It had been a few months since Mary and I started having sex, she was open to trying new things but she also exactly knew what she liked. If she tried it and did not enjoy it we were never doing it again. Tonight was date night and we decided to go to our usual bar. Our relationship was still a secret, so we tried to avoid places we knew our family and friends frequented.
We were sitting in a booth enjoying some food, drinks and conversation. The bar was large, had live music and was dimly lit. The ambiance and the company was amazing. Since it was a Tuesday it wasn’t as packed and the music was also more mellow.
Mary sipped on her drink and nonchalantly asked, “Where to tonight?”
Since we couldn’t meet at each other’s homes we’d find isolated places to make out or just outright have sex. My favorite one so far had been the detached garage at her place, I snuck in at two in the morning and she bought pillows and blankets to lay on the cold floor. We fucked right behind her dads vintage Porsche. Hers was in a classroom at her college after hours. We role played the teacher student act there and had to run towards the end when a security guard came by. That chase left us so excited we fucked again in my car after we escaped. The excitement of being caught really elevated the experience.
“The usual?” I asked lifting my drink.
Mary nodded in disagreement, “I have all night tonight, my parents think I’m staying over at a friends place. New place, maybe?”
This was great news, she usually had to rush back home after our dates since they were after her bible study or classes. This means tonight we could just walk around this town and find new places that fit our needs.
“Cheers to that”, I said and sipped on my drink.
“**Marrrry!”** roared someone across the bar.
We froze and had the same dreaded expression as we saw Liz rushing towards us. Not her I thought, I hadn’t told Mary about the Snapchat incident yet. Liz was a very attractive and charming woman. Blue eyes, long flowing red hair, freckled face and curvaceous body had everyone gawking at her.
She was definitely flaunting her curves tonight with her attire. A tight shimmering black dress with straps that wrapped around her neck like a choker. There was an opening in the middle which left an area from her chest to her belly button bare. There was a cross hanging right below the neck straps which was bouncing between her breasts. The dress was short and I mean *really* short, If she bent over, her butt would just pop out. Her monstrous breasts were bouncing and slamming against each other as she moved, it was mezmerizing.
“*Hey you*”, she looked at me, with a piercing gaze, “How are you guys?” She said animatedly.
I was frozen and couldn’t say a word but thankfully Mary took charge.
“Good, we’re just… *hanging out*”, Mary said emphasizing the last part.
“Oh come on! you guys are on a date, I’m not going to tell anyone. In fact…” Liz whispering now, “I’m here to hopefully pick up some guys”.
“You wha….” Mary stopped as I kicked her in the knee.
“Oh that’s great” I said trying to make the conversation less awkward.
“Yea I come here about once a month with the college just a few blocks away there’s a lot to pick from”, Liz said sitting next to Mary and waving to the bartender. Well now she’s going to sit here with us, *great*, I thought to myself.
Mary still seemed dumbstruck at the whole idea of a girl from her bible study picking up random men for fun. Oh how sheltered she was I thought.
Liz had an infectious personality. You could never just walk away from a conversation with her, you had to be let go. As Mary listened, Liz said, “You know Mary… you know what guys like? The forbidden fruit. You tell them how religious you are and how you’ve never been with a man and they get obsessed. Especially committed men, the dangers of being caught and the lust of taking away a woman’s purity drives them mad.”
“Isn’t that right?”, she said looking right at me.
“I guess.. maybe, I… I wouldn’t know”, I gulped.
“Oh calm down, I’m just teasing” Liz said smiling as she held my hand.
Mary and Liz continued talking and drinking. I was relieved to see them have such good chemistry. They were laughing, sharing stories and even teasing each other, like they were best friends. It was amazing and sad to see how these two had spent years in the same church and bible study and were just acquaintances.
Mary excused herself to use the restroom leaving me and Liz alone. I tried to avoid looking at Liz directly and the silence between us was getting awkward. Say something I thought to myself.
