[MF] I fucked my ex-girlfriend’s best friend, Part 3.

Part 2:

https://redd.it/cnnp0f

Part 3.

First of all, I just want to tell you that this is going to be a long story. If you are looking for something to read for a quick jerk, I recommend you skip this one. But if you have read my past stories and feel emotionally invested, please feel free to read on. Thank you.

If you have read all my previous stories, you probably know that about a year ago my ex-girlfriend Heather and I went on what we thought was our dream vacation to Phuket, Thailand and ended up having sex with a lady boy named Phun. After that adventure, Heather was on a high. Though we talked about keeping what happened with Phun between just the two of us, no sooner had we landed that all her friends already knew about it. I should have seen it for what it was, the beginning of the end for Heather and me.

A few other things happened which led to us breaking up, but it was mostly centered around Phun.

Friday

Kelly and I were coming home from dinner at her parents’ house when she received a text from Heather. Like I said before, it’s not about if Heather was going to find out about Kelly and me, it’s a matter of when she will find out and from whom. We (Heather, Kelly and myself) have a lot of mutual acquaintances.

Kelly told me that Heather wanted to meet with her for dinner on Saturday. Though we were both unsure if Heather already knew, we were about 99% sure that is why she wanted to have dinner with Kelly. I asked her if she wanted me to join her and Kelly said she needs to put her big girl pants on and deal with Heather herself. I asked her if she was willing to face the possible consequence of losing Heather as a friend and she was confident that she was not going to. Kelly and Heather have been through worse, a lot worse.

We arrived at her house and since her son was staying the night at her parents’, Kelly and I started fooling around the second we walked in the door. I stuck my hand under her dress and felt up her pussy and she moaned as we kissed. I made some corny comment that I was looking forward to having my real dessert. Kelly smiled and replied that she was too.

“If you eat my pussy until I cum, I’ll let you fuck me in the ass, so you don’t have to suffer wearing a condom.” She said.

I was not expecting that.

“Are you sure? You don’t mind it?” I asked.

“It’s not my favorite, but I don’t hate it. But don’t expect me to put your cock in my mouth afterwards.” She replied.
“Of course. I didn’t expect nor want you to.:” I replied.

We headed to her bedroom and striped, but Kelly wanted to take a shower first. I told her I’ll join her.

One thing about Kelly is she doesn’t want shower sex. I guess she had an incident before where she and an old boyfriend were fooling around in the shower, and she slipped and really hurt herself. We do make out though and she encourages me to fondle her as much as I want, and she does return the favor.

After the shower, we headed to bed. I was very excited about being able to fuck her in the ass and she knew it, because she teased me a lot with her ass. We made out and as Kelly started to fondle my cock, she commented on how hard I already was. I told her I really wanted to fuck her ass and she smiled and told me to be patient. Before she lets me do it, she wanted me to eat her out first. I exaggerated a look of disappointment and she explained that if I cum first, I will be half-assed in eating her pussy since I already got what I wanted. At least right now, she knows I will do a good job since I’d want her to cum as soon as possible. “Besides, would you really enjoy eating my pussy if your cum dripped out of my ass and ran down my pussy?” she added.

I must admit this woman had flawless logic.

We kissed again and I started to make my way down and I stopped to suck on her tits. She let me go on for about 10 seconds and then she goes “enough with the foreplay. We both know what we want so let’s get it on already.” Then she laughed. I guess she was as horny as I was.

Kelly spread her legs as wide as she could and raised them. She asked me if the stubble around her pussy bothered me. She meant to shave tonight but she forgot. If it bothered me, she’ll clean it up really quick.

I was already hard as a rock and was ready and I did not want to ruin the mood. I told her it didn’t bother me, and I went straight for her clit.

“Not messing around, are we?” she said.

“You were the one that said enough with the foreplay.” I responded.

“Shut up and eat.” She demanded. And I did so like a good boy.

