Continuing on with some of my Craigslist personals (RIP) best of, is every dude’s bucket list entry, the schoolgirl virgin. She answered to a pretty generic ad, so I figured it was probably fake. I don’t remember it word for word, but it basically said “I just turned 18, I’m tired of waiting, and I want to be fucked.”
As I said, I was hesitant at first, partly because I still didn’t believe it, partly because of her age, and also I had never been with a virgin before, so didn’t know what to expect. We continued to talk and I confirmed she was definitely real. She was a Latino girl, pretty cute, a bit chubby, but pretty nonetheless.
I wanted to make sure this was one hundred percent something she wanted, as there is no going back, you know? She wanted it, badder than I even imagined. So she tells me goes to a local Catholic all girl high school and we arrange for me to pick her up after she gets out on one of my days off.
The day comes, and I was pretty nervous. I was seriously picking up a virgin Catholic schoolgirl. She found my car easily enough, and was super nice. We had some good conversation on the way back to my place. She asked if she could use the shower, since she just had gym, and I said no problem.
I was waiting patiently on the living room couch when she walked out of the bathroom wearing just purple panties and a white t shirt and sat on my lap. She started talking dirty to me immediately, and it was a huge turn on because she had the most sultry, lusty voice. We started making out hardcore, feeling up each other’s bodies. She was so soft and supple. I broke off just for a moment to ask her for the last time if she wanted to go to my bedroom and she gave me a very enthusiastic yes.
We head into the bedroom and I strip down to my boxers, and help her out of her shirt. Her breasts were super perky, not too big not too small, a perfect handful. I began suckling them as she moaned in pleasure. I fingered her through her panties as we continued making out and fondling her breasts. She pulled out my cock and began kissing and licking it softly. I was already rock hard and she was soaking so there wasn’t much need for further foreplay. She wanted quite badly for me to just fuck her raw and cum inside for her first time, which was extremely hard to decline considering I have a big creampie fetish, but I’m not about that baby daddy life so I put on a rubber.
I slowly eased my way in her, surprised at the lack of resistance and/or blood I was expecting. I guess she had already popped it herself. She was so tight and warm, along with her sexy moaning, it was almost too much. It didn’t take long for her to start spasming underneath me in her first orgasm. She was squeezing me so tight, I was done right after her.
I asked her how everything was, and she said great with a big smile. We cuddled for a little bit, which turned into making out, and I asked her if she was ready to learn about giving blowjobs, which she was very much for. She was a natural as she kneeled over on the bed, sucking me off. I told her this time I wanted her to ride me, and handed her a condom. I instructed her how to apply it, and she started straddling me, but couldn’t quite figure out how to get it in, which I thought was pretty cute and funny. I didn’t want to waste too much time on it, so I just flipped her over and started giving her a real boning, now that I had done her proper the first time. She was really moaning now, digging her fingers into me, as we kissed while I pounded away at her. Another orgasm was not long for her. I did her doggy after that for a little while before I hit my 2nd. I finished off her third with some oral because I still wanted a taste of that freshly broken in pussy, and it was great ;)
We cuddled a bit longer and then got dressed, as we didn’t want to keep her out too long after school. I dropped her off a street over so she could inconspicuously pretend she walked home from a friends house, Haha. We did not meet up again, but did have a couple phone sex sessions, which she was great at with that sexy voice of hers. She told me that she felt more confident about her body and herself after our encounter and I told her I was very happy for her and glad I could help. She was a really sweet girl. We stopped talking shortly after that, but I’m sure neither of us will forget our experience together. :)
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/bmpr43/mf_the_barely_legal_virgin_catholic_schoolgirl