Threesome Turns to Foursome [Group]

This continues the story in my last post. tl;dr I (Mike) started dating a girl (Amy) casually, drunkenly decided to have a threesome with an acquaintance/friend (Josh), ended up getting cuckolded.

After brunch, Josh went back to the frat house to sleep off his hangover while Amy and I walked back to our dorm together. Since she had a roommate, we usually spent more time in my room, even though it was smaller. As we walked down the hall, Ryan came around the corner.

“Mike! Hey man, saw you at the party, then you kinda disappeared? What’d you end up doing?”

I froze. I didn’t know what to say. “Oh uh…I uh…Amy..uhh..”

Ryan laughed, “don’t remember? Not surprising man, you drank a metric fuckton. I’ll remember that for Brotherhood Olympics. When you’re a brother, of course,” he added with a grin.

Good thing Ryan was such an easygoing guy. Amy and I went into my room, and as soon as the door closed she grabbed and kissed me. I was startled, but I went with it. And then just as suddenly, she pulled away and fell to the floor crying.

“Are you okay??” I asked, perplexed.

“I’m so sorry Mike. I’m so sorry. I really like you. I mean it. And I know we weren’t really dating, but it kind of felt like it, and I liked it. But I fucked Josh last night. Twice. I know I’m terrible for saying it. I should’ve just taken it to the grave. But I need to tell you so that even if we’re not together after this, you’ll know it was my fault and not yours.”

Wow. That was a lot to process.

“Amy. Okay. I’m just going to think out loud. I really like you. I already knew you fucked Josh last night. I was awake when you guys came in from the shower. And I heard you talk about having sex in the shower. And I still really like you, even knowing all that. I was really turned on by everything last night. Everything. And I’m slightly confused by that too? I was turned on, but I’m not sure if I’d want to do it again? But I think we should figure that out together. Or at least that’s what I want.”

She hiccuped and looked up at me. “That’s what I want too.” She smiled.

And from then on, we were dating! We did talk more about that night, and agreed that what she had done was cheating, and that I forgave her for that one instance, but we would both not cheat going forward. I joked about how I should get a “hall pass,” and without blinking, she said she would be more okay with it if it were a threesome with another girl, or if she could at least watch. When she saw the dumb look I gave her, she realized I’d been joking, but that led to us having a discussion about threesomes with a girl, and we agreed to be on the lookout for someone.

What we didn’t talk about was the penis size comment that I’d heard her make while in bed with Josh. I know I’d heard her correclty that night, but I wasn’t sure how to bring it up, or what to say, so I didn’t say anything. And neither did she.

The rest of the semester passed like this. Amy told me that Josh gave her a booty call one night, but when she told him that we were seriously dating, he respectfully backed off and didn’t try again. The three of us actually ended up hanging out a lot, both with and without others, but things were never awkward.

Come spring, I received a bid and started pledging Delta. My life honestly got pretty hectic when pledging started, what with all the drinking, and drinking, and drinking, and drinking….

So it was a relief when our Pledge Master told us that we would be getting the week for Spring Fling off. So that we could go drink. OK, so we were going to be doing more drinking. But having drinks on a sunny lawn while listening to live music isn’t the same thing as pounding shots in a frat basement while blindfolded! I told Amy the good news, and she nearly screamed out of excitement.

“Okay okay okay I gotta go I gotta make a call ahhh I wish you’d told me sooner okay I love you bye see you later” she ran off before I could get a word in.

When I saw her later for dinner, she told me that she’d been so excited because her best friend Alice had been wanting to visit but didn’t know when since I’d been so busy with pledging and Amy really wanted us to meet and spend time together and, she added with a sly look, “maybe we can have a threesome with her.” I felt my dick get hard just from hearing that. I knew Alice – she was a Japanese girl who’d come to the US for part of middle and high school. Since Amy was Japanese and spoke fluently, the school actually assigned her as Alice’s “friend” to help her get used to America. Alice was only a few months younger than Amy, but apparently she had always called her “older sister” and treated her as such. I knew that they were about as close as real siblings.

I also knew that Alice was hot. Like smoking hot. She’d actually moved back to Japan to be a model, and she had a slender model’s build and pretty face. The thought of both her and Amy, at the same time, it was almost too much.

Amy started laughing. “Oh my god you dirty pervert! You should see the face you’re making! You looked so stupid! And cute. But stupid!” I couldn’t help but give a sheepish grin in response.

