Part 1 – [https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ghxtow/the_apology_cake_part_1_mf/](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ghxtow/the_apology_cake_part_1_mf/)
Pracis of Part 1 – Met a new girl who introduced me to kink & took me to a sex party. Met another girl there she wanted to play with but didn’t. We went back next time hoping to play with her.
And so part 2 begins…
It felt like the whole of the next month was spent with Katie running through scenarios of how to get Imogen to have a threesome with us. It was actually quite funny. She practiced lines, obsessed about what she was going to wear, made sure she was plucked and groomed and shaved to perfection. Talked to her friends to see if she could figure out who Imogen was so she could get some more intelligence. I on the other hand, was doing research into what to do in a threesome, and trying not to get too nervous. Our sex life was even better – Katie fantasised constantly about what we were going to do, and just whispering in her ear about how much I wanted to watch her eat another girl out as I fucked her was enough to push her over the edge into orgasm. The next month rolled around, and we headed out to play, Katie looking amazing, and me really excited about playing in public and determined that I would look at other people when we played!
Katie had her patter down, and as we arrived, Imogen was already there, drink in hand. We said hello, and before Katie could start her endlessly rehearsed spiel, Imogen said “I saw you guys play last time, and it was really hot, do you both want to play with me?”. I did my best not to laugh and Katie actually looked disappointed how easy it was! I got us both a drink and we discussed likes and dislikes and limits, while we waited for the early birds to go down and play them come back up for a rest. I was in a state of shock at this point, my hands we visibly trembling with a mix of nervousness & excitement, and my cock was already hard and twitching. As people started to filter back upstairs, Imogen took us both by the hand and led us downstairs. Just having her touch my hand almost made me come in my pants.
We found a free bed, and things got started. Imogen was wearing all black, a skin tight two piece skirt and crop top, that showed off her toned stomach and round arse. Underneath was an ensemble I’d never seen before – it was all straps and no material, the open cups and crotch perfectly framing her assets and forming a delightful invitation. In order to maximise my attractiveness, I was wearing a suit, and had gone all out wearing my bow tie, which never failed to set Katie’s heart fluttering and her pussy dripping. Katie was a real girlie girl – the weather was good, so she wore a light floaty, flowery summer dress, and nothing else. So there I was, getting stripped down by 2 gorgeous women, doing my best to keep control. Most of it came off, but when it came to the bow tie, the missive came from Katie “it stays on”. So there I was, stark naked except for my bow tie. I felt like Chris Farley in that SNL skit, but it was working for the girls, so who was I to complain? In one swift movement, I lifted Katie’s dress off over her head, and I sat back to watch 2 stunning women kiss and touch each other. Having calmed down a bit, the urge to get involved was too strong, and so began my first threesome. It was awesome – I was worried about coming too soon, so I made sure I concentrated on Katie & Imogen, kissing them all over, touching, rubbing, pinching and licking wherever I could. The most memorable for me was going down on Imogen, seeing them kiss and then watching Katie sit on Imogen’s face and almost instantly come. Fucking Katie’s face as Imogen had her tongue on Katie’s clit and her fingers in her pussy and stretching her arsehole is a sight that has stayed with me and I hope to never forget. Pushing my tongue deep into Katie’s arsehole as she licked Imogen’s was pretty amazing, and having 2 girls (very briefly) suck my cock was an incredible experience. All through this, I struggled not to come – I was on a hair trigger the whole time, and I knew my orgasm was going to be a big one. I was unsure if I was going to be able to get it up again, nerves being a thing and if I come really hard getting hard again can sometimes be a challenge.
I don’t know how long we played, it felt like minutes but was likely a couple of hours. Positions changed, orgasms were had and my kegel muscled had been clamped for a long, long time. As things were starting to wind down, Katie started to come down and realised that I hadn’t come yet. A nod to Imogen and I got attacked. Katie got on my face, kneeling over me and pinning my arms above my head. Imogen grabbed my cock and licked it from root to tip, engulfed the whole thing and started to suck with real intent. She alternated between sucking and giving me a slow, leisurely hand job. It felt amazing!
Now, I like to give a bit of notice that I’m about to come so that the person on the receiving end can be ready. I felt the pressure start to build, and I knew orgasm was close. However I had a challenge. Katie was sat on my face, and my arms were pinned, with her knelt on my upper arms. As I started thinking this, Katie began to get close too. Katie had a muscular orgasmic style, and when she was close, started to ride my face, essentially rubbing herself to orgasm. So there I was, at the point of no return, my girlfriend trying to push my nose up into my brain with her clitoris and a girl I barely knew in the firing line. I tried to say something, but nothing other than a muffled “MMM MMM MMM” came out and waving my arms didn’t do much. I was a little glad that Imogen was giving me a hand job at the time, and I came like a fire hose, 2 hours of holding back building up the pressure quite impressively. I heard an “Ow” as the first rope sailed unfortunately, but accurately directly into her left eye. At this point, my legs were shaking, I went temporarily deaf and my whole body tensed then relaxed as I had the hardest orgasm of my life that far. Katie finished her own orgasm and collapsed off me. When I could sit up, I made sure Imogen was ok, and helped her to wash the semen out of her eye. She took it very philosophically, accidents happen was her opinion. The girls walked and I crawled up the stairs and we got a drink.
After getting our breath back, we went back down to watch other people play. I was done, but Imogen and Katie played (for my benefit, my male ego told me!) and I got the chance to look around to see a goodly number of people were watching, and I rather enjoyed seeing a few guys were wanking while watching these two stunning women play.
Finally the afternoon came to an end and we got ready to leave. It turned out that Imogen didn’t live in our city, but a few hours away. She only came down for the party, and so we agreed to meet up next time. I felt guilty about my misfire, and so I wanted to get something to apologise to her. I had seen a picture of a cake that had been made, that said “I’m sorry I came in your eye”. So I got my apron on, and made a chocolate cake with white icing (naturally) and green writing. I even drew a picture of an eye, with some come dripping out of it! I took it along to the next party, and Imogen found it hilarious! She brought a friend along with her this time, and so I had my first foursome, and the first time I watched Katie fucked by another man. The first but not the last!
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/gja91g/the_apology_cake_part_2_mff