[MM] An unexpected encounter I will never forget

So. Normally I post in the gaystoriesgonewild sub, but a recent conversation helped me realize that there are maybe some women who don’t browse there that might find this kind of thing really hot, so I thought I’d see what this sub thinks of a sensual interaction between two men. I am always trying to hone my writing skills and all comments are extremely appreciated. ? Enjoy!!

… …

I have GOT to stop thinking of myself as a “newbie”. At this point I have probably hooked up with as many guys as I have girls. When it comes to girls, i always think of myself as confident and experienced, but with men, I always find myself acting shy and inexperienced. Maybe its because I so often find myself feeling “in-control” of my life, that the novelty of feeling submissive and “out of my comfort zone” gets me so much hotter. The idea of a stronger man who has made mental plans for my body that he will reveal to me at his own pace with me as a passenger and him as the driver on our shared ride to extreme pleasure always makes my dick hard and my asshole pulse. This is a story of me (once again) pulling the “first-timer” card on a hot slightly older man who wanted to fuck me since the moment he saw me. And made it happen.

I am a 31yr guy who lives in the mountains in Colorado. Though I don’t work out explicitly every day, i lead a very active lifestyle that keeps me in-shape and flexible. I am 5’9” 150lb and am slim but trim. And the thing that got Daniel’s attention first and foremost: I have red hair.

I was on a road trip from Colorado to Los Angeles with a stop in Oakland, CA to visit some old friends. My girlfriend had to stay home because her firm had just laid off a couple employees and she was forced to reschedule her vacation. So suddenly I found I was going all by myself. Whenever I learn that i will be going out of town by myself, my mind immediately shoots to the idea of meeting a guy a long the way. I wrote out some CL ads and jerked off thinking about who might respond. But… as I tend to do, I lose confidence, think of myself as “new” “inexperienced” and “out of my depth” and never hit submit on the ad. Resigned that I was too shy to go through with it, I packed up and headed out, with no bootie call lined up.

I met Daniel in Tahoe.

I had been running ahead of schedule on my drive. Really crushing the miles. My friends in Oakland expected me there around 10AM monday morning and it was now 8PM sunday night. I thought I might just drive the extra 4 hrs and surprise them, but as i had that thought, my stomach let out a massive rumble and I determined to at least pull over for some dinner. I pulled into a small diner off the main highway, in some small town i don’t remember the name of. I sat down at the counter and ordered. As i waited, i took out my phone and absent-mindedly scrolled through the Oakland m4m Craigslist looking for prospects. Suddenly I felt a tap on my shoulder. I jumped and nearly dropped my phone.

“Hey, sorry to bother you, but i think you dropped your car keys.” He said, smiling.

Did he see me just browsing cocks on the internet?? I thought, frozen in fear.

He smiled again and bent down to pick them up.

“‘Here.” He handed me the keys. “Better not lose those, you won’t get too far without them”

I let out a weak laugh and stammered a thanks and held out my hand for the keys. Still afraid i had been caught, i noticed my hand was shaking. I looked up. He had noticed too. He laughed.

“Hey no need to be nervous, we’re friendly people around here.” He gave me the keys, his hand lingering on mine a half-second longer than normal. I looked around the diner, aside from the cook/waiter/owner making my meal in back, we were the only ones here.

The lingering hand calmed me somehow and I gathered myself and finally strung a sentence together. “Sorry, I have been on the road by myself for a while now, I’m a little out of it.” A lame excuse but he seemed to accept it.

“Hey, I am here by myself too, if you’d like a little company while you eat, I am a good conversationalist.”

Not wanting to be rude to this seemingly friendly (and…now, that i looked) incredibly attractive man, i took him up on his offer and joined him at his booth. Things became very comfortable very fast, we talked about hiking and wildlife and the outdoors, girlfriends, wives (he had been married, now divorced) and eventually my fear that he had caught me browsing craigslist faded completely. As we talked I found myself staring and sizing him up. He was around 39, rugged, about 6’ tall with strong arms and a tight torso. He didn’t flash it with a tight shirt, but you could tell he was built. He had green eyes and short brown hair and a short trimmed beard.

