[MFF] Starting off in college, I got to be the lucky judge in a blowjob competition. (Part 3 and finale with Ellie)

This is the 3nd part and end of my [previous stories](https://www.reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/b86fop/mf_starting_off_in_college_i_got_to_be_the_lucky/) Where I was the lucky recipient of a blowjob competition from some friends in college. I’m finishing off the story with my favorite fuck with each girl.

**Backstory:** I was close FWB’s with Ellie throughout college, and even to this day we occasionally meet once in a while. I spent a lot of time at Ellie’s dorm. Whether it was having sex all night, or as simple as studying. Ellie was also more experimental than other girls, she had one perverse mind and was nearly up for anything. One benefit to staying at Ellie’s so much, was that I began to spend time with her roommate, Rachel.

I mostly only saw Rachel during the day, or in the morning. She had a boyfriend that lived in another dorm and she spent nearly every night in his room. I always found their pairing odd. Rachel was the girl most girls were jealous of. She was maybe 5’8, long legs, tanned skin, long blonde hair, busty, and athletic. She played volleyball and soccer, and hit the gym to be toned all over her body. In contrast her boyfriend was short, like 5’5, scrawny, geeky looking. I don’t know if she would put on a show, but anytime they were in the dorm the same time as Ellie and I, she would humiliate the guy. Like pinning his arms down on the bed and calling him a little bitch, daring him to try and get up when he couldn’t. I always just watched their antics without saying anything, but sometimes our eyes would meet and it felt like she was trying to stare me down.

Ellie and I chatted about it often. Apparently through some unintentional snooping of the PC they shared, Ellie noticed that Rachel had bought some latex outfit and a flogger. When Ellie confessed that she had a small crush on her roommate, I remember telling Ellie that, “I want to tame her.”

Now for the story itself. It was a Friday night and Ellie and I were well under way. Her mattress was squeaking with every short and fast stroke of my cock. Ellie was on her back, legs wrapped, arms around my shoulders. When her dorm room door closed shut, we both realized that we had just been caught. I slunk down on Ellie’s sweaty body, pulling a sheet up over our bodies. If Rachel looked, it was still obvious we were in the midst of sex, and I’m sure the smell lingered in the room. However, Rachel just walked over to her side of the room where her bed was and started kicking off her shoes. I noticed that she was wearing ear buds. *Maybe she had no idea.* I thought to myself, but when our eyes met, Rachel gave me a small smirk. She pulled off one of the ear buds and spoke out. “I’m just going to chill to some music, don’t mind me.” She put the ear bud back in, and turned up the music as she laid down on her bed.

Looking down, Ellie’s face was red, blushing from embarrassment. Her eyes were closed, as if she could pretend that she really hadn’t been caught. But when I started to rock into her, her eyes opened back up. I could tell that she was conflicted between wanting fucked and wanting to stop, but as my cock slid back and forth inside of her, the resistances melted away. I had Ellie get into a spooning position as I came up from behind her. This, would start driving her crazy. I think she secretly liked knowing Rachel was in the room, but was afraid the feeling wasn’t mutual. Now that she was facing the wall, away from Rachel, she was letting loose.

Ellie was getting louder and louder, as I bucked into her. Slamming my cock into her that made her legs shake. Slowly retreating until most of my slathered cock appeared, and then holding still for a second, before slamming back to the hilt all at once. I know she was feeling some pain from the depth and force of my thrusts, but after a hard thrust, she came. A cry rang out in the room as her body shook and quivered. With all the noise, I turned my head back toward Rachel’s side of the room and our eyes met. Rachel was on her stomach, and it looked like her hand was moving down in the blanket she had now covered up with. I hammered my cock back into Ellie, while maintaining eye contact with Rachel. It became more obvious that she was enjoying the show as she bit her lip and closed her eyes, not wanting to let any sound of pleasure break forth. The movement of the blanket around her shoulder was more noticeable as her hand must have been moving faster.

