College Threesome Turns into Cuckolding [MFM]

A few years ago, I (Mike) moved across the country to attend college. New state, new school, new life. College was my opportunity to re-invent myself. No longer would I be the nerd who had never had a girlfriend, let alone get laid. Instead, I would be cool and, probably more importantly, get laid. Now for background, I’m Asian, a little over 6 feet tall, with a thin but athletic build.

The first few months of college were great! I was doing well in my classes, made a lot of friends in my dorm, and even had a number of one-night stands with girls I met at parties. None of them led to much though; in fact I only ever had sex once with each of these girls. Not that I minded – I actually preferred fucking girls with no strings attached.

Then I met Amy in my computer science lab. We were randomly assigned to work together on a project, but it turned out we had a lot in common and got along pretty well. One thing led to another, and we eventually started dating, but casually. While we didn’t put a label on it, we both agreed that we wouldn’t see other people. And honestly, we didn’t really have time to. Amy had an incredibly high sex drive, and so what little time we had after classes and freshman year activities was spent in one of our beds. To top it all off, she had an amazing body: around 5’5″, Asian, and had relatively large (34C) breasts and a fit ass from squatting.

The night before Halloween, my neighbor knocked on my door and invited me to a small, private party that was happening at his frat. I’d been there a few times, was close with a lot of the brothers, and was heavily leaning towards pledging in the spring, so I told him I’d be there later, and he told me to bring Amy as well. I texted Amy about the party and she seemed excited – she’d just finished her second round of midterms and wanted to drink. And fuck. Without fail, Amy would want rough, wild sex whenever she was drunk. And I was happy to have it!

A few hours later, Amy and I walked up to the Delta house. I mentioned that I lived next door to Ryan, and the guy at the door let us in, not so subtly giving Amy a quick up and down. I couldn’t blame him – her tits were pushed up and nearly popping out of her top, and her skirt was just long enough that you couldn’t see her underwear, but short enough that it felt like you might get a glimpse at any moment. I put my arm around her, proud of myself for having such a hot girlfriend (ok, technically she wasn’t my girlfriend, but still), and steered us into the common room.

“Mike!!!”

I saw Ryan walking forward from a group of people, clearly drunk.

“Dude what’s up man?! And Amy!! Hey girl! Anyway man, you gotta meet everyone here – I was just talking about you!”

And with that, he pulled me (and by extension, Amy) into a small circle of people holding beers and talking. Some of them were brothers that I’d met before, but around half of them were recent alumni who were apparently back on campus to recruit interns for their companies. Suddenly I felt something being pushed into my hand. I looked and it was Ryan, putting a beer into my hand. I noticed he was also pushing one into Amy’s.

“Oh thanks man,” I replied, “but uh…not to be ungrateful or anything, but I’m not a big fan of beer. Neither is Amy. Got any liquor?”

People started laughing and cheering at the suggestion of liquor, then someone pulled a handle of vodka out from what looked like behind the sofa. I suppose it wasn’t too surprising that liquor would just be lying around a frat house. From then on, the night seemed to fly by. We made some screwdrivers and played some drinking games, did a round of shots, and then someone, Steve, pulled out a joint.

I looked at Amy. While I smoked weed occasionally, she did rarely, but to my surprise she started getting up to go out back with the smoking crew. I took that as a sign that tonight was going to really get wild, so I quickly followed out to the back yard. There were already some others outside smoking cigarettes, so we mingled among them and Steve started passing joints around. After a few joints had been smoked, most people went back inside, but Amy said she wanted to smoke one more, so she and I stayed outside with Steve and one other guy, Josh. I started talking to Steve about his weed, in particular where he got it from, since I was having trouble finding a good source.

Meanwhile, I noticed Amy and Josh were talking. Josh was actually the president of the frat and an all-around cool guy. He was a senior, double majoring in philosophy and psychology, played on the school’s Varsity basketball team, and honestly a pretty good looking dude. I knew Amy definitely thought so – she was giggling every time he said something and lightly touching or stroking him at every opportunity. And I noticed Josh checking out every exposed inch of her. But I didn’t care. If anything, I still felt proud that I had such a hot girl with me that everyone was checking out.

