[MFF] Our First Threesome

My fiancé, now wife (I’ll call her Cheri), and I had discussed having a threesome many times during our time dating and being engaged. She had never been with a girl and while she never had an intense desire to be with a girl, it was something she thought she should experience. So we set upon our quest to find a unicorn. We opened up discreet profiles on MeetMe, Tinder, and made a few Craigslist ads. Roxie had no desire to spend any time messaging or sexting any potential women, so that task fell to me. It probably took three to four weeks until we found a woman who Cheri was interested in and who was willing to jump in bed with us.

We are both in our early twenties. I’m an average build guy, hairy chest, and I’ve a beard since I can remember. Cheri is a fiery redhead with curves for days and a cute face to match! We’d always had a pretty steady sex life and always very passionate.

I started messaging a girl who was very interested from the beginning. We exchange some pictures and talked about what we were all into. I had been talking to my coworkers about our quest and had been mulling over how to get over the initial awkwardness and get sexual. One coworker suggest a no pants rule, basically that as soon as the woman walked into our house she had to depants. When I made this suggestion to my fiance she thought it was silly and a little strange but admitted that it might be kind of fun.I mentioned this to the girl during one of our conversations and she loved the idea. We set a date and waited!

The day finally came around and my wife I went out for dinner and few drinks before she was set to arrive. After we got home we anxiously waited for the knock on our front door. We heard the knock and knew there so no going back. We invited her in and were immediately a little surprised that she didn’t quite look like her photos. We discussed after and determined that it wasn’t so much that the photos were inaccurate but that they were probably old and she had taken a little more time to put herself together for them. This woman, who we’ll call Sarah, was a thick girl with small breasts and wide hips. She had a surprisingly small ass for her wide hips but regardless she wasn’t ugly by any means. Alas, we were already this far in, might as well slide into home.

I made a joke about her still wearing pants and she immediately stripped them off and hopped on the couch. We chatted for a bit and got to know each other. She definitely wasn’t someone we would spend time with platonically but she was nice enough. She showed off her tattoos, as did we, and then her nipple piercings. Neither of us never seen nipple piercings in person before but immediately I knew I was very into them. She then demonstrated her twerking abilities, which honestly were pretty bad but it was entertaining to watch.

At this point I knew my next goal was to get those pierced nipples in my mouth. Sarah sat down between Cheri and I sliding her shirt over her head. We both latched onto a nipple and she started to moan and squirm. I then moved moved up and started kissing her. Ya’ know how after you’ve only kissed the same person for so long that kissing someone new feels fucking weird, well, that was most definitely the case! She wasn’t a bad kisser but I wasn’t enjoying it.

I jumped off the couch, slid her leggings off, and was greeted by a smooth, plump pussy. I love eating pussy, so I knew this was gonna be a blast! I dove in like a mad man and she jumped a little bit. When she jumped Cheri, who had just been taking in the scene, took that opportunity to get her first kiss and finish removing Sarah’s bra. I was to consumed with spreading her thighs and licking her pussy that I didn’t notice that Cheri had removed her shirt and bra and Sarah had begun sucking her nipples and groping her breasts. When I finally took a breath and looked up to meet Cheri’s gaze, Sarah had a breast in each hand and her lips latched onto a nipple. Cheri and I have always been able to communicate without saying anything and we both knew this something we’d be doing a lot.

I jumped back onto the couch and took off my clothes. Sarah slid off and grabbed my cock. I’m not huge, just under 7” and decent thickness. Sarah slowly jerked me off as she licked her lips and popped the head into her mouth. As I basked in the glow of having my dick in a new mouth, I grabbed Cheri and kissed her. We started to make out as Sarah began to deepthroat me. Normally I love having my cock down a woman’s throat but Sarah didn’t quite have the technique down and I felt her teeth a few to many times. I pulled her to her feet, got behind her, and started to kiss her neck and grab her breasts. Cheri got her first touch of Sarah’s already soaked pussy and slid a finger in. I could tell when she did it because Sarah threw her head back and started to kiss me. We stayed in that position for several minutes before I suggested we go into the bedroom. As we headed towards the bedroom, Cheri stripped off the rest of her clothes and I grabbed the condoms and the lube.

Sarah jumped onto the bed and spread her legs. She asked Cheri if she wanted to lick her pussy and she responded by bending over the edge of the bed and getting her first taste of another woman. I took this as my invitation to slide my cock into my fiance. I heard Cheri’s muffled moan and she continued to lick her first pussy.

All three of us stayed in that position for several minutes before I decided it was time for Sarah to taste Cheri pussy off my cock. I slide out of Cheri, moved around the bed, and offered my slippery cock to Sarah. She immediately snatch it up with her mouth. She turned her head sideways and I was at the perfect anlge to fucked her mouth. Cheri came up from Sarah’s pussy and began to kiss me while I manhandled her big tits. Cheri whispered into my ear, “do you want to fuck her?”.

I didn’t need to be told twice! I got down between Sarah’s legs, rolled a condom over my cock, and asked Sarah if she was ready. She nodded yes while Cheri played with her tits and I slide into a different pussy for the first time in almost three years.

This is the part of the story where things start to go down hill. Sarah was tight and had, what seemed to me, like a very shallow pussy. I fucked her for probably three to five minutes while I watch her and Cheri kiss and play with each other’s bodies. It felt like out of nowhere the urge to cum hit me like a freight train. I tried to pull out before I did but it was already to late. As soon as I withdrew, I filled up the condom.

At this point I had to make a choice between letting this be the end or soldiering on. I chose the latter, snapping off the condom and dove into my wife’s pussy. Eating pussy always gets me hard again and in no time I was erect. I started to fuck Cheri while Sarah watched and we all three took turns making out. After a few minutes, I pulled out and had Sarah get on all fours with her ass in the air. I rolled another condom in and slide back inside of her.

Cheri grabbed Sarah’s ass and spread it apart for me, all while kissing me and encouraging me to fuck her. It was about this time that I realized what would later be confirmed by my fiancé; she really enjoyed watching me fuck another woman.

I was about completely spent but wanted to give Cheri a couple more orgasms. I pushed her onto her back and after taking the condom off, slide into her. The sensation of going from one pussy to another, even with a condom on, is intense. We fucked like that for a bit, while taking turns kissing and fingering Sarah.

I had lost all steam at this point and decided it was best to faked an orgasm. Probably the worst acting ever but who cares. Cheri and I separated and noticed that Sarah was laying there masturbating. Then Sarah said one of the most awkward sentences I’ll ever hear, “I’m gonna stay here and rub one out.” We both got up and assumed she would wrap up shortly and join us in the living room. Nope! She stayed in our bed and masturbated for probably about ten minutes. She finally got up and got dressed. We made awkward conversation and vague plans to do it again. She finally left and Cheri and I just started laughing because of all the nervousness.

We learned several things from this experience:

1. Next time find a girl who was clearly interested in women because Cheri was a little disappointed Sarah didn’t do more with her, mainly eat her out.

2. Screen the next woman a bit better because we both thought Sarah was a little trashy. Don’t get me wrong, I like trashy but it wasn’t quite in the attractive way.

3. Cheri really enjoyed watch me have sex with another women! She has never been much for labels but even she admitted that it was probably as close to a fetish as she’ll ever admit she has.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/e4sc57/mff_our_first_threesome