I did my best to bring her to orgasm and as she was getting close, she said

“Put your cock in my pussy. Fuck me as I cum. I want to cum all over your cock”. Her hand replaced my tongue on her clit as I put my cock as deep as I can in her pussy. I fucked her with long strokes and then she told me to hold it in as she came. She shook, she twitched, and she throbbed as she came.

Kelly asked me to lay down and she put my cock in her mouth and she licked every inch of it.
She came up to my face and asked me to taste her juices on her tongue.

When this girl gets horny, she really gets horny.

I did so, and she kissed me with a very wet and lustful kiss. As she did so, I felt her put me back in her pussy and she started to ride me. I wanted to be in her ass really bad, but I was not complaining. Her pussy was hot and wet, and it felt absolutely wonderful.

“You know you’re playing with a loaded weapon. It might go off accidentally.” I told her.

“I know how to handle it.” She answered. She leaned over and kissed me again.

Kelly stopped kissing me and looked me in the eyes. “Are you ready for my ass, baby?”

I nodded enthusiastically. She pulled me out of her pussy and slid me into her ass. I was in heaven. Kelly continued to ride me. I put my hands on her waist and she took them and put it on her tits. She gyrated her hips and did all sorts of movements as she rode me. Finally, Kelly told me she wanted to feel me cum in her ass. She did a fast, steady pace just moving her hips and it did not take me long to cum deep inside her ass.

Kelly laid next to me. She asked me if I enjoyed what she did, and I said I loved it. We kissed and she snuggled next to me, resting her head on my chest.

I felt Kelly relax in my arms and as I started to drift, Kelly asked if I was asleep.

I said no and she said there was something she wanted to tell me.

“Remember when I said, the last time I had sex was two years ago? I remembered today that I had sex with Heather twice after you guys got back from Thailand. I didn’t intentionally leave them off, I just didn’t think about it.”

I told Kelly I didn’t care, but what did she mean they had sex? Was it more than tit sucking?
She hesitated and then said yes.

She said that a few days after we got back from Thailand, Heather came over to her house and they started out making out and playing with each other’s tits as they usually do, but Heather got carried away. She said Heather ate her pussy and got upset when she did not want to return the favor. Heather got over it and asked if Kelly had a dildo because she wanted to fuck Kelly while she sucked her nipples.

“She knew I didn’t, and she said it was too bad since she wanted to do it the same way Phun did it to her. I remember being weirded out with what she said.

Then one time she dropped by my house, without saying a word kissed me and fondled my breasts. She took off my shirt almost ripping it off, sucked and bit my nipples and fingered me. Then she said she wished I had a dick so she can suck my tits as I fucked her. She weirded me out again.

After that she asked me if I would do a three way with you and her and I said no. It was not something I was interested in doing. “ Kelly said.

“Really?” I asked.

“At the time, yes. You guys were starting to have problems and I didn’t want get dragged into it.

But that didn’t end there. She once asked me to do it in front of a camera as Phun watched.”
“Did you do it?” I asked her.

“Not just no, hell no. Then when Phun was here she asked if we can have a three way with Phun. Again, I told her no.

I told Heather that what we did was for of us and no one else, not even to know. Up until I told I believed we were the only ones who knew. The idea of sharing me with her lovers was offensive to me. I was not her plaything. She did not have the right to share me with anybody.

That was when Heather and I started not to talk as much”.

“Looking back, I am not surprised.” I told Kelly.

“I am sorry for not telling you. I really did not leave them out, I just didn’t think about it.”

“Don’t worry about it. You can make it up to me by letting me fuck you in the ass tomorrow night.” I joked.

Kelly smiled and said “deal”.

Saturday

in the morning, we picked up her son from her mom’s and took him to breakfast. We hung out until around noon and then I headed home.

I asked Kelly if she was okay with meeting with Heather alone and she assured me that she was.

Kelly said she will head to my place after dinner.