We had been talking for what felt like half and hour max. However, when I looked down at my watch I noticed it was 1030pm and the diner was closing. Shit. I still had 4 hrs to drive ahead of me. As we paid our bills and headed out, i asked Daniel if he knew any good cheap hotels in the area, there was no way was I going to make it to Oakland tonight.

“I hope you don’t take this the wrong way.” He replied. “But I have a guest cabin at my place that you are more than welcome to stay in for the night, but i totally understand if you’d rather stay in a hotel.”

I caught his eye, but his face was hard to read. I started to think maybe he had seen me looking for guys online. This thought started to make my cock grow in my pants and i could feel myself getting nervous again.

“Uh, sure.” I stammered. And that was all he needed.

“Cool, follow me” He hopped into his car and before i could think twice i was following him down the road. A full boner growing in my pants. I resisted the urge to not just jerk off in the car on my way there.

20 minutes later I was sitting on the back porch of his guest house enjoying a cold beer on a warm summer night staring into the darkness of the forrest surrounding me. I thought maybe i should feel worried about being deep in the woods with a strange man, but Daniel had been very friendly and accommodating. he was presently finding extra sheets and making the bed for me to sleep in. Once again i found my mind wandering, fantasizing that he was making the bed for us to fuck in later. He had shown no further signs of wanting to take that route, but I still had a strange feeling this was more than mountain hospitality. I put my hand in my shorts and started slowly stroking my hardening cock.

“Beautiful night, huh?” Daniel had once again snuck up on me and my hand immediately shot out of my shorts, embarrassed at being caught for a second time. He didn’t hide noticing.

“Don’t worry Jack. I am not shy about that kind of thing. If you want to play with yourself on my porch, I won’t stop you.”

“Sorry” I stammered. “My hands were cold.”

He laughed loudly. “Jack, no need to make up lame excuses. I told you we’re very friendly here. Next I expect you’re going to tell me you were browsing dicks at the diner for research on a school paper?”

My mouth gaped open. He had seen. I didn’t know what to say. But he HAD noticed, and he HAD invited me back to his cabin. My heart started to race and my dick grew harder.

“I… Well, I’m on this road trip… and. well. you know, being away from my girlfriend… i was. I don’t know. Curious. about, you know, what it might be like.” Here i was, playing the first-timer card. I didn’t know why i couldn’t just look this man in the eyes and tell him I wanted him to fuck me, that i wanted it ever since our hands touched at the diner.

He leaned over me. Took my beer out of my hands and whispered very softly in my ear: “I dream everyday that a hot slim red-head like you will walk into that diner, and tonight I want to show you how good being with a man can make you feel. I want to be deep inside you.” His hot breath on my ear and the words ringing in my head. I let out a small gasp of pleasure and my hips rolled around in my chair, my groin filling with warmth. It was all the sign he needed.

His hand slipped down my chest and into my shorts. I gasped as his strong hand grabbed my throbbing cock as he started to kiss my neck. My hips slowly bucked pushing my cock towards him. He kissed my neck and stroked my cock slowly. Then he stopped and looked me deep in the eyes.

“You sure you want this?”

“For a very long time. But take it slow, I’ve never done this before.” Ugh, Why must I lie??? I thought.

But this seemed to make him even hornier. He grabbed my neck with his other hand and drew me into a deep kiss. All the while stroking my cock. I submitted myself to him, letting him explore my entire body with his hands, kissing me deeply the whole time. He grabbed my hand and brought it to his pants. I eagerly undid his belt and grabbed the cock i had been fantasizing about all night. It did not disappoint.

it was 7.5” inches long, cut and smooth. No blemishes, it looked absolutely delicious. I started stroking it slowly matching the rhythm he was using on me. He kissed me deeply once more and then pulled away, slipping down between my legs. Removing my shirt and kissing my chest, making his way to my cock. He pulled my pants down and took my rock-hard dick in his hands and gently kissed the tip. I laid my head back and moaned. He then went absolutely to town on it. Sucking and slurping and taking me all the way into his mouth. His fingers running through my ginger pubes and driving my wild. I pushed my hips into his face and he took his arm and put it around my waist pulling me more into him. My mind was spinning with pleasure. His tongue working the head of my cock as he sucked. I could feel my balls tightening and my orgasm building in my pelvis.

