Long time reader, but this is my first post. This story happened about five years ago, so the details are as accurate as they can be, ha! Details are a combination of what I remember and what each of the girls told me after the fact. A little background first, skip down for the NSFW part if that is what you are after.
After graduating college, before moving out of my parents’ house, I threw a Memorial Day party with a bunch of college friends including my girlfriend, Sam, and my ex-girlfriend, Hannah. Sam is average height for a girl, a little extra weight, red hair and freckles, small boobs, but a big ass. Sam and I at this point had been dating for about 6 months. Sexually, Sam has always been pretty vanilla, but loved sex and got a little crazier when she was drunk(who doesn’t? haha). Outside of the occasional drunk make out session, completely straight. Hannah is almost the complete opposite. Hannah is heavy set, pitch black hair, small ass, but massive boobs. Hannah and I had dated during Sophomore year for about 8 months. This was our first time hanging out in almost a year. Sexually, Hannah was extremely kinky, which I sadly found out about after we broke up. Think of a kink and she is probably into it. Little to nothing was off limits with her and she was very much bisexual.
So, the party was going everyone was having a good time and everyone was getting pretty drunk. I noticed Hannah had stepped outside, so I went out to make sure she was okay. We talked for a while on the side of the house, drunkenly I tried to make out with her. She stopped me and reminded me that I was dating Sam. We went back in the house and back to the party. When I came back in Sam was eying me up wondering what was going on out there. The party went on playing flip cup, etc. A little later on I went upstairs to get something out of my room and come out to find Hannah sitting on the floor in the hallway, looking a little sad. I sit down next to her and ask her what’s wrong. She doesn’t say much and we sit there for a little. Then out of no where she say’s “I hate how you do this to me.” To which I responded, “do what?” She reached her hand under her dress and into her pussy, pulled her hand out and put her fingers in my mouth. “I hate how wet you make me without actually doing anything.” I sucked her juices off her fingers and sat there in disbelief. Sadly, I heard a commotion going on downstairs, so I quickly got up to see what was going.
When I got downstairs, I found out that Sam was in the backroom upset thinking that I was upstairs fucking Hannah. I go in and try to calm her down, assuring her that we were not fucking upstairs. Everyone else is continuing to party, there is a knock on the door, and it is Hannah. Hannah came in to reassure Sam that nothing had happened. She was getting upset that she made Sam upset. Hannah suggested we go upstairs to talk away from the party and wanted to prove that nothing had happened. Sam agreed and we all headed upstairs to my room ignoring everyone else who had moved to the back porch. When we got to my room, Sam saw it looked exactly how we left it earlier that day and there was no smell of sex. She sat down on the bed and Hannah sat next to her, while I dropped down into a chair next to the bed.
NSFW Part:
Hannah told Sam she wanted to make it up to her for making her upset and thinking that we hooked up. Hannah put her hand on Sam’s bare kneed as she leaned in and kissed her deeply. Sam didn’t move away, instead leaned into the kiss and began passionately making out with Hannah. Hannah started to move her hand up Sam’s leg, under her dress. Sam reached a hand up, placing it on the back of Hannah’s head, seemingly ignoring the hand that is moving up her leg. Hannah backed away for a second, stood up and pulled Sam up with her. She reached down, grabbed the bottom of Sam’s dress, and pulled it up over her head exposing a lacy bra and black thong. Hannah leaned in, kissed Sam again, reached around her back, unclipped her bra and slid it off her arms. She took a step back and gently pushed Sam back onto the bed, climbed on the bed next to her and started to make out with her again. All the while, I sat in the chair, my cock rock hard as I watch my ex-girlfriend take charge with my current girlfriend. I started to rub my erection through my jeans.
Hannah reached her hand under Sam’s thong and started to aggressively rub her clit. Sam let out a loud moan into Hannah’s mouth. Sam ran her hands through Hannah’s hair as Hannah slipped two fingers deep inside of her wet pussy. Sam pulled away from the kiss and moaned out, oh my god, grabbing at the sheets of the bed. Hannah, finger fucked her even faster as Sam’s body tensed, and she let out one more loud moan as she hit her first orgasm of the night. Hannah, slowly slid her fingers out, licked her one finger clean and then put the other finger into Sam’s mouth. Not even knowing what was happening, Sam sucked on Hannah’s finger tasting her own juices. At this point, I had undone my belt, unbutton and unzipped my jeans and was full on playing with myself as I watched from the chair.