I knew the anticipation of hearing what happened was going to kill me, so I decided to go to my parents’ house and help my dad with some stuff to keep my mind occupied.

In my eyes, my dad is the wisest person in this world. A lot of my male friends, go to him for relationship advice. We refer to him as “Yoda”, not as an insult, but as a compliment.

It was not lost on my dad why I was there on a Saturday night instead of hanging out with Kelly and though I tried my best to tell him that I had nothing else to do that night he knew something was up.

I helped him put up some cabinets and shelves that he bought in the garage and then had dinner with him and my mom. After we cleaned up, he asked me if I wanted to go with him to the bar down the street to meet up with some of his friends. I said yes and since the bar was close to halfway between their house and my place, we drove separately. I knew I would want to head home as soon as Kelly texted me that she is on her way.

It was about 8:30 and I thought that Heather and Kelly’s dinner should be ending soon since they met up around 7.

I got to the bar and found my dad sitting at a table by himself. I sat down and he said that he already ordered us some beers. I knew then that he wanted to check on me if everything was alright. Without asking me, I started to tell my dad about what was going on with Heather and Kelly. And his answer
“I figured.” Did not surprise me at all.

I also told my dad about what Kelly confessed to me.

“Are you okay with it?” he asked. I paused.

“You know, it’s okay for you not to be okay with it.” He said. I nodded. I know I said I was okay with it, but really, I was not. Or was I. I was looking at it from two different perspectives. As a jilted ex-boyfriend that found out he was being cheated on and as a new lover, who found out that his new possible girlfriend had a sexual history that she tried to hide.
It was hard to merge the two perspectives, since if I look at it from the new lover’s perspective, I had to be okay with Heather cheating on me with Kelly while we were together and if I look at it from the jilted ex-boyfriend’s perspective, I have to be mad at Kelly for playing a big part in it. And I did not want to do either one. I did not want to be okay with Heather cheating on me nor did I want to get mad at Kelly.

I told my dad all this and he simplified it for me. “It all comes down to if I was willing to be okay with it or not. I shouldn’t choose to be okay with it just so I can be with Kelly. I have to realize that there may be consequences. Knowing what I know now, will I be able to trust her fully? Is there any guarantee that the whole thing with Heather is done? If it’s not, then how will I deal with it?”
As he said that I happen to glance at my phone, and it was now 9:15. The thought of them fooling around popped into my head. What my dad just told me actually made a lot of sense.

I did my best to silence those thoughts and I guess the whole anticipation thing was affecting me more that I should have let it. I must admit, I can be a very anxious person and if I don’t center myself before I realize it, it can, and it has gotten away from me before. Somehow talking to my dad, calmed me down because I found sense in what he was saying.

At 9:45, Kelly called and asked me to meet her at her house, but she was going to stop at her parents’ house to kiss her son good night and put him to bed. I guess I was too anxious that I asked her “so what happened?” and she said she will tell me when she saw me. She said if I got there before she did, to just let myself in.

I told my dad Kelly was on her way. I said good night, gave him a hug, told him I love him and kissed him on the cheek. Most of all, I told how lucky I was that he was my dad. He gave me a pat on the back and told me “everything is going to be okay”.

I got to Kelly’s before she did and just like she said, I let myself in. A billion different possibilities went through my head on what to expect. Of that billion, not a single one prepared me for what was about to happen.

I went to the kitchen to get another beer to calm my nerves and I heard the garage door open. I did not want to seem anxious, so I sat down on the kitchen table and had a drink. Kelly went into the kitchen first and right behind her was Heather.

I guess the two of them expected and saw the shock in my face. Heather was the first to say something.

“Hi, baby.”

“I haven’t been that in a while.” I replied.

“I know. Sorry, force of habit.” She said.

I looked at Kelly with a WTF look, waiting for her to say something and she averted her eyes. Unsurprisingly, Heather was the one that spoke up.

