Backstory can be found in part One and two; to summarize, I lucked my way into a threesome with two gorgeous older women. Not just once, not just twice, but three times.
Molly and I ended up having a great relationship, especially sexually. She’s the first woman I’d ever successfully had anal sex with because of my size (8.3 inches long and pretty thick, from what I’ve been told). Every now and then, she’d ask to be fucked in the ass and she loved every minute of it. In fact, she stared squirting when we would do it, something she’d never done before. And you’d get no complaints about it from me cause it was hot as Fuck.
We had our routine of going out to the bar I met her and Sarah at, have some drinks with our friends and then go back to her place. We saw Sarah up there a lot too, a lot of the times, she would come back and chill with us but would leave before anything happened like the last two times we played together… until my birthday weekend.
Although Molly had promised to give me a heads up if she had plans for us to play with Sarah, she kept this night quiet since it was something of a “birthday present” to me, so I didn’t mind. Didn’t think much of it either when Sarah came home with us from the bar either since she’d done it a bunch of times without anything happening. But this night, something was going to happen.
The three of us were outside smoking and drinking Crown & Cokes. Molly offered to refill our drinks and went back in the house. Sarah immediately looked at me and smiled, “so I hear you turned our girl into a squirter. Good job, young man.” I was probably blushing and replied, “yeah but only when I Fuck her in the ass.” Sarah was uncharacteristically silent for a little bit (she’d usually say something, anything about it quickly). “She forgot to tell me that was how you got her to do it.” I nodded and said, “yeah, I guess the secret is out” and laughed. Then, in an extremely serious tone, Sarah looked at me and said, “I’ve never done that before. Believe it or not, I’ve thought about it but I don’t want just some random guy to be my first. I want it to be you.”
I was fuckin speechless. Literally couldn’t think of anything funny or clever to say. Thankfully Molly came back with our drinks and sat next to me. “What are you two talking about?” She asked. “I told him my secret & that I want him to be my first.” Molly looked at me and asked if I was OK with it and I said, “yeah, if you’re ok with it I’m totally down.”
The three of us went back inside and headed straight for Molly’s room. I kicked off my shoes, took off my shirt and jumped onto the bed (in case you couldn’t tell, I was pretty Fucking stoked at this point). The ladies sat down on both sides of me and began undressing. Let me just say that these women had great taste in lingerie; Molly had a pink bra and black “booty” panties while Sarah wore a matching dark blue bra and thong. When she took off her pants, I couldn’t help but spank her round, firm ass. “Ooh… soon baby. Soon” she squealed and joined Molly in sucking on my cock.
They took turns on it; one would suck and stroke it while the other sucked on my balls. Fuck, it felt incredible having them both sharing my cock. At one point when Sarah was in control, she slapped it against Molly’s face and gave it back to her. They then took turns; Molly started licking the shaft while Sarah licked and sucked the tip. I looked down at her to let her know I was about to cum and I exploded inside Sarah’s mouth. I think most of it went straight down her throat because when she went to share my cum with Molly, there wasn’t very much there & I knew that there was a LOT more than what she shared.
They wiped off their faces with the bedside towel and Sarah seemed slightly confused about where to go. “Lay down, baby. This is your night” Molly said and Sarah laid down on her back with her legs eagerly awaiting. Molly and I began caressing her body; Molly made her way from Sarah’s legs to her beautiful pussy and dove in with her tongue. I knew how much Sarah liked her tits to be played with, so I started to lick one of her nipples while I pulled and twisted on the other. She had one hand holding Molly’s hair and with her free hand, grabbed my cock and stroked it. I could tell she was gonna cum soon cause she stroked my dick faster and faster until she squirted all over Molly’s face. I kissed her, tasting Sarah’s juices all over Molly’s mouth and it tasted like heaven.
