My second threesome with my boyfriend [MFM]

Now is the tale of our first threesome with another guy.

​

After we hooked up with a girl, my boyfriend agreed to let me have another guy. We were sorta picky with finding someone and didn’t really know which “direction” to go initially. I love my boyfriend (James) and his dick is great (about 7″ and long) and I wanted someone as big, if not bigger. He was cool with the other guy being bigger than him if we found someone we liked. He is bi-curious but wasn’t quite ready to try much stuff with another guy (the most he wanted to try initially was dicks touching if I gave them head together). We eventually found a guy on Craigslist of all places (when that was still a thing). He was sorta like my boyfriend, white and tall-ish, BUT he had a slightly bigger dick, which I was excited for!

The guy (we’ll call him Shane) was 20 (slightly younger than us) but very cute. He was white, average height, skinny/cut and almost an inch bigger than my boyfriend. He was bi and actually wanted my BF to fuck him too, but he declined lol. We all talked and ultimately agreed that my boyfriend would fuck me and, if and when he was comfortable, would let met fuck Shane. I was fine either way because I at least got to suck him. Shane was also cool with dicks touching if I sucked them both, so it was a win-win.

One night, we finally invited Shane over. James and I were fooling around beforehand on the couch and were already naked, planning on giving Shane a surprise. We heard a knock on the door, and we both smiled excitedly. I couldn’t believe I was answering the door naked! Of course, I made sure it was him before opening the door the whole way. “You must be Shane,” I said and extended a handshake like a dork. He awkwardly laughed, as did I, and said hi as he came inside and checked me up and down. He looked over and saw James on the couch, who had a blanket covering his dick. James pulled the blanket off, got up and said hi as well, still semi-hard. “I really wasn’t expecting this right away,” said Shane, and we all laughed as my boyfriend and I were completely naked in front of a stranger. “We got a head start,” I joked, and then got to the point and said, “Are you ok with joining us?” He said yes very excitedly, and told him to get comfortable.

I started sucking James and got him hard pretty quickly while Shane started stripping down until he was just in his socks. I looked over and saw he was getting hard, and I looked up at James and asked “Can I suck him?” James said “Yeah!” and I had permission to grab Shane’s dick. He was freshly shaved all over and his dick got bigger as my mouth circled his tip. His balls were smooth in my hands (and later my mouth) as I took turns going back and forth with him and James. After a few minutes, I told Shane “Move closer” and, next moment, him and James’ dicks were touching! It was hot and they both laughed as their dicks made contact and pressed together in my mouth.

After a minute of catching my breath, James said “let’s move to the bedroom,” which we all did. I had them both lay on the bed and kept taking turns between their two dicks. After a minute, James got up and began licking my pussy while I was sucking Shane. It was so hot and I was so wet. After several more minutes, I felt James slide his fingers in me and, shortly after, his dick. I was moaning so much from getting fucked from behind and sucking a (practically stranger’s) long dick. It took a minute to get used to it all as I was tempted to bite down on Shane’s dick while getting fucked! It felt so good and I felt like such a slut, but I loved it.

Soon after, James flipped me on my back and kept fucking me. Shane was on his knees next to me and positioned himself right where i could suck him. James went a little slower to get more used to things and let me get a bit more comfortable. He asked me “Does all this feel good?” I responded with a “Mhmmmm!” as I kept sucking Shane and playing with his balls. “It’s fucking hot,” James replied and Shane agreed. Soon after, James was on the other side of me and I was taking turns giving them head again. I loved tasting myself and getting to see their dicks lined up again.

Finally, James asked, “Do you want to fuck him?” My eyes widen and I said “You sure?” and he said “Yeah, it’s cool!” I looked at Shane and asked what position, to which he asked me to ride him. He laid down and I got on top and couldn’t believe I was taking another dick in front of my boyfriend. James watched Shane’s dick disappear inside me and I let out a moan slightly louder than expected. I was slowly riding his dick and making out with my boyfriend. It was amazing!

After about 5 minutes or so, Shane motioned for me to flip over and started doing me from behind. James got in front so I could suck him. At one point, to my surprise, James slid his hand underneath and began rubbing my clit while Shane was fucking me. It, of course, made me extra wet, and I think it made Shane harder as well (James later admitted that Shane’s dick/balls grazed him a couple of times and it was kinda hot). Suddenly, Shane pulled out and came all over my back. It was a big load and it got all the way up to my shoulder blades! We were all surprised and laughed some as we caught our breath. James went and got a towel to clean me up and, after I was cum-free, he actually continued fucking me as well until he came all over my back too. I had came 3 times total, so all in all, it was a successful night!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/bpygcy/my_second_threesome_with_my_boyfriend_mfm