If you’ve read any of my stories you already know that after high school I was playing around part time at community college and not doing much else. I had the house to myself most weekends and threw parties on occasion. You might have even read my story about Lindsay and Leah in the pool. This story features both girls again at a party a few weeks later. I might have even told part of this story in that post. Here is a quick description of each girl…
Lindsay was about 5’2” with straight, shoulder length brunette hair, really big tits and a cute little belly. She had a cute freckled face and I always thought she was really fucking hot. She seemed to fly under other guy’s radar, maybe because of the weird people she hung out with.
Leah was tall and slender with long, dirty blonde hair, and perky little tits. She was kind of hippy-ish, and not as bubbly or girly as Lindsay.
I knew Lindsay from theater and Leah I had only met once before in my previous story.
On this night they came over my house with another friend of theirs named Danielle. Danielle was openly gay and she wasn’t girly at all. She was a little chubby, had a lip ring, short brown hair, and glasses. They knew my house was a place where we could hang out and drink and smoke without getting caught. I’ve never been a big smoker but they brought over some weed and were passing around a bowl. Lindsay spent half the night distracted by texting with some guy she’d been “talking” to.
I had bought a video camera and always broke it out at parties like this. This was before cellphone videos were a common occurrence. The four of us were just hanging out in my basement. We were getting pretty drunk and the room was hazy from them passing around a bowl.
“Why do you have a video camera?” Danielle asked.
“Because he’s hoping one of us will show our tits!” Leah answered, totally calling me out.
“Hey,” I teased, “It’s not like I haven’t seen them already.”
“I’ll show my tits. I don’t care,” Lindsay added.
“So do it!” I encouraged as I turned the camera toward her.
Without missing a beat, Lindsay held the bowl in her right hand and used her left to pull her shirt and bra up, allowing one of her gorgeous tits to drop out for everyone to see.
“Happy now? You got tits on camera!” Linsday said, looking directly into the lens.
Danielle was taken aback, “Oh my god, you guys are fucking crazy!”
“That’s nothing compared to last time we hung out here,” I responded, hinting at our previous escapades.
Danielle looked puzzled.
“I sucked his dick in the pool!” Linsday admitted, almost proudly, as she pointed at me. Lindsay was quite drunk, quite baked, and was definitely feeling herself.
“You did not!” Danielle judged.
“It’s true, I can confirm this happened,” Leah assured Danielle, raising her hand as if swearing an oath.
“True or false… you’ve never sucked a dick, have you?” Lindsay asked Danielle.
“Well…” Danielle started.
“You did?! You lesbian slut!” Lindsay teased.
“No!” Danielle insisted, “I just gave [a guy] a handjob once. Wasn’t for me. No offense.”
“None taken,” I replied.
The night went on like that. Lindsay and Leah recounted the whole story from the pool. We drank some more and played some truth or dare.
At this point I had gotten tired of holding the camera so I put it up on a shelf but left it recording. It was too high up to capture most of what happened on video but all the sound was recorded.
Lindsay was drunk and feeling super bold. She lasered in on Danielle. Danielle was openly gay and we were obviously all cool with that but it was still in a time when admitting you were gay THAT young was uncommon and Lindsay must have found in intriguing or exotic. She got Danielle to tell us about the first female celebrity she masturbated to.
Then Leah decided to have a go at me. She dared me to show my dick. I didn’t even hesitate. I unzipped my fly and pulled out my dick. It’s only average, but it was fully hard.
“There he is!” Lindsay shouted.
To my surprise, Danielle reacted with, “I’m gay but thats a pretty nice dick you’ve got there.”
“Danielle!” Leah reacted incredulously.
“What? Just because I’m gay doesn’t mean I can’t acknowledge a nice dick!” Danielle said defensively.
“Preach!” Linsday agreed.
Now that my dick was out, I had no desire to put it away. On my turn at truth or dare I dared Leah to show her tits.
“You’ve already seen them. Why don’t you dare Danielle to show HER boobs?” Leah argued.
“Fine then, Danielle I dare you to show your boobs,” I redirected.
“I don’t even get to choose truth instead?!” Danielle protested.
“Let’s see them tiddies, gurl!” Lindsay insisted.
Danielle rolled her eyes, “Fine!”
Then she proceeded to lift up her shirt and bra exposing her pierced nipples. I wasn’t as attracted to her as I was Lindsay or Leah but I was super turned on just by the fact that she did it. It surprised me!
“Those are some nice tits, Danielle,” I returned her compliment.
“Why thank you!” She replied in a silly voice, “Now I dare Leah to show her boobs.”
“Whatever,” Leah sighed as she lifted her tank top to reveal she wasn’t wearing a bra.
“You’re obsessed with tits,” Lindsay said derisively.
“Hey, at least I didn’t dare you to suck my dick again,” I said teasingly.
“No way! You had your fun! No more BJ’s for you!” Lindsay shot back at me.