I was already close when Rachel first arrived, and now I was at the tipping point. I leaned over Ellie, turning her a bit on her stomach rather than sideways and started to fuck hard. I thought about kicking off the sheet, to let Rachel get a better view, but I was focused in the moment. Quickly, I sawed in and out of Ellie as she moaned consistently. When I grunted that I was going to cum, she started going wild, crashing down with another orgasm as she cried out “yes” over and over. Once again, I felt the bliss and joy as I started pumping her with my cum. When it was over, we laid down as I held her close. I took the time to look over once, but Rachel had laid down on her side.

Eventually, I grabbed Ellie’s clothes that were on the floor next to the bed and she got dressed under the sheet. She got up from the bed, wearing nothing other than a tank top and shorts, her panties in her hand covered with my cum. “I want to take a quick shower.” She stated as I replied that I would lay and wait. She grabbed her key, and shower caddy and left. Now alone in the room with Rachel, not an uncommon occurrence, but the first after having sex, I sat up and looked over. The small sound of music played, and Rachel sat up from her bed as well, the ear buds no longer in her ears. “Sorry.” I apologized. “We thought at this point you would be at your boyfriends.” She replied quickly. “It’s fine, we had a fight so I left, and it’s no big deal. It was even a bit fun.” I just watched the smile on her face grow, but wasn’t sure how far I should push things when she brought the sex up. “I’m really surprised, I didn’t think Ellie would be like that, she’s always so shy and timid.”

I wasn’t sure how I could fuck Rachel. She had a boyfriend, who seemed like the complete opposite of myself. In the end, I decided to just brag a little. “That’s what a lot of girls say until I’m with them.” Rachel kinda just rolled her eyes at me. Wanting to get this sheet off of myself, and back into clothes, I decided to just go for it. I threw the sheet off my body and stepped off the bed, completely naked. My cock was soft, but still showing quite the size. It hung low, as I grabbed my clothes off the ground. Looking over again, I noticed Rachel was staring silently. “It gets bigger if you’d like to see.” I teased, as she finally looked away. “No, I’m okay.” Even though she was declining, I could tell her voice was having trouble saying the words.

Not too long after, Ellie came back from her shower. She gave me a damp wash cloth to clean up a bit. (All girl’s dorm where men are banned for life if caught in any restroom or shower.) The three of us chatted like normal, watching television. After an hour or so, I started getting horny again. I slipped Ellie’s hand onto my shorts to feel my hard cock, and she removed it quickly. Nodding me a “no.” A few minutes later, I did the same thing but Ellie left her hand this time. She started gripping what she could, slowly palming my cock. I reached over, and was able to apply pressure through the shorts between her legs, and Ellie was once again melting away. She laid down, moving her lips to my ear. “Wait til she falls asleep.” I simply shook my head left to right and started to pull up the sheet above us. My hand pushed on Ellie’s head, lightly, but enough for her to start slipping down the bed. I pulled the sheet to my chest and Ellie positioned herself between my legs.

Lifting my hips up, she pulled my shorts and boxers off, freeing my cock to her as it tented up the sheet. I lifted the sheet straight up as I watched Ellie grab my cock and I’m pretty sure mouthing, “you’re so bad.” I just smiled before lowering the sheet again. I started to feel the warm embrace of Ellie’s mouth as she started to wrap her lips around the head of my cock. Her tongue swirling around the tip. I just sat back and enjoyed as Ellie started to bob. Whatever fear she had before was long gone. Maybe it was being underneath the sheet, but Ellie’s blowjob started getting sloppy. Wet sloshing and sucking sounds started to become noticeable. She was on her knees, hunched over with both of her hands at the base of my cock. It wasn’t long again before I was looking into Rachel’s eyes once again.