Once the joint went out, we went inside. Turned out we’d been outside longer than we’d thought, and the party was mostly dying down as the alumni had gone back to their hotels. Amy and I still wanted to party though, so we were considering going to another frat, but Josh said he was still going to be raging here with anyone else who was still up, so we decided to stick around. We walked through the house, going door-by-door, but from the sounds and looks of it, most people were sleeping. We found ourselves in front of the last door of the house.

“Oh. This is actually my room. Uh…well, not gonna lie I thought at least one other person would be up. But if you guys still want to hang, I have alcohol and weed in my room.”

“That’s good with me – I was actually hoping to kinda chill and kick back today anyway,” I looked towards Amy. “But if you wanna go somewhere else we can”.

“No I’m okay too,” she chimed in. “I do want to drink more though!”

Josh laughed as he opened the door, “alright then – let’s do some shots!”

At least another hour of drinking, listening to music, and watching random YouTube videos must have gone by when we heard thumping on the wall.

“HEY KEEP IT DOWN YOU HORNY FUCKS!” Josh yelled out. “Oh woops,” he turned to us, much more quietly, “sorry, habit. That’s Alex, fucking some girl. He and I have been neighbors since sophomore year, so we fuck with each other a lot.”

“Oh no it’s okay!” Amy’s voice was a little higher than usual. “After all, we all have sex, right? Nothing weird about it. Have you been having sex lately, Josh?”

I nearly spit out my drink. I looked at Amy and couple tell she was pretty cross-faded, as was I, but I didn’t expect her to be so blunt about sex with another guy. In front of me too!

Josh looked nearly as surprised as I was, and then laughed. “Yeah I suppose I have. I mean, I can’t remember off the top of my head when the last time was, but I have my fun.”

“OH. Do you have a girlfriend?” Amy inquired.

“Oh no no. Too much love to limit it to one person,” he added with a wink. “Just girls I meet here and there. You know, in classes, at bars, at parties…” he trailed off.

“In your room.” Amy interjected.

Ok at this point, something was definitely up. I turned to Amy and asked what was going on.

“Mike, can we have a threesome with Josh? I’m really drunk and high and horny and I know you are too and we’ve talked about it before and you said you’d be down and-”

She stopped to take a big breath. I gave Josh a look. He shot back a quizzical one, before shrugging his shoulders as if to say why not. Amy and I had discussed having a threesome before, and I definitely was interested in having one (though I’d been thinking with another girl first), so I replied, “fuck it. Let’s do it.”

Amy squealed. Without missing a beat, she jumped onto the couch and started making out with me, sticking her ass in Josh’s face. To his credit, Josh rolled with it and started feeling and grabbing her ass. She moaned into my mouth before pulling away and turning to Josh, jumping onto his lap and kissing him deeply. At this point, I was so horny that I just wanted to get to the main course, so I pulled her top down, exposing her tits, and pulled her skirt down as Josh started grabbing her breasts. She broke away from him.

“Take your pants off and sit down,” she commanded, looking first at Josh and then turning to look at me.

Without a word, both of us removed our pants, leaving our boxers on, and sat down on the couch. She got down and kneeled between us, more in front of me than Josh, and started pulling my boxers down. My dick popped out, rock hard, and Amy immediately swallowed me down to the base. I moaned loudly as she slurped and sucked on my cock, using one hand to hold her hair back for her. After a few seconds of this, she pulled away and then shifted to face Josh.

“Now your turn!” she smiled widely.

Josh shifted slightly and pulled his underwear off, exposing a massive throbbing monster of a cock. It legitimately looked bigger than a lot of the dicks I saw in porn.

Amy was similarly surprised. “Oh my god that’s HUGE! I’ve never seen one that big! How big is it??”

Josh smirked. “7 and a half inches long, 6 and a half inches thick.”

I sat there, feeling my face burn as I stared at Josh’s cock, which looked even larger with Amy’s hand on it.

“Oh where are my manners?” Amy giggled before taking Josh’s cock into her mouth. At least the head of it. She struggled to get much more, her mouth stretched wider than I’d ever seen, both hands grasping the shaft. She never had trouble taking my entire cock in her mouth, and when she put just one hand on mine the head barely poked out. She pulled away, gasping for air, and licked all the way up and down, stroking with her hands as she went.

