Can you make a mistake and feel good at the same time? I close my eyes in the shower with the water pressure relentlessly pouring on me. The vivid memories from yesterday haunt me and I realize that no amount of water can wash those memories from my brain. Here’s what happened.
My girlfriend Joanna is a stunner. She’s Persian; She’s about 5’4, 100 pounds with C cup boobs. She hasn’t had that many boyfriends and I was the first guy to actually go down on her. The sex was incredible and while she was conservative, she was very open to making me happy in any way sexually.
I have had a cuck fantasy for several years now and while she is still not completely to the idea, she plays into my fantasy. Before we were dating exclusively, she was dating her high school friend, Larry, a couple of times. Larry was white and taller than me (6’3 to my 5’10). The reason why I knew about Larry was that she told me that if we weren’t exclusive, she was going to date him. I ended up wanting to date her exclusively.
2 months into us dating and having the best sex of our lives, I was always interested in what made her want to date Larry exclusively. I know they didn’t have sex, but how far did they go? We had a couple of masturbation sessions about Larry and she would tell what had happened during these sessions. I won’t spend too much time walking you through the details on the sessions (he got her off by grinding his dick on her clit), but it’s important to note that I recorded some of these sessions and I have been getting off to them for a year. She has asked me if she could get a pass and fuck him, and to be honest – I am 99.9% sure she was joking.
Since I couldn’t stop getting off to the audio clips and a part of me truly thought that Joanna wanted a pass. Because I loved her so much and the thought of another guy making her feel like a goddess turned me on so much that I decided to message Larry to try and set this up.
I message Larry on Instagram. I saw that he had a girlfriend, but this didn’t deter me. Our messages were as below:
**Me**: Hey Larry, this is Gary. We sort of know each other.
**Larry**: Uh, who are you?
**Me**: You know Joanna right? Well, Joanna and I dated shortly after you two…
**Larry**: Why are you messaging me?
**Me**: It’s complicated. I know you two had fooled around a bit – are you still attracted to her?
**Larry**: This is really weird. I am going to go.
**Me**: Ok I’ll go straight to the point. Would you want to fuck her?
**Larry**: What kind of sick joke is this?
**Me**: I want you to fuck her. She might be down. She was always intrigued by what could have happened if we didn’t start dating seriously. I know she got really wet for you and got off tot you a lot.
**Larry**: Uhh… how do I know this is not a joke?
**Me**: She’s asked me for a pass before. It may have been a joke, but I really want this to happen. And I think she needs you too.
Larry and I end up jumping on a call; I convinced him by telling him the stories that Joanna had told me. He seemed amused that I would be into this kind of stuff and I could tell his ego was getting bigger as he found out about how much Joanna enjoyed his touch. I promised him that we would keep this from his girlfriend and he told me that Joanna was hotter than his current GF and that he still thinks about Joanna from Garye to Garye. Her moaning was the hottest he had heard from any girl.
The next step of my plan was to get all three of us together. I invited Joanna to my place to talk things out and I told Larry to drop by 30 minutes after Joanna came. I took advantage of the first 30 minutes by making Joanna feel comfortable and making out with her. I gently massaged her neck and back to get her wet; I felt bold and asked if she got off to Larry recently. She said, “No, I only think of you.” I was a little disappointed with her answer and so I told her I really wanted to hear their story again while she touched herself. She rolled her eyes and reluctantly agreed. She started rubbing her clit and telling me; I could tell she was thinking about the previous events and it got me incredibly hard. This is when the doorbell rang and I let Larry in.
Joanna was incredibly shocked and quickly asked, “What the hell is going on?” She looked at me incredulously but I could also see her pupils dilating and her getting nervous in an excited way. They hadn’t seen each other for awhile and I am guessing there was still a lot of physical attraction.
I explained to her that I wanted to reconcile what had happened before and if she wanted the pass… I am happy to give it to her today. She seemed very annoyed with what I had done, but she was like OK… I told her that I felt like I have been really selfish with my actions and wanted her to just focus on herself and feel good.
We ended up all chatting on the couch. We all shoot the shit and I could tell that Larry was eyeing her hard. Joanna was wearing a short skirt with a tank top, so you could see her nice boobs and its cleavage. We end up taking shots to lighten the mood. I wink at Larry and say I am going to the restroom. Joanna looks at me with eyes that looked scared, but I could sense some excitement in her eyes as well. I leave to the “restroom’ but I am only hiding to see what Larry does next.
Joanna says she needs to get a cup of water and proceeds to get up, grabs her class and as she walks away Larry gets up behind her, hold his hands over her hips and she could feel his hard thick cock against her butt. She is a little shocked at first and says, “What are you doing”, but I could tell that the alcohol also made her horny. She instinctively but subtly grinds on his penis and I see Larry slide his hands from her hips to her stomach and up to her gorgeous breasts. I think I hear her say, “God this feels good,” and she moves her arms above her head giving me more room to slide his hands all over her chest. He starts kissing her on her neck as she starts running her hands through my hair.