It was at that moment Lindsay’s phone started to vibrate. It was the guy she’d been texting with.
“OooooOooooh,” Leah teased Lindsay, “That’s the guy who’s gonna get a BJ!”
Lindsay laugh hard at that, pushed her fingers to her lips to tell us to be quiet, and answered her phone as she stepped out of the room.
Leah and Danielle shouted some teasing words at Lindsay through the door. Then they tried to get me to take a hit off the bowl. I took the tiniest hit. I remember it made me cough like crazy so I handed the bowl back to Leah, jumped up with my dick still hanging out, and went to the bathroom to get some water.
After I got done getting a sip of water I heard Lindsay talking on the phone out in the main living room area so I decided to go mess with her. She was laying on her back on the couch talking to the guy and she looks over and notices I’ve still got my dick out. She kind of curled her eyebrow and laughed a muffled laugh at me. I decided to walk over to her and as I did she kept kind of absentmindedly responding to the guy on the phone with “uh huh,” and “yeah”‘s.
I couldn’t resist fucking with her so I went right up to her and lightly tapped my cock on her forehead. She covered her mouth to stiffle her laughter so the guy on the phone wouldn’t think something was up. Then I shifted down and leaned in a little more and edged my dick right up to the side of Lindsay’s mouth. She turned her head away and gently whacked me on the side of my leg with her hand. I tapped her cheek with the head of my dick. She turned her head back and looked up at me with her eyes kind of squinted, feigning annoyance, so I pushed myself forward a little bit so that the tip of my dick just touched her lips. I pushed my cock against her pursed lips twice and then on the third time, to my delight, she open her mouth and let me slide my dick inside.
I was shocked she let me do it! Her mouth felt so warm and wet. I started thrusting my hips forward and backward. Lindsay just laid their holding the phone to her ear while letting me fuck her mouth. Every now and then she’d let out an “mhmm” to let him know she hadn’t hung up. This probably went on for about 30 seconds and I started squeezing her tits. Then I got greedy and tried to pull one of her tits out and that’s when she decided to stop.
“That’s all you get,” Lindsay said as she covered the phone so the other guy wouldn’t hear.
I made a pouty face but she didn’t give in so I went back to the other room.
I opened the door to the other room and stepped into a thick cloud of smoke.
“Do you STILL have your dick out?” Leah asked.
“I had to go tea bag Lindsay,” I said jokingly.
The three of us went back to playing truth or dare. I dared Danielle to make out with Leah. Leah was down for anything and Danielle didn’t seem to mind. They started kissing and I could see their tongues touching. Then Leah reached forward and groped one of Danielle’s breast. That cause Danielle to yelp in surprise.
They dared me to get a ruler and measure my dick in front of them, which I did.
At this point I was so horny I couldn’t see straight. When it was my turn I worked up the courage and dared Leah to suck my dick.
“Ugh, you are, like, OBSESSED with BJ’s,” Leah said exasperatedly.
“Hey, you don’t have to do it. Just go ahead and forfeit the game!” I responded.
“Oh shut up and stand up,” Leah rolled her eyes.
I stood up and pulled my pants down.
Danielle was like, “Oh… MY god.”
“Don’t worry it won’t take long,” Leah assured Danielle while taking a shot at me.
Danielle just sat there shock as Leah leaned forward in her chair and began to suck me off.
“This is sooooo fucking weird,” Danielle said without looking away.
Leah knew what she was doing. I could barely hold on as she took the entire length of my cock in her mouth. Then I noticed a red light out of the corner of my eye. My video camera was still sitting on the shelf. In a moment of brazen greediness I told Leah to hang on one second because I wanted to make a home movie. I reached over with my left hand and pulled the camera off the shelf. I turned it around in my hand and pointed it down at Leah.
Leah looked up and smiled at me and asked, “Are you ready?”
Before I could say yes she was back to sucking my dick. I tried to hold the camera steady as I watched my veiny, rock hard cock slide in and out of Leah’s mouth.
I took a moment and panned the camera up to an embarrassed Danielle.
“Pay attention to HER, jackass!” Danielle laughed.
I put the camera back on Leah who smiled up at me with my dick in her mouth. It wasn’t long before I was ready to cum. I asked Leah if it was ok. Leah mumbled yes as she continued to suck my cock aggressively. I felt a wave come over me and I couldn’t hold back anymore. I started to cum right inside Leah’s mouth. Leah held steady until my cock finished pulsating in her mouth, pulled away, and then swallowed to the sound of Danielle’s applause.
We went back to drinking and waiting for Lindsay to come back. When she did it was only to tell us that she was going to go over that other guy’s house for what I assumed was a booty call.
Leah and Danielle ended up staying over. We got breakfast the next morning and I gave them both a ride home.
I don’t have the tape anymore. It was a long time ago and the tape got destroyed at some point but I still have the memory.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/brwo57/lindsay_and_leah_round_two_mf