She looked like a kid in a candy store, eyes glossed over with desire as she watched on. I slipped a hand beneath the sheet and grabbed Ellie’s hair right at the scalp. Pushing her mouth down, I forced her to impale herself until the gagging sound filled the room as I let her back up. Rachel now had her back against her wall, legs spread with knees bent as I started to see her rub herself through her short athletic shorts. I wanted her, as I nearly licked my lips as my eyes trailed up and down her long tan legs. I needed to try. My other hand reached to the edge of the bed, palm up, and curled my fingers back, beckoning Rachel over. Her hand stopped moving but she shook her head as she declined. I repeated the motion and it seemed to have a worse effect as Rachel closed her legs together and looked like whatever lust she had was gone. Even though I had one girl licking all over the length of my shaft, I was annoyed and underwhelmed. I felt that I had screwed things up with Rachel, if anything. In a last ditch effort I tried again, only this time I turned my hand and pointed to the bed, as if saying “now!”

Then, a change in Rachel’s demeanor took place. She looked annoyed herself, but slowly started to get off her bed and walk over. When she was at the edge, I once again pointed to the bed and slowly Rachel sat down. The weight was noticeable and Ellie stopped pleasuring me with her mouth upon realization that Rachel was right next to her. My hand had other ideas as I started to make her bob up and down. “Pull the sheet off.” I told Rachel. She looked conflicted, but obliged as she pulled the thin fabric down and off of Ellie. For the first time, they both looked at each other during an actual sex act, and merely a foot away from each other. This time, my hand didn’t move. Instead, Ellie looked back down and started sucking my cock on her own.

I pulled my shirt off my body and looked at Rachel. Her hand had started to move from my side and over towards my cock when I spoke up. “Remove your clothes first.” Her hand laid at my hip, the contact feeling nearly burning hot. After a few seconds, I watched as she sat up and tossed her t-shirt back onto her bed. Next, she unclasped the white satin bra she had on and it to went the same way of her shirt. I was in heaven seeing her nearly naked body for the first time. Ellie had slowed down to a teasing pace as she watched Rachel strip. We both were in awe of her body. She went to sit down again but I reminded her of the green panties she was wearing. Quickly she pulled them down and kicked them off her ankles.

“Give her some room, Ellie.” I called out as I let go of Ellie’s hair and she scooted over to the side of the bed against the wall. Rachel sat back down on the edge and her had moved to my cock. She gripped the girth with her hand and started stroking up and down, already wet from Ellie. “How can you take this?” She asked Ellie, who responded with. “A lot of practice.” I had never seen Rachel like this before. Usually she was like an amazon, full of pure confidence. But now, she was obeying my instructions and looking vulnerable. “Try to suck it.” I ordered. “It’s too big, Nick (her boyfriend) is not even close.” I started to feel a way of dominance to Rachel’s new found submissive attitude. “Suck it….now!” I ordered in a sterner tone as if there was no other option. Rachel moved down the bed and leaned over. “Fine, just be patient, please.”

She stuck her tongue out, licking near the head and suckling the very tip of my cock. Slowly, she opened her mouth wide open and plunged down. She struggled to get much past the head. By now I was enjoying the humiliation I could give her, the same she did to Nick. “Is that all you can do? Have you never sucked a cock in your life?” With every insult, she tried harder and to her credit was starting to gag herself. “Help her with her hair.” I called out to Ellie. She sat up and pulled Rachel’s hair in a pony tail and held it up. Ellie was beaming with a smile, clearly enjoying this new experience. Rachel started to worship the shaft of my cock. Licking, kissing, sucking all over before she gained the composure to impale her throat again. Not long after she was getting into it, she complained of pain in her jaw.

I was more than ready to fuck, so I ordered Rachel to “hop on up.” As Rachel started climbing forward, I looked at Ellie and asked if she was okay. “Yes.” She blurted out her reply loud and quickly. Rachel lifted her hips up, placed a hand on my chest, and grabbed my cock as she positioned herself. “Take it.” She slowly descended, but even the head wasn’t getting in. “Grab the lube, Ellie.” She leaned over to her desk and pulled the small bottle out. By now, I had learned that it was always good to keep a bottle with my regulars. “Lube us up.” Ellie poured some of the liquid onto my cock as Rachel had lifted out of the way. I felt her slippery hand slather and coat the shaft and head with lubrication. When she thought she was finished her hand went away but I stopped her. “I said lube *us* up.” I could see Rachel’s eyes go wide but she didn’t protest. In contrast, Ellie seemed more than happy as she poured more of the lube onto her fingers and started to rub it into Rachel.

