Never written one of these before but just gonna send it.
This past New Years, I was visiting some friends from college that I hadn’t seen in a few years. We were in NYC (definitely not my favorite place to be during the holiday) staying in my friends tiny apartment. There were 4 of us, two guys and two girls. We had been friends for a long time, but none of us had ever done anything together (The other guy is gay, one girl is a no-sex-until-marriage person). That changed this weekend.
We had gone out earlier in the night, watched the ball drop from some bar and were headed back to my friends apartment. It was pretty late and none of us are night owls. We were crashing pretty hard. In the uber on the way back, one of the girls (call her Stacey) was coming in and out of sleepiness, and ended up falling asleep in my lap. I didn’t think much about it, but as that I was pretty lit and kinda horny, her head being down there definitely got me kinda hard. She noticed, but was nice enough (or too tired) and didn’t say anything.
When we got back to the apartment, we put on a movie and laid a bunch of blankets and pillows down on the floor. My guy friend (whose apartment it was) went to his bedroom and the other three of us were just gonna sleep on the floor. Luckily enough, it ended up where I was between the two girls.
Within 20 minutes, both girls were asleep and I was on the verge. I don’t know if it was the drunkenness or the horniness or whatever, but I decided I would spoon with Stacey to fall asleep. I wrapped my arm around her, pressed my waist against her ass and fell asleep.
Now Stacey is an athlete. She isn’t razor thin, definitely a little on the thicc side but it’s mostly leg muscle and her ass is TIGHT. I was having a hard time sleeping because she kept moving around, rubbing her ass against my dick and I was getting very aroused. It didn’t take long before I realized she was awake and doing it intentionally. She looked back over her shoulder and said “I was gonna ask if you like that, but I can already tell”. Right then, I knew we were going somewhere.
I started kissing her neck and ear from behind as she became more aggressive with her ass, rubbing it in rhythm up and down against me. She had been wearing a tight, typical NYE dress, and that slid up very easily, revealing a tiny black thong underneath. I let my hands wander around to the front, where I could tell how wet she was just with some light rubbing around her pussy. With one hand rubbing, the other I reached under and started playing with her tits. She started moaning softly, and quickly we had to keep it down, because our other friend was sleeping right next to us!
We were still in the spooning position, but she expertly got my pants unzipped and got my cock out and start jerking me off, slowly, as I played with her pussy through her panties. After a little while, she said exactly what we were both thinking: I needed to be inside her. So, trusting her when she said she was on BC, I slipped it inside her from behind and we started fucking. At first it was slow, but quickly got faster and faster. At one point, the girl next to us stirred, so we had to throw a blanket over us and pretend we were asleep, motionless with my cock still inside her tight, wet pussy.
Once it was clear the other girl was asleep, we got back to it. She rolled over on top and started riding me. I had to keep kissing her, or sticking my fingers in her mouth to keep her silent. She rode me for a while, and it was definitely a huge turn on having to keep quiet like that.
We finished the night with her on her back, fucking missionary. She let me cum all over her stomach and tits (I love watching a girls face as my cum lands on her). And then I got down and ate her and fingered her until she finished as well. That was the hardest part to stay silent, as she keep clenching her whole body, would scream into a pillow, as I did it. By the time she came, there was a huge wet spot on the floor where all of her juices mingled with our sweat.
We ended up having to get dressed and go back to sleep. In the morning, the other girl didn’t say anything, but she gave us a look that let us know that she knew EVERYTHING that had happened the night before.
I could’ve been misreading it, but I also think I saw a little twinkle that said “that was actually kinda hot- include me next time”. We went our separate ways later that day, but let’s just say I really look forward to our next friend reunion :)
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/etdmz7/my_secret_new_years_hookup_mf