“First of all, I wanted to tell you that I am very happy for the both of you. My two-favorite people in the world getting together.”

I looked at Heather with a “BULLSHIT!” look.

“But mostly, I wanted to apologize that happened between us. I just want to clear the air between the two of us, so if the three of use decide to hang out together, nobody will feel uncomfortable.” She continued.

I looked at Kelly and our eyes met. Her eyes opened wide upon hearing what Heather said. Then she mouthed “I’m sorry”.

My mind went back to the conversation I had with my dad. Him pointing out that “I cannot choose to be okay with it, just so I can be with Kelly”.

“Are you kidding me?” I asked, giving it as much gravity as I can short of shouting.

Heather came up to me, smiling and said “No I am not kidding. If you want it, I can give you the fantasy that you always wanted. You, me and another girl”.

“HEATHER!” I heard Kelly yell, but Heather ignored her.

Three things stood out in my mind.

1. Kelly told me the night before that she was not Heather’s plaything to share with anybody and she did not appreciate it when Heather would ask. So, this was all Heather. Kelly probably did not see this coming.
2. She just referred to Kelly as “another girl”. If she was sincere about anything, she would not refer to her best friend as “another girl”.

3. After Heather and I broke up and I was moving out, she had the nerve to tell me that she had me wrapped around her finger and if she ever decided that she wanted me back, I’ll come running back to her as fast as I can. What she was doing now was trying to prove herself right. In front of Kelly. Screw that!

It took me all of a quarter second to gain my resolve and as calmly as I could, I told Heather “That is not yours to give anymore”.

I saw the stunned look in Heather’s face for about a second and then she put her arms around me and tried to give me a kiss. As I calmly as I could I pushed her back.

“You know you want me, baby.” She said.

I smirked. “Not as bad as you want me”. I answered back. Then I pulled her arms off of me, grabbed my keys, and got in my car. Kelly came after me. I ignored her as I drove away.

Since my phone went on “do not disturb” mode at 10 PM, her calls and her texts went unnoticed.

Sunday

I woke up as the sunlight hit my eyes. Surprisingly I slept better than I expected. Not only did I feel rested, I felt relieved. Why? I wasn’t really sure.

I looked at my phone and I had 4 texts and 3 missed calls from Kelly.

Her texts were (in order) “I am so sorry. Please let me explain.” “Please talk to me I am so sorry.” “I’m coming over, please give me the chance to explain.” “Please call me in the morning.”

I also noticed that she left me a voice mail, but I was sure it was all going to be the same as her texts so I ignored it.

I got up and proceeded with my morning routine. As I walked past the front door, I noticed a note under the door.

“When you wake up please come downstairs, I’ll wait for you in my car.”

Wait, what? I asked myself. I looked at my phone to check what time she said she was heading over and it was at 2:30. It was now 7:30. I looked out my window and I did see her car in the parking lot, next to mine.

I put some pants on and headed down stairs. I found Kelly sleeping in the driver’s seat in her car. I tapped on the window. She opened her eyes, jumped out of the car and gave me a hug. She started crying and apologizing. I did not want to make a scene, so I held her, had her cry it out and then told her to go home.

She promised that if I give her the chance to explain she will go home and not bother me anymore. But first she asked if she can use my bathroom.
We made our way into my apartment and Kelly ran into the bathroom as I poured myself some coffee.

Kelly came out of my bathroom in just her underwear. I asked her why she took her clothes off and she told me they stank of alcohol since she spilled some of her drink on her dress and the smell was making her feel sick. I took a house coat from the coat closet and asked her to cover up.

She took it and asked if she can have some coffee, so I poured her a cup as she sat down on the couch.

She was silent. I was getting impatient. I exaggerated looking at my watch and told her I had to be somewhere. She looked at me and asked “where?” and I said it doesn’t matter. I told her she had 5 minutes.

“I am so sorry. Heather said that she wanted to apologize to you and make amends. I was not expecting her to do what she did.”