Neither seemed to mind as Ellie’s fingers kept rubbing the lubrication in, but I was in need. “Try again.” Ellie’s hand retreated and Rachel once again start to descend her body. Her eyes closed as she yelled out a “hnnnnnggg” sound as the head of my cock was stretching her wide. Rachel was so tight, I myself was feeling that mixture of both pleasure and pain as the head slipped in. “It’s too much.” She cried out with her hands pressing down on my chest. “Stay still, try to get used to it.” I replied. Her eyes were closed, her face full of pain as I started to feel her nails dig into me. Time felt like it was standing still as Rachel started panting like a dog. Ellie, in both a gesture of support and experimentation, straddled my legs behind Rachel. Her hand started rubbing over Rachel’s tight stomach, while the other began to rub lower.

Frequent hisses escaped Rachel’s mouth as her she started trembling. Slowly, she started descending as I felt my cock being tightly enveloped, half an inch or so at a time. The more she took, the more her body trembled, the more I felt my chest shaking from her vibrating hands. I couldn’t see Ellie beyond Rachel’s much larger frame, but her hand had moved from her Rachel’s stomach, to playing with a breast. Her other hand was softly rubbing between the crevice of Rachel’s inner thigh. Finally, I felt released from such a death grip as Rachel’s body became more accommodating. She had to take breaks roughly every inch, but eventually seven inches became eight, and eight became nine as she bottomed out.

Rachel collapsed over me, panting hard while her blonde hair cascaded all around my head. I brushed what I could out of the way and pulled her lips onto mine as we kissed. Hungrily, our tongues danced on each other for minutes on end as Rachel kept her lower body from moving at all. When she broke off, she leaned her lips to my ear. “I’ve never felt so fucking full in my life.” Then she followed up with a statement that drove me wild. “I’m going to have to stay away from Nick for a week before I let him touch me again.” In all this time, I had solely been thinking about how much I wanted Rachel. But the thoughts of having made her cheat had given me a sense of arousal I hadn’t felt since Sarah. Maybe it was because I fucked a married woman to lose my virginity, but I had finally realized that I was more than happy to be an asshole. I enjoyed taking committed woman, something that has driven me even to this very day.

I started to push Rachel upward and off my body until she moved herself upright. Ellie resumed roaming her hands over the athletic body. My hands went to Rachel’s hips, gripping them tightly as I started to raise her. She didn’t resist, rising up as I felt the relief of her burning hot and wet walls. She moved up halfway off my cock, and then slid back down again. Releasing my grip, Rachel started to move up and down on her own. Her moans had a pitch of pain intertwined but she started to pick up speed. Ellie now only had both of her hands rubbing clits. One giving pleasure to herself, and the other now to Rachel who was more than welcome to the response. With her eyes closed, Rachel started to get louder. Almost worrying loud, as her hips were bucking back and forth. Her body was thrashing as she was riding quickly until she yelled out an intermittent scream and hopped off my cock. A stream of liquid gushed out down onto me as Rachel had the first squirting of her life.

She fell down on the bed, near the wall at my side while Ellie and I just looked in disbelief while smiling. “You’re doing my laundry.” Ellie joked before laughing. I looked over at Rachel who looked like she was resting from running a marathon. I got up from the bed and pushed Ellie down, pulling her to the edge of the bed while I stood on the ground. When Rachel finally came to, she watched as I was fucking Ellie quickly. I had Ellie’s feet pressed against my shoulders as the continuous wet sounds of slapping into her was only deafened by her moans. Rachel moved her hand to the large stain on the sheet on Ellie’s bed. I think she was finally starting to get an idea of what happened.

