teeth. I panicked, what fucking thing. He motioned towards my sisters dresser so I walked over and opened the top drawer and didn’t see anything that really stood out, and he said, “Did you move it” and sounded a bit weird. I opened the bottom drawer and moved a pile of workout clothes and saw a vibrator and a bulbous jeweled butt plug. I grabbed both and tossed them on the bed, trying my best to just go with it.

He instantly snatched up the butt plug and reached into the bedside table and pulled out a tube of lube. He motioned with his head to get on the bed, so I did, I climbed on and got on my hands and knees and he turned my body so my ass was facing him. It had been about a year since I had a buttplug in my asshole and a while since I had anal sex so I was bracing myself for dear life.

Darius lubed up one of his fingers and slid it slowly into my ass, sliding it in and out and around and I was just grabbing onto the pillow for support. He started finger fucking my asshole and I was hugging the pillow and gasping, it was a lot, but it felt amazing. He moved to two fingers and I moaned loud and he laughed. Then I felt the steel tip of the plug, cold against my asshole. He pushed slowly and I held on and tried to stay loose. This plug was larger than any I’d ever owned, it was definitely the medium size and I had never graduated from small. My asshole expanded then snapped close around the base and I was panting. Darius slapped my ass and pushed on the end and smiled.

He turned me and sat me on the edge of the bed and I don’t think my asshole had ever felt so filled. The pressure made me feel full. He leaned in and we kissed more as he pushed the end of the plug more making me squirm like crazy. I could feel my pussy dripping wet. He told me to go to the window, so I stood and walked over, stopping in front of the blinds which were pulled shut. He told me to open them, so I did, and I looked out onto the side road that runs along the school.

Then, he stood behind me, leaning over and swinging the window wide open. He pushed me forward against the window ledge and I could feel him holding my hips. I felt the head of his cock sliding around my wet pussy lips and I grabbed onto the window ledge and he touched the side of my face and said that I wasn’t talking much and was it ok.

I said, yeah for sure, and as I was about to add something else I felt his cock part my pussy lips and slide inside of me. I gasped in shock at the girth and bent fully over. He stood behind me and pushed deeper and deeper and I felt so incredibly full with my ass filled and him inside of me. I had never felt something like this before it was insane and intense and amazing. He started fucking me hard, slamming me into the window and I could barely breath I was panting so hard. He started calling me his little white fuck toy and his personal whore, and so I just started saying whatever came to mind, fuck me harder, and I tossed in a with your huge black cock. He leaned in and pushed his cock fully inside of me after ten minutes of hard fucking that left me a sweaty mess and I was almost in shock and he asked me if I loved his n-word dick and I came the hardest I’d ever cum before in my life. I was almost crying.

He grabbed me from the window and pushed me down on the floor and unleashed a stream of cum all over my chin and neck. I was just in awe at the fucking I had gotten and could barely move. He walked over to the desk and used my shorts to wipe the cum off his own dick and tossed them on the floor then he opened a beer and sat down on the bed. I stood up and pulled on the cum soaked shorts and pulled my tank top over my head and said I had to go to the bathroom. I covered my face in case anyone walked along and got to the bathroom. Using a fist full of paper towels I wiped the cum off my face and was wondering what to do with the butt plug still in my ass.

My sister walked in the bathroom looking about the same and she started laughing, she grabbed some paper towels and wiped my neck and chest and said we should trade clothes since hers were clean. I asked her what I should do with the plug and she told me Darius likes me to leave it in until the second round. So, very unceremoniously I bent over the bathroom sink as my sister pulled the huge plug out of my asshole and proceeded to slide it back into her own. Then she told me my boyfriend was boring and walked out.

I jogged over to my dorm and found Tom already asleep in the bed so I laid down next to him.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/iaue9w/swapping_with_my_twin_late_one_night_fm