Larry turns her around to face him and that’s when I come back. I looked at them and asked, “Do you want the pass? To be honest, I asked Larry here today to fuck you. I want to see you both fuck.” She looked at me and asked, “Are you sure…? I am drunk… “ I look at her and say, “I will be here.”
She looks at me for final approval and I nod in her direction. I felt that she was too nervous and I really wanted her to open up. So I help remove her clothes while Larry is busy kissing her on the lips, under the ears (I remember her saying she really liked it) and using his big arms to hold her balance. I start removing her clothes, her tank top, her skirt, her bra and her panties. It is almost night and day as Joanna starts moaning in excitement and doesn’t seem to be questioning the situation anymore.
I could feel my jealousy rising, but my sexual excitement rose to even greater heights.
I asked her, “How do u like it baby? Are u horny?” Stupid question…I thought.
She moans louder and says,”Yes, he’s making me wet. Are you sure you want him to open me up? I feel really bad…”
I told her, “It’s only okay if you want it. Do you want it?” He’s now putting his tongue on her hard nipples and she’s moaning while talking to me.
She says, “Yes, but I still love you. I hope you know that.”
I tell Larry to use his other hands to touch her boobs and that he should know that her boobs are very sensitive. He replies, “I don’t need you to tell me. I probably made her feel better than you could ever.” I felt my heart sink at that moment.
After a while of licking and sucking on her nipples he slides one hand between her legs, spreading them a little and playfully touching her around her vagina -not touching her clit or going in – and just feeling the dampness and making her moan louder. I know she’s gradually opening up and I could feel hear her sexual intensity going higher and higher
Larry decides to involve me and points at the big bulge in my pants, while turning her towards me. It makes sense though. I know he wanted her to suck my dick and feel her attention slowly – but surely – transferring over completely to him. She takes off my pants/underwear and drops to her knees herself, taking my hard dick in her hands while looking at me. I am silent at this point and Larry tells her to suck me.
I gently place my hand on the back of her head, pushing her face towards your dick. I was geting turned on that he was commanding her and I could feel him press her mouth harder on my penis.
I am incredibly nervous as Larry removes his clothes as I didn’t know his size. When he takes off his pants, I can see that he’s at least 2 inches longer than my 5.5 inches and his girth was definitely more than 6.5 inches. I am pretty proud of my girth, but this was huge. My heart sank thinking that maybe this is why she still wanted him.
Larry gets up behind her and starts feeling her up from behind. I could see his large and hard dick getting close to her wet, soaking vagina and my heart starts to accelerate in pace.
I tell him, “She doesn’t open up easily for anyone including me so u will need to really make her feel comfortable.” He answers, “Don’t worry, I know she’s already open for me.”
My dick is throbbing so hard at this point I tell her that “It’s okay… I am sorry for all the things I have done and you need to have your fun.”
I then point blank told her, “I want you to feel good and really want him to be inside of you.”
Larry slid his hand over her back and gently squeezed her ass. He tells her she smells amazing and asks if he can finally lick her pussy, “Remember when you rejected me, but I know you wanted it? Let me taste you.”
I loved the fact that she was still partially resisting and immediately she looked at me. I tell her it’s ok and tell u to go for it. She nods her head shyly.
While Joanna was sucking me off, Larry slid on his back and positioned himself with his head right beneath her pussy in her kneeling position. He places his hands on her hips and gestures for her to sit lower on his face, with his tongue extended.
I could see Larry getting his first good taste of her and she lets out a loud moan – louder than any moan that I have heard her make – and he’s talking dirty to her. “Now you know what you have been missing out on. I know you wanted my dick the first time we were making out on the couch and I made you cum.”
Larry licks around her pussy lips and finds her clit; He uncovers it and softly swipes the tip of his tongue along and over it for a while in a circular motion. I felt her getting into it more and more; I could see her grinding on his tongue and it was so hot seeing them getting more and more in sync. I felt her moaning a lot more and she was not even sucking my dick at this point.
I then see Larry get a little more ballsy, and he presses his tongue deeper into her pussy, making long strokes from bottom to top of her juicy vagina – ending every time with a short little tickle or sucking motion on her clit.
As he increases his speed, she starts moaning loudly and so erotically.
At this point, she was so into it that she straightened her back so she could start controlling how his tongue was pleasing her. She put her hand over her mouth trying to restrain herself from showing how good she was feeling, but it was evident that she only wanted to feel good and forgot about me.
