This is a continuation of my post the other night, it’ll probably be confusing if you don’t read that first, so here’s the link. [https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/hb88sg/the_time_i_fucked_an_ex_and_his_friend/](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/hb88sg/the_time_i_fucked_an_ex_and_his_friend/)
We leave off there with us all heading out to grab dinner at the local sports bar. We walked there since it was warm, and we were all going to have some drinks. During the walk we chatted, and didn’t really acknowledge what had just happened. It was a little weird to be honest.
When we arrived at the place for dinner, we eneded up in one of those horse shoe booths. The boys were facing one another and I was between them. Dinner was mostly un eventful except for some heavy flirting an inuendo by all three of us. I had kind of assumed that the boys would be done with me, and after dinner we’d all go our own way, maybe meet up in the future, maybe not.
Our server was a really pretty girl, good sized breasts, and a tight body. She had a tattoo behind her ear which I thought was pretty cute, even though I don’t know what it was. She was flirty, but clearly just for tips. I don’t think the boys were cluing into that, because they were both trying hard. She was a little too flirty if she had thought that I was one of their girlfriends. Just some random observations of mine.
At one point I went to the bathroom, I realized I hadn’t pee’d since earlier, and I had to go anyways, so I took the opertunity. When I got back I climbed back in and sat next to Mitch. I’m not sure what came over me, but I just started rubbing his leg. It was kinda taboo that I was rubbing a leg of my ex’s friend, even though we had just been naked together. I rubed him through his shorts too, just making his cock perky, and then backing off so he didn’t get too crazyy. I shuffled back around to Jake’s side of the booth after pulling my soaked panties out of my bag and stealthy slipping them into his pocket.
When I got to jake, I gave him a little stroke through his shorts, and leaned over to table to tell Mitch to check his pocket. He looked at his lap, looked at me, and called me a naughty girl. I realized at that point that the boys were still up for more if I wanted it, and since I hadn’t cum before, I was definitely still in the mood. The beers didn’t hurt either.
We each paid our bills, and then headed out of the bar and started walking back to Jakes place. Jake and I ended up holding hands at one point just like we had when we dated, which felt really normal until I realized what I was doing and let go of his hand and shuffled over to hold Mitch’s hand, giving Jake a naughty look. I was being very flirty, and I think they both knew that when we got back we would go for round two.
We didn’t make it home, outside a closed dry cleaner, Mitch pushed me into the door way and kissed me aggressively, he pushed his hand inside my jeans, and fumbled with my clit.. Jake kept walking a moment and then slowed and turned to us saying “Really?” we continued home. I was once again dripping with anticipation of being with the boys when I got back to Jakes place.
Mitch and I barely made it in the door, and he had me against the wall again. His hands were on my hips, he kissed me fiercely. Then he kissed my neck as he undid the button on my jeans. Looking over his shoulder I could see Jake close the door very calmly, and head to the kitchen to get a beer from the fridge. I undid Mitch’s shorts, and pushed them and his briefs over his ass, I didn’t get them all the way off, and he grabbed my hips and spun me around, pressing my head against the wall.
He reached around me and pulled my jeans down, I shimmied a little to help him, and my jeans ended up a my knees, he put a foot on either side of mine, and I pushed my bottom towards him. leaning against the wall I could see into the kitchen, Jake was standing there taking the cap off the bottle, he took a sip. Mitch reached into his pocket and grabbed my panties, he brought them up to my mouth with his hand and started using his fingers to poke them into my mouth. I was a little caught off guard, but I loved the feeling of how he was controlling me, I was being held against the wall, his body against mine, and his hand holding the side of my face as he pushed my soaked thong into my mouth.
Mitch pushed his shorts down to the floor and stepped out of just one leg of them. He pulled up his shirt and I could feel him grabbing his cock and rubbing it from my back, down my ass cheeks, and he found my pussy with his fingers. He flicked my pussy with a finger, and then immediately guided himself into me. I moaned, and continued making really amazing eye contact with Jake.
Mitch started pumping. I moaned through the panties. His hands were on my hips, helping him thrust, I was rocking my hips to his thrusts helping him get deep. He couldn’t bottom out in this position, and so I was really into it. He slid my blouse up over my head as I raised my hands up.. and pulled my bra down roughly. My breasts half came out, but were mostly smooshed by the now mishapen bra. He grabbed a breast and a hip and thrust into me as I leaned against the wall moaning softly through my own panties as I continued to make eye contact with Jake.
This lasted maybe 3 or more min, until Jake, without dropping eye contact, put his beer down, and while walking over dropped his shorts and kicked them off to the side, when he arrived I immediately took ahold of his large cock and started stroking it, he leaned in a pulled the panties from my mouth, kissed me deeply, and then stuffed the panties back in my mouth.
