This happened almost six years ago, back when Craigslist personals was still a thing. I had always wondered what it would be like to be with a guy, and I started watching gay/bi porn to see if it was actually a turn on. It was.
I found myself jerking it to the thought of getting a blowjob from a guy and one day after smoking a shit ton of weed for courage and just enough “fuck it”, I replied to a post on the m4m personals. The poster simply wanted to come over and service a cock, that’s all. Sounded perfect to me and while I waited for him to arrive my heart was pounding and my cock was hard as rock in anticipation.
The guy arrived about fifteen minutes later and I let him inside. I was super stoned and nervous but super excited, and since I had answered the door only wearing tight boxer briefs he could see my excited state as well. I sat on the couch and he got down between my legs and massaged my cock and balls through my boxers and asked if it was my first time with another guy. I said yes and he smiled and slowly pulled down my boxers.
My cock sprung out and he gently took it in his hand and licked me from my balls all the way to the tip of my cock. His tongue felt amazing but then he slowly slid my dick into his mouth and the feeling amped up a million degrees. He sucked the hell out of my dick. To this day I have never had a partner service me the way he did. He bobbed his head up and down my shaft, swallowing a little bit more of my dick each time and as he did he sucked hard and swirled his tongue and I thought I would nut right then and there. Then his hands found my balls and my asshole and he played with them while never once removing his mouth from my cock.
It went on like that for a while, one finger deep in my ass, one hand massaging my balls and my cock sliding in and out of his throat. He stopped sucking me and ate my ass, and I had my first handsfree orgasm from the way he fingered my prostate. He licked the cum off my dick and then started sucking again, but this time he laid backwards over the arm of the couch so I could fuck his throat. He continued to play in my ass while I fucked his throat, and it wasn’t long until I was shooting a massive load into his mouth.
I was spent and sat on the couch next to him and he licked and slowly stroked my cock for a little bit, giving it gentle kisses and occasionally sucking on my balls. Then he got ready to leave, told me to get in touch with him again if I ever wanted more of the same, and then he left.
He serviced me a few times after that, but I lost his contact info and I haven’t seen him in a long time. I still think about that first time and it never fails to get me rock hard.
Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/bg3g5g/mm_my_first_encounter_with_another_guy
Did you ever do anything to him?