“Fuuuuuck,” Josh moaned, “yeah that’s good”. Amy paused to smile at him before going back down on him. Meanwhile, I sat to the side, still shocked by how big Josh’s dick was, but also harder than before. I thought of a MFM threesome as being mostly for Amy’s sake, I would basically ignore the other guy, but watching her struggling to take more of Josh in her mouth was turning me beyond belief. It almost felt like I was watching a live porno! I don’t know when I started, but I realized I was already masturbating as I watched.

Finally, Amy pulled away with make-up messily running down her face. She looked at me jacking off and smiled, “having fun? Don’t finish too early, you still haven’t fucked me yet!” And with that, she stood up and jumped onto Josh’s bed on her hands and knees, ass facing us. “Who’s going first??” she excitedly asked without turning around to look.

Josh and I looked at each other. I looked at his cock, glistening with Amy’s spit, and then looked down at my own. How was it possible that penises could vary so much in size?? I looked back up and noticed Josh had held his gaze the entire time. He saw me look down at his cock and then at mine. And the look in his eyes told me he knew what I was thinking. Since Amy was my kinda girlfriend, I thought I should go first, but I knew what was going to happen. I just couldn’t believe I’d be the one saying it.

“I think Josh should go first. I’m kinda drunk and I want to sit down for a bit.”

Amy turned around, “oh why don’t you come sit here? I’ll suck you while Josh fucks me!”

You know. I don’t know why I hadn’t thought of that first. I’d been planning on just sitting on the couch as Josh fucked my kinda girlfriend. Relieved, I climbed around her and got in position before she took my dick in her mouth. I looked up and realized I was looking Josh right in the eye. I awkwardly looked down and watched Amy bob her head, then she suddenly pulled my dick out and screamed.

“OHHHHHHH!!!!!”

I jumped at the sound and was sure someone would come barging in to the room to see who was being murdered. Instead, all I heard was, “HEY KEEP IT DOWN YOU HORNY FUCKS!” It was Alex, Josh’s neighbor. Wait. That’s what Josh yelled when he heard Alex having sex earlier. So these kinds of noises regularly came from Josh’s room?! Then again, with a cock so big, was it really surprising?

I looked down at Amy. “Hey, are you okay?” I inquired.

“Oh god. Baby. It’s so big. IT’S SO BIG. God it doesn’t even feel like a dick it’s so big.” Amy rambled.

“Is it too big? Are you oka-” “No no NO!” She cut me off. “It’s not too big. It’s good. It’s perfect.”

I looked up at Josh, and he had a huge grin plastered on his face. He was clearly enjoying this, and why wouldn’t he be? I couldn’t deny how jealous I was of his manhood. “I’m gonna start moving now,” he warned. True to his word, he slowly began pushing forward.

“WAIT THAT WASN’T IT?!?” Amy began moaning uncontrollably as Josh continued to push inside of her.

“That was just the tip,” he replied. “This.” He punctuated with a thrust, “is it.” And with that, Josh had bottomed out inside of her. But he was just getting started. He pulled back then went straight back in, building a rhythm and increasing in intensity, each thrust pushing her closer to me. She’d completely forgotten about sucking my dick, to be honest, I wasn’t even sure if she realized I was still there.

“Oh god it’s so good!” she moaned. “Fuck you’re so deep!! Ughhhhh stretch me out Josh, stretch me out with your big cock GOD FUCK I love your big cock I love it I love it,” her words began to slur as she started screaming incoherently, cumming on Josh’s cock. I’d never been able to make her cum before I did. I always fingered her or ate her out after. She said it was okay and that she still enjoyed sex, but I had felt like sometimes she seemed a bit disinterested after I came. Josh, however, clearly was not done. He continued to thrust in and out of her, not stopping while she came, and soon she was back to moaning and singing his praises.

I was stunned. I’d started the night thinking I’d go to a party with my kinda girlfriend, get wasted, and then have wild sex before passing out. Now I was here, watching Amy get pounded by Josh’s porn star cock. And yet despite how unusually things had turned out, I was most surprised by how turned on I was by all of this. I felt like I was going to blow my load, and my dick hadn’t even been touched since Amy had briefly attempted a spitroast. I tried to guide Amy towards my dick again, but she couldn’t focus on anything but Josh inside of her. So I grabbed my cock and immediately knew I was going to cum.

And I did.

