Hookup I met on Craigslist made me finally accept my bisexuality [MM]

So, back in 2013, I had already had some experiences with other guys. I’d jerked off with another guy, and I even sucked a guy with his wife in a really sexy threesome(which I plan to write a story for at some point). But, despite all of this, I wasn’t sure if I was truly bisexual yet. I hadn’t enjoyed it to a level that really made me want to take the title yet. But I kept occasionally looking, periodically jerking off to guys, and thinking that I’d try it again, IF the right guy came along.

In those days, Craigslist was still very much a thing. Sure, it was filled with sketchy people in search of nefarious and depraved sex, but it also had really fun and sexy people sprinkled in.

I had been horny to play with a guy for a few days, and I would peruse the site daily. Mostly, it was the same nasty guys posting daily. I think it’s safe to say that most of them were also looking to feed their drug habits. Some seemed legit, but were not looking for what I was looking for. Until I found Lucas’s post.

On this particular day, I noticed a new post that I hadn’t seen up to this point: “Hung uncut 28 year old college student curious to get sucked by a guy” was the title. My cock tingled with excitement as I clicked the ad. “Never done anything with a guy. Would be willing to host in my dorm room if you’re a real person. Pictures available if you email me. Not looking for anything other than a hook up.” I knew I had to respond.

One thing about me that you should know is that I have a whole complex surrounding uncut cock. I am American, and I am also uncut. But we anteaters are in an extreme minority. And many people here have so many completely false notions about foreskin. I grew up feeling really weird about my body. I’ve heard people making all kinds of comments about uncut dicks being dirty and disgusting. I’ve been the first natural penis for every single girl I’ve ever been with. As a kid, I wanted to get cut because I was different. My parents told me to wait until I was grown to decide. Eventually, I did my research, and I couldn’t be happier to have my cock be natural. I’m proud of my foreskin. I’ve never had a single negative reaction from anybody who has played with it, sucked it, or been fucked by it.

I say all of that to say that I also developed a fetish for other uncut guys. If it’s at all possible, I only watch porn with uncut guys. I will make exceptions for certain porn girls who are with cut guys in a scene, but I typically go for natural dick porn. This extended to my bi desires. At this point, the only cock I’d sucked was cut. I told myself I wouldn’t rule out sucking dick until I got to try it with an uncut guy. So, as I was looking at ads on Craigslist, I was specifically looking for an uncut guy. Porno also made me a bit of a size queen, so I took the fact that this guy could be hung as a bonus. I clicked the link to the poster’s email and drafted my response.

“Hey, man. 25-year-old curious, straightish guy here looking to possibly blow a big, uncut dick here. I’m not far from campus, I’m drug and disease free, and I’m uncut, too, so I know some tricks. Wanna swap pictures?”

My heart beat out of my chest as I pressed send. This was possibly something that was real and could be about to happen. In looking for random online sex, I very rarely got the sense that I would actually meet up with someone when I messaged them. This just felt different. I went and got a drink from the kitchen and tried not to look at my inbox or a minute. It didn’t take long for a reply, complete with a photo attachment.

“Hey there. You sound like what I’m looking for. I’m clean too. Here’s a dick pick to see if you’re interested let me know.”

I opened the attachment to find a picture that was much more blurry than I would have preferred. He had just a slight belly, but I could tell he was packing a good bit. And I could see his foreskin was about halfway down his shiny purple helmet. My heart kept on beating out of my chest as I replied. It was almost like a state of suspended animation with my hands acting on their own.

“I am totally down to meet up and see what happens. I think we could have some fun.”

He responded quickly. “Alright, dude. I’m in Apartment 8 in the ********** dorms by the baseball stadium. Here’s my phone number. Give me about 30 minutes, and text me when you’re walking up to the building.”

At this point, everything was a rush of adrenaline. I hopped in the shower and cleaned off quickly and dressed in running shorts and a t-shirt because I knew I could take them off easily. I brushed my teeth, and walked out to my truck. My hands were shaking on the wheel as I took the 10 minute drive to campus.

I pulled into a parking spot right in front of his dorm building. As I put my truck in park, I spotted two blonde college chicks jogging together to the sidewalk. One was in tights with a juicy ass and perky tits, and the other was in a tank top and really short shorts, also with an incredible bubble butt. I wondered what they’d think of me if they knew I was there to suck a guy’s cock. In a different time, I would’ve been there to see one of them and enjoy all the awesomeness the female body has to offer. But today wasn’t about that. I sent him a message that I was outside.

“Okay. It’s on the left side of the first hallway. The door is unlocked. Try to be quiet. There’s a girl across the hall I’m trying to fuck, and I don’t want her to know I’m doing stuff like this.”

“No problem,” was my response. I got out and started walking up the path to his building. This was my last chance to turn back and go beat off at home. I couldn’t, though. You only live once. You only have so much time to explore everything in life. This was an experience I wanted to have.

I walked in the main door and turned left and walked right to where his door was. One last deep breath, and I opened the door.

I walked in to find him sitting in cargo shorts and a t-shirt at his computer desk, which was off. He wasn’t very tall, probably about 5’8” with short brown hair and brown eyes. He had just a little bit of muscle definition and, as I mentioned, a very small bit of gut. In short, he looked like a completely normal and average college guy. In different circumstances, he could’ve easily been one of my buddies. But as it stood, I was there to put his cock in my mouth and get him off.

“Hey, man,” he said, “If you want, we can get naked. My idea was that I’d sit on the bed and look at my phone while you do your thing. Is that okay?”

