The time my fwb/ex convinced her friend that I would be a great judge for a BJ contest [MF][Cheating]

Dear Penthouse Letters…

Ok well honestly I’m a little too young to get that reference but still old enough to read a ton of erotica that started with it, satirical or not. Either way, the following is true, no I can’t prove it… I was a good Christian kid who’s dad had found his porn stash one too many times so I stopped keeping evidence.

This story is about Anders, and how she somehow convinced me to judge a Blowjob contest while I was dating neither of the contestants. Anders was the type of girl who was able to charm their way past just about anyone. When I first met her I was your typical quiet Christian cult member. (Think Mormon, but we called ourselves “non-denominational”) I’d been porn free for almost a year, I denied the deep seeded perversion growing within me, and there was no way I was going to get married without my virginity intact. Anders had different ideas. Within a year of meeting she was my first girlfriend. She spent the whole first date innocently grinding on my lap, the second date she didn’t stop until I’d accidentally came. A date later she my first hand job, within a few weeks my first BJ was surpassed… hell within the year we dated she was everything except my first PiV, but due to the emotional attachment I still consider her as the one I lost my virginity too.

This contest takes place a few years later, I was at the tail end of a pretty pointless relationship (doesn’t excuse my actions). Anders and I had started talking again, I knew I was about to be single and we’d started up a FWB arrangement when that was the case. I was trying to be somewhat moral and had kept our contact to sexting until I’d broken up with my current girlfriend. This day that backfired, Anders started snapping my pictures of her with a mutual friend, Kaity, who we both knew had nursed a crush on me since high school. Anders spent all night teasing me about it, since she was a bit of a cuck-queen who loved getting me riled up thinking of other women. As the night wears on they both started drinking a little and Kaity catches Anders texting me. Soon enough I’m getting bombarded with texts by both girls. It starts off innocent enough as Kaity and I haven’t talked in almost 3 years at this point. But Anders, who is horny as hell and a bit tipsy, is stoking the flames of Kaity‘s ancient crush. Soon the texts and snaps start getting flirty, and then they stopped. I was a tad bit disappointed as I was now horny and alone, so I jerked one out sat down and played some Dragon Age 2.

When they finally facetime me 3 hours later, the tone has definitely changed. Both girls are giggling like mad and can barely finish a sentence. Kaity immediately starts laughing and asking me about Anders and I’s sexual history. We had all been in the same church so we’d always lied about that all of us pretending to be virgins until recently. At this point I have no idea how we got here but I know unequivocally that it was Anders doing… Mostly because Kaity was the one who breached the subject, so I know Anders put her up to it. I have a feeling now is a good time to be truthful, so I fess up… it takes a while, but I embellish certain details when I can see Kaity blushing or Anders pulling close to her friend. It basically turns into a 30mins audio gone wild thread as Kaity quizzes us. The stories finally come to a close as Anders grow impatient and blurts out that the reason Kaity is asking, is that her ex thinks she gives the best head and is trying to come over.

Apparently this revelation had started an argument and Anders thought the best solution was for Kaity to call me and see if I supported my ex’s skills. I’m sure you can see where this is going… after a lot of nervous laughter Anders convinced us all that there is only one solution! Which we all laughed off… but still the girls invited me to come hang out with them now that everyone else had gone home. (But definitely not as a BJ judge… that would be wrong of course.) Can I just say, never have I made it across town and stopped for liquor faster.

I guess now is a good time to describe everyone involved. Kaity was the quiet high school girl who hit puberty first, she had gorgeous strawberry blonde hair and these vivid green eyes and shone with her cute smile. As an adult looking back almost ten years I can tell you she was struggling with some body issues. She’d definitely put on weight by now, and looked like an attractive blonde from gonewildplus but she had been an athletic softball type last time I’d seen her. (fun fact, if we still talked I’d definitely tell her that her current weight loss is super impressive since she’s thinner than me now a days.)

Anders was your picturesque cute geek girl from the early 00’s. Think 5’ nothing, Minnie Mouse bow in her hair, swoop top, short shorts or skirt, giant thick framed nerdy glasses. But those shorts were perfectly full, her stomach was flat from years of pageants, and the swoop top was always giving you a peek at her impressive, more than a handful, chest. Anders wore the adorableness like a mask her eyes always sparkling with mischief whenever I got within arm length.

I was a 6’3” blonde construction worker at the time. I have a wide build, but I was pretty thin around this time, clean shaven with blue green eyes. I’m nothing to be ashamed of downstairs but I also won’t be starting a porn site anytime soon.

