The Gangbang of Catan: The Carnal Quartet (Part 3.1) [Group]

This is part 3.1 of my Gangbang of Catan story. To start at the beginning, check out [part 1](https://old.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/cnf4vh/the_gangbang_of_catan_prelude_to_debauchery_group/) and then give [part 2](https://old.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/cnlydk/the_gangbang_of_catan_nocturne_of_naughtiness/) a chance. When you finish this, feel free to read [part 3.2](https://old.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/crnv03/the_gangbang_of_catan_the_carnal_quartet_part_32/?). Since this is so long and I know that’s not everyone’s thing, I’ll try to post a TLDR version in a couple days.

The next two weeks seemed to rush by between homework, studying, intramurals, and just random life stuff. I barely saw Tim, Ryan, or Tiffany during that time, but the little I did see them, and in any messages we had back and forth things didn’t really seem awkward. I had been a little concerned they would be; I had never cum on someone with two of my best friends before. I hadn’t even ever masturbated in front of someone before, so there was plenty of room for awkwardness, but it seemed like somehow we were all just going to be pretty chill about everything and see where it took us.

When that Saturday finally arrived, you could feel the charge in the air. Tim’s roommate was staying for the weekend, so we moved to Ryan’s apartment for this game. Tiffany showed up wearing a tight fitting, open-backed dress that only went down to about mid thigh and heels, which was very out of character. I don’t remember the joke now or who said it, but somehow her heels were referred to as “victory boots” which is a weird phrase that has stuck in our lexicon and other members of our friend group now use without fully understanding its origin.

We were pretty blown away by Tiffany’s outfit – she was dressed more like she was going to a frat party than just coming to play games with her friends. We were used to seeing her in t shirts and sweat pants… So this was very different. And she really pulled it off, although maybe there’s something I preferred about the sweatpants.

As she mentioned at the end of the last game, she had some additional rule changes she wanted to make. As we gathered around the table she laid them out for us:

1. We would double the number of clothing removal tiles to 2, and they couldn’t take the place of the same resource (otherwise the actual game might get too hard.)
2. Any time anyone rolled doubles, they got to pick one person to kiss them for at least the number of seconds as the number rolled.
3. Any time a 7 was rolled, any player with more than 7 cards (in addition to discarding half) must complete an action/dare to be voted on by the other 3 players – if the 3 players can’t decide with a 2 vote majority in 30 seconds, no action is required.
4. We have to keep playing until the game is finished. If it’s your turn, you have 5 minutes to make your move or you forfeit all benefits the game provides. (we took this to mean no more seeing boobies, etc.) 
5. The winner earns one favor from the other 3 players that must be redeemed at a future date. 

Her rules were relatively simple to add in, even though there were 5 of them. We figured we could pretty easily manage them. I was incredibly excited because even though last time was amazing, this time immediately held the promise of more since she had included kissing in her rules. We had all cum when we played before, but none of us had even touched each other. Even if it was only a kiss, touching was pretty much guaranteed at some point. 

I did feel like I needed some clarification on a couple points. With two clothing removal tiles, the chance of people getting completely naked was also pretty high. What happens after people are naked? We’re not allowed to quit like last time (rule 4) so did the clothing removal cards just become useless? 

We all decided that once everyone was completely naked, the clothing removal cards could be used (still 3 at a time) to get someone to complete a dare, similar to rule 3. The catch was that if there were still people wearing clothes, the clothing removal cards had to be used on them, even if someone else was completely naked. (This meant that if we got Tiffany naked, but we were still wearing clothes, we would have to use the clothing removal cards on ourselves before we could start using it for dares.) 

My other question was about the dares themselves – like, what was off limits? It would kind of be a killjoy to constantly be negotiating the dares trying to find something someone was willing to do. And none of us wanted to be responsible for guilting someone into something they weren’t really consenting to. 

Ultimately we decided the only thing off the table is for any of the guys do something with another guy. Tiffany had suggested we all get STD tests after our last encounter in preparation for tonight, and she was on birth control, so we didn’t even have to worry about condoms. The fact that Tiffany said she had no limits really set the horny butterflies in my stomach into a tizzy. (Now with much more awareness of the wide range of kinks and interests out there, I’m sure Tiffany would have had plenty of limits. But for our purposes, being relatively inexperienced and vanilla college students in the late aughts, no limits was adequate. None of us even thought to establish a safe word.) The one corollary that Tiffany added to the no limits rule was “don’t be a dick.” Basically, there’s a natural sort of progression to things. Don’t get overly enthusiastic and skip to the really dirty stuff early in the game. 

Game on. The board has a solid layout. A pasture and a wheat field have been replaced by clothing removal tiles, with a 4 and a 9, respectively. I really wanted to ask if we could put a 6 or an 8 on one of them, but I thought that might seem too eager. 