“I know that much. Believe me I know her a lot better than you both think I do”. I said.

“Kelly I am not mad at you for what Heather did. I am disappointed that you let her play you like that to get to me.” I know it sounded self-absorbed, but that was how I felt.

“We both knew that she was going to try something to make it about herself and I guess I just didn’t expect you to lower your guard down so easily and fall for it, hook, line and sinker.” I added.

Kelly started crying and I was lost on what I should do. It wasn’t with what just happened the night before, but the whole Kelly and Heather affair. That was what it was, an affair.

I did not want for Kelly to feel that I was emotionally beating her up, so I gave her sometime to regain her composure. She looked up at me a few times, maybe expecting me to open my arms to her and hold her. I was not going to give her that. Not until I get some questions answered.

“So what happened at dinner?” I asked her.
“She was very pleasant. She said she found out about me and you from one of our mutual friends. At first she said that she didn’t know how to feel about it but eventually she said that she just wanted you to be happy”.
I rolled my eyes at the last statement.

“Then she told me not to tell you about me and her. She said you would freak out. I told her that you already knew, and she asked how you took it. I told her you were fine.

After that all she talked about was how she screwed things up with you and her and that she hoped to make amends with you.

She convinced me that it will mean the world to her if you can forgive her and maybe let her back into your life even if it’s just as a friend.” Kelly added.

I took a minute to understand everything Kelly just said. I guess I was weary of Heather that is why I knew she was not sincere in everything she told Kelly. But Kelly and she have a different history. They still regarded each other as a best friend. And that was the issue that I am dealing with. I thought of everything my dad and I spoke about.

I had to lay it on the line for Kelly if we were going to be together.

“Kelly, I have something to tell you. I have thought about everything regarding you and Heather. From your friendship to you having sex, etc. I wanted to believe that I was okay with everything because I want to be with you.

But the truth is, I am not okay with it”.

Kelly started crying even more.

“I want to be with you, but I don’t know what to do. I don’t want to have to worry if you are cheating on me with Heather, because that is what you guys did. You cheated on me and your boyfriend at the time. Regardless what you believe that it was something that you did for the both of you. I mean, you do realize you guys crossed a line?”

Kelly nodded.

“Are you asking me to chose between you and Heather?” She asked.

“No I didn’t. What I am telling you is this is not going to work with Heather and me in your life. So I am taking myself out of the equation.”

“Why are you making that decision for me? Shouldn’t I be the one to make the decision on who I want in my life or not?” Kelly responded.

“Maybe you should. But I did not want to put you in that position. But if I am going to share my life with you, Heather cannot be in it. That is why I made the decision.” I replied.

“That is not fair. I want you in my life. Just in case it hasn’t been glaringly obvious to you, I am madly in love with you. Do you remember what I let you do to me last Friday? Do you think that is something I would let just any person do to me? For God’s sake, I slept in my car last night in the hopes that you would give me the chance to explain myself.

I love you and I care a lot about your happiness. I want you to be happy. I want you to be happy with me.

And no, there is no choice. I don’t want Heather in my life anymore especially after what she did last night. I wanted to believe that she and I can still be best friends. But she is not the same person I knew. She has become so selfish; she thinks the world revolves around her. I can’t stand her.”

Kelly stood up and held my hand.

“I love you and I know you love me. Please give me, give us another chance.” She said.

I sighed.

“Promise me that as long as we are together that I am the only person you will have sex with. I don’t care how innocent you make think it is, but if somebody else is sexually using your body with your consent, it is cheating. “ I said.

“I promise. I promise that you are the only one who can have me in any way, shape or form.”

I held Kelly and we kissed.

“I do love you too.” I said. We kissed.

“Now I believe you owe me a butt fucking.” Kelly said.

I smiled.

I led her to the bedroom where she again let me fuck her in the ass.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/cqsfht/mf_i_fucked_my_exgirlfriends_best_friend_part_3