The Christian Girlfriend Part 2 [MF]

[Part 1](https://www.reddit.com/r/sexstories/comments/etbs9a/the_christian_girlfriend_mf/)

​

I was early, I waited in my car outside Mary’s house for more people to show up. House is an understatement it was a three story mansion with a giant swimming pool and a large open air balcony for parties. The weather was pleasant tonight, it was warm with a slight cool breeze.

Mary’s family was attending the Kentucky derby and a wedding. Her sisters were leaving for vacations with their friends the following day too. This meant she would be alone at home for the rest of the week. After the family left her, the eldest sister, Teresa had organised a party at their place. Everyone from their church group was invited. I was probably the only non church group person there. Our plan was once everyone leaves the party I sneak into her room and we hangout there.

People started arriving and I joined a group walking in. I was excited to see Mary, we weren’t getting to spend a lot of time recently due to other obligations. We did have many more sexual adventures since the first one at the parking lot. No intercourse yet but she did start reciprocating. Her blow jobs were terrible in the beginning, but she got better as I started sending her porn and guided her each time she worked on me. Within no time she was a pro and knew exactly what worked best on me.

I rang the door bell and her sister opened the door with Mary by her side. Mary’s hair was down and curled. She was wearing mascara, bright red lipstick and subtle makeup which made it look like she wasn’t wearing any at all. Her outfit was quite sexy and revealing, a red floral deep V neck dress which was barely knee high. She wore a cross that sat right above her cleavage but I was mostly starting at her partially exposed breasts. She gave me a mischievous smile. Everyone walked in as I stood there just awestruck.

“Aren’t you going to come in?” she asked casually.

“You look phenomenal”, I whispered to her.

“It’s all for your cute butt, I don’t usually get to dress up for our secret dates. Now go before people start getting suspicious” she whispered back.

As I walked past her she pinched my butt causing me to jump a little. It was nice way to welcome me.

The balcony was packed with people, there was food, booze and music. Since I didn’t really know anyone there I was floating from group to group. There were the nerds who were using bible quotes with popular memes. The young newly weds who couldn’t stop talking about how Christ enriched their love. The couples with five kids who were running around trying to keep their kids in check. Then there was Elizabeth.

Elizabeth or Liz as she insisted I call her was a 20 year old red head from Mary’s bible study. She caught hold of me and started talking. It was actually fun talking to her and getting to know her. She was as tall as me with a fit but curvaceous body. Her large bosom, tight waist and firm butt drew a lot of eyes. She had an infectious personality and tonight I was her target. Since Mary and I weren’t dating publicly I was single and apparently ready to mingle according to Liz. I will say I enjoyed the attention and her views on things especially in this monotone group. I spent most of my evening talking to Liz. We exchanged contact info and social media accounts, I even danced a little with her.

The party started dying down and I was amongst the last ones to leave. Liz was still glued to me. I could tell by Mary’s piercing gaze and pursed lips that she was not happy. As we were leaving Liz grabbed my hand and with a wicked smile on her face said “Call me, I loved being around you”. Mary saw this from a distance but did not react. I drove to the nearest gas station and waited for Mary to call me.

About 30 mins later she called.

“Hey” I said

Before I could say anything else she said in a very calm but commanding tone “My sisters are asleep now so meet me at the back entrance and from there we can sneak up to my room. Don’t bring your car near the estate, park it a little further up the road.”

I followed her instructions and we snuck up to her room. I locked the door behind us and reached out to hug her, she took a step back to avoid it.

“I missed yo…”

“You know Liz is a slut right?” she cut me off

“Woah, we were just being social” I said trying to downplay Liz’s behavior.

“I’m just.. I can’t…you shouldn’t” she was trying to form a cohesive sentence.

I walked up to her and hugged her. Holding her face in my hands and looking right into her eyes I said with a serious tone, “She is nothing to me hun. What you’re feeling right now is insecurity. I could have an easy public relationship with anyone but I chose this because I love you, only you and I want to be with you. Let’s not ruin our evening because of a fleeting entity like Liz. Our relationship is stronger than this.”

“You’re right” she said sounding relieved as she hugged me back.

“I love that you dressed up for me tonight. You looked stunning” I said a little more cheerfully as I kissed her forehead.

“I have another surprise for you, Liz almost ruined it” she mumbled that last part.

“Hey, forget her, she is inconsequential. Now tell me what the surprise is?” I said smiling

Her face lit up with excitement “Aaaah I’ve been planning this for days. Turn around and close your eyes, no peeking.” she squealed as she raced to her closet.

