Crazy, Weird Threesome-ish in College [MFF]

Okay so, this story is from college. I (M, 20 at the time)) was an above average sort of guy, but not part of like the “cool bunch” or anything, but I was friends with most of them and did join in for their parties and plans once in a while.

Through some college project type stuff, I became really good friends with one of the “hot” chicks in our class, Emily. She was curvy, with dirty blonde hair and total ‘rich girl’ vibes. She used to have multitude of boyfriends / hook ups, she was really fun and cool with a healthy dose of sluttiness and everything. We just developed a super fun, close and totally platonic friendship out of the blues. Complete buddy types. She was extremely out of my league and too high maintenance for me. I had my own group of friends, had a few girlfriends (over the couple of years) and I was having fun, otherwise. 

We got so close for an year or so, we used to sleep over at each other’s place, do college stuff together, have meals together and party quite often. Our whole college was confused what was happening. People (including professors) had actual cash bets on 2 extreme scenarios – either I was friendzoned to hell or I was secretly screwing her and the whole platonic thing was just a facade! It was so funny but both of us didn’t care and kept giving mixed signals to everybody to confuse then even more.

She used to keep trying to introduce me to her “hot” friends or she used to be my ‘wingman’ when we went to bars or parties. It was fun. One day she brought her friend (Mia, 22 – 2 years senior from another college in our campus), who had just had a really bad break up. Emily wanted to cheer her up and she asked me to join them for pub-hopping to make her “forget” and in Emily’s words, ‘hang out with someone who’s actually a good guy, for once’. I was like yeah cool, why not.

We went to a bar, started drinking, and as soon as the first drink hit Mia, she started flirting with me. She was wearing a low cut dark green t-shirt showing off her beautiful soft cleavage and tight jeans. She was about 5’4″, quite pretty, blue eyes and brown hair. She l kept staring at me and kept touching my arm, thigh, hair and face while talking to me. Emily, who probably was expecting this, suddenly said she had to go to the loo, and as soon as she left, Mia turned to me, and in a very typical, almost movie like, “drunk bimbo” fashion, said, ‘I like you!’, touching my cheek. Well, it’s hard to resist when someone so pretty behaves so into you. I said, ‘You’re really nice, I like you too.’ She put her arms around me and kissed me. I was surprised, but elated. We kissed for a while, and it was so good! It wasn’t drunken, horny kissing, but surprisingly affectionate.

We suddenly heard a loud, ‘ahem’ and we opened our eyes, to see Emily staring at us, with her hands on her waist trying to act all shocked like, “What are you guys doing???” But she gave me naughty, “Yes!! I knew you guys would hit it off” look. Mia, kept her arms around me and was like, “He’s mine now. You don’t get to tell me what to do.” And went back to kissing me. I mean, that’s certainly a self esteem boost!

All 3 of us continued drinking and laughing, with me and Mia making out once in a while. We went to Emily’s friend’s place (Andy. She had a lot of such friends), who apparently always had drinks and weed and loved having people over. We went over, drank a bit more and smoked up a little. It started getting quite late, we set up beds on the floor for us in the same room. Me and Mia, just ended up on the same bed and started making out almost violently!

Emily announced to Andy, ‘I want ice cream’ and took him out of the apartment, which was good, as me and Mia just continued as if it was our last day on earth. And probably would have continued, even if they didn’t leave. It was so hot. We were grinding, kissing and licking and just all over each other’s body, tugging on each other’s clothes. We were still dressed but we were dry humping like crazy and she was getting on top of me and dry-riding (is it what that’s called?). She started to remove my shirt but, I started getting a bit conscious. She was too drunk, too high and too fresh from her break up. I knew sex would be crazy hot, but I just wasn’t comfortable. I said to her, I really don’t think we should go any further, and told her why. She slowed down and said, you know what, you’re right.

We sat up and just went back to chatting and making out. Andy and Emily came back soon , Emily saw us and probably understood I didn’t go through with it and just gave a knowing smile subtly shaking her head and rolling her eyes, teasing me.

Me and Mia, met up a couple of times for coffee that week.