“You look nice”, I said. *What…. was that…ugh?* I thought to myself.
Before I could say anything else, “Did I look nice… when I masturbated thinking about you?” She scowled.
I’m in trouble I thought and gulped.
“You never replied…” Her eyes locked onto mine.
After a brief pause she said, “I get it though, you were with *her*.” Now looking at the empty spot where Mary was sitting.
I nodded in agreement words failing me right now. She reached across the table bringing her face as close to mine as possible and whispered, “I want to know… did you… did you touch yourself thinking about me? Can you still hear me… moaning your name each time you close your eyes?”
I wanted to say I did and every time I masturbated I fantasized about the things I wanted to do to her but my entire body was tense and I froze.
“**I’m back**” Mary yelled. I heaved a sigh of relief she had just saved me. A few more moments and I would have imploded.
I was afraid of Liz but in that moment but I was also extremely turned on. Liz sat back down, her eyes still locked on to me. Not sure what to do, I jumped out of my seat and excused myself to use the restroom.
As I headed back to the table I heaved a sigh of relief when I didn’t see Liz there. I sat across from Mary who informed me that Liz was using the restroom too. I guess my relief was premature.
My phone buzzed and I almost choked when I saw the snap Liz had sent. I should have learned my lesson not to open her snaps in public. She’d gone to the restroom and taken a picture of her clean shaven underside, her middle and index finger holding her vagina wide open. The text read “Oops! forgot my underwear..” I sighed.
“Everything okay hun?” Mary asked as she held my hands across the table.
“Yeah.. all good” I stuttered as I scrambled to put my phone away.
She continued, “you know Liz isn’t that bad a person, yes she sounds terrible on paper but she isn’t a bad person.”
I grunted. *Oh Mary, if you only knew*, I thought.
We sat there silently enjoying the music. Liz walked over with three double shots of tequila, a giant wicked smile and sat snugly next to Mary.
“***Shots!***” She screamed.
Salt, shot and lime the three of us downed the drink. Mary was sticking her tongue out in disgust and sprinkled sugar over it. She had never tasted tequila before and clearly she did not like it. Liz and I laughed at her reaction. Liz pulled Mary close and ruffled her hair. “There there” she said as Mary’s head rested on Liz’s bosom.
More of the evening passed with us talking and drinking some more. As the drinks flowed our lips loosened and we told Liz about our sexual adventures. Liz listened intently biting her lip, I could tell by her face that she was fantasizing about herself in our stories. Her right hand was under the table. She was most definitely touching herself down there. God this woman was a sensual beast I thought.
Liz pulled Mary close to her and whispered into her ears. Mary’s eyes widened and moments later had a wicked smile.
“What?” I asked.
“Oh nothing just girl talk”, Mary said awkwardly.
Liz bit Mary’s ear as she pulled away.
*Uh oh* I thought.
They got up and held my hands. “Come on… let’s go” and dragged me out of the bar.
We got into a cab headed for Liz’s apartment. Was this really happening I thought to myself. Mary on my right rested her head on my chest. Liz on my left, licked my ear and seductively whispered, “*Fuck me… fuck me hard like you fuck Mary.*” Mary gripped my chest harder, she might have heard Liz.
Mary kept her hands around me as we climbed up to Liz’s apartment. Once we entered Mary stopped me and whispered “I love you hun, *always*.”
I kissed Mary and asked, “are you good, love?”
“mmmm hmmm” is all the response I got.
We crashed on the couch. Me seated, Mary on me, Liz standing behind her. Liz held Mary’s hair up and started unzipping Mary’s dress. Mary arched backwards as the zipper moved down. Liz threw Mary’s dress across the room and proceeded to kiss her neck. Mary moaned softly as Liz and I kissed her. I reached my hand behind Mary and unhooked her white satin bra then I went on to grab Liz’s breasts. Liz let out a soft moan as I fondled her tits.