“Are you warmed up yet, baby?” Molly asked Sarah, who replied “I’m Sooooo fuckin ready. How should I be?” Molly told her it’d be easier if she went into Doggystyle position, so Sarah rolled over and arched her sweet ass as high as she possibly could. I turned around and got behind her but I wanted that pussy first. I slapped her on her butt cheeks to tease her a little bit & she called me on it. “Oh, you fuckin tease” Sarah said and almost immediately after she spoke, I thrust my cock inside of her sweet, wet pussy and began to fuck her brains out at a very fast pace. Molly moved around so that her pussy was in Sarah’s face and Sarah started liking her pussy furiously. In the middle of all of this, Molly reached into the nightstand, pulled out the lube (KY, of course) and tossed it to where I could reach it & winked at me.
The three of us kept on like this for a while until Sarah started moaning and groaning and squirting all over the place. I held her hips and kept thrusting into her warm, dripping wet pussy while she continued to cum. Soon after, Molly began to cum as well and the three of us slowed down a little. I took the lube and poured it onto Sarah’s beautiful asshole before applying a generous amount to my cock. I gently pressed the head of my cock against her “brown-eye” and slowly slid into her ass. Sarah let out a soft moan and I stopped for a second to let her get used to it. “Keep going” she said and I put my entire length inside of her. As soon as I was balls deep, Sarah started moaning and cumming just by having me inside of her. When she was finished, she let out a deep breath and said, “OK stud, I’m ready.”
I began to gently thrust in and out of Sarah’s ass, so as not to hurt her. Molly had moved underneath her so that the two of them were in the 69 position, eating each other while I continued fucking Sarah in the ass. The sounds of the two of them moaning drove me wild but I kept going, making sure that Sarah was getting the pleasure she desired. I held on as long as I could and announced that I was gonna cum. Sarah told me to keep going and to cum inside her and before long, I did. I unleashed my load deep inside of Sarah’s ass and heard her moan with passion as I came inside her. When I finished, I pulled out and let my semi-hard cock rest against her warm pussy. To my surprise, Molly took me into her mouth and sucked all of the juices off of my cock.
The three of us laid down in bed for a little while. Molly asked Sarah how she was feeling and Sarah said it was the most incredible feeling and said that she didn’t ever want anyone else besides me to fuck her in the ass. She put her hand up and swore on her daughter’s life that no other man would ever be allowed there except for me. I felt kinda honored by the gesture. Not soon after, Molly moved around so that she was in the Doggystyle position and told me to fuck her in the ass, which I gladly did.
We continued on like this for hours and hours, with me switching off between Molly and Sarah until the sun came up. The three of us were exhausted and ended up sleeping throughout the day together in Molly’s bed. It was about five in the evening when we finally woke up, which was perfect timing because Sarah had to go pick up her kid from the sitter. She quickly threw on her clothes, kissed us both and left. Knowing me the way she did, Molly knew I was starving because I’d worked up an appetite the night before. So we hopped in the shower and of course, we had sex. We got dressed and went out for some of the best street tacos I’ve ever had. Maybe it was from the night before but the food was exceptionally good that day. We went back home and just chilled out watching TV until we fell asleep. The rest of the weekend went by fast; probably because we spent the first half of it fucking like stoned test bunnies.
I wasn’t the only one who got a great present for my birthday. Unfortunately, Molly and I broke up a few months later and that weekend was the last time the three of us played together. Despite the breakup, I ended up having sex with Sarah a few times until the”guilt of fucking her best friend’s ex” got to her and we stopped things.
So that’s the story of how I hooked up with two beautiful, curvy, fucking drop dead sexy older women. I lightweight became a legend amongst my friends who knew all of us, but that didn’t matter to me. The memories of my adventures with Molly, Sarah was the reward.
Although that was the last time I played with Molly and Sarah, it wasn’t the last time I had a threesome. About a year later I was contacted by an old crush from high school and ended up having a LOT of adventures with her. But that’s another story for another time. Hopefully you enjoyed reading about my adventures with the Soccer MILFS. I’ll be back to tell about the adventures with my friend from high school, hopefully sooner than later. If you liked the Soccer MILFS saga, you’ll definitely love what happened to me with my old high school friend
Thanks for taking the time to read it. Positive vibes only, please. Stay tuned and stay safe out there ???
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/gl08e3/soccer_milfs_part_three_slip_and_slide_mff