Few days later Emily, Mia and I were hanging out at their friend’s place (Carla). Again drinking and chilling. Mia and me were getting naughty and handsy. Carla had to go out for an hour, so she left. (Carla too was one of the “hot” one’s, but was really genuine, friendly and one of the nicest girls I knew. She had a stable long running relationship as well, apparently.)

After a while, suddenly Emily and Mia started getting a bit flirty. Mia, still in my arms, said to me, ‘You know, me and Emily have been having some fun recently’! My eyes widened and I was like, ‘Okay!! Go on! ‘. 

Emily was like, ‘Yeah, we used to have some fun before as well, but after her break up, we cranked it up a notch! And Carla is in on it too, why do you think we hang out here so much!’

I was like ‘It’s not like I didn’t expect it, but it’s definitely amazing! I like it!’ I had no idea whether they were just teasing, but it seemed very believable. Emily used to tell me she’s experimented with a few girls before and kissed girls at parties and stuff.

Mia let go of me, went over to Emily, downed a couple of vodka shots, and said, ‘You know, earlier we used to just kiss and playfully touch each other, but now we’re really into it.’ I was getting turned on and weirded out at the same time. All I could do was laugh in response. Mia started kissing Emily and Emily just dove right in. I was just sitting there with my mouth wide open staring at them. I mean however cliche it may be, but watching 2 hot girls making out is one of the hottest sights I’ve seen in my life. Mia looked at me, and then put her hand inside Emily’s shirt. I blurted out, ‘Uh-oh!’

Mia, really sluttily bit Emily’s lip as she pulled away and came and sat next to me and started kissing me hard. I gasped and went all in, tongue and all. Mia, felt up my hard junk, looked over at Emily and called her over. Emily paused for a bit, but then, playfully smiled, threw her hands in the air and said ‘what the hell!’ and came and sat next to Mia. They kissed, Emily started playing with Mia’s boobs. Mia, started stroking me over my pants. I wasn’t sure what to feel, but I got so horny I started groping Mia’s ass and putting my hand inside her pajamas. Mia let out a gasp and started kissing me again and took off her top! I got her bra off and sucked her B-cup boobs and slightly puffy nipples as Mia then started kissing Emily again.

Mia suddenly tried to pull off Emily’s top. Emily, paused, but then just let her! My brain went blank and I just stared at her huge boobs popping out of her shirt, barely contained in her bra. I had always noticed Emily had amazing boobs and appreciated them, but never really had given more thought than that or ever thought I’d see them or anything. Emily noticed that, put on a ridiculously naughty smile, and said to me, “As if you’ve never fantasized about them”. 

I looked away and let out the most uncomfortable laugh in the world. Mia was thoroughly enjoying this, and suddenly pulled down my lose sweat pants down and I was sitting there with my cock pointing to the moon and balls hanging. 

I was frozen now. Mia started stroking my junk with 1 hand and playing with Emily’s boobs over her bra with the other. Alternating between kissing me and Emily.

Mia then got rid of her pants and Emily started touching Mia’s crotch. Mia moaning now, while still stroking my cock. 

Mia looked at Emily, and said in a raspy whisper, ‘now you do it’ looking at my cock. Mia was massively getting off the whole thing. Emily looked at me, raised her eyebrows playfully, got up, came over to my side, smiled extremely teasingly and playfully, then sat next to me. She kissed me lightly on the lips, and then raised her eyebrows and said, ‘prepare yourself’ almost sarcastically and held my junk in a death grip! Not moving or stroking it. She made a fake horny ‘oh my god’ face with her mouth wide open. I very feebly tried to oppose, but she put finger on my lips and said, ‘Don’t worry, darling’, again in a very sarcastic teasing ‘porn’ style voice. I slowly started realizing, she was just teasing, being naughty and going along for fun. More to indulge Mia than actually being into it. I was still rather shocked from Emily holding my junk. I was uncomfortable but really turned on as well.

Mia was touching and playing with her clit aggressively looking at us and kept saying, ‘Common, do it!’. Emily let go of my junk and then took Mia’s face and pushed it into my face. Me and Mia kissed. 

Emily turned to Mia, and said really sarcastically, ‘You know, me and him have always wanted each other’. Mia probably didn’t get the sarcasm, was really feeling the vodka shots now, and let out a moan, and whispered, ‘I knew it!’ and went for Emily’s crotch with one hand and started aggressively giving me a handjob with the other.

