So here is a true Craigslist success story from a few years ago. To set the scene I was 45 at the time, just an average guy who is lucky enough to have done some swinging. In 2014 I saw an ad from a guy on the north side of town near me. He had a submissive girlfriend who wanted to have her first three way. She apparently loved anal and wanted to try DP.
I ended up meeting the guy at a local irish pub for a beer where we discussed it, his name was Rob. The gal was a nurse named Kat, redhead, about 40. She had a few kids at home but her body was still tight. She was married to somebody else but Rob told me that her husband was abusive and they were headed toward divorce. Rob was strictly her Dom/fuckbuddy, they weren’t really dating in the traditional sense. Their relationship was mostly her getting off working the night shift and go straight to his place and get banged out before she had to go home.
Rob and I hit it off and he took me back to his place to show me the layout. The deal was that Kat was going to be blindfolded and ready, this was part of their Dom/sub play and my role was strictly stunt cock. The plan was that they would already have been fucking for an hour and I was to let myself in at a pre-determined time and join the party. They also wanted it bareback and I had just gotten an STD test so we traded results. I don’t usually fuck bareback in these situations so this promised to be a treat.
Two days later at 9:00 AM I showed up at Rob’s house, let myself in, and went to the bedroom. She was super cute wearing nothing but a blindfold and a thin little camisole top. She had curves in all the right places, big tits and a nice round ass. She had a shamrock tattoo near her gorgeous pink pussy, which was completely shaved. They had been at it for a few hours, Kat got off work early and Rob was mostly spent and ended up just watching and directing the action.
I stripped down and began eating Kat’s pussy and ass. She really was hot and very orgasmic. I was hard as a rock. I am fit with a thick cut cock. They were both very eager for me to fuck her so I slid my cock into her hot cunt then quickly switched to her ass. They had a small bowl of warmed coconut oil to use as lube. I hadn’t used that before but it turned out to be very good for assfucking. She absolutely loved it in the ass, I was not used to being able to pound away the way Kat liked it, so much fun.
I kept going back and forth between her pussy and ass in different positions but mostly missionary and doggy style. The bed was at the right height I could stand on the ground and pound her while she hung her ass over the edge. Every time I felt like I was going to cum I either slowed down the tempo, pulled out and had her suck my cock, or went back to eating her pussy. Then I would do the whole thing all over again. They never removed her blindfold.
Rob got hard enough to try some DP but we didn’t go for very long because he couldn’t keep it up. I ended up fucking her for an hour until she asked me to cum in her so I picked up the pace and filled her pussy up with a huge load.
We were all spent and I had to go to work. I went to the bathroom and took a hot shower to rinse off all the coconut oil and got dressed. Kat and Rob were still on the bed and she was still blindfolded, she never did see my face to my knowledge. We had a nice chat about how fun it was and promised to get together again but that never happened. Kat divorced her husband and Rob got a new girlfriend and moved out of state.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/f0d6ah/mfm_craigslist_blindfold_anal