“Doggy.” I instructed with a single word as I pulled my cock out of Ellie. She complied, flipping over and scooting back until her ass was hanging off the bed. Unlike before, I started to slide my cock slowly in and out of Ellie. When Rachel’s eyes were on mine, I gave the same order. “Doggy.” My eyes went from here and to the edge of the bed next to Ellie. Rachel took a second to understand but she to got into position as she lined up. Slipping out of Ellie, I stepped to my right and positioned myself at Rachel’s entrance. I could see Rachel reaching out and holding Ellie’s hand, their fingers intertwined. Like Ellie, I slipped into Rachel and just stroked her pussy with slow and deep strokes. Although it was more difficult to do her tightness, Rachel’s longer legs gave her the perfect height.

I started alternating between the two girls, living out my fantasy. With Ellie, I was always slow, winding myself down from any height of an orgasm. However, with Rachel, I started to gradually fuck her harder and faster. At one point, I slapped her ass cheek, just enough to give a sting. Her eyes darted back at me as she turned her head. At first I thought it was a look of disdain, but then it felt more like a dare. So while she watched, I slapped her ass again. She moaned and looked straight ahead again. I kept getting rougher with Rachel. Wrapping her hair in my hand and pulling near the scalp. I remember thinking, *I’ll make her wait two weeks before Nick can touch her.* A moment of guilt was felt for Ellie, while even a slow rocking is more than enough for her, I was really focusing all my efforts on Rachel.

The next time, I switched, I pounded into Ellie harder and faster. My fingers started rubbing her clit and soon she was moaning wildly until she arched her back and collapsed on the bed. I grabbed the bottle of lube and added some more to myself and Rachel. This time there would be no switching back and forth, I would take her from behind like I owned her. I hoped Ellie’s neighbor was away as I made Rachel bellow out loud cries and moan. When Ellie recovered, I made her kiss Rachel, hoping to drown out the sounds emitting from her mouth. As all good things, I felt myself getting that feeling from deep within.

I grabbed Rachel’s body and flipped her over onto the bed. Now on her back, I got between her legs and hovered over her. I wanted to watch her face as I was going to cum inside of her, this goddess body with a boyfriend. Most of all, I wanted her to watch me right back. I ordered to “look at me.” Only thirty seconds later, my face expressed that I was ready. Rachel had wrapped her legs around me, ankles locked and pulling me in. Through her moans of ecstasy, she started begging for me to cum inside of her. It’s now my favorite thing to hear, and so I obliged. I’ll never forget the look on her face as she knew I was firing off my ropes of cum inside of her, a look that was no longer virgin or unknown to her.

Later, the three of us finally got off the bed. We were all a mess, soaked in sweat and other fluids. Ellie complained about needing a shower again, but Rachel said she would join her. I needed to wash up but wasn’t wanting to go back to my dorm, so for the first time I actually risked using the showers at the all girl’s dorm. Both kept a lookout instead of joining, and when I was finished and back in Ellie’s dorm, the girls showered for what seemed like quite a long time. We all went to sleep together in Rachel’s bed. I tried to initiate more the next morning, but Rachel was far too sore.

In the end, Nick never had a real chance afterward. I guess he was Rachel’s childhood friend, and submissive. But eventually those weren’t good enough reasons to stay with him. Rachel did date him for another year in their straining relationship. She is what you would call a “switch.” While she primarily likes to be a dom, she has an itch to submit every now and then. That’s roughly how often we would get together. After college, we lost touch for years until our paths crossed randomly in a mall. Turns out she became a trophy wife to a rich bodybuilder. But when she convinced him to do their clothing shopping separately, she took me to the backseat of their Porsche Cayenne in the parking lot. When she needs her submissive scratched itched, I’m more than happy to help.

As written prior, Ellie and I remain friends. She didn’t mind at all that I was more focused on Rachel than her. I would later find out that her and Rachel occasionally hooked up until they were no longer dorm mates. Ellie is a real keeper for anyone with a healthy sexual appetite as she’s likely more perverse and with a higher libido than anyone she dates. However, I’m not one to be tied down, so I never tried to get into a relationship with her.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/bbputx/mff_starting_off_in_college_i_got_to_be_the_lucky