“Yeah, sure. That sounds like fun.” We both were being pretty awkward with the situation at hand. He took his shirt off. “What are you waiting for?”

I quickly took off my shirt and shorts. My cock was only slightly hard, mostly because of my nerves, but it felt good to be naked. I watched him turn around and take off his pants and underwear. Then he slowly turned back to face me. It was like slow motion as I looked directly at his package turning towards me. I quickly saw an incredibly beautiful, uncut cock flopping and dangling semi-hard between his legs. And he WAS hung. He had to be pushing 7.5 inches at half mast. And he had a very pink foreskin covering his ever-swelling head. His dick and balls shaved with a very well manicured patch of pubes resting above. I. Was. Smitten. This was exactly the kind of cock I wanted to try being bi with. I looked down to see that I was hard enough to cut diamonds with a huge pool of precum on my foreskin. He sat down and spread his legs on the bed. His balls were really big and low-hanging, too.

We didn’t say a word. He just pulled his phone out, propped up a pillow, and sat back. I walked towards him never breaking eye contact with his luscious and gorgeous cock. I was really about to do this. I got on my knees and his dick was at eye level. I could see how veiny and fat it was. I could see his head protruding from his foreskin. Without thinking, I reached out and grabbed it and pulled his skin down revealing a fat and deeply purple head. Then, I felt him throb hard right in my hand. It was so fucking hot. I gently started stroking him with one hand and caressing his nuts with the other as he too became absolutely rock hard. I watched my hand slide his foreskin up and down his head as I stroked him.

“You should put it in your mouth,” he whispered.

This was it, no going back. It was now or never. I felt like I was crossing some line here, but I wasn’t sure what it was. I briefly considered asking if I could just jerk him off, but I had come too far to wimp out now. It was time to see what this was like.

I pulled his skin completely over his head and leaned in. I gently licked the tip of his cock and foreskin. The , I slowly slid my tongue underneath his skin and started swirling it around. He let out and audible and clearly pleasure-filled moan. I pulled his skin down, and wrapped my lips around his head and slowly bobbed up and down a few times.

The taste was something I was completely uncertain about going into this. But I was surprised, it really didn’t have much taste at all. He had a good bit of pre-cum, but it only tasted missing salty. The rest just tasted like skin, and his foreskin felt like lips on a mouth. It was really very nice and enjoyable.

I started working up a good rhythm. I had my hand working with my mouth like so many porn girls I’ve seen. I synced up the motion of the two, and enjoyed myself. I started pausing to pull his skin all the way down and lick his cock directly on the frenulum on the underside of his thick head. He was moaning with so much pleasure. I was really getting into it. “What are you looking at up there?” I asked.

“Just this girl I found online.” He turned his phone around to reveal Kayden Kross masturbating on a couch. She is my absolute favorite porn star of all time. I’ve jerked off to her more than anybody else. In obsessed with her. This was perfect.

“Oh, shit. Man, I love her. She’s so fucking hot,” I replied. And I went back to worshipping his incredible tool. I varied my rhythm and strokes. I felt him throb in my hand and my mouth. I really was having a great time. I hadn’t touched my own cock, but precum was leaking on the floor from it beneath me. I took time to stroke him and marvel at how big he was, which was just over 8 inches. I’m not super small, right at 6 inches, but I couldn’t help thinking to myself that this is what it would be like to jerk off if my cock were this big.

He started moaning more and more as I continued to slut out with his rod. “I’m going to cum soon,” he said.

“Where do you wanna cum?” I asked.

“I’d like to shoot it in your mouth if that’s cool, but on my stomach also works.”

At this point, I never thought I’d be open to letting another guy shoot jizz in my mouth. I was also a little worried about disease. He really did seem like he was clean, but I wasn’t ready yet.

“I think we’ll just go stomach this time if that’s alright,” I muttered.

“Sure, man. Just make me cum. I’m so close.”

I went to work quickly. I got into the pace that always brings me over the edge working his swollen head with my mouth while also stroking with my hand. Faster. Faster. Faster.

“Oh, God!”

Just like that, I felt a huge twitching from his asshole up through his balls and cock. I tried to pull off in time, but some cum got in my mouth as I watched him erupt like a geyser all over himself. I kept stroking as he kept cumming a huge load. His whole body shuddered. He sat up.

“Dude, that was pretty great. You did a great job!” He was all smiles. I got up in a daze and started dressing. I didn’t want to cum there and face the immediate regret I was worried I’d feel with post-nut clarity. It was back to being a little but awkward. He asked me to grab him a rag out of his bathroom, which I did. He wiped himself off with his triumphant cock still half-hard and his nuts hanging low. He got dressed and opened the door for me. “Maybe we’ll do this again sometime?” He asked.

“Yeah, maybe so. That was pretty fun.”

I walked out and got back in my truck. I drove home and got naked. I didn’t look at any porn at all. I just stroked my dick to the memory of everything that had just happened. And I came buckets. The cool thing is that I didn’t experience any post-nut regrets at all. I wanted to try something l and I did and I enjoyed it. It wasn’t wrong at all.

“Well, I guess I am really bi, after all,” I thought.

Any feedback is greatly appreciated. If you got this far, thanks for reading my story! Everything in it is 100% true and real. Nothing is dramatized or fictionalized in any way. I hooked up with him three more times after this, and I’m interested to know if anybody would want to read about those stories. I am also interested to see if anybody would want to read the story of my MMF bisexual threesome with the married couple I met on Craigslist. Cheers!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/i5h45x/hookup_i_met_on_craigslist_made_me_finally_accept