I could hear her running around and throwing things. After a few mins she said in a very sexy tone, “Turn around and open your eyes slowly”

She stood there like a runway model one foot in front of the other wearing a long winter jacket. Before I could say anything, she dropped the jacket revealing the sexy red lingerie with black stockings that she was wearing. Her bra did not cover the nipple area, easy access I thought to myself. She looked away as I sheepishly stared at her.

“Wow you…you look so sexy” I said

She gave a warm smile and said “Yay! I was super nervous and thought I was going to get this all wrong.”

“No, no, it’s perfect” I responded my eyes still fixated on her.

She held my hands, looked down and said nervously. “I’m ready, I want us to.. to have sex hun, I want you inside me tonight.”

I could feel her heart racing as I pulled her close.

“You know I’ve been doing some research from the links you had sent me and since it’s my first time there are some things I want to try” she said shyly.

“Go on”, I said with a wicked smile.

She started with “I want to try missionary”

“Of course, the one true position, God recommended, Church approved”, I joked.

“Oh shush”, teasingly she hit my chest.

“Doggy” she paused for a few seconds and covered her face in embarrassment.

“And I want you ……..,” I couldn’t quite tell since she was mumbling in her hands. I pulled her hands away, embarrassed she looked down and said “I want you to spank me.”

I heard her but I wanted to tease her. “Sorry, what was that, I couldn’t hear you?” I asked.

“I want you to **SPANK** me” she almost yelled.

I started laughing. “Don’t make fun of me” she said as she pushed me away nodding her head furiously.

I pulled her close into a tight grip. “No you just want to make fun of me” she said as she struggled to free herself from my grip.

I kissed her and squeezed her butt. She let out a little moan. I bit her left ear lobe gently and whispered “I’ve been waiting for this for a long time. I love you and tonight I’m going to show you how much.”

I unhooked her bra and let it slide down. With the palm of my hands I lightly massaged here nipples. She closed her eyes and her breathing got heavier. As I pushed down on her breasts she moaned “I’m yours. I want to feel you inside me.”

I turned her around and started kissing her neck. With each kiss I kept moving down. From her back to to her butt. As I kissed her buns I unhooked her garter belt and pulled off her underwear and stockings. I bent her down face first into the bed. Her moist vagina now visible, I licked it and she moaned softly.

I raised my right hand and gripped her tight with my left one. There was silence then “***aahhh***” she moaned as her legs trembled. I could see the red hand print I had just made on her pale butt cheek. I waited.

“Why’d you stop?” she mumbled in the pillow approvingly.

After several minutes of spanking and licking she sat up straight by the edge of the bed. Her face pink and her butt red she grabbed my pants by the pockets and pulled my crotch right to her face. I removed my belt and dropped my pants. She kissed my erect penis through my underwear and then pulled my underwear down. My cock bounced in front of her face. She focused on it like a snake hypnotized by a snake charmers flute.

She gripped the base of my shaft firmly and sucked on the tip while moving her tongue in circular motions around it. Just my tip was insider her mouth and she was teasing all my sexual receptors causing me to moan audibly and my muscles to tighten. Her mouth now wide open, she swallowed my penis whole. I could feel the back of her throat as she gaged on it. She continued making circular motions but now her tongue had engulfed my shaft too. Gently she pulled back leaving a lot of saliva.

“It’s all lubed up” she said smiling as she booped my penis and looked up at me with puppy dog eyes.

She wrapped her legs around my waist as I picked her up. I started kissing her and climbed atop the bed. I lost my footing and ended up dropping her into the pile of pillows. She lay there giggling at what happened her hair spread out like an explosion. She opened her legs still laughing “Can your penis also fall in here now” she said pointing to her vagina. Her laughter was contagious and her comment genuinely funny in the moment.

“Let me give you something to laugh about” I said as I dragged her towards me and started tickling her.

“**Noooo staaaaph**” she yelled as she continued giggling.

I kissed her tummy and continued tickling her. A few moments later someone knocked on her door and I froze.

“Mary, are you okay?” A voice came from outside. It was Teresa.

I covered my mouth and Mary still uncontrollably laughing said, “Sorry! I’m just watching something.” She was barely able to keep a straight face.

“Ok, keep it down we have an early flight tomorrow,” Teresa replied.

“Good night sis”, Mary responded.

“Oh Shit”, I whispered.

Mary gave me a peck on my nose and pulled me over her as she fell back into bed. I positioned myself right over her with my hands holding me up. She held my face and kissed me. As we were kissing I started breaching her opening with the tip. Only insert the tip then pullout, I did that a few times to tease her. Once I knew I was ready for a full insertion I pulled back from the kiss.

I looked right into her emerald green eyes and whispered “I want to see you while you experience this.”

