I think I (M/26) may have turned my neighbor (F/19) into a good girl [MF]

Some context first: I live in a small-ish house with 2 apartments. Used to live downstairs alone for the longest time. For financial reasons decided it’s best to rent out the upstairs apartment. Earlier this year I rented it out to this girl called Emma. At the time I was still with my now ex-girlfriend. I didn’t have much to do with Emma, except for the occasional neighborly small talk when you randomly stumble upon each other. Emma is 19, just started going to university and is very introverted. She’s not a supermodel, but she’s cute. She’s skinny I’d say, she’s tiny, has brown, shoulder length hair, the kind of tits you can perfectly fit into one hand and a really great ass in my opinion.

I’ve never much noticed she’s there, she’s always been kinda invisible to me. A while ago I broke up with my ex-girlfriend. Emma has been surprisingly chatty since and we’ve been talking a lot. One Saturday afternoon we’ve been texting all day and eventually we started sexting. I thought “fuck it” and just went upstairs, wanting to see what happens. We hooked up and got to talk afterwards, turned out she has had a crush on me since forever. She said she could hear me and my ex have sex all the time and it would always make her horny, it was super frustrating for her because she doesn’t have anyone. This turned into a regular thing and we’ve hooked up a lot since then.

Hooking up with her was a bit weird at first. She has really low self esteem and is very shy and barely had any sexual experience yet. Most of what she knows she knows from porn.

I could tell quickly that this girl had submissive tendencies, cuz she’d always let me take the lead and let me do what I want. At first I thought it was just because I was experienced and she wasn’t, but I’d quickly find out she likes being told what to do and letting me be in charge. Maybe it’s got something to do with the fact that she watches hardcore porn all day, i don’t know.

She’s always very obedient and she’d never make me feel like what I’m doing is uncomfortable for her. Like I’d slowly introduce more and more stuff everytime we hooked up and she always liked it and went along with it. Some examples: The first times she went down on me I’d just let her do her thing (which for someone who’s never really done it before she was good, but there was lots of room for improvement, especially since I like it rough and messy). I’d start grabbing her head by the hair, controlling the pace, suggesting she try deep throating or licking my balls and just being messy in general, told her she shouldn’t be afraid to be messy and to use spit. That kinda stuff. She’s a quick learner and she’s pretty good at it now. I’d introduce her to dirty talking, slap her ass sometimes or pull her hair during sex and just be a little bit rough and possessive, nothing really crazy yet.

I’d always tease her asshole during doggy and earlier last week she casually mentioned it and said she likes how it feels when I play with her asshole (either with my thumb or my tongue). So I suggested we try anal. She had concerns at first because I’m slightly above abverage in size, but eventually she agreed. I’ve been slow and gentle, we used lube and it was fine. She said it felt weird at first and it kinda hurt, but she got really into it and really liked it towards the end.

______________________

Now, what happened last Friday: I don’t wanna talk much about my ex, but last week I found out she killed herself, so I’m still kind of fucked up in the head because of it. But what you gotta know about my ex is, is that she’s introduced me to lots of kinky shit. Now she had in the most literal sense of the word daddy issues, so she was very submissive and into CNC/rape play and all that stuff. It was a challenge for me at first because I’ve never had this kinky sex before, but I’ve started to get really into it and enjoy it and accept it for what it was.

I was sitting on the couch that Friday, watching TV like a zombie. Emma didn’t even know about what happened to my ex yet, I hadn’t told anyone. I heard her come home from work and a little while later she just came downstairs, looking to hook up. I heard her talk about all kinds of things but I wasn’t really listening, my mind was occupied with other things. She’d start trying to get me hard by touching my dick through my sweat pants and I was telling her “I’m not really in the mood right now”. She’s like “oh come on, I have like another hour left before I have to start getting ready to go out”. She just proceeds to pull out my dick and starts going down on me. She said “maybe this’ll make you feel better”. I just let her do it but I wasn’t really into it. She’d tease me and say dirty things, trying to get me to fuck her. None of them would really get my attention.

Suddenly she says: “come on, please fuck me. I need you inside me, daddy”. “Daddy”. She’s never said that before. My ex girlfriend did all the time, but Emma has never said it before. I kind of snapped, like someone lit a fire under my ass. I got kinda angry and had to think about my ex. I said “What did you just call me?”. And she kind of giggles and says “You didn’t like that?”. I said “oh I do, I’m just not sure you can handle me being your daddy.”. She starts giggling, laughing almost. She’s never been like this before, I felt sort of provoked. She said “oh I can handle it. show me what you got tough guy”. I grabbed her by the throat, pulled her towards me, close to my face. I said “Are you sure?”, she replies “Yes, daddy”.

I stood up, ripped off her clothes and bent her over the couch, both of us standing. I’d pound her from behind with full force, choking her and spanking her ass really hard every now and then. I said “you like getting pounded like that?”. She said “fuck yes”. I pulled her head back by the hair and slapped her face a little. I said “yes what?”. She said “yes, daddy. please fuck me harder daddy”. This continued for a while, all the while her begging for me to go harder.

I threw her (carefully) on the floor, she was lying flat on the floor, face down. I put both her hands behind her back, held them both down with 1 hand and started fucking her again. “You like getting fucked on the floor like that?”. “I love it daddy”. Then, I pulled out, spread her cheeks and spit on her asshole. I started pressing the tip of my dick against it. She started wiggling. I said “What? Not so tough anymore?”. She said “please not my ass daddy”. I said “why not?”. She said “it’s too big and i’m not ready”. I said “oh you want me to lube it up first?”. She said “please daddy”. I said “open your mouth”. I stuck a bunch of fingers down her throat until she almost had to puke. I got my hand really wet. I told her “spit in my hand”. I got a good chunk of spit and I rubbed it all over her asshole. I pressed my dick against the asshole again and said “are you gonna be a good girl for daddy and take it without whining?”. She said “yes daddy”. I’ve been somewhat gentle at first but I’ve been going pretty hard at it after a little while. I could tell it was somewhat painful for her but she’s a trooper. I could tell it was a mix of pain and pleasure for her. Her still calling me daddy while fucking her ass roughly was quite the sensation for me too. I wasn’t gonna last much longer and told her “I’m gonna cum soon, are you ready for your reward?”. She said “yes daddy, just please don’t cum inside me”. I had other intentions anyway. She was still lying flat on the floor. I pressed her head down on the floor to the side, me kneeling next to her and jerking off until I was ready. I made her beg for it. “Please cum for me daddy”, is what she said. I came all over her face. I stood up and got dressed again and just admired the sight of her lying on the floor like that covered in my cum, it was so unbelievably hot. She hasn’t said a word. I just went to the bathroom to clean up. Eventually she joined me in the bathroom. Still no words exchanged. She took a quick shower, while I was sitting on the couch again watching TV. She came out, got dressed, joined me on the couch, cuddled up next to me. I said “you okay? I hope it wasn’t too much”. She said “no it was fine, thank you. just a bit unexpected and intense towards the end, but I think I liked it”. She didn’t go out with her friends anymore that night. I told her what happened to my ex and she didn’t wanna leave me alone and we’ve been ordering food and watching TV/movies all night. It’s only been a few days but what happened on Friday completely changed things, it’s like I’ve broken her, like she discovered her ultimate kink. Safe to say the sex has been amazing since then.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/dp03ln/i_think_i_m26_may_have_turned_my_neighbor_f19