So this must’ve been January. We were just kissing, not really doing anything sexual since her whole family were in. She often sat on top of me just sitting on her phone; facing me sometimes and sometimes with her ass in my face. It was a strange little thing but it was nice. On this day I had the horn. Like A LOT so when she had her ass facing me I couldn’t help myself. I started taking her bottoms down a bit. She really appreciated this and got up a bit to allow me to take them down more. We both liked anal a lot so I started playing with her ass and getting her to lick my fingers after etc. It was really hot and we could somehow do anal pretty well with just spit, no lube.
So I had the usual 2 fingers inside her ass and she was moaning. We sometimes put 3 in so I asked if that would be okay in this occasion. She was more than happy for me to do that. I realised after a while that there was some room left for another finger. I asked how she’d feel and she egged me on to go for it. I had four fingers in her little ass with no lube. Never though I’d be doing that. She moaned so heavily, having to cover her mouth so her family wouldn’t hear. This turned me on so so so much and I couldn’t help but shove my thumb up there as well. This only made her turn round and do a sexy smile.
After a little bit of this is put more of my hand in, with her only begging me not to stop. Eventually she started rubbing her pussy as I fisted her ass with me telling her the filthiest, sexiest things that I knew would help her get there. She eventually came and I slowly took my hand out her asshole to see it gaping at me. I washed my hand she gave me the best wank she ever gave as a “thank you” for doing that to her. She said I hit something different but she loved it. One of my hottest memories of that relationship. Shame we only did it a couple of times. Damn I miss that girl’s libido.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/hqhgd5/i_19m_spontaneously_fisted_my_ex_gfs_18f_asshole