I didn’t even stroke it. Just grabbing it alone was enough to push me over the edge. I shot a huge load straight into Amy’s face, the cum spurting so hard that it splashed off of her face and onto my thighs and shirt. Honestly, I think I even felt some of it land on my own face. Luckily, her eyes were closed, but her mouth was open, and she choked a bit on some of the cum that had found its way into her mouth. None of this phased Josh though, as he continued to pound her, alternating between grabbing her hips and spanking her ass.

Josh was fucking Amy.

Now that I’d cum, I felt like I was seeing the world through different eyes.

Josh, with his massive cock, was fucking Amy, the girl who I honestly really wanted to be my girlfriend. And he was fucking her better than I ever did. I knew it. There was no denying that he was far bigger and better than I was. But I still wanted Amy to be my girlfriend. Even as I watched her scream Josh’s name as she came on his cock for the second time that night, my feelings for her didn’t change. I just hoped her feelings for me didn’t either. I sat there, worried, wallowing in anxiety, all but ignored as Josh carried Amy over to the couch and had her ride him.

I never got to fuck her like that. While Amy had tried to ride me before, saying it was her favorite position, she had always stopped after a few minutes of trying since my dick would slip out as soon as she moved. But here she was, bouncing on Josh’s cock, his big hands grabbing her ass and helping pull her up before slamming her back down until his cock disappeared inside of her. And as I watched him give her yet another experience I was unable to, I felt my dick getting hard again. I’d just cum, but I was so aroused by the sight of Josh and Amy that I found myself masturbating again. This time, I was at least able to last a few strokes, but I quickly came again, dribbling out a meager load compared to my first one.

After another fifteen minutes of this, Josh finally grunted, “Fuck I’m gonna cum. Where do you want it?” “Not inside! I’m not on the pill!” Fuck. In all my excitement, I’d forgotten. Amy and I always used condoms because birth control messed with her mood. I’d never actually fucked her without a condom, and yet here she was, taking Josh’s cock raw. Josh had clearly done this before – he lifted her off of his cock and then dropped her onto the couch before standing up. Amy got on her knees in front of him, pushing her boobs up and together. “Cum on my tits baby, give me a big load.”

Wait, baby? She was calling him baby now?? My thoughts were interrupted by Josh’s groans as he shot a massive stream of cum onto her face and tits. And then another. And another. And another. Spurt after spurt of his cum covered her, even getting into her hair and on the couch behind her, before Josh gave his cock one last stroke, squeezing out the rest of his cum into her open mouth.

“Mmmmmm,” she moaned as she wiped up his cum with a finger and sucked it off. “God you taste good too.”

Josh chuckled as he grabbed a nearby towel and threw it at Amy. He then grabbed another and wiped Amy’s juices off of his cock before looking at me. “Oh, Mike, do you need a towel too? Not sure because you uh..” he trailed off, and I realized that throughout this whole “threesome”, I hadn’t actually had sex and had barely gotten my dick sucked. “Oh yeah, uh. Yeah. Towel would be great”, I replied, though I honestly didn’t really need one. “Shit I don’t have any other clean towels…why don’t you use Amy’s?” he suggested. I nodded and grabbed Amy’s cum-covered towel, then half-heartedly rubbed my penis with it.

“So I’m gonna go take a shower….” Josh trailed off again. “You guys are welcome to stay in my room if you want though! Just I feel really sweaty you know. I won’t take long.”

“Nah man, it’s late. I’ll probably just crash on the couch in common room if that’s cool?” I’d slept on the couch in common room before since the frat house was a little over a mile from my dorm. “Amy, wanna join me? The couch is big, and the dorm is far…”

“Oh, no. Well. I kinda wanted to shower too? You know, I had a lot of cum on me after all. Do you mind if I just shower with Josh? And then um, maybe I could just sleep with him tonight? I don’t really want to sleep in the living room of a frat, especially since I don’t have clothes to sleep in, and since Josh and I have already had sex, it’s not like sleeping together would be anything.”

I just wanted to sleep. And her logic sounded fine. “Yeah sure thing. Hey actually, Josh, could I just crash on your couch? I’m fucking beat man, and downstairs is sooo far.”

Josh was already halfway out the door to the shower. “Haha sure bro. Help yourself.”

And with that, I rolled my way off the bed and onto the couch as Amy followed Josh to the bathroom. I felt some of Josh’s cum that had landed on the couch, but I was so tired that I fell asleep before I could grab a towel to wipe it up.

