[M]y ex’s open minded roommate [F] cheating

I started dating my ex during her last year of college, she was 21 at the time and I was 24. She went to school in a large east coast city that I had moved to for a job. We had grown up in the same town and had mutual friends that introduced us.

We got a long great and I was excited when she told me she was going to grad school in the city. She would be moving in with her (f)ormer teammate from college. My ex Beth and her roommate Elsa were both very fit and continued their gym routine post college sports (working out was something we were all into)Now Beth was/is the prettiest woman I ever dated but Elsa was cute and had a bit of a slutty edge to her that always had me curious.

So things were going great, we both had our own apartments on the opposite sides of the city but it was fairly easy to get together. We would often stay at each other’s apartments on alternate nights. We were both young and could not get enough of each other but Beth was all about “making love” and sometime I just really wanted to fuck. That being said, it was hard to complain.

As our relationship progressed Beth would tell me stories of Elsa’s adventures and Elsa would also drop me hints occasionally. These always got me going and on more than a few occasions Elsa caught me staring at her ass ( world class) or her tits (B’s). It was fairly innocent but she would give me knowing glances.

Now I was rarely if ever alone with Elsa and We all left their apartment around the same time (Beth for school, Elsa and I for work). Beth and I were still going at it like bunnies but I was starting to fantasize about Elsa more and more.

During Beth’s second semester of grad school she had 2-3 days a week of student teaching at a city high school just outside the city, but closer to her apartment than mine. This was a 30 train ride to get to, and started early. This had me staying with her on student teaching days and her leaving the apartment before I usually got up, leaving Elsa and I to get ready and leave together on nights I stayed there.

Now this was a smaller two bedroom apartment with Beth’s bedroom on one end, next to living room and Elsas on the other end next to the bathroom and kitchen. It made it hard to use either without Elsa knowing, and here begins the story

So one morning right as Beth was heading out the door early I got up to kiss her goodbye , pulled on boxers briefs and walked her out. Then walked down to the bathroom. I closed the door to relieve myself, flushed and walked out to catch a bit more sleep. As soon as I open the door Elsa is directly in front of me waiting for the bathroom, in shorts and a t-shirt, I was a bit embarrassed but she looked me up and down and said “is this a underwear only dress code now”, to which I replied sheepish “guess so”, she grinned and said “good to know”.

Now there was not anything overly sexual about this but I was really turned on by the vibe. I went back to Beth’s room and looked at myself in mirror, I looked good and was having a good dick day which was evident in my boxer briefs. I proceeded to rub one out, shower and get ready for work. I got ready before Elsa and did not see her before I left.

The next time I stayed over when Beth Student taught I was excited to see if I could repeat as I am a bit of an exhibitionist, and her seeing me in my boxers turned me on. I tried the same ploy but no luck I showered, came back out and went to the bedroom to get dressed. I then went to the kitchen got coffee and a bagel. Just as I was wrapping up and getting ready to leave Elsa walks in in a matching baby blue bra and panties. My jaw hits the floor as this is the first time I have seen her in so little clothes. She quickly says “thought this was the new dress code”. To which I replied “yes it is, you missed me earlier, my work doesn’t approve though”. She says while staring me in the eyes, “sorry I missed it, maybe tomorrow” I was rock hard instantly and awkwardly tried to conceal it while stammering that I had to go. I was flustered but managed to say hope to see you tomorrow.

Now the next day my ex stayed at my place but I could not keep my mind off Elsas body or what she said. I was dying for my next chance to be alone.

A few days later I got that chance, as per normal my ex left early and I went to the bathroom in just boxer briefs again (I had bought several new “sexier” pairs just for this) she did not meet me in the by the bathroom so I decided to make breakfast in my boxers. 10 or so minutes pass and Elsa walks into the kitchen in a matching bra and thong. She looks me up and down while I ogle her and she says “that’s better”.

I start getting a chub, and she can tell. I am nervous and anxious as hell. She asked for coffee and brushes against me when reaching for a cup, I am now raging hardon that is now threatening to break free. She states that can’t be comfortable, I agree and say sometimes no clothes are better. She grins and say”you are right”. At this point she turns and goes back to her room. I stand lustful in the kitchen but she shuts the door and turns on music.

This is fairly long. If there is interest I will finish the story in another post.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/bf6o23/my_exs_open_minded_roommate_f_cheating