Anyway, apparently Alice had booked tickets on the spot and was going to be spending the entire week with us! She was going to sleep in Amy’s room while Amy and I slept together in my room. The next week couldn’t go by fast enough, but soon enough it was Monday again, which marked the start of Spring Fling!

Alice was scheduled to arrive that afternoon, so Amy and I decided to go to the first day’s morning events before we went to meet her at the airport. We actually ended up at Delta again, and had a few drinks with some of my pledge brothers before we excused ourselves to go meet Alice. I’d shown the guys Alice’s Instagram page, and so they were all incredibly excited to meet her as well. I also not so subtly dropped hints about the threesome that was being planned, just to rub it in.

Amy and I took a cab to the airport, and within fifteen minutes Amy was jumping up and down excitedly as Alice came out of the security gate. Damn. She was hot. I mean, I’d seen her pictures, even Skyped with her and Amy a few times, but she just exuded this aura of self-confidence that was even more attractive than her physical appearance. It was slightly intimidating, but also incredibly arousing. I could barely process before she ran in for a huge hug, first with Alice, and then me, and I awkwardly tried not to poke her with my erection.

I was surprised by how well Alice spoke English, though it was noticeably not native. Apparently, after she studied in the US, she switched to an international school where most of the students were children of diplomats or ex-pats. She said she couldn’t get used to the Japanese school system and social life after living in the US. She and Amy chattered in Japanese most of the way back to campus, excited to be reunited.

After a quick stop at my dorm to drop off Alice’s bags, we were back at the Delta house. We’d been gone a few hours, but it looked the exact same as when we’d left. All of the brothers were incredibly excited to meet Alice as they shamelessly flirted with her, but Alice seemed excited to meet so many people. You could tell that she was excited to be in America again, and she was drinking and partying with the rest of us as if she’d been there the whole time.

“So, who is Josh?” Alice suddenly asked, looking around.

I immediately looked at Amy. She gave me an embarrassed/guilty face. “I’m sorry!” she whispered. “But you know I tell Alice everything! She’s my best friend!” I guess she had a point. I’d been telling my friends some stories, so it was only fair that she told Alice about Josh.

“Josh? He’s up in his room, smoking and playing Mario Kart,” Josh’s neighbor Alex chimed in as he walked by. “I’m just grabbing some beers then I’m going back up. Feel free to follow, the more the merrier!”

Alice and Amy exchanged a look, then looked at me. I shrugged. Why not? Josh and I had actually gotten a lot closer over the last semester, and I really liked the guy. We made some drinks and then followed Alex upstairs to Josh’s room.

“Hey buddy, I brought friends!”

Josh, with a joint in one hand, turned toward the door.

“Mike! And Amy! Hey guys! Oh and I don’t think I know you? Alice? Nice to meet you – I’m Josh.”

Alice giggled as she shook his hand. “Yes, I know. Josh.”

He looked puzzled, then shrugged and took another puff from his joint. “You guys want some?” he asked.

Amy took the joint, took a quick hit, passed it off to me, and then I took a hit and passed it to Alice. I started to take it back when I remembered that Japan has really strict drug laws, but she snatched it out of my hand and inhaled deeply before blowing smoke into my face. “Hey! I lived in America. I know how to smoke marijuana!”

Josh, Alex, and Amy burst out laughing, and I couldn’t help but join them. “Yeah man, in America, we know how to smoke marijuana!” Josh struggled to get the line out as he was laughing so hard.

The five of us continued to smoke and drink while playing Mario Kart, which Alice had somehow never played. At a certain point, Alex’s girlfriend came over and hung out with us for a bit, before the two of them went out for dinner.

“Wow it’s already 5? Guess time flies when you’re drunk and high,” Josh quipped.

For some reason, Alice thought that was hilarious, and couldn’t stop laughing for a solid five minutes. Afterwards, still laughing, she managed to choke out a phrase in Japanese.

I look towards Amy, “what did she say?” Amy was smiling and blushing a little, “Alice said she wants to have sex. All of us.”

I couldn’t believe it. It felt eerily similar to the night where Amy had asked if we could have a threesome with Josh. I looked at Josh, and he also had a look of deja vu on his face, but a very happy one. “I’m down if you’re down,” he said to me.

“Okay let’s just set some ground rules,” I interjected. “Like is this a foursome? Or are we sticking to one partner?” We agreed to a foursome, where it was fair game to have sex with anyone else in the foursome. Once the rules were established, Amy pulled Alice in and the two started making out.

