Crowded Bathroom Part 2 [mf][sleepover][quiet][sister’s friend]

The first part is [here](https://www.reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/gj1rfo/crowded_bathroom_mf_shower_sex_sisters_friend/). Thanks for the support on the first part.

As I drove, I knew what I was doing was in stark disobedience to my sister Jane’s instruction. Ever since Jane caught Micaiah and I’s hookup, she separated us like bleach and vinegar. Micaiah’s visits to the house decreased and Jane wouldn’t leave Micaiah and I in a room together for ten seconds. As much as I wanted to see her and do the deed again, I had to cooperate with my sister. She had a bargaining chip above me; our parents. If I didn’t, in her words, stay away from Micaiah, she would simply tell our parents that we fucked in the shower. That was a wrath I did not want to invoke, and though at times I was tempted to bear their punishment so Jane couldn’t hold it over me, I was worried that they might cut me off from Micaiah. So, in the end, if Jane told me to leave the room, I left the room, and if Jane told me to get lost for the night, I did just that. The latter of which was her instructions for the night so she could have a sleepover. And that was just the instruction I was about to break.

I pulled up at our house as quietly as my old brakes could and hopped out of my car, stealthily closing my car door. It wasn’t like I was there to see Micaiah, all I wanted was to grab my wallet. A couple friends and I went clubbing, and I was the DD, so I was going to drive around. I didn’t bring my wallet so I wouldn’t buy any drinks, but I didn’t realize I was low on gas. So all I planned to do was slip into the house, grab my wallet, and leave without anyone being the wiser. Given the time, I was pretty sure they’d all be asleep, but even if they weren’t, I could just explain to my sister why I was here.

I quietly unlocked and opened the door, sneaking inside. To get to my bedroom, I had to go through the living room then downstairs. To my surprise, the girls were all lying in different locations in the living room. In the low light I could make out my sister on one couch, Sami and Faith in sleeping bags on the ground, and finally, Micaiah on the back couch. I couldn’t help but stare at Micaiah, her chosen sleeping position being on her back with one leg on the back of the couch and the other slumping to the floor. As I approached her I realized she had bare legs, and once I stood over her I noticed all she was wearing was an oversized shirt that had rode up thanks to the position of her legs and a pair of panties that were exposed to wandering eyes. My eyes were more than just wandering, they were there to stay.

I knew I should go to my room and forget about her. It was the dead of night; any noise could wake everyone up, which would mean we would be done for. There’s no way my sister won’t go straight to my parents if she caught us again, and if they caught us things would only be worse. Yet I couldn’t stop staring at this beautiful girl who was so open to me. I couldn’t pass up this chance at her.

I knelt down beside the couch and put my hands on her stomach, rubbing up her torso. She started to stir so I moved my hands to envelope her breasts. She groaned and sleepily pushed my hands away.

“What-” She started before I shushed her.

“I’m here for my rematch.” I whispered in her ear.

She turned to me with wide eyes and smiled. I gave her tits a squeeze before running my hands up to her head. I pulled her head to mine and we kissed, her hands finding the back of my neck. We broke up the kiss to breath.

“We have to be stealthy.” I whispered.

“Don’t we always.” She replied.

I took off my shirt and she did the same. She sat up on the couch and took her bra off as I took my pants off without making much noise. Micaiah was sitting so her hips were at the edge of the couch and her back slouched against the back of the couch. She had her legs spread wide apart, so I crawled up between them and kissed at her tits. I slowly kissed down her stomach until I got to her panties. I pulled them down and was about to kiss that too when Micaiah put a hand in my way.

“No cheating.” She whispered.

I took off my underwear to expose my raging boner. Luckily, the couch was at the perfect height that my erection was on level with her pussy. I moved my dick to her cunt and rubbed up and down her slit, covering my dick in her juices. Not wanting to waste time getting in her pussy, nor did I want to cheat as she called it, I put my dick at her entrance. She nodded to me and I slipped it inside her hole. In the silence I could hear the sound of my dick slipping into her pussy and parting her lips. But what was better than the sound was the feel. She was tight and it had been long enough that I had forgotten the sensation. I put myself all the way inside her to which I could hear the slightest whimper from her.

I pulled back and thrust in carefully this time, making sure our pelvises didn’t touch. I could still hear the subtle sounds of our fucking, but I doubted it would wake anyone up. I pulled back and thrusted into her a bit harder, stopping again before our pelvises smacked together. I was able to pick up the pace, still making sure that we were making almost no sound. Now that I was getting the rhythm, I used my hands to grab her tits, focusing on caressing the nipple. Micaiah had her head back and was lightly moaning as I fucked her.

Her legs found my lower back and hooked around it, gaining some leverage. She started humping her hips to my rhythm, but it was hard to synchronize when you can’t touch. I grabbed her hips for better control and after a moment of slowing down our thrusts, we were thrusting faster than before. Her arms reached out and held my back. She put some pressure on it so I leaned over her which placed my head by hers.

“You’re going to cum first this time.” She whispered between moans.

“Don’t be so sure.” I replied, also struggling to keep my volume down.

“You’re about to-” She had to pause her sentence so stop from moaning loudly “To cum deep inside me.” I couldn’t deny that I was getting close, and her telling me to cum inside her was hot, but this battle was far from over.

“You’re going to cum first.” I insisted.

I could tell she was close to cumming too, but I had no idea if I could outlast her. I kept thrusting into her as hard as I could, hoping to push her over the top. We were both breathing heavily in each other’s ear and trying to not cum first. Her moans were noticeable now, and not just because I was by her ear, but I didn’t care if anyone heard now. I was on the very edge and I could feel my balls tingling when I pumped into her as hard as I could. I started pumping cum into her but at the same time her back arched and she humped me while letting out little squeals. Our simultaneous orgasms lasted a long time and was the best thing I had felt. My body sagged and I had to use my arms to stop from falling on top of her.

“I guess it’s a tie then.” I whispered.

Micaiah didn’t respond, instead she looked behind me. I turned around to see someone in a sleeping bag sitting up and staring at us. It was dark but it was incredibly obvious what we had just done. I was too frozen to do anything but I could hear a quiet shush from Micaiah. I realized it was Sami, who at the moment was as frozen as I was. Eventually she laid back down as if nothing happened, which I was thankful for. Not willing to risk it again, we started redressing. After a quick goodbye kiss I grabbed my wallet and left quietly. They say to quit when you’re winning, but I don’t think I would mind going a couple more rounds.

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/gseh6q/crowded_bathroom_part_2_mfsleepoverquietsisters