Mitch slowed, and then stopped as I continued stroking Jake. then he pulled out of me, I turned towards him, swapping hands on Jakes cock, and looking at Mitch. I grabbed his cock and stroked it, getting my wetness all over my hands as I did. I looked down at both cocks, and slid down the wall into a crouch. I started to take Mitch’s cock in my mouth as I stroked Jake. Then after a few moments I switched and stroked Mitch as I sucked on Jake. I stood back up, and said to them “I think it’s time to take this to the bedroom.” I walked to the room and took my bra off as I went, they both walked in after me.
I climbed up on the bed with my ass in the air towards them, and rolled onto my back when I got to the head of the bed. Mitch climbed onto the bed right after me, and slapped my knees appart. He shuffled fowards and I wrapped my legs around him, Jake came up to my head, and as Mitch slid back inside me, I flicked my tongue at Jakes cock, urging him into my mouth. He complied.
I sucked on Jakes cock, eventually getting a hand free from Mitch’s hold to feel his balls, and stroke. Meanwhile Mitch layed between my thighs thrusting away, and having his way with my pussy.
Mitch eventually pulled my legs up tight around him, and hugged me tight as he rolled off me, pulling me ontop of him, he actually did the whole move without having his cock slide out which was impressive. I rode him for a few moments as Jake moved away from the head of the bed and around behind me. I lifted myself off of Mitch’s cock, and slid back putting my ass in the air. Jake immediately grabbed my hips, grabbed his cock, and slid his big member into my pussy. I suddenly felt very full, as he slowly slid in and out of me, allowing my pussy to get used to it, I dropped my head in pleasure, and found Mitch stroking his cock slowly, so I did what any good girl would do, and took over. Grabbing Mitch’s cock and sucking on his head. His cock was covered in the white grool that I had been making for a while now, and I just realized it was probably also a bit of Jake’s cum from earlier. I hadn’t showered or anything, just wiped up in the bathroom, and I do remember a drip of cum sliding out into my jeans when we were walking, but it never all comes out like that.
I sucked on Mitch like that while Jake had his way with me in doggy. I was really enjoying it, and ended up with my hand down rubbing my clit. I had always enjoyed Jakes cock and how full it made me feel. He took his fingers and after feeling my lips, presumably to get some of my wetness, he played with my asshole. Not pushing the fingers in, but just on the surface, he knew I loved that and he knew he was good at it. I kept sucking Mitch even more enthusiastically. I started to get close to cumming, and I started moaning very loudly on Mitch’s cock.
As soon as I did, Jake stopped thrusting into me, and pulled his fingers from my ass, he also reached around and pulled my hand off my clit, I immediately came back from the edge of orgasm. He pulled me up wtih an arm around me, and whispered in my ear “No cumming until we do.” He knew me too well and knew that if I came I’d immediately lose interest and leave them with blue balls. I gave him a “Mmhm” and he let go of me, letting me back down on my hands and knees.
Then Jake said “climb back on that cock.” and I obliged. Sliding fowards, taking Mitch’s cock in my hand, and sliding it back in my pussy. I slowly rode Mitch, who suddely felt very small inside me compared to Jake. I’m not a size queen at all, I think all cocks are beautiful. Jake is definitely the biggest ive been with, but I’ve had a lot of fun with guys of all sizes, including pretty small. (not micro penis stuff, thats weird, but just genrally small isn’t neccessarily bad.)
Jake stayed behind me and rubbed my shoulders and back as I rode Mitch at my own pace, eventually I felt his hand on my back pushing me forward and I layed down ontop of Mitch’s body, using the oppertunity to kiss Mitch deeply.
Jake grabbed my ass with his hand, and felt me up, as I slowly rode Mitch. Then he slid a finger down and rubbed my asshole which was now fully drenched in my pussy juices from before when he was fucking me and playing with me. I knew what he was about to do, but I let him continue anyways.
I felt him raise up on his knees, and I rolled my hips backwards with Mitch still inside me. I had really enjoyed the double penetration from earlier and was eager to experience it again. He put his cock head on my asshole, and pushed on it. I pushed back on him just like normal to help it get in, and his cock slowly parted my asshole, and just barely slipped in. I moaned “OUUUUCH”. Mitch laughed. Jake apologiesed..everyone stopped moving for a moment. I put a hand back on Jakes hip to stop him from pushing in anymore. and moaned “Ow ow ow ow ow” It really freaking hurt. and not in a good way. I could feel myself coming to tears. Jake pushed against me again, and I dug my nails into his hip pushing him away.