Suddenly, Carla came in, made the funniest confused, “what the fuck is going on” face, turning away from us and went out of the door and exclaimed loudly, ‘Why are you defiling him!?! Poor thing!’, and started laughing. Emily said raunchily, ‘Oh you know what’s happening, I know you want to join in too!’.

Mia said a bit drunkenly, ‘Come here baby’. Carla came in again and said biting her lip jokingly, ‘You know I’ve been thinking about this for so long!’. Mia moaned a little hearing that. Carla gave Emily a ‘okay, what’s up with her?!’ look, made a slutty face, pulled up her shirt, flashed her bra, said, ‘here you go’ and left!!

Emily very lightly kissed me again, winked and said to Mia that she’d be back from the loo.

Mia was pretty out of control now, she said ‘no’ aggressively and tried pulling Emily back. But Emily got up, went out and closed the door as she left. Mia looked at me, grunted and suddenly slid down, and started sucking me off like crazy. I was crazy turned on now, I held her head pushing her down with each stroke and groped her face, boobs and back. Mia then moved up and got on top of me and started riding my raw cock hard. It was crazy and definitely not something I normally would have done, but hey, this wasn’t a normal night by any means! I was pretty much loosing my mind.

I took charge (probably first time in this whole scenario) then threw her on her back, held her down, sucked her boobs and then went down. Licking, sucking and fingering. Mia was moaning like crazy. She almost shook the whole building as she orgasmed. I moved up, entered her, and pounded quite hard. After a while, I gasped out, ‘I’m close’. She pushed me up, slid down under me and took my cock deep in her mouth, me on all fours, and she on her back!

She sucked my balls, licked my dick and started sucking again. I started to fuck her mouth as she smashed her clit. And then I came, I gave no warning, she took the first burst it in her mouth and the jerked the rest of it on her face and boobs and moaned as she came again.

We went off to sleep, Emily and Carla slept in the other room. In the morning, Mia was still passed out. I woke up, and went outside.

Emily was there, sitting on the couch having coffee. She had the biggest teasing smile on her face when she saw me, turned her head very slowly, extremely dramatically, and sarcastically said, ‘Good morning darling!’ I got so awkward, I looked away and gave out an embarrassed laugh. She started laughing and patted on the couch signalling me to come sit right next to her. I went and sat on another chair, and mumbled, ‘What the fuck was happening last night’?

She laughed out loud, and said, ‘My love, don’t act like it’s a big deal. We all know you’ve always wanted that!’

I said, ‘Shut the fuck up!’ Getting extremely embarrassed.

She then said something like, ‘It’s okay, it was just a bit of fun. It’s not a huge surprise but Mia turned out to be much more of a freak than I’d expected. I was just teasing initially, but then found it so funny that I had to go along. I was having so much fun seeing Mia go off like that! It seemed like it was Mia’s fantasy, to have a threesome and make us fuck each other or something.

‘And I knew you wouldn’t really do anything to me. It’s not like you haven’t seen me in a bikini before. And you have had enough chances on our night outs, but you’ve never tried anything on me, so I was confident you wouldn’t even now, so I just played along with Mia’s game. And don’t fucking act like it’s a big deal. I know it went kinda extreme but it was really funny.

‘Anyway, I got Mia so fired up, I know she banged your fucking brains out! You’re welcome! And yeah, dickhead, I’ll kick your fucking ass if you decide to go all awkward and weird with me after this.”

Well I was awkward for a few days after that. And like she promised, she pretty much kicked my ass, as well. But (I never would have believed it) but we literally went back to being really good friends not too long after. She would never leave a chance to tease me about it, though.

Me and Mia stopped seeing each other soon, I mean, it was really not going to work anyway. I was her rebound. It was fucking crazy but I had a hell of a time!

Me and Emily are still really good friends even today, after so many years. Though we live very far from each other, we do talk once in a while. She’s still as crazy, fun and awesome as ever. I have a hard time believing now, it really happened all those years back…

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/cw5hfj/crazy_weird_threesomeish_in_college_mff