Josh and I exchanged a look – I had no idea Amy was into girls at all.

Amy then moved over towards me and brought Alice with her. She got me to pull my pants and underwear off in one go, and my cock sprung to attention. I was already fully hard after watching Amy and Alice make out. Alice giggled, then took it in her mouth. At the same time, Amy leaned in and started sucking on one of my balls. Looking down, it was a sight to behold. Two beautiful Japanese girls sucking my cock and balls. I looked over at Josh with a shit-eating grin, and he gave me a double thumbs up. I noticed that a large bulge was visible through his basketball shorts and questioned my decision for a second – was I really ready to see Amy fuck Josh again?

My thoughts were interrupted as the two girls pulled away.

Alice turned to Josh. “I hear you are very gifted.”

Josh smiled, “I’m afraid I don’t know what you’re talking about.”

Alice laughed, “Big penis. Amy says you have very big penis.”

Josh laughed in turn, “I suppose you could say it’s ‘very big.'”

Alice motioned to Josh to remove his pants, and he did. Somehow, his cock looked even bigger than the last time I saw it. Thick veins stuck out and it throbbed as it sprung out, freed from his boxers and shorts.

Alice squealed and said something in Japanese. I looked at Amy again. “Amazing,” she replied.

“Can I suck?” Alice shyly asked Josh. When he nodded his head, she gripped the base of his dick and started to lick the head. She paused to turn to me, “fuck me.”

I stammered, “I don’t have a condom.”

“No condom,” she replied. “I take birth control.”

I didn’t need to be told twice. Josh knelt on the floor and Alice shifted onto her hands and knees and took the head of his cock in her mouth. I knelt behind her and got a good look at her tight, completely shaved pussy before lining my cock up and slowly pushing in. As I pushed in, she let out a moan with Josh’s cock still in her mouth until I was balls deep in her pussy.

Damn. That felt amazing. While I honestly can’t say her pussy felt different than Amy’s did, just the psychological aspect of fucking my girlfriend’s hot model friend added so much to the experience. I started thrusting in and out of her as she continued to suck and stroke Josh’s penis. She didn’t seem to be able to get more than the head in her mouth.

Amy, who had been sitting to the side and touching herself, suddenly got up and pushed Josh back so that he was faced up, head resting against the edge of the mattress behind him. She straddled his face and squatted down so that he could eat her pussy as Alice continued to suck him off. Seeing all of this was turning me on so much that I shot a huge load into Alice’s pussy.

“My pussy feels good?” Alice took Josh’s dick out of her mouth with a pop as she turned to ask me with a smile.

I was still recovering from cumming and dumbly nodded. Meanwhile, Amy was still squatting over Josh’s face, facing away from us, and moaning as Josh expertly licked her pussy. Alice looked at me and held a finger to her lips, shh. She quietly turned around so that she was now facing me, and I knew what was about to happen. She grabbed Josh’s cock in one hand and slowly backed into it, rubbing it on her entrance but struggling to get it in.

Josh had figured out what was going on by now, and he gently pushed Amy off of him, who was confused until she turned and saw what was going on. Now Alice was the one who didn’t know what was happening, as she was still facing me. Josh grabbed on to her hips and thrust forward.

“Ahhhh!” Alice began screaming in Japanese. This time Josh was the one who turned to look at Amy. “She’s good,” she replied, before moving over to kiss her friend deeply. Josh didn’t need any more encouragement, and he slowly started working more and more of his cock in. I moved to get behind Amy, who was still kissing Alice, and began eating her out. She stopped kissing Alice to look back at me: “yesss you’re the best at eating pussy make me cum baby eat my pussy”. I was determined not to be a bystander this time and went to work, going for all the spots I knew she liked.

Josh was still working more and more of his dick into Alice. From my position, I could see him going in, Alice’s formerly tight pussy now stretched to accommodate his immense girth, and he wasn’t even halfway. It seemed like she was having more trouble than Amy had with Josh, but she seemed to be enjoying it just as much. The two girls stopped kissing mainly because Alice was too busy moaning and shouting Japanese phrases with the occasional English word thrown in. “Cock! Dick! Big! Fuck! Pussy!”

It wasn’t long before she came with a yelp. As she did, so did Amy. They held hands and locked fingers as they came together, then Alice slumped forward, comatose, and Amy held her, stroking her hair.

“Hey wait. Is she okay?” I asked.