I teared up, and said “I’m sorry, it hurts.” He paused. I eventually slapped him on the hip and told him to pull out slowly. I told him my ass was sore from earlier, it was a lie, but I didn’t want to tell Jake that he was too big for my ass right infront of Mitch who had cum in my ass just a few hours prior. I told him that if he had lube we could try that, but I knew he didnt have any. He didn’t have any when we were together, he wasn’t about to have some now. He said he didn’t. Asked if we could use vegetable oil. I said no. All the while Mitch was still inside me waiting there paitently.
Eventualyl I started rocking back and forth on Mitch again. I started to enjoy myself, and Mitch put a hand down on my clit and started rubbing it. He was pretty good, or I was really into it, either way, I was starting to think I could cum. Jake stayeed behind me for a bit, rubbing his cock on my ass as I rode Mitch.
Then he put his hand on my back again, and pushed me down again. I was thinking to myself “We just went through this, it doesn’t fit.” and I felt his hand on my pussy lips, right next to Mitch’s cock that was inisde me. He put his thumb into my pussy, sliding it in behind Mitch’s cock, I could see Mitch’s eyes roll, and he lost concentration because he stopped rubbing my clit. I thought it was strage, he was essentually giving his friend a hand job inside my pussy. But almost immediately his cock and his thumb swaped places, and his cock was inside me. Again a wave of pain flowed over me, but this time more of a pleasurable one. I moaned loudly and grunted.
Mitch didn’t seem to even acknowledge what was going on. Jake grabbed my hips and pulled himself into me. Mitch put his hands on my breasts and half held me up. I essentially stopped moving, and the boys thrust against one another for a moment, until they found a rythm. I let Mitch hold me up, and Jake hold my hips and I kind of just went limp with these two cocks in my pussy. I put my hand on my clit and started rubbing. I didn’t care that they hadn’t cum, I was going to cum. They thurst together for a few moments, maybe not even a min, and I opened my eyes to see Mitch making his orgasm face. I could feel him thrusting harder underneat me. I strated rubbing my clit furiously knowing that if he pulled out, I’d miss my opertunity to cum with two cocks in my pussy.
Jake kept thrusting Mitch just layed there, and I strated pushing back into Jakes cock, but Mitch didn’t fall out of me. Jake came moments later thrusting hard into me and bottoming out. I kept rubbing my clit, and just about when he stopped moaning I reached my climax thinking about how there were two hard cocks in me, and two loads of cum that Jake had just blended together inside my pussy. It didn’t tkae much effort to cum at that point.
Once we had all come down from our orgasms, Mitch had softened up and his cock just kind of slid out of me, when it did Jake gave me a couple of more thrusts and then pulled out of me. Immediately a large slug of cum slid out of my pussy and dripped onto Mitch’s stomach as I pushed myself upright while still straddling him. He said “eww” and Jake laughed standing next to the bed towling off his cock. I put my hand out to get the towel and he threw it in the corner of the room. He looked at me and leaned in to kiss me. Then said “you have a tongue, use that.”
I instantly thought what an asshole, but then thought what the hell, I’m sure it will make Mitch happy, so I leaned over, holding my hair back and sucked the very large drip of cum off of his very nice stomach. They both cheered, and I flopped off of Mitch and wiggled under the covers in a ball. The both said that it was fun, and thanked me for it. I replied with “no, thankyou!” and then said I needed a minute.
They left the room. I actually fell asleep exausted in the moment. I was woken at like midnight by Jake, saying he was coming to bed, he said that Mitch had left. He asked me to blow him once he was in bed, and I obliged. A normal plain blowjob in bed, except that he tasted like pussy and cum already. Once he had cum in my mouth, and I had swallowed it, I wnet to kiss him, and he rejected me, saying that I probably had Jakes cum in my mouth still, which was strange, but fair I guess.
I told him I had fun, and he should message me next time he wanted to do it again, he said only if he got to fuck my ass, I gave him a smirk as I put my clothes back on, and then I let myself out of his place and got back on the bus to get home.
when I got home, I masturbated again thinking about how I had two mens cum inside my pussy and Mitch’s cum was probably still in my ass, because I hadn’t been to the bathroom. I slept really well that night.
That’s the end of this story. I really enjoyed typing it out. If Mitch or Jake ends up reading this (not their real names), one of you still has my thong, I’d like it back. :P I’ll make it worth your while to bring it over.
I hope everyone enjoyed reading this, if you make it to the end, I’d love to talk to any couples that enjoyed it.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/hcgat0/the_time_i_fucked_an_ex_and_his_friend