Teasing me on the Fourth of July with his brother in the next room [FM]

Me: 21F, tall and curvy brunette, about 5’9″ and 155 lbs. 34DD which isn’t as big as it sounds when you’re tall, but plenty for a good time

Him: 24M, slim with light brown hair and about 5’11”, in good shape with a great ass ?

I met Jeremy on Tinder a couple months ago and we hit it off. The sex with Jeremy has been incredible, plus he’s a really great guy. He’s been patient while encouraging me to try new things, so I definitely have a few other stories with him that I like. I love teasing, but this 4th of July he took it to a whole new, frustrating level.

After a day with my family, I stopped by Jeremy’s place to meet his brother who was in town and spend time with him and his friends. Jeremy, his brother, and I passed around a bottle of vodka at the hot tub and while I wasn’t particularly drunk, driving was a bad idea. So, Jeremy generously offered to let me stay the night ?

———–

We head into his room and start getting ready for bed. I get in a t-shirt and panties, he gets in just a pair of athletic shorts. We lay down cuddling, but it’s not long before our hands start to wander. His hand runs up and down my thighs, occasionally sliding between my legs. It’s enough to get me turned on, and I start getting a little excited when he says, “Now remember, if you want to have fun you need to stay quiet.”

Jeremy has a private room, but also has his brother sleeping on his couch and two roommates. Understandably, he didn’t really want to bother his brother.

“I promise I’ll be good,” I whisper as I run my hands all over his back and chest. To stay quiet, I stick to those harsh breaths through my nose, resisting the urge to moan as he starts playing with my nipples. I arch my back and grab his hair, pushing his face down so I can feel his stubble on my sensitive skin while he licks and sucks them. He starts nibbling and it’s all I can do not to moan. As I gasp, he grips my hand and moved it down where I find he’s already taken off his shorts. He places my hand on his cock and I can tell he’s throbbing. I put pressure on it and start rubbing his shaft the best I can while being played with, feeling it pulse with every stroke. I’m already soaking and thinking about what that cock will feel like inside me.

I hear another breathy whisper, clearly having more difficulty talking this time: “I want you…to suck my cock…*quietly*.” I’m happy to help, so I give him a grin and slowly kiss my way down his chest. When I get down there, I swirl my tongue around the head of his cock, focusing on the little spot where it joins his shaft. I use my hands while I go up and down his shaft and then try my best to take him all in my mouth, but I’m struggling. Jeremy grabs me by the hair and slowly pushes my mouth onto his cock until I run out of breath and have to come up for air. When I go back down, he starts shivering, so I take my mouth off his cock and come up to kiss him. I’m not ready for him to cum yet. He grabs me roughly and holds me for a minute, still shaking, before I whisper “I want to feel your tongue in my pussy.”

I’d only ever had oral once before because I felt weird asking for it and was nervous about sitting on someone’s face, I’m thick and it seems risky ? But I am desperate and he whispers, “You’re in charge now. I’ll do whatever you want.”

Well I’d already told him what I want, so I work my way up to his face and let him get to work. It feels incredible and when I move down for a kiss, I can taste myself on his lips. At this point, I want his cock so badly it hurts.

“Jeremy, I want you to fuck me. Please.”

“Not yet.”

Well apparently the “you’re in charge” was all talk then, because all I want is his cock and he won’t give it to me.

I’m dying. I’m soaking wet, I’ve been making out with this incredibly attractive guy for at least half an hour, and when I ask him to fuck me, he pins me to the bed and just starts teasing me with his tip. There’s plenty of juices down there to let him slide all around, moving around my clit and teasing my lips, barely in and out. He’s so close to giving me what I want, he’s right there, but he won’t give it to me. His cock is right in my opening, but I’m not on birth control, or else I might have just pushed back so I could feel him inside me. But he doesn’t have a condom on, so I start begging.

“Please, please, please,” I keep repeating in a quiet whisper, barely audible even in his quiet room. I lean in near his ear. “*Please* fuck me with your thick cock. I want to feel you inside me.”

“Not while my brother’s here. You are going to have to be patient. I want you so, so much, but you have to wait.”

His brother is in town for three more days but I am rubbing against Jeremy’s cock right now. I don’t want him to fuck me next week, I want him to fuck me now. I am dripping wet and aching for him. I get more desperate, acting a little wild trying to change his mind as I run my hands all over him, kiss his neck, kiss and lick his ear, play with his ass. I promise to be quiet, I promise that he can go slow so the bed doesn’t creak, but he just says “I love to tease you like this, to see how desperate you get while you squirm for my cock.”

“Will you at least finger fuck me please?”

I expect that he will finger me (he’s done it in a public bar, but that’s another story) but he refuses even though his brother has got to be asleep by now. My begging is getting me nowhere. He keeps teasing me with his cock and fingers, barely touching me and refusing to go in, even when I grab his hand and try to push his fingers in. He announces it’s time for bed and pulls up his shorts. I pout and stay naked, willing to bet that if I do he’ll get handsy during the night.

Turns out I was right. We wake up in the middle of the night and get going but it turns out the same way as the first session: with him teasing and me frustrated. I’ll spare you the details so this doesn’t turn into a novel ? He tells me, “Just think and fantasize about what you want me to do to you next time. Because I’m going to make you tell me.” We eventually lay back down to sleep and my mind is definitely coming up with things I want him to do to me.

We wake up early and he turns over and we cuddle for a bit. We lay there for a bit, me naked and him just in those damn shorts, and he starts to kiss me. I can feel that he’s hard and even though I know what he’ll say, once he starts playing with me I can’t help but beg him to please for the love of all that is good not blue balls me again. Unfortunately I was right and I knew what he was going to say, so I am 0/3.

Soon, he gets a text from his brother and it’s time to get up. We get dressed and while we stand by the door before we leave the room I wrap my arms around his neck and say, “You had better make up for this next time I see you, I think I’ve earned it.”

Instead of giving a promise or even a snarky reply like I expected, he drops to his knees and slowly pulls down my pants. I breathe sharply as he leans, gives me a kiss just above my pussy, and dives in. I have to grab a bookshelf while I try to stay quiet, knowing his brother is awake in the next room. After a while that feels way too short, he stands back up and I give him a kiss so I can taste myself on his lips one more time.

Then it’s time to leave. I go home still aching and anxious to see him again, but definitely appreciating his very enjoyable apology before I left ?

​

Edit: This is my first post here! I’d love feedback or advice!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/c9nh1k/teasing_me_on_the_fourth_of_july_with_his_brother