Tiffany won the roll and places first, she snagged the corner on the 9 clothing removal tile that also bordered a 6 forest. Ryan and then Tim join her around that clothing removal tile. For my turn I place on an intersection that had two ore with high probability and a forest with a moderate number. It was close to the 2:1 ore port, so I figured it would be a pretty good strategy. I immediately got to place again thanks to the snake style of the initial placements and I claimed a spot on the other clothing removal tile with brick and the final ore tile. 

Placement continued and the game started. Only Tim and myself had started the game with a clothing removal card, so there was no easy trade that could be made. We needed to wait until one was rolled. It took a round or two before one came up. Tiffany (and maybe Ryan, I don’t remember) had already built a road. 

It was a 9 that turned up first, on Ryan’s roll. Tim, Ryan, and Tiffany all collected their clothing removal cards. Ryan offered Tim his card, since Tim already had 2, in exchange for brick (which he really needed) but Tim didn’t want to give it up. He tried to convince Ryan to trade him wood for the two cards. “I’ll take that trade,” Tiffany said. We all laughed. For a second I thought Tim was going to do it, until I reminded them it was Ryan’s turn and they couldn’t trade amongst themselves. Ultimately Tim and Ryan couldn’t come to a deal. 

It was interesting how much people were prioritizing the actual game play this time. The last game we were all colluding to get Tiffany naked as efficiently as possible, but now it seemed like the prospect of winning that favor-to-be-named-later had effectively dissolved our masculine bloc. I wondered if Tiffany had planned that when making her rules. 

I didn’t want to fall for her plan, if that was indeed the case. Yes, it would be ideal to win and get those favors, but I could get favors/actions tonight from Tiffany if I played my cards right, and that was all that really mattered. With it now being Tim’s turn, I readily traded him my clothing removal card and excitedly watched as he played his three.

Either Tiffany forgot the first rule of strip games or she’s a better actor than we knew. She suddenly realized her sexy dress was a real liability, since she was only wearing one outer layer instead of two. She asked us if she could just roll it down to the waist, as if it were a shirt, but we didn’t agree. Soon we were rewarded with her reaching up and unfastening something behind her neck, which let the front of the dress fall forward. She was wearing some sort of mystical bra that didn’t have a strap around her back or shoulders and seemed to float cupping her breasts by either dark magic or magnetism or something. She peeled the dress down and her smooth, ample hips were soon shimmying the dress over them before it fell to the floor. Her bra was skin colored, but she was wearing red panties. They were a red, lacy, boy short type that fit very tightly against her skin. The color contrast made it very clear that there was a slight wet spot already in her crotch. The blood had already been flooding into my cock seeing her beautiful body, but seeing how turned on she was already caused it to give an extra twitch.

She sat back down and smiled at us, barely blushing. I know we were all sitting, staring, open-mouthed like a bunch of cavemen finally seeing fire. We’d seen her completely naked and masturbating herself to orgasm while covered in our cum just two weeks ago, but that did nothing to curb our enthusiasm for seeing her body again.

I had the luck of rolling the first set of doubles of the game. I rolled an eight, made of two fours. I grinned. This was it. I was going to get to kiss her. I pointed at her (in the background I heard Ryan make some snarky remark along the lines of how surprised he was I selected Tiffany. I think he was jealous.) Tiffany and I both stood and it was like our bodies glided together effortlessly. I thought it might be awkward or we might be hesitant, but her arms wound around my shoulders, her breasts pressed against me, and she smiled softly as our lips met and opened. Our tongues lightly emerged and softly flitted over each other. My hand slid down toward her ass of its own accord. It seemed like only a moment before Tim was yelling at us that the eight seconds was up and to break it up. Before she pulled all the way away, I felt Tiffany slightly grind herself against my boner. We went back to our seats, wiping our lips. 

The emergence of her body seemed to restore our teamwork. Over the next few turns Tiffany managed to collect enough cards to get our shirts off, but we colluded and got her bra off. She seriously had such delectable breasts. Like delicious cupcakes topped with a small candle and it was my birthday. It seems like a weird description now, but that’s literally what I thought at the time. If you can imagine sexy cupcake boobs, you’re imagining it correctly. If you’re imagining boobs that look weird, ignore that description and go back to your previously scheduled fantasizing. Somewhere in this time frame Tim also got to kiss Tiffany (I think for six seconds.) I thought I might feel a little jealous, but ultimately it was just hot seeing them go at each other. 

Tiffany rolled a 12 and, since she had already kissed Tim and me, she selected Ryan. She walked up to him before he could get out of his chair and straddled him. The view of her heart-shaped ass with her legs spread out so wide was amazing. Her red panties clung so tightly to her cheeks. I know Tim was imagining pulling them off as much as I was. 