Hannah stood up, looked at me and smiled, and lifter her dress up over her head, exposing her massive tits without a bra and a small red thong. She again smiled at me, briefly touched my knee, before dropping to her knees between Sam’s legs and slid her thong to the floor. Sam, not expecting this, shot her head up looked down at Hannah then over at me. I smiled at her and gave her a nod as if to say let it happen. Before she could even smile back at me, she let out a moan and quickly fell back down to the bed. Hannah had started twirling her tongue on Sam’s clit, making her instantly go crazy. Sam took one hand and placed it on the back of Hannah’s head, her other hand grabbed a pillow to cover her mouth. Hannah welcomed the hand on her head and dove in deeper. Sam let out loud moans that the pillow couldn’t even muffle. Sliding a finger deep inside her, Hannah began fingering her as her tongue continued to attack Sam’s clit. “Oh my God I’m cumming,” Sam screamed into the pillow. Hannah didn’t slow down, rather, she slid a finger into Sam’s tight ass and fingered her pussy and ass at the same time. She lifted her head for a minute to catch her breath, looked me up and down smiling when she saw my cock in my hand, then returned to Sam’s pussy. Sam, barely able to control herself, had put the sheets in her mouth and was digging her nails into Hannah’s shoulders. She cried out as she hit her absolutely climax. Hannah very slowly removed her fingers, climbed up next to Sam and kissed her deeply.
At this point I was ready for my turn. Still not sure on how Sam felt about me doing anything with Hannah, I focused on Sam. I took the rest of my clothes off and laid on the other side of Sam from Hannah. I started to make out with her while I ran my hands up and down her body, groping her breasts and pinching her nipples. She reached over and slowly started to move her hand up and down my erection. When I moved my hand down her stomach to her pussy, she stopped me and simply said “I want you to fuck me.” Hannah took this are her cue to give us a little space, getting up from the bed, she went and knelt just to the side of the bed. I turned Sam to fully be on the bed and climbed on top of her as I continued to kiss her. I tried to tease her a little by sliding my cock up and down against her clit, she wanted none of this and wanted me to fuck her. She reached down and guided me into her warm wet pussy. I took the hint and started to quickly pound her, pinning her hands above her head. Still extremely sensitive from her play with Hannah, I knew it won’t take her long to cum, I knew it wouldn’t take me long either after playing with myself for a while. She started to moan out loudly and called out, “fuck me from behind.” I didn’t hesitate, slid out of her and flipped her over, spread her legs and guide myself back deep inside of her. With my first hard thrust she moans out, “Oh my god.” I take a quick look over to see Hannah, still kneeling completely naked, slowly playing with herself. I smiled and focused back on Sam. I give Sam a few hard spanks as I pound her harder and harder from behind. She moans out and bites down on the sheets. I hear a moan out from Hannah as well, which excites me even more. I grab her hips and pull her into me with every thrust. Sam, now unable to muffle her moans, moaned out loudly and I felt her body starting to tense. Her body started to shake and I knew she was cumming, I was right behind her. I moaned out loudly as I unloaded a massive load of cum deep inside of her.
I slid out of Sam and get up to clean myself up a little. She slumped down on the bed, completely exhausted. As I came back from getting cleaned up, Sam had sat up on the side of the bed, her facing glowing. Hannah grabbed my leather belt from my jeans and handed it to Sam. “Please spank me with this,” she asked. Sam look at me a little confused but stood up and Hannah bent down over the bed. I sat back down in the chair trying to recoup myself. Sam gave Hannah two soft hits with the belt to her ass. “Harder, please,” she begged. Sam smacked Hannah’s ass a few more times harder each time. “Oh my god yes, harder please,” she called out. Sam looked back at me, still a little confused by all of this, and gave Hannah three hard smacks with the belt. “Oh my god thank you,” she said and stood up from the bed, “one more time for you.”
Hannah sat Sam back down on the bed, put her back up against the wall, and sat down next to her. She began kissing her and wasted no timing moving her hand between her legs. Sam was still soaking wet from all the action earlier. Hannah leaned forward a little and slipped two fingers deep inside of her. She began sliding her fingers in and out slowly as Sam started to quiet moan. Hannah smiled over at me right before she looked back at Sam and slid a finger deep into her ass. Sam grabbed at Hannah’s leg with one hand and the sheets with her other hand as she closed her eyes. Sam moved her one hand between Hannah’s legs and started to rub her clit. Hannah began to moan softly but stayed focused on Sam. She turned her body for a slightly better angle and started to rapidly move her fingers in and out. Sam tried her best to keep rubbing Hannah’s clit, but she couldn’t focus and could barely reach her. Hannah didn’t seem to mind and went even harder at Sam. Sam couldn’t handle it anymore and cried out that she was about to cum. When Hannah heard this, she slipped a second finger into Sam’s ass and fingered her as fast as she could. Sam let loose and hit a massive orgasm cumming all over Hannah’s fingers. Hannah pulled her fingers out, licked the two from Sam’s pussy clean, kissed Sam one more time and stood up. She threw her dress on, left her thong on the floor, and said we should probably get back to the party before walking out of the room.
Sam and I looked at each other and smiled. We didn’t say much to each other and got up and got dressed. We kissed each other and headed back down to the party.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/e21jlp/mff_post_college_semi_threesome_long
Wow! Living the dream! How did everything work out afterwards with the three of y’all?