Liz placed her wet tongue near Mary’s nape and ran it down her back all the way to her butt. Her saliva dripping in between her buns. I could feel Mary tremble and her smooth soft skin got bumpy with goosebumps. Liz removed Mary’s underwear and spanked her.
“Is this how he spanks you”, Liz whispered in Mary’s ear but her eyes were dead set on mine.
“*mmmmmm*” Mary moaned her lips still locked with mine.
I joined in too, Liz spanked her right cheek I spanked her left cheek.
“*mmmmm mmmmm*” Mary moaned louder with each hit.
Liz mouthed to me, “Lift her up” and made a licking motion holding her fingers in a V shape. I grabbed Mary by her butt and lifted her. Her vagina right above my mouth. I spread her legs and ran my tongue in vertical motions over her labia.
I felt Liz grab Mary’s butt cheeks. “Liz, *aaahhh*”, Mary jumped.
Confused I looked down and saw Liz had her face buried in Mary ass. Mary arched backwards and held my head tight. I pushed my tongue deep into her. Mary moaned louder as both Liz and I pleasured her. Her moaning turned into screaming as she fell backwards her entire body trembling. Liz stepped back and I caught Mary from falling. Mary curled up as I lay her on the couch.
Liz poked Mary and all we got was a grunt.
“It’s just us now”, Liz whispered as she held the base of my shaft, squeezing as hard as she could. She pulled me using my cock as her handle and sat atop the dining table. She pulled her dress upheld her legs wide open. Her look said it all, she wanted to be fucked. As I moved closer, I turned over to see Mary sleeping like a baby. Liz grabbed my butt and pull me right inside her.
“Aaaah” she moaned.
I pushed Liz flat on the table and split her dress in the middle. Her exposed succulent melons bouncing as I thrusted.
“That’s it, fuck me hard.” She said moaning.
I cupped her breasts, my hands barely able to wrap around them and thrusted hard. As my thrusting got more aggressive Liz brought her face closer to mine and whispered, “Look at me, *aaaaaah!* Look at how you make me feel when you’re inside me. You do this to me *aaah*” she could barely contain her moans. Liz was loud and I was surprised Mary was still asleep.
Liz fell back on the table moaning she squeezed her breasts and her legs trembled violently as she came. Before she could fully recover she jumped down to her knees and started sucking my cock.
“Unload in my mouth” she mumbled my cock choking her. My muscles tensed up, she knew I was about to blow. Liz grabbed my butt and pull my cock deeper into her mouth. My cum filled her mouth some of it leaking out. She pulled back and licked everything clean.
“Delicious” she said licking her lips.
Mary and I got up the next morning with severe hangovers but Liz seemed fine. She could handle her alcohol better than us by the looks of it.
Mary was rather quiet and she was looking down as we walked back to my car. I pulled her close kissed her head and asked, “Are you ok?”
Mary burst out crying, she was covering her face. “I did not want us there, I’m sorry, I’m…I’m really sorry, I panicked.” Mary said sobbing.
“At the end there when Liz was whispering in my ear she told me she had recorded everything we said tonight and that if I did not do as she said she’d send the recordings to our parents and friends”, Mary jumped in my arms as she said that.
Right there my heart dropped and I started sweating. The one time we dropped our guard Liz fucked us over.
“**Fuck!** …. fuck fuck fuck” I yelled. I held Mary tight and said, “It’s not your fault. I should have seen this. I should have realized, you are always so talkative and cheerful but since we left the bar….. fuck. God damnit!”
My phone buzzed, it was a snap from Liz. Fuck this bitch I thought. I opened it right in front of Mary this time. Both of us stared at it with dread. It was a clip of Mary moaning, her face clearly visible. I could see silhouettes of me and Liz under her. Liz recorded us with her phone last night at her place.
The text underneath read. “Same place and time next week!”
“What do we do now?” Mary asked her body shivering.
“Now we do her bidding” I said.
Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/ezqsdn/the_christian_girlfriend_part_3_mff
Awesome twist