At this point, Tim and Ryan got into a bit of a race for a settlement location that distracted them from focusing on the sexier aspects of the game. I decided to try to push towards my ore port. Tiffany kept trading in resources for clothing removal cards and got our shorts off. Despite our focus actually being on the game, there was still a lot of sexual tension. We were definitely checking Tiffany out at any opportunity and she seemed to be enjoying our eyes on her. I noticed her eyes drift to my obvious erection and the bat back up to meet mine. She smiled. I wanted to leap across the table and feel those lips on mine again. 

I succeeded in getting my ore port and had upgraded my settlement on the two ore tiles to a city. A couple lucky rolls and I had a nice pile of rocks in my hand. I was lucky a seven hadn’t been rolled in a while because I would have become the first person to fall victim to rule 3. On my turn I was able to trade in enough cards, taking advantage of my 2:1 deal on ore to have 6 clothing removal cards. I played both sets of three, one to get her panties off, one to get to dare her. My plan was to dare her to stand in the middle of the room facing away from us and bend over and touch her toes for 10 seconds. I thought that would be fair enough as I wasn’t pushing any touching, etc. but that pussy and ass view from behind was definitely something I was craving. Unfortunately I forgot all about the fact that I couldn’t dare her until there was no clothing to remove. I tried to take it back and hold onto them for later, but she overruled that. I effectively played the cards to have Tim and Ryan whip their dicks out. At least Tiffany seemed to really enjoy having our cocks exposed, almost as much as we enjoyed seeing her glistening pussy. She was completely shaved now (when Tim asked her what happened to the landing strip, she confessed that she had tried to shave in a more exotic design and had botched it, so had to go bare.) 

I was lucky I had cleaned out all my cards either way. Two rolls later a 7 popped up again. No one was over the limit though. On Tiffany’s turn we got to experience our first dare. She played her cards and dared all three of us to give her a massage for 2 minutes. While we had been thinking that the dares would apply to each of us individually, she apparently had decided they could apply to all three, the same way the clothing removal applied. It was a valid argument and we basically all wanted to get our hands on her, so we rolled with it.

Tiffany lay down on her stomach across three chairs. We alternated the side of her the back of the chair was on, which meant Tim and I were on the same side of her (at her legs and back, respectively) and Ryan was across from us, even with her ass. We wasted little time reaching out and letting our fingers knead her skin. I lightly ran my fingertips up and down her back before circling my thumbs into her muscles with more pressure. Ryan greedily cupped her ass cheeks (I watched jealously) and tried to massage them, but mostly seemed to just be grabbing and squeezing. Tim had started with her ankles and was working his way up her calves. Soon he was to her hamstrings and was sliding the backs of his fingers up the inside of her thighs. Tiffany had been subtly moaning throughout (the 2 minutes had long past, no one was keeping track) and her purring seemed to really increase as Tim drew close to her pussy. She arched her back slightly, spreading her legs a little. Her hips rotated forward and I could tell Tim was getting an amazing view of her ass and pussy. Ryan leaned over trying to see. I felt Tiffany shudder and it looked like Tim’s fingers had brushed over her pussy lips. I was still rubbing her back when I felt her hand on the back of my leg. She ran it upward, reaching my ass and squeezing. Her arm wrapped around me and pulled me closer. I let my fingers slide up into her hair, swirling them around against her scalp a few times before grabbing a fistful of hair. Tim’s hand was cupping her pussy now, massaging his fingers over her clit. She whimpered and looked up at my, past my cock. She bit her lip. “OK, I think the two minutes is up.” she said.

She stood up and her hand lightly played over my cock. I saw her give Ryan a squeeze too as she took her chair back to the table. When she sat down, she was facing me, with one foot up on the seat of her chair and the other leg spread wide. Her pussy was soaked and I couldn’t take my eyes off it.

I was so distracted that I didn’t do a good enough job clearing out my hand on my turn. Which meant, after my ore was rolled, I had 8 cards. I thought I’d be alright, but when my turn came around again mine own flesh and blood betrayeth me as I rolled a 7. Tiffany cackled.

“what are we going to make him do?” she asked. Tim immediately said “finger up his butt.” To which I responded, “For real?” Ryan laughed but Tiffany said no. I reminded them they had less than twenty seconds remaining to decide. “Make him eat me out,” Tiffany said. Tim and Ryan protested that that was something I wanted to do, so it wasn’t a good option. I made a ticking noise at them. Ryan said, “Make him wrap cheese around his dick and then eat it.” “Ugh, gross!” Tiffany exclaimed. “Three,” I said. “Two.” “Guys. Vote now. Eat me out. Go.” Tiffany quickly interjected. Tim and Ryan shot their hands up.

I smiled despite myself. “How long?” I asked, already getting to my knees. “Until I say stop,” she replied.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/crnus0/the_gangbang_of_catan_the_carnal_quartet_part_31