“I think so,” Amy replied. “I think she just knocked out. She’s probably jet-lagged, and then there’s all the alcohol and weed. And the dick,” she giggled. “She probably just needs to sleep it off. Could you guys put her on the bed?”

Josh picked her up with ease and laid her down by himself.

“Oh! Thanks Josh,” Amy smiled. “So um…I see you’re still ready for action.” She looked at his dick meaningfully.

Josh smiled back. “Let’s do it.” He sat down on the couch and spread his legs, motioning with his eyes for her to come ride him. Amy got on top and spread her legs grabbing hold of his cock and slowly lowered herself onto it. I noticed she hadn’t stopped to put a condom on him, but I was so aroused that I didn’t want to stop them.

“Fuuuuuck yes,” she let out as she went down. “God it’s been so long since I’ve had a big cock. I forgot how good they feel.” She turned to me, “Baby, come put it in my ass.”

While Amy and I had done anal together many times, we’d never done a DP, so I was surprised but not against it. I’d gotten hard again watching her mount his cock, so I got behind her and started pushing my cock into her ass.

She moaned again, “yessss I feel so full it’s amazing.” Her ass felt tighter than it’d ever felt, and I even heard Josh moan and breathe more heavily after we started DPing her. Moving around in this position was actually a lot more awkward than I’d thought, and Josh and I ended up taking turns thrusting while the other stayed still. However, Amy seemed to really enjoy it, as she came quickly, moaning both of our names loudly.

Her asshole clenched as she came, and it drove me over the edge as I groaned and shot my load into her. With that, I pulled out and leaned back, exhausted.

Josh, however, wasn’t done. Once he saw that I had fallen back, he grabbed Amy’s ass and started bouncing her on his cock. Her moans gradually increased until I was positive everyone in the house could hear her, but Josh showed no sign of letting up. She came again and again, screaming loudly until at a certain point, she went quiet. Her mouth was still open, but it was as though she was so focused on his cock that she couldn’t even make noise.

Finally, he slid her almost all the way up his cock then slammed her all the way down to the base, holding her down as his balls pulsed. She let out a loud, guttural moan, like a woman possessed. After holding her still for a minute, he carried her to the bed, still inside of her, and laid her down next to Alice, who was now awake again. As Josh pulled out of Amy, his cum poured out of her loosely stretched pussy, and I saw Alice bite her lip.

“Can I taste?” she asked Josh.

“It’s her pussy, not mine,” he joked.

Alice took that as a yes and began licking his cum out of Amy’s pussy. Amy moaned a little but otherwise didn’t move or even open her eyes. “Mmm. American semen,” Alice seemed to enjoy the taste of Josh’s load. “American cock. So big. So strong,” she said to him.

“Do Japanese guys not have big, strong dicks?” Josh joked.

“Noo. Japanese penis is not small, but not big. Like Mike. But your penis is very big! Too big!”

Hm. Well, I guess being big isn’t always a good thing. It was also reassuring to hear that my penis wouldn’t be considered small in Asia.

“There’s no such thing as too big,” Josh replied. “You just need more practice.”

Alice giggled. “Practice? But we just had sex? You can go again?”

“For a beautiful girl like you, I could go two more times.” I tried not to gag. Come on Josh, that’s just corny.

Alice didn’t seem to think so. She giggled again before reaching over and slowly stroking his cock. He pulled her in and gave her a deep kiss before pulling her off the bed. “Hey uh, you mind?” he asked, as I was still sitting on the couch. “Oh right my bad man,” I moved and sat on the bed next to Amy, who was fast asleep.

Once Alice was on the couch, Josh kneeled in front of her and began eating her out, making her moan gently. She ran her fingers through his hair and locked her thighs around his head, pulling him closer to her as she shivered with an orgasm. Satisfied, Josh sat down on the couch and motioned to Alice to get on top of him.

“Amy came really hard in this position, do you want to try?”

“Yes!”

She spread her legs and mounted him. I felt some serious deja vu as I watched her lower herself onto his cock just like Amy did minutes ago. My cock started to come back to life as I heard her moan as she struggled to get her pussy lips around his thick cock head, and I started to think about how we’d DPed Amy, and wondered if Alice would want to do the same.

As if reading my mind, Josh looked at me and gave a questioning look. “Hey,” he said to Alice, “Amy also did a DP. Do you want to do that too?”

“DP? What is DP?” she cocked her head slightly as she asked.

“It means double penetration. I fuck your pussy, and Mike can fuck your asshole.”

