I took a Mormons virginity [F]

Sooooo this is kind of an awkward story lol. I was pretty innocent in high school but after I graduated I fucked multiple boys from my class. I used to be good friends with these two Mormon brothers and I had a crush on the older brother for yearssss and he knew, but wasn’t allowed to date at that age because it went against his religion. So when we matched on tinder after we graduated, I was pretty surprised.

He took me out to a really nice Italian restaurant and then we went back to my place to watch a movie. One thing lead to another and soon enough I was riding his dick while he sat on my desk chair. He lasted a long time and honestly wore me out, changing positions multiple times and making my pussy sore. He finally came and after we just laid in bed cuddling and having pillow talk. He asked how it was for me and I said great and asked the same. He said “I think it was good” kinda in a questionable way and I was like uhhhh what do you mean. He then said “that was my first time, you didn’t know?”

Literally my face looked like the surprised pikachu meme for about 3 minutes straight. I was so taken aback because I knew Mormons aren’t supposed to have sex before marriage, but I figured he had already had sex before because of how smooth he was and how he fucked like he was very experienced. I felt a little bit guilty and wish he would’ve told me he was a virgin before we had sex. He was so so sweet but I didn’t want a boyfriend at that time and he was leaving the state for college. He got a little bit obsessed with me and I had to ghost him. I still feel bad about it and hope he doesn’t regret it.

(This is my own repost, I’ve posted this story in slutty confessions before)

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/ehan9b/i_took_a_mormons_virginity_f