Anyway, when I get to Kaity’s place I’m ushered inside, Anders grabs the fireball I brought (god I had bad taste) and starts pouring me shots… after two in as many minutes she shoves Kaity in the tiny galley kitchen and it’s obvious she’s been fanning the crush flames. Kaity is stammering which doesn’t help my bashful stuttering self as we pretty much say nothing for a few minutes until Anders returns and starts pouring drinks again. Two more shots and 30mins later and I’m feeling pretty decent as Anders perches on my lap and Kaity sits on the couch next to us trying to ignore the fact that her friend is grinding on the lap of the guy she’s trying to hit on. Anders is obviously getting impatient as she didn’t have the little evening orgasm that I did. She does her best to return to subjects of the past, as Kaity starts blushing… Anders brings up that she thinks she might be bi, but isn’t sure (she really was exploring and curious around this time). I’m not sure if Kaity was also crushing on Anders, if this was all a plan, or if she did it to try and impress me… honestly I don’t really care. Soon enough two tipsy girls are discovering each others boundaries on my lap. Anders is the eternal manipulative submissive and ends up laying on my lap as she pulls Kaity down on top of her. The swoop top is trying its hardest to contain those amazing breasts as Kaity gropes at them. Her fingers kneeding as Anders’ tongue forces its way into her mouth. My fwb arches under the larger girl as she moans her little fingers hooking into the blonde’s jeans. I’m not sure who started the biting but before long Anders had left an intense hickey on the other girls neck after Kaity’s fingers found the damp patch on the nerdy girls shorts.

I let them play for a while, too stunned to make much of a move fearful they might snap out of their lustful haze. Luckily Anders ass is keeping track of my growing arousal… and being the little slut she is, it finally became too much. Shoving her make out partner off she turns and madly tears at my jeans. A stunned Kaity knelt on the couch as Anders pulls me from my boxers and begins to work my length… it was so sudden the both of us really had no time to react in our half drunk state. It isn’t too long until Kaity breaks the ice with a quiet “you are pretty good…” That’s all it really took for Anders to snap out of her hormone driven spell. She looked up at her friend smiling at the compliment, I’m not sure whether it was alcohol or lust that had her more drunk but she starts teasing the larger girl back, trying to see if she still thought she could do better. Kaity blushes hard, a reaction that always encouraged Anders as she pressed ahead, slowly stroking my naked cock the whole time.

Soon Kaity had been riled up enough that she felt compelled to defend her honor. Crawling along the couch she paused just above my cock as Anders kept it vertical just under the girl’s lips. Kaity looked up into my eyes, the guy she’d crushed on for most of her adult life… and she did not disappoint. In one motion she took my entire length, leaning deep as I felt her nose touch my thighs. I look down to see her staring at me with a smile as her tongue teases my balls. Let me just say, Anders gives amazing head… probably the best I’ve ever had, but she can only take my entire length with a warm up and never is able to just hold it inside her while she teases me. So fuck me as I almost loose my mind at this new sensation. Anders loves watching me react as she holds the other girl down, finally pulling Kaity off as she takes her place. I pull the blonde up by her hair for my first kiss of the night, she returns the kiss with the passion only a childhood crush can bring. She tears at my shirt as I return the favor, groping her enormous tits as my ex skillfully works my cock. After a few mins I pull the judge card “I need to compare…” guiding Kaity back to my length as I pull Anders up for a kiss. I can tell Kaity doesn’t enjoy watching me interact with my ex: her blowjob grows aggressive as we make out and when I strip the nerd’s top, Kaity pulls away and slowly strokes my cock until I push Anders off the couch to sit next to her friend. I never got the double blowjob treatment, but the two girls took turns working my cock with the enthusiasm only drunk college girls can. All while I thanked the heavens I had jerked off earlier. Finally they tired out, sitting on the floor in front of the couch as Anders lazily strokes my cock while they argued over who was better.

In the end Kaity’s puppy dog eyes and her deep throat ease won the day, edging out Ander’s superior technique. The winner jumped up and straddled my lap as we made out in celebration of her victory. Anders pouted for a few minutes but brightened up when she thought of a reward for the winner. Leaning over her friends shoulders she whispered sweet nothings in Kaity’s ear, which made the pale girl blush deeper than I’d seen all night.

This has gotten super long, but if people enjoy it I can finish the story…

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/c1jezb/the_time_my_fwbex_convinced_her_friend_that_i