I then stood there, throbbing hard with my dick in her hands. She was using it more to stay upright and I couldn’t help but see his bigger cock ready to go while he was eating out Joanna’s wet pussy. I didn’t expect this to happen so early, but she screams, “omg, I am going to cum. Stop, please.” Larry ends up grabbing onto her more tightly and Joanna cums uncontrollably. The crescendo of her moans made me cum instantly.
I could tell Joanna’s orgasm was very powerful because she stayed on the floor for a bit until Larry grabbed her and pushed her against the wall. Joanna’s face is against the wall and I loved the look of Joanna’s ass/pussy fully exposed. Larry then raises her arms and pins her gainst the wall while using his tongue to feel her neck to her shoulders. This is when I see him about to insert his penis. I tell him to go slowly to ensure she doesn’t feel pain, but he waves me off and says he knows what he is doing.
He gently moved his hips so his penis was touching her wet lip – without entering it. I was glad he was taking his Garye and Joanna was still moaning. Larry asks, “What do you want?” Joanna says, “I want you inside of me right now. Please.”
She bites her lips and I could see her turn her head to me as if to say sorry, and I knew it was about to happen. .
Larry grabs her whole body in his two arms and finally shoves his large penis inside of her. She exclaims a little bit and I ask, “Are you okay?”
She muffles out, “y–yes. He’s just so big, but it feels good now.” I could feel my cock start to stiffen again and I could feel my hand start to touch my penis. I felt a sense of betrayal because she always said my penis was the perfect size, but maybe she will think I am too small for her. However, the fact that she was expanding her sexual experience made me as horny as ever.
He ends up fucking her in that position for awhile until he says that he wants her to sit on him so he can see her nice small waist and big boobs.
They get on the couch and Larry sits down. Joanna comfortably starts straddling his lap and then finally puts it in. She’s as wet as I have ever seen her and she takes in all of his cock. Larry tells her to lean back as he uses his hand to support her so she can move directly up and down; I could tell that Larry was getting an amazing view of her gorgeous breasts bouncing gracefully as I see Larry stare in awe and lust of Joanna. Perhaps Joanna was super tight, but I could hear Larry feeling like he was losing control. He was moaning louder while I was stroking my dick harder while watching them on the couch in front of me.
After fucking for a bit, Larry tells me to come on the edge of the couch and he pushes her playfully so she falls into the couch next to you. Her head on your lap while I am on the edge. Larry then repositions her and tells her to suck my dick. He takes her by her ankles, pulls them up, looks at her gorgeous vagina and ass and re-enters her while she is struggling to focus on my penis. I notice she isn’t focused on sucking anymore and she is just moaning with my dick in her mouth. I continue, slow at first, then somewhat harder and faster. As she gets closer and closer I look at you and ask you if we should let her cum yet.
I moaned, “Yes please. Make her cum.”
I ask her if Larry is fucking her better than I do and she shakes her head. But her moans betray her words.
I can feel that Larry has been holding this in for awhile and I didn’t know how to feel about the way he was fucking her. He was rough, but he wanted to be in intimate with her too; I could feel that he really liked her and he started losing control from his end. If he only treated her as pussy, I am sure he could fuck her all day.
He was pumping his penis deep into her wet, warm pussy while he placed one hand on her butt cheek to hold himself stable and to squeeze her ass; His planted his other hand between her held up legs with his thumbs right on her clit. It was hot to see that he didn’t do much to play with it, cause her body is moving and shaking already, like she’s grinding herself on his thumb. I could tell they were both close to cumming, especially Joanna.
Larry drags my thumb around her pussy quickly giving her ten seconds before he reaches around her legs and puts his finger in her mouth; He pulls her away from your dick and makes her taste herself.
Larry then takes control of her legs and tells me to grab one of her arms with one hand and hold them back over her head while I was playing with her boobs with my other. Wow, she was flexible.
Larry pushed her legs apart, almost in a “splits” position and I could tell he was hitting the right spot and making her twitch and scream and making her pussy pulse as she finally climaxed. Larry yelled, “I am almost cumming. Where do you want me to cum?”
I froze and at this second she moaned and begs Larry to cum inside of her. Larry replied in a matter-of-fact tone, “Oh good, because I would have done that any way.”
I could see Larry shaking with euphoria as he makes his last push deep into her a few last times before unloading a huge warm load into her perfect pussy. and then collapsing over her – between her legs.
Joanna was visibly exhausted and she had initially reached out for me, but Larry pulled her into his arms and she chose to hug him back. I was still in shock and thought it was over, but I saw her wrap legs around him and she was rubbing herself against him….
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/iaha69/the_pass_sharing_my_gf_mf_humiliation_cuck
What happened after
Damn, that made me hot!!
Looks like you did a find and replace for Tim and Gary — every time the word “time” comes up, it reads “Garye.”