I have only posted one experience on this sub before and it was well received so I thought I would try again. This took place a handful of years ago when Craigslist personals was a thing. I always had moderately good success when it was around, I miss it.
I was bouncing around CL looking for a casual hook-up and I saw a post that was looking for a guy to join this female poster at an orgy. She said it was an orgy with mostly BBWs (and I’m very fit) and it was her friend’s birthday and wanted a bunch of guys to fuck her at this party. I figured it was bullshit, as many CL posts were, but I answered it way. I figured it was worth a shot. I was right.
She replied an hour or so and asked more about me. She asked for a pic and I replied with one. She sent one of her and I was pleasantly surprised. She was tall, fit and around 35ish. I was instantly interested.
The weird part was she was Eastern European and had very poor English skills. I assumed she had someone write the post for her. It was a huge red flag to me but I had always wanted to go to an orgy and I really wanted to fuck her. So, I suspended my usual caution and moved forward. I asked to voice chat with her to verify and somehow we communicated. She said she had gotten tons of replies and I was the only one she wanted to go with. The only stipulation was that I had to fuck her friend too. She warned me that her friend was very fat. I agreed and she gave me the name of the hotel which was about a 1/2 hour drive from my home.
We planned to meet in the hotel parking lot. She also sent me a text with the “rules” of the orgy. $50 per couple (she wanted me to pay), no single guys, no drugs, no gay play for guys, condoms a must, had to out of the room by 2:00 am. All of that worked for me.
When I got there I half expected to get mugged and my car stolen. That she was almost an hour late make it seem even more likely. But I was horny and the lure of an orgy and fucking here made me extra stupid and and more so patient. And, just as I was starting the car to leave, she showed up. I was thrilled, scared, and shocked all at the same time. But she looked just as good as her picture. So, after briefly considering running, I thought “fuck it, gotta die sometime” and went for it. So glad I did.
When we walked into the room the group clearly knew her and greeted her. It was a suite type hotel room with 3 BRs with two beds in each. And because we were so late guys were fucking fat chicks all over the fucking place. And honestly I was turned on immediately.
She introduced me to a really cute BBW whose name I never got because of the broken English of my “date” but I didn’t care. She smiled at me and asked us both if we wanted to fuck. I was so down.
The three of us went over to the only open bed and they started to make out. I took off my clothes and they both gave me a blow job at the same time. It was long and amazing. I was so fucking hard and I was really close to finishing that I had to stop them. I wanted to fuck my “date”. Bad. But I also wanted to eat her pussy. She started licking the BBW while I went down on her. She tasted amazing. I didn’t want to stop. By every bed there was a bowl of rubbers and she put one on me with her mouth. She climbed on top of me while the BBW sat on my face and they make out while I fucked one and licked the other one. The BBW came multiple times one my face and my “date” once while I fucked hear. Feeling the both cum caused me to drain deep inside of her (in the condom actually). It was fucking amazing.
I then noticed in another bedroom a line of guys waiting to fuck someone. She was getting trained and then I realized it was the birthday girl. I took a closer look and honestly she was disgusting. I mean not an attractive woman. I then found out it was her 60th birthday. I immediately felt sick.
My date was already in another room fucking some other guy (she was the queen of this party) and I looked around for other options. Everyone seemed to know each other and I knew I couldn’t fuck the birthday girl, so, I quickly snuck out and left before anyone could catch me leaving. I ran to the car and drove away, got home, and crashed.
I woke up the next morning with shitty texts from my “date” pissed I had run out without fucking the birthday girl and even more pissed I have stiffed her on the $50. I honestly didn’t mean to do that. I asked if I could see her again or even go to another party but she was furious. I fucked that up. But, I did have one memorable night.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/eghoy7/my_only_orgy_mff