“Ah!” Alice exclaimed before saying a word in Japanese. “Yes! I want DP!”

Josh turned to me, “you heard the girl!” And I wasted no time getting into position again. Her ass was definitely tighter than Amy’s, but I was gradually able to ease my way inside of her. I managed to get my cock all the way in, but it looked like Alice was still having trouble with the entirety of Josh’s length and girth. Our experience with Amy paid off though; this DP had a lot less awkward movement than the first.

Within a few minutes, I was again cumming, this time into Alice’s asshole. As I tried to pull out, we lost balance, and I accidentally ended up pushing Alice further down onto Josh’s cock. She screamed and came as he stretched her out and hit even deeper inside of her, and he immediately started to give his telltale groan as he came inside of her.

We all fell apart, and I was completely spent. I crawled onto the bed next to Amy and just lay there, closing my eyes, trying to catch my breath. There was a squeaking noise, but I kept my eyes closed and tried to ignore it. It kept going, and I heard Amy stirring next to me, so I propped myself up to see what was going and noticed that Josh and Alice were still going at it. She’d never gotten off of his cock, and after taking a short rest she was riding his cock again, this time taking nearly three quarters of his cock inside of her with each bounce. True to his word, he was going two more times for the beautiful Alice.

Once he noticed I was watching, Josh lifted Alice off of him and onto the couch. Cum spilled out of her gaping pussy as his cock came out, and I noticed that his cock wasn’t even fully hard, but was still far larger than my own. He put her in doggy style and entered her from behind, this time grabbing a handful of her hair and pulling her back. He placed his other hand on her hip and started grinding her into his cock. This new move must’ve been something, because Alice’s moans redoubled in volume, and she soon started cumming on his cock again.

I don’t think Josh even came again this time, or if he did he was shooting blanks at this point, but he finally pulled out, his cock glistening in the light with a mixture of his, Amy, and Alice’s cum coating it. We all ended up sleeping in his room that night. Since Amy and I were already half asleep on his bed, we stayed there, while he slept with Alice on the couch.

The next morning, I woke up to the sights and sounds of Amy fucking Josh. Alice had moved over to the bed while they’d taken over the couch, and she was touching herself.

“Not going to join them?” I asked.

She shook her head no. “I want. But too big. I am sore.”

While this was going on, Amy was being bent over the couch and fucked. “I love your cock Josh. It’s so big it’s perfect!! God your big cock feels so good.”

Alice continued to touch herself, staring intently at Amy’s pussy, stretched over Josh’s cock like hers had been, and then glanced at my penis, which had gotten hard again. She smiled at me, “You like watching? I like watching too. Amy is sexy. Josh is sexy.”

She reached over with one hand and started stroking my cock while guiding one of my hands towards her pussy. I rubbed her clit as she stroked my cock, and we both came as we watched my girlfriend, her best friend, fuck Josh’s “big American penis.” A small spurt of cum erupted from my cock and the rest trickled down, onto Alice’s hand. She brought her hand to her mouth and licked it clean, before giving me a peck on the lips. I was startled, both by the kiss and the taste of my own cum on her lips.

It wasn’t long after we both came that I could tell Josh was getting close. Amy had already cum twice, God knows how many times she came before I woke up, and looked like she was going to cum again as Josh continued to pound her from behind.

“Alice. Come here,” he grunted.

She looked puzzled, but nonetheless jumped off the bed and got in front of them.

“Kneel,” he commanded both of them as he pulled out of Amy.

The two girls got on their knees in front of him, and he grabbed his throbbing cock and gave it a few jerks before cumming with a loud moan. The first shot hit Alice square in the face, and she screamed and laughed as her face was coated with his thick cum. The next few shots went to Amy, and soon both of their faces were covered in white.

“Shit I have to get a picture. That cool?” he looked around at all of us. Amy and Alice smiled and nodded, and I found myself nodding without even thinking. Josh grabbed his phone and started taking pictures, and the girls put on a show for him, kissing each other and licking the cum off each other’s faces. I wondered if he was going to show anyone those pictures. I wondered if he would send me a copy if I asked.

As I put my clothes back on, I wondered how things had gotten so crazy again. It was only the first day of Fling and the first day of Alice’s visit – I’d thought we were going to have a relatively casual night, and yet we ended up having a wild foursome! I was excited, to say the least, to see what the rest of the week had in store for Amy, Alice, and me.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/hhl1vm/threesome_turns_to_foursome_group