Some time later, I heard the door open. I stayed where I was, hoping I could just go back to sleep, and heard Josh, and Amy, coming into the room. And it seemed like they were coming back from the shower. They didn’t turn the light on, but noted that it seemed like I was out cold. That’s odd. It felt like I’d been asleep for some time, but I guess it had only been a few minutes. As I lay there, trying to fall back asleep, I heard Josh and Amy talking.

“You know, I’d actually never had shower sex before,” Amy giggled. “It was fun!”

Wait, what? They had sex in the shower? I stayed quiet. I was still drunk and high, and so was Amy. Maybe she’d just phrased it poorly. Maybe she meant to say she’d never had shower sex but thought it would be fun. Yeah, that had to be it.

“And why hadn’t you done it before? Why not with Mike?” Josh asked in a mock tone. “Oh come on, you know why!” I heard some movement and a light slapping noise as if Amy had just hit his arm. “Are you going to make me say it? Mike has a small dick. I’m sure he knows it too. But it’s okay! I really like him!”

I was shocked. Amy thinks my dick is small? Wait, more importantly, she really likes me? I was so excited, nervous, and confused.

“Awww, that’s cute. Little freshmen in love,” Josh teased her playfully. “And hey, don’t worry, if you need more than what he has, you can always come get a little bit of this. Mike’s a good guy; I’m sure he’ll understand.” I couldn’t see, but I heard some shuffling again and guessed that he’d moved her hand to his cock.

“Oh my god it’s hard again?!” Amy uttered in disbelief. “But you just came! How can you go again??”

Despite her disbelief, the rustling noises didn’t stop. In fact, they started to pick up in intensity. Soon, Amy was moaning again.

“Ohhhhh Josh. Ohhh you’re so big. God you’re so big. I love your cock. It makes me feel so good!”

I didn’t have to see to know what was going on. Josh and Amy were having sex, just a few away from me. And it was too late now for me to reveal that I’d been awake this whole time. Maybe I could pretend that I just woke up? After all, they weren’t being particularly quiet by this point. But instead of pretending to wake up, I found myself moving my hand down to my once-again hard cock, quietly stroking it to the sound of Josh and Amy making love.

After what felt like an hour of this, during which I heard Amy cum, albeit more quietly than before, at least three more times, I finally heard Josh’s now familiar groans as he came. I couldn’t hold it any longer and came again too, getting my boxers wet with my little load.

“Josh! I told you not to cum inside me!” Amy scolded him.

“Does it matter though?” he replied. “You said you would take a morning after pill when you asked me to cum in you earlier, so an extra load shouldn’t matter.”

“I guess…” Amy sounded hesitant, “it’s just. It feels like I’m going to get pregnant when you shoot your load in me. It’s just so…big. And it feels so strong.”

At this point, I wasn’t surprised by what I was hearing. I’d seen how they’d had sex during our “threesome” and knew that Josh had a control over Amy that I would never had. That’s why he was allowed to cum inside her not once, but twice! It also confirmed that I hadn’t misheard anything earlier, they did have sex in the shower.

I lay there quietly, trying to process everything that had happened. I heard Josh and Amy talk a little more, but so quietly that I couldn’t really make out what they were saying, and then even those noises stopped.

I must’ve fallen asleep at some point, because the next thing I know, Amy is in my face. “Helloooooo. Michaeeeeel. Are you awake? Are you hungover? Because I am. And so’s Josh. Wanna get brunch with us?”

I groaned but nodded yes. After a quick shower, I put my clothes back on (thank god I hadn’t slept with them on, there were so many cum stains on the couch) and walked back into Josh’s room. Josh was standing next to his couch, and Amy was sitting in front of him, face flushed and hair slightly messy. I couldn’t help but wonder if something had happened while I was showering.

“You good, bro?” Josh asked, the look on his face telling me that he meant more than just whether I was good to go.

I thought about everything that had happened last night. How big his cock was, how hard Amy had cum on his cock, how turned on I was. “Yeah, I’m good.” I gave him a genuine smile and looked at Amy, still smiling. She smiled back. “Great! Then let’s go!” she grabbed my hand as she walked past me and out the door.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/hhadsg/college_threesome_turns_into_cuckolding_mfm