Sharing a FWB for the first time Pt 2 [MFF]

Realized that I never posted the other “part” of our threesome experience.

We had a threesome with another guy & she agreed to another girl. Luckily she was true to her word.

We actually got lucky with another girl we went to school with at the time. Since we were only FWBs, we had agreed that if we wanted to see other people it was fine. I had hit it off with a girl who was a theater geek (Gabby). She was latina, curvy and pretty tall at about 5′ 10″. We had texted back and forth a bit, eventually getting into sexual stuff. She asked what was the wildest thing I’ve done sexually and I admitted to the previous threesome. She was surprised and admitted that she had wanted to try one someday. I jokingly had said “even with another girl?” and she just replied “lol yeah.” At that point, I was convinced we found our 3rd. I mentioned it to my FWB and she didn’t know the girl but thought she was cute enough and was down if we could talk her into it. I was halfway there!

After we reached the point of trading semi-dirty pics of each other (underwear was the furthest I got with her), I eventully hinted at Gabby that I knew a girl who’d be down for a threesome. She replied “nuh uh shut up!” and I had a feeling she was down at this point. I didn’t tell Gabby who it was but, the next day at lunch when her and I were eating, my FWB (Samantha/Sam) “walked by coincedentally” and joined us briefly. I introduced them and things seemed to go well. When Sam left, Gabby said she was really nice and also pretty. I probably should’ve waited until after classes but I was excited and basically spilled the beans via text that she was one down for a threesome. I didn’t hear from Gabby the rest of the day and I was nervous as hell. After school as I was leaving, she caught me and asked to talk. Luckily, she wasn’t mad and asked if I was serious about Sam. I said yes and admitted to previous hookups (since none of us were exclusive). Gabby thought it over that night and finally texted “I’m down lol.”

I was kinda shocked that she was down for a threesome when we haven’t even hooked up before. Sam & I set it up where we could all hang out Friday after school and have a threesome. I was beyond stoked. The time finally came and we all met up back at my place. Luckily my parents were both gone for the night so no disturbances. We hadn’t talked about anything about sex or the threesome in our conversations up until we got to my house, just casual talk about shows and music and stuff we liked. We even continued just talking and hanging out having a good time for at least half an hour. Eventually, Gabby awkwardly said “So……” and we all awkwardly laughed. After some playful flirting, she asked again “Are we gonna do anything?” followed by “How do we even start this?!” We laughed and exchanged looks, and eventually I said “fuck it” and just started undressing. They were laughing that I was being awkward but at least the tension was breaking. I was standing in front of them in my boxers at one point and said “To be fair, I’ve practically seen you both naked already.” They laughed and I convinced them to start undressing as well. As Sam was taking offher shirt, I started making out with her and slid her pants off. Now she was in her bra and blue thong, and Gabby exclaimed that she was “pretty turned on.” She then let me take her shirt off and kiss her as well and Sam walked over and said “I want in on this as well” and started unbuttoning Gabby’s pants as her pink panties revealed themselves.

Sam then kissed Gabby’s neck and Gabby pulled back a bit. We asked what was wrong and Gabby said something along the lines of “I consider myself straight mostly and all of this is a big step for me. Girls are hot but idk if I can kiss one.” We awkwardly stood there for a moment and Sam apologized. Gabby said it was cool because we didn’t really discuss things before hand. I was a bit disappointed I wasn’t going to watch them kiss, but it was the least of my problems, as they did just about everything else. As I took Gabby’s bra off, Sam complimented her tits and proceeded to go topless ad well. Sam’s were bigger but Gabby had her on perkiness. We were groping each other and finally Sam slid my boxers off to start sucking my dick. Gabby watched on and let out an “Oh my god” as she giggled and teasingly covered her eyes. I said “I hope that’s not a bad OMG” and she said it wasn’t and just still couldn’t believe this was all happening (and neither could I). I convinced her to join Sam and she got on her knees and before I knew it, they were taking turns sucking my dick. I was in heaven.

After several minutes, I was ready to fuck them both. I stood Sam up and then Gabby and awkwardly asked them what they were wanting and ok with doing. Sam was pretty much up for whatever but Gabby was being reserved again. We ended up with me fucking Sam’s freshly shaved pussy from behind and Gabby agreed to being eaten out (by Sam). It was so hot watching Sam lick Gabby’s hairy pussy (she apologized for not fully shaving, which we were fine with). Sam said it was strange tasting someone other than herself and Gabby was covering and uncovering her eyes as she still couldn’t believe she was letting this happen, but we all still were respecting each other’s boundaries. Gabby didn’t want to eat out Sam but I was lucky enough to have her suck me briefly after fucking Sam. Gabby was cool with me fucking her but since it was our first time she requested a condom. I put one on and began fucking her while she was on her back and Sam laid next to her. She was super wet and moaned like crazy, more so as Sam played with her nipples and even rubbed her clit some. Gabby seemed to “dick distacted” to mind that Sam was all over her. I then swapped positions with her and had her ride me while Sam was rubbing my balls and grabbing Gabby’s ass.

We kept it up for a while until I finally came all over Sam’s stomach. Gabby let out another “Oh my God” at the fact that she was staring at another girl covered in cum. We all laid on my bed naked after Sam cleaned up and discussed things. Gabby thanked us for respecting what she wanted and apologized for any awkwardness, to which we were fine with. We even did it again with Gabby, and I got to fuck her w/o a condom and have Sam taste her while sucking me. It was an awesome experience all around.

Source: reddit.com/r/gonewildstories/comments/b3y2pv/sharing_a_fwb_for_the_first_time_pt_2_mff