She placed her hand on my chest near my heart and with a look of caution in her eyes whispered “Be gentle.”

I started pushing my penis inside her. Like a bad bulb flickering hey eyes blinked rapidly, her muscles tensed up and her body arched backwards. She bit her lips and moaned softly. Once I was fully in I paused and pulled out at the same speed. Her moans louder this time.

She pulled my forehead close to hers, closed her eyes and whispered “I want this, I want you, *please give this to me*.”

Having gotten her approval I started thrusting, gently at first then increasing my pace with each thrust. As I thrusted I could tell her brain was overloaded. She grabbed my butt then my chest then her breasts. She arched backwards, curled forwards, pulled her hair, my hair, massaged her clit, spanked my butt all within a few moments. She was desperately trying to keep her eyes open and her moans contained. Finally she settled on squeezing my butt while biting into my forearms to control her moans.

After sometime I pulled out and flipped her over. She was now on all fours. Holding her waist I tried to enter her again. I missed and poked her anus instead. She jumped while audibly yelling out. “That’s a one way tunnel mister.”

I chuckled and entered her. As I entered she arched backwards and moaned. Holding her shoulders I proceeded to fuck her. I varied my pace and sometimes made circular motions, she seemed to enjoy those. Her face now planted into the pillow she continued moaning. “Spank me” I heard in a muffled voice. I obliged, “*aaah*” she moaned each time I slapped her butt.

Beads of sweat were rolling down my neck to my chest. I could see her sweating too. All the spanking and my crotch slamming against her butt caused her to have a red backside and the sweat was making it shine.

She pulled herself out of the pillow and turned to me. Her face pink and hair blown up like she had just been shocked by electricity. She pushed me down and climbed on top, sitting right on my cock.

“*My turn!*” she squealed giggling

She rocked back and forth with her hands gripping my chest as I fondled her luscious breasts. I tried sucking on them but her rocking kept pushing me back down. Her moans started growing louder, she arched backwards and rested her hands on my legs. She moved even more aggressively now. I was thrusting in sync with her and I could feel the explosion coming.

“Ma..Mary I’m going to cum, I’m close” I gasped.

“Inside me ple… aah come inside me” she moaned.

It felt like a giant valve being opened. I orgasmed and could feel all the fluids rushing from the base of shaft to the tip. My legs trembled and toes curled up, I couldn’t keep my eyes open as I emptied inside her.

“Oh Jesus, I feel it inside me, fuck fuck I’m close I don’t want to stop” she gasped

She was rocking my now overly sensitive penis even more aggressively. I couldn’t bear it and I bit down on my forearms and held my eyes shut.

“**Aah aaahh**, I’m almost there” she screamed.

A few moments later her legs snapped shut and she fell on her back, her whole body trembling. My penis now limp and sore just lay there. Both of us rested in the same position for several minutes. I got up and saw her curled up with a smile on her face.

She opened here eyes and started giggling. “He’s such a little wee wee. What happened? Little girl drain you out.” she said pointing at my limp penis.

“Do you want me to tickle you again?” I said in a serious tone. She giggled and hid her face under the pillow.

After cleaning up we spooned and talked a little but she fell asleep mid conversation. She had a peaceful look on her face. I wasn’t as tired and decided to check my phone.

I had two snapchats from Liz. On opening the first one there was a loud moaning sound, I rushed to mute my phone and checked if Mary got up. I slid away from her and checked the snap in more detail.

Liz recorded herself masturbating in a selfie view from the top. I could see her exposed breasts and they were as large as I had imagined them to be. She was biting her lip as she orgasmed. Her face was full of expressions hard to describe. It ended with her winking and sending a flying kiss to the camera. Looking at the clip got me fully erect again. Before my brain could process what happened it opened the second snap. It was a picture of the moment she orgasmed. Her eyes shut, muscles tightened and mouth open, screaming. There was text below the image. “*Thinking about you,* ***YOU*** *did this to me.*” I found myself involuntarily stroking myself. When I realized what I was doing I killed the app, tossed the phone to the other corner and moved back towards Mary. She felt me hug her and dug herself deeper into my hug.

My erection poked her in the butt. “Sorry shop is closed now, please come by later” she said sleepily.

I let out a nervous chuckle and kissed her forehead and tried to sleep.

Mary and I had a lot of fun that week. We made each other meals, we did chores, watched movies and had a lot of sex, *a lot*. I loved Mary but I couldn’t get the image of Liz orgasming out of my mind and that bothered me.

Source: reddit.com/r/eroticliterature/comments/euzw6u/the_christian_girlfriend_part_2_mf