“Stop, stop” I said, pulling him off.

“something wrong?” he said.

“I don’t want to blow yet.” I said.

He smiled. “Then its your turn.” He stood up and dropped his shorts. His magnificent cock staring me right in face. He ran his hand through my hair and slowly brought me in. I grabbed his beautiful cock and dove right in. Sucking and stroking and taking it in all the way to my gag reflexing. His rubbery and rock hard cock felt amazing in my mouth. I took in the smell of his man-ness as my nose drew into his hips, taking him deeper and deeper into my throat. He moaned and started grinding his hips, fucking my mouth to the rhythm of my sucking. i could feel his cock throbbing and twitching in my mouth as he reeled with pleasure. The now-familiar taste of precum filling my senses.

He pulled out and stood me up. Guiding me over to the porch railing, he stood behind me and held me close, his strong hands running up and down my torso, kissing my neck from behind. His hard cock resting between my asscheeks. I started grinding up and down on his cock, trying to give the signal. He grabbed my cock and grinded back. His cock slipping up and down my tight ass I closed my eyes and instinctually started to bend over. He grabbed my chest and pulled me back up. Whispering in my ear:

“You want me to fuck you, you fine virgin little ginger?” The idea of this being my first time was definitely a turn on for him.

“God, Yes.” I stammered. “I want your hard cock inside me.”

He grabbed my waist and led me inside. Throwing me on the bed. I fucking loved being manhandled like this. He grabbed bottle of oil from the table and flipped me on my stomach. He oiled up his hands and started massaging my back, working his way to my ass. I pushed my hips up, exposing my hole. He didn’t wait any longer. He dove in and started licking my ass, working his tongue in and out and around. I moaned deeply and pushed my hips even more. My whole groin filling with warmth and anticipation. Then i felt the fingers. Slight pressure on my eager whole. I pushed back, taking them in. Feeling him enter me. I shuddered and my asshole pulsed.

“Holy fucking shit, yes” I moaned. “OH god, yes. Fuck me Daniel, fuck me for real. I want you inside me.”

He quickly put on a condom and flipped me over onto my back.

“I want to see your face as i enter you.” he said. It was one of the hottest things i had ever heard and it drove me fucking crazy.

He placed the tip at rim of my ass and pushed slowly. I relaxed and let him in. Filling me up slowly, inch by inch. His cock working deeper and deeper into me. My eyes widened and I choked in a gasp as his hips reached my ass, i could feel him fully inside me the tip of his cock pressing on the inside of my prostate. Then he started to work slowly in and out pumping harder and harder each time. I was swimming in euphoria, the feeling of his hot cock going in and out, his sweat, his smell, he soft grunts as my tight hole worked his cock. I wasn’t going to be able to go much longer. I tried to tell him, but i couldn’t speak. He was working me faster and faster now and I could feel that he was getting close. He let out a massive moan and pushed hard and deep one last time. That was it. My balls contracted, my asshole pulsed and i shot string after string of cum onto my chest. My hips writhing uncontrollably in full pleasure.

Daniel collapsed onto of me. Seemingly dealing with similar mind-bending pleasure. He slowly pulled out and revealed that he had filled the condom completely with his seed.

“So that was really your first time?” He asked. Gasping with exhaustion and pleasure.

“Would it make a difference if it wasn’t?” I shot back. Slightly shocked at my quickness in this situation.

“God no.” He said. “I was just curious.”

“Me too” I said winking. “…and on my way back… we’re ditching the condoms.”

As Always PMs and comments welcome!!

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/bieixo